211 réponses à ce sujet

[The Night Mammoth]

That depends, are they passed the idiot ball in this situation like Shepard was? 

Modifié par The Night Mammoth, 06 janvier 2013 - 04:05 .

[Galbrant]

Refuse, unless they are indoctrinated or metagaming.

[Liamv2]

no idea

[dreman9999]

Galbrant wrote...

Refuse, unless they are indoctrinated or metagaming.

HAHAHAHAH...Nope. Here's a hint. Garrus is ok with you killing Mordin because the end results aids his race.

It pretty cleary everyone in your crew will use the crusible. The question is wheather it destory, control or synthisis.

[His Name was HYR!!]

 Mostly Destroy. Which is fine, but not everyone.

IMO...

Kaidan: Synthesis.
Ashley: Destroy.
Garrus: Destroy.
Tali: Destroy.
Liara: Control.
Wrex: Destroy.
Jacob: Destroy.
Miranda: Destroy (ME2 Miranda may have Controlled, though).
Mordin: Synthesis.
Jack: Destroy.
Grunt: Destroy.
Thane: Synthesis.
Samara: Refuse.
Kasumi: Destroy (but greybox gives Synthesis an outside chance).
Zaeed: Destroy.
James: Destroy.
Javik: Destroy.
EDI: Synthesis.

[Galbrant]

dreman9999 wrote...

Galbrant wrote...

Refuse, unless they are indoctrinated or metagaming.

HAHAHAHAH...Nope. Here's a hint. Garrus is ok with you killing Mordin because the end results aids his race.

It pretty cleary everyone in your crew will use the crusible. The question is wheather it destory, control or synthisis.

My Garrus is not influence by your Shepard.  So he'll refuse like any logical Shepard. 

[dreman9999]

Galbrant wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Galbrant wrote...

Refuse, unless they are indoctrinated or metagaming.

HAHAHAHAH...Nope. Here's a hint. Garrus is ok with you killing Mordin because the end results aids his race.

It pretty cleary everyone in your crew will use the crusible. The question is wheather it destory, control or synthisis.

My Garrus is not influence by your Shepard.  So he'll refuse like any logical Shepard. 

It's not Shepard logic. It's his own. What do you thing Garrus means by ruthless calculus?He says this no matter what Shepard anyone has.

Understand this, no one in your crew is going to pick refuse. Not one person.

[dreman9999]

HYR 2.0 wrote...

 Mostly Destroy. Which is fine, but not everyone.

IMO...

Kaidan: Synthesis.
Ashley: Destroy.
Garrus: Destroy.
Tali: Destroy.
Liara: Control.
Wrex: Destroy.
Jacob: Destroy.
Miranda: Destroy (ME2 Miranda may have Controlled, though).
Mordin: Synthesis.
Jack: Destroy.
Grunt: Destroy.
Thane: Synthesis.
Samara: Refuse.
Kasumi: Destroy (but greybox gives Synthesis an outside chance).
Zaeed: Destroy.
James: Destroy.
Javik: Destroy.
EDI: Synthesis.

Change most of those synthesis to control. I onlysee mordin doing it.

[m2iCodeJockey]

HYR 2.0 wrote...

Mostly Destroy. Which is fine, but not everyone.

IMO...

Kaidan: Synthesis.
Ashley: Destroy.
Garrus: Destroy.
Tali: Destroy.
Liara: Control.
Wrex: Destroy.
Jacob: Destroy.
Miranda: Destroy (ME2 Miranda may have Controlled, though).
Mordin: Synthesis.
Jack: Destroy.
Grunt: Destroy.
Thane: Synthesis.
Samara: Refuse.
Kasumi: Destroy (but greybox gives Synthesis an outside chance).
Zaeed: Destroy.
James: Destroy.
Javik: Destroy.
EDI: Synthesis.

I agreed with most except:
Miranda: Control (Miranda is nearly as evil as TIM, doesn't grow much since the start of ME2)
EDI: Not determinable (She chooses to control EVA yet, expresses curiosity then, expresses the desire to protect Jeff up to the ultimate cost)

[Volc19]

Liara: Control
Ash: Destroy
Kaidan: Synthesis
Tali: Destroy
Wrex: Destroy
Garrus: Destroy
Miranda: Control
Jacob: Refuse
Jack: Destroy
Mordin: Synthesis in ME3, Destroy in ME2
Grunt: Destroy
Zaeed: Destroy
Kasumi: Destroy (unless Control counts as stealing the Reapers)
Thane: either Synthesis or Destroy
Samara: Control (she would be able to fulfill The Code at maximum efficiency with a Reaper fleet)
ME2!Legion: Control (keeps his people alive without changing them into an undesirable pseudo organic state)
ME3!Legion: Synthesis
Vega: Refuse or Destroy
EDI: Synthesis
Javik: Destroy

[dreman9999]

Volc19 wrote...

Liara: Control
Ash: Destroy
Kaidan: Synthesis
Tali: Destroy
Wrex: Destroy
Garrus: Destroy
Miranda: Control
Jacob: Refuse
Jack: Destroy
Mordin: Synthesis in ME3, Destroy in ME2
Grunt: Destroy
Zaeed: Destroy
Kasumi: Destroy (unless Control counts as stealing the Reapers)
Thane: either Synthesis or Destroy
Samara: Control (she would be able to fulfill The Code at maximum efficiency with a Reaper fleet)
ME2!Legion: Control (keeps his people alive without changing them into an undesirable pseudo organic state)
ME3!Legion: Synthesis
Vega: Refuse or Destroy
EDI: Synthesis
Javik: Destroy

Based on James past actions and Jacobs current situation with a child...No way will they pick refuse.
And why do people think EDI will pick synthesis. She is too pro free will to pick that.

Modifié par dreman9999, 06 janvier 2013 - 04:39 .

[Liamv2]

dreman9999 wrote...

Volc19 wrote...

Liara: Control
Ash: Destroy
Kaidan: Synthesis
Tali: Destroy
Wrex: Destroy
Garrus: Destroy
Miranda: Control
Jacob: Refuse
Jack: Destroy
Mordin: Synthesis in ME3, Destroy in ME2
Grunt: Destroy
Zaeed: Destroy
Kasumi: Destroy (unless Control counts as stealing the Reapers)
Thane: either Synthesis or Destroy
Samara: Control (she would be able to fulfill The Code at maximum efficiency with a Reaper fleet)
ME2!Legion: Control (keeps his people alive without changing them into an undesirable pseudo organic state)
ME3!Legion: Synthesis
Vega: Refuse or Destroy
EDI: Synthesis
Javik: Destroy

Based on James past actions and Jacobs current situation with a child...No way will they pick refuse.
And why do people think EDI will pick synthesis. She is too pro free will to pick that.

The fact that she does the speach for that ending proberly helps

[Yate]

HYR 2.0 wrote...

 Mostly Destroy. Which is fine, but not everyone.

IMO...

Kaidan: Synthesis.
Ashley: Destroy.
Garrus: Destroy.
Tali: Destroy.
Liara: Control.
Wrex: Destroy.
Jacob: Destroy.
Miranda: Destroy (ME2 Miranda may have Controlled, though).
Mordin: Synthesis.
Jack: Destroy.
Grunt: Destroy.
Thane: Synthesis.
Samara: Refuse.
Kasumi: Destroy (but greybox gives Synthesis an outside chance).
Zaeed: Destroy.
James: Destroy.
Javik: Destroy.
EDI: Synthesis.

P much this. Except James might go for Synthesis and Jacob for Control.

[Dr_Extrem]

Volc19 wrote...

Liara: Control
Ash: Destroy
Kaidan: Synthesis
Tali: Destroy
Wrex: Destroy
Garrus: Destroy
Miranda: Control
Jacob: Refuse
Jack: Destroy
Mordin: Synthesis in ME3, Destroy in ME2
Grunt: Destroy
Zaeed: Destroy
Kasumi: Destroy (unless Control counts as stealing the Reapers)
Thane: either Synthesis or Destroy
Samara: Control (she would be able to fulfill The Code at maximum efficiency with a Reaper fleet)
ME2!Legion: Control (keeps his people alive without changing them into an undesirable pseudo organic state)
ME3!Legion: Synthesis
Vega: Refuse or Destroy
EDI: Synthesis
Javik: Destroy

only one objection - liara would choose destroy after thessia.

[Steelcan]

Garrus, Miranda, Javik, Liara, Mordin, Grunt, Jack, Hackett, James, EDI, Legion, Thane, Wrex, Ashley, Kaidan, Tali, Jacob would all pick Destroy.

[dreman9999]

Liamv2 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Volc19 wrote...

Liara: Control
Ash: Destroy
Kaidan: Synthesis
Tali: Destroy
Wrex: Destroy
Garrus: Destroy
Miranda: Control
Jacob: Refuse
Jack: Destroy
Mordin: Synthesis in ME3, Destroy in ME2
Grunt: Destroy
Zaeed: Destroy
Kasumi: Destroy (unless Control counts as stealing the Reapers)
Thane: either Synthesis or Destroy
Samara: Control (she would be able to fulfill The Code at maximum efficiency with a Reaper fleet)
ME2!Legion: Control (keeps his people alive without changing them into an undesirable pseudo organic state)
ME3!Legion: Synthesis
Vega: Refuse or Destroy
EDI: Synthesis
Javik: Destroy

Based on James past actions and Jacobs current situation with a child...No way will they pick refuse.
And why do people think EDI will pick synthesis. She is too pro free will to pick that.

The fact that she does the speach for that ending proberly helps

She says if the only way to save the crew and Joker is the let herself be destroyed she would do it. She would do anything to save them. The other issue is that she is still pro free will. She would not do anything that could lead to others losing that.

That only leaves control open, it also is a sacrifice and it does not have a major danger od distoring free will. Her second option would be destroy.

[Steelcan]

Sorry I don't see Miranda controlling the reapers in ME3, she is too opposed to Cerberus to do that. In ME2 maybe, but I still think she would destroy them, see her dialogue on saving the Collector Base.

[dreman9999]

Steelcan wrote...

Garrus, Miranda, Javik, Liara, Mordin, Grunt, Jack, Hackett, James, EDI, Legion, Thane, Wrex, Ashley, Kaidan, Tali, Jacob would all pick Destroy.

Mordin would pick synthesis.

[dreman9999]

Steelcan wrote...

Sorry I don't see Miranda controlling the reapers in ME3, she is too opposed to Cerberus to do that. In ME2 maybe, but I still think she would destroy them, see her dialogue on saving the Collector Base.

Who areyou taking to?

[Steelcan]

dreman9999 wrote...

Steelcan wrote...

Sorry I don't see Miranda controlling the reapers in ME3, she is too opposed to Cerberus to do that. In ME2 maybe, but I still think she would destroy them, see her dialogue on saving the Collector Base.

Who areyou taking to?

does it matter?

[Galbrant]

dreman9999 wrote...

Galbrant wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Galbrant wrote...

Refuse, unless they are indoctrinated or metagaming.

HAHAHAHAH...Nope. Here's a hint. Garrus is ok with you killing Mordin because the end results aids his race.

It pretty cleary everyone in your crew will use the crusible. The question is wheather it destory, control or synthisis.

My Garrus is not influence by your Shepard.  So he'll refuse like any logical Shepard. 

It's not Shepard logic. It's his own. What do you thing Garrus means by ruthless calculus?He says this no matter what Shepard anyone has.

Understand this, no one in your crew is going to pick refuse. Not one person.

I have a very hard time  believing Garrus would choose one of the Catalyst inane options.  Shepard was given no evidence to back up the catalyst claims all you have is a word from a monster who is riddle with broken logic that created an entire Army of monsters  that excel at indoctrination.  

Unless it was forced from Biowares ****** poor writing every one would refuse. 

[Steelcan]

dreman9999 wrote...

Steelcan wrote...

Garrus, Miranda, Javik, Liara, Mordin, Grunt, Jack, Hackett, James, EDI, Legion, Thane, Wrex, Ashley, Kaidan, Tali, Jacob would all pick Destroy.

Mordin would pick synthesis.

http://m.youtube.com...h?v=VJIQfmWx3dI

[m2iCodeJockey]

Steelcan wrote...

Sorry I don't see Miranda controlling the reapers in ME3, she is too opposed to Cerberus to do that. In ME2 maybe, but I still think she would destroy them, see her dialogue on saving the Collector Base.

What gave you the impression she was opposed to Cerberus and not just TIM?

[MacroSpamMK]

They better pick Destroy or straight out of the airlock.
Anyone of them that does not agree with me gets a Renegade Interrupt to the head.