MisterJB wrote...
Conditions in the Circle of Kirkwall were unnusually harsh, I'll grant you that. But there was also an unusually number of blood mages threatening the people of the City. Some undoubtedly created by Meredith but also many who were not.
Therefore, I hesitate when deeming her measures "unnecessary".
Some things were inexcusable, of course, such as Alrik breaking every law of the Chantry but, according to the girl Hawke saves should she be sent back to the Circle, the other templars are glad Alrik is gone and just want things to return to normal. Bethany claims as much.
Let's quote Varic at the beginning of Act 3.
Meredith ruled with an iron fist. The harder she squeezed, the more the mages resisted. The more they resisted, the harder she squeezed.
It was a horrible situation altogether. There were an unusually high amount of blood mages, but from what I can gather, most of them became blood mages because they were driven to that point by the templars.
Let's look at how many blood mages Hawke meets throughout his seven years in Kirkwall. If I forget any, feel free to remind me. And this is only confirmed blood mages, not rogue mages. There is a difference.
1. The Lily serial murderer-killer, driven mad by grief long before Hawke even showed up, and there is evidence he wasn't even from Kirkwall. (Hawke doesn't actually meet him at this point, but there is evidence he's lurking around)
2. Tehrone (I know I spelled it wrong.)-A mage spremist who summoned demons and put them into templar recruits, in an effort to drive the templars crazy with paranoia....and it worked. Also mad.
3. Denarius-pseudo revolutionist who can't tell an escaped slave, a dwarf, and a Dalish elf from a templar.
4. That one prostitute whose name I can't remember at the Blooming Rose.
That's act 1. And that's less blood mages than the warden meets in one year during the Blight, especially if we do the Mages Collective quests.
Act 2.
Gascard DuPuis-former pupil of Quintin. We are fed this line on him wanting to avenge his sister, and I do believe that's true to a point, but he also wanted the power and research that Quentin had. Standard noble.
Quintin- the Lily serial murderer. Driven mad by grief before the game began and sought to revive his wife through necromancy. Had outside help gathering research materials. Later confirmed to be Orsino if we side with the templars in the final act.
Hadrianna-magister, and apprentice to Denarius, who is also a Magister. Tevinter is full of blood mages in their leadership so this is no real surprise.
.....I can't remember any other confirmed blood mages in Act 2. I know I fought those bandits and they had a mage, but I don't think he was a blood mage. Just a bandit who happened to be a mage.
And once again, Hawke actually ran into less blood mages than the Warden did in Origins. Even the first two acts combined has less blood mages than the Warden meets and fights (if we do the Mages Collective quests.) In triple the length. Doesn't look like in Act 1 or Act 2 that Kirkwall had a blood mage problem at all. Merely a crime problem, a qunari problem, and a lot of emotional problems.
Act 3.
This entire act revolves around the templars and mages, and blood mages, and it's this act that they are all over the place. On the streets at night, plotting with the templars to depose Meredith, in gangs that we clean up at night, and later, Orsino uses it himself in despair and desperation.
To put it bluntly, the blood mage problem officially started after Meredith became the defacto Viscount and refused to let the city run itself. She claimed she was the only one qualified to protect the city, but the blood mage problems arose enmass only AFTER she claimed power.