Who do you think it is. The one who I think got the worst is morinth (though she always dies in ME2 cause I am not choosing that freak over samara). Of the ME2 squademates I have I think jacob did if you romanced him but for someone you aren't talking about them as an LI it is jack since they make you like her even more and then say no you only get to see her twice (I don't count earth)
Which ME2 squademate got the worst treatment in ME3
Débuté par
garrusfan1
, janv. 08 2013 04:19
Retour en haut
#3
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:27
Nero Narmeril
-
- Members
- 1 474 messages
Thane. Kicked a**es in ME2, cannot defeat Kai Leng in ME3.
#4
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:28
MACharlie1
-
- Members
- 3 437 messages
Morinth because of pure content
Miranda got her character butchered - she dies when you don't love her anymore.
Jacob is becomes a cheating bastard.
Miranda got her character butchered - she dies when you don't love her anymore.
Jacob is becomes a cheating bastard.
#5
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:28
N7Avin180
-
- Members
- 70 messages
Is this even a question. Morinth fo sure. Though I never used her.
#6
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:29
IMNOTCRAZYiminsane
-
- Members
- 450 messages
Jacob if romanced
Zaeed! he needs to be on my goddamn Ship not standing looking at nothing with the batarians!
Zaeed! he needs to be on my goddamn Ship not standing looking at nothing with the batarians!
#8
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:30
geceka
-
- Members
- 208 messages
dreamgazer wrote...
Morinth.
Absolutely. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't bitter about that, even though I'm very happy with ME3 in general, including the endings.
The Banshee was so pointless, it would have been better to leave her fate open instead, at the very least...
#9
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:38
Geomon19
-
- Members
- 425 messages
Morinth and I couldn't stand her anyway but she was pretty much forgotten in ME3.
#10
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:39
Belisarius25
-
- Members
- 699 messages
Teammates that get good treatment:
Garrus/Tali (fan favorites/been around since ME1),
Mordin goes out in a blaze of glory,
Grunt actually improves from his ME2 persona (I thought he was a waste of space mostly and his loyalty mission was terrible).
Unromanced Jack has some nice character development
The Meh
Morinth gets banshee'd off screen, although I guess it's hard to be sympathetic towards her (imo)
Samara (still doing her own thing, actually agrees to help fight the Reapers directly unlike people like Jacob who wants to babysit his girlfriend or [ugh] having Miranda's sister/father take precedence over the Reaper invasion.
The bad
Jacob - especially if romanced, but also responsible for making Shepard really uncomfortable at Huerta, decides he'd rather hang out with his girlfriend than fight the reapers. Just glad I didn't have to hear "THROWING DOWN A BARRIER" again
Thane - He's your LI? Too bad. Even if he's not, he gets only a few lines of dialogue and falls victim to Captain Cutscene/acting utterly stupid in the fight. Nice death scene, I guess
Miranda - If you're going to essentially write her out of the game, couldn't you at least make her storyline about undercover operatives fighting against Cerberus (maybe with news reports about them sabotaging a base here, etc.) on top of it? Did we really have to dip into the daddy issues/sister yet again? Even worse if you're romancing her and/or she dies because you didn't do something that's, at best, tertiary to everything else you're doing.
Legion - I loved Legion in ME2 but the more I've played ME3, the more I dislike what they did with him. The Geth want to build their own future (ME2)? Well, since we have this Reaper code handy that will magically skip ahead, never mind that. Also, really disliked how they made him continously act behind Shepard's back on Rannoch when the trust-building in ME2 was supposedly such a big deal.
Kasumi/Zaeed - Non-entities except to give people who bought the DLCs some extra war assets. I wonder if poor Kasumi knows about Jacob
Romanced Jack - .....there's a trend here! Also suck sif you didn't realize Grissom Academy has a timer and you end up having to kill her
Kelly Chambers - Technically not a squadmate but her fate is really obnoxious - doesn't show up at all unless you had dinner with her (uh, okay), plus you can get her killed!
Garrus/Tali (fan favorites/been around since ME1),
Mordin goes out in a blaze of glory,
Grunt actually improves from his ME2 persona (I thought he was a waste of space mostly and his loyalty mission was terrible).
Unromanced Jack has some nice character development
The Meh
Morinth gets banshee'd off screen, although I guess it's hard to be sympathetic towards her (imo)
Samara (still doing her own thing, actually agrees to help fight the Reapers directly unlike people like Jacob who wants to babysit his girlfriend or [ugh] having Miranda's sister/father take precedence over the Reaper invasion.
The bad
Jacob - especially if romanced, but also responsible for making Shepard really uncomfortable at Huerta, decides he'd rather hang out with his girlfriend than fight the reapers. Just glad I didn't have to hear "THROWING DOWN A BARRIER" again
Thane - He's your LI? Too bad. Even if he's not, he gets only a few lines of dialogue and falls victim to Captain Cutscene/acting utterly stupid in the fight. Nice death scene, I guess
Miranda - If you're going to essentially write her out of the game, couldn't you at least make her storyline about undercover operatives fighting against Cerberus (maybe with news reports about them sabotaging a base here, etc.) on top of it? Did we really have to dip into the daddy issues/sister yet again? Even worse if you're romancing her and/or she dies because you didn't do something that's, at best, tertiary to everything else you're doing.
Legion - I loved Legion in ME2 but the more I've played ME3, the more I dislike what they did with him. The Geth want to build their own future (ME2)? Well, since we have this Reaper code handy that will magically skip ahead, never mind that. Also, really disliked how they made him continously act behind Shepard's back on Rannoch when the trust-building in ME2 was supposedly such a big deal.
Kasumi/Zaeed - Non-entities except to give people who bought the DLCs some extra war assets. I wonder if poor Kasumi knows about Jacob
Romanced Jack - .....there's a trend here! Also suck sif you didn't realize Grissom Academy has a timer and you end up having to kill her
Kelly Chambers - Technically not a squadmate but her fate is really obnoxious - doesn't show up at all unless you had dinner with her (uh, okay), plus you can get her killed!
Modifié par Belisarius25, 08 janvier 2013 - 04:46 .
#11
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:39
kalasaurus
-
- Members
- 5 575 messages
Morinth's made me lol.
Jacob's was pretty bad too- forgetting his biotic barrier and getting shot, cheating on FemShep, "helping" with the Crucible and his prego lady friend by standing in Huerta Memorial hospital the rest of the game.
Zaeed and Kasumi had small roles, but they were DLC.
Jacob's was pretty bad too- forgetting his biotic barrier and getting shot, cheating on FemShep, "helping" with the Crucible and his prego lady friend by standing in Huerta Memorial hospital the rest of the game.
Zaeed and Kasumi had small roles, but they were DLC.
#12
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:39
JBPBRC
-
- Members
- 3 444 messages
Morinth and Thane to be sure.
Thane because he dies to the hopeless failure known as Kai Lame, and Morinth for obvious reasons.
Runner-ups are Miranda and Zaeed.
Thane because he dies to the hopeless failure known as Kai Lame, and Morinth for obvious reasons.
Runner-ups are Miranda and Zaeed.
#13
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:40
fiendishchicken
-
- Members
- 3 389 messages
The actual answer is anyone who doesn't have a Dextro-based DNA.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Jack doesn't have much, but she's got good character growth if you don't romance her. Samara, Kasumi, and Grunt are meh. They have a cameo mission then just disappear.
Anyone you romance basically gets it bad.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Jack doesn't have much, but she's got good character growth if you don't romance her. Samara, Kasumi, and Grunt are meh. They have a cameo mission then just disappear.
Anyone you romance basically gets it bad.
Modifié par fiendishchicken, 08 janvier 2013 - 04:45 .
#14
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:43
clarkusdarkus
-
- Members
- 2 460 messages
Samara as man she will always be my favourite asari, shooting herself in the head was as bemusing as trying to figure out the journal.....samara' loyalty quest in ME2 was my favourite as it at least tried to be different so yeah id say samara got the short straw....
#15
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:43
AnubisOnly
-
- Members
- 680 messages
All besides Mordin, Grunt...
Overall, the team from ME2 was treated much worse than that of ME1 ...
Overall, the team from ME2 was treated much worse than that of ME1 ...
#16
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:46
JBPBRC
-
- Members
- 3 444 messages
fiendishchicken wrote...
The actual answer is anyone who doesn't have a Dextro-based DNA.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Its just the fate of ME2 characters. They can either die, or live on as a meaningless war asset number. Because of reasons.
#17
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:47
fiendishchicken
-
- Members
- 3 389 messages
Lucas1987Dion wrote...
All besides Mordin, Grunt...
Overall, the team from ME2 was treated much worse than that of ME1 ...
BW thinks that the ME1 team is Shepard's 'team'
Nevermind the team assembled in ME2 was the deadliest in history and you commanded their undying loyalty and skill if you know how to.
#18
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:47
fiendishchicken
-
- Members
- 3 389 messages
JBPBRC wrote...
fiendishchicken wrote...
The actual answer is anyone who doesn't have a Dextro-based DNA.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Its just the fate of ME2 characters. They can either die, or live on as a meaningless war asset number. Because of reasons.
That disturbs me more than anything.
#19
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:50
AnubisOnly
-
- Members
- 680 messages
JBPBRC wrote...
fiendishchicken wrote...
The actual answer is anyone who doesn't have a Dextro-based DNA.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Its just the fate of ME2 characters. They can either die, or live on as a meaningless war asset number. Because of reasons.
Tali & Garrus can die in ME2 too, also Ash & Kaidan + Wrex in ME1... <_<
Modifié par Lucas1987Dion, 08 janvier 2013 - 04:52 .
#20
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:51
JBPBRC
-
- Members
- 3 444 messages
Lucas1987Dion wrote...
JBPBRC wrote...
fiendishchicken wrote...
The actual answer is anyone who doesn't have a Dextro-based DNA.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Its just the fate of ME2 characters. They can either die, or live on as a meaningless war asset number. Because of reasons.
Tali & Garrus can die in ME2 too, also Ash & Kaidan in ME1... <_<
All of which are ME1 characters.
#21
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:54
Belisarius25
-
- Members
- 699 messages
Lucas1987Dion wrote...
JBPBRC wrote...
fiendishchicken wrote...
The actual answer is anyone who doesn't have a Dextro-based DNA.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Its just the fate of ME2 characters. They can either die, or live on as a meaningless war asset number. Because of reasons.
Tali & Garrus can die in ME2 too, also Ash & Kaidan in ME1... <_<
Eh, sort of. The Virmire choice was actually well done. Garrus/Tali are clearly not meant to die in ME2 and requires to player to actively try to kill them. Really it just comes down to Garrus/Tali getting upgraded to Shepard's BFFs, plus Bioware gave us Vega (who's an okay character but could easily be replaced) and EDI (....) which took the two other slots.
Modifié par Belisarius25, 08 janvier 2013 - 04:57 .
#22
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:55
AnubisOnly
-
- Members
- 680 messages
JBPBRC wrote...
Lucas1987Dion wrote...
JBPBRC wrote...
fiendishchicken wrote...
The actual answer is anyone who doesn't have a Dextro-based DNA.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Its just the fate of ME2 characters. They can either die, or live on as a meaningless war asset number. Because of reasons.
Tali & Garrus can die in ME2 too, also Ash & Kaidan in ME1... <_<
All of which are ME1 characters.
The point is Tali and Garrus can die in ME2 like the others from ME2... And still even after that they have ''big'' roles in ME3
#23
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 04:59
matt-bassist
-
- Members
- 1 245 messages
how does Jack become a banshee though?
#24
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 05:01
Belisarius25
-
- Members
- 699 messages
matt-bassist wrote...
how does Jack become a banshee though?
If you don't do the Grissom Academy mission quickly enough, Cerberus captures it and you end up hearing recordings of Jack being tortured at Cerberus HQ. When you get to the human reaper area, you find her as a phantom (with her standard lines)
#25
Posté 08 janvier 2013 - 05:01
JBPBRC
-
- Members
- 3 444 messages
Lucas1987Dion wrote...
JBPBRC wrote...
Lucas1987Dion wrote...
JBPBRC wrote...
fiendishchicken wrote...
The actual answer is anyone who doesn't have a Dextro-based DNA.
Mordin has an incredible story. Legion has a lot of weight too, even if I still don't understand why he had to die.
Its just the fate of ME2 characters. They can either die, or live on as a meaningless war asset number. Because of reasons.
Tali & Garrus can die in ME2 too, also Ash & Kaidan in ME1... <_<
All of which are ME1 characters.
The point is Tali and Garrus can die in ME2 like the others from ME2... And still even after that they have ''big'' roles in ME3
However, seeing as they are ME1 characters, they aren't put on a bus heading towards obscurity like any ME2 castmember who isn't named Mordin or Legion.
And even Mordin and Legion are replaceable.
Modifié par JBPBRC, 08 janvier 2013 - 05:02 .
