Aller au contenu

Photo

The Architect's Plan (The Calling/Awakening) vs. Synthesis


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
78 réponses à ce sujet

#76
tooducks58

tooducks58
  • Members
  • 26 messages

Fast Jimmy wrote...

Would monkeys be included in this hybridization? They have rudimentary communication, use of tools and low-level tribe systems. If not, would the Neadrathals have been? If not, would the Yahg? Would the Hanar? It's a terribly slippery slope that defies any sort of ability to answer with the only feedback mechanism being a FTL energy blast. Not to mention the only thing that the Crucible adds is more power, which would not be the limiting factor in such an endeavor, but the logistics in how to identify a sentient being and then inherently know how to rearrange their biology to accommodate a technological integration. It's not science, it's space magic, pure and simple.


You realize that technologically the reapers are about a billion years ahead of us, maybe more? Just a few hundred years ago flight was impossible. Do the math.

#77
tooducks58

tooducks58
  • Members
  • 26 messages

AtreiyaN7 wrote...

My opinion is that Synthesis does nothing more than to change the nature of the building blocks of life at the most basic level.

For example, let's say that you replace a carbon atom (which is fundamental to organic life) with a silicon atom that has the same structure in terms of the outermost valence shell (where you would have four "open" spaces just like carbon).

The silicon could replace the carbon, and you might hypothetically retain a DNA structure analogous to your previously fully organic one (with some help from sci-fi voodoo). You keep the uniqueness of your DNA and individual genes - they're just encoded in a slightly different form. Aside from a slight change in biochemistry, business would largely go about as normal for everyone.

Synthetics who don't have their own specific genetic code in the first place might, after Synthesis, have their unique characteristics rendered into a DNA-like code of their own. The point of Synthesis is, in my opinion, that under our respective skins, what really matters is that we're all people. Organics aren't better because they're organics, we're all equals, etc. if you want a detailed explanation, read my blog.

In any case, I got tired of the idiotic "hurr-durr, you're brainwashed borgs/monsters" and general hypocrisy in the ME3 forums, so I haven't given a flying fig about the issue in a while. As for the darkspawn situation, I don't think it's even remotely equivalent.

Why? Because we're not talking about species on an equal footing. All major parties involved in Synthesis are thinking, sentient beings (not counting cannon fodder like husks, etc. whose status after synthesis is kind of an unknown).

Aside from the Architect and very few darkspawn, they don't seem to have much in the way of native intelligence or creativity or compassion (versus EDI and the geth for example). They're enslaved by the "song," and the Architect is trying to uplift them in his own way.


wow .Posted Image Awesomeness in text format.

#78
CosmicGnosis

CosmicGnosis
  • Members
  • 1 594 messages

AtreiyaN7 wrote...

My opinion is that Synthesis does nothing more than to change the nature of the building blocks of life at the most basic level.

For example, let's say that you replace a carbon atom (which is fundamental to organic life) with a silicon atom that has the same structure in terms of the outermost valence shell (where you would have four "open" spaces just like carbon).

The silicon could replace the carbon, and you might hypothetically retain a DNA structure analogous to your previously fully organic one (with some help from sci-fi voodoo). You keep the uniqueness of your DNA and individual genes - they're just encoded in a slightly different form. Aside from a slight change in biochemistry, business would largely go about as normal for everyone.

Synthetics who don't have their own specific genetic code in the first place might, after Synthesis, have their unique characteristics rendered into a DNA-like code of their own. The point of Synthesis is, in my opinion, that under our respective skins, what really matters is that we're all people. Organics aren't better because they're organics, we're all equals, etc. if you want a detailed explanation, read my blog.


Interesting perspective.

#79
jpbreon

jpbreon
  • Members
  • 36 messages
Fiona has a child (likely Alistair, by the way) to Maric while she is a Grey Warden. There's proof of concept right away. An un-Tainted human impregnated a Tainted elf that presumably had an untainted child. Whether this child really is Alistair is an open question, of course. However, it is plausible. Yet that wouldn't explain how the child was born without the Taint.

Then there's Bregan, Utha, and the Architect. Utha would have spent an unbelievable amount of time as a Ghoul, yet we know she retained her sanity. Tamlen retained his sanity (to a degree) if you play as a Dalish Warden - including a very moving moment he professes his love for the female Dalish if you select the right options in the origin.

Sorry for the non-sequitor.