Aller au contenu

Photo

Claymore is OP


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
175 réponses à ce sujet

#51
RoundedPlanet88

RoundedPlanet88
  • Members
  • 1 671 messages

k1ngl1ves wrote...

It's only OP in the right hands. Hell, the Disciple is probably OP for someone...

Disciple was really a pretty solid weapon before it got aht insane buff, now its actually pretty good. Still doesn`t compare to the other shotguns, but then again, claymore and wraith are just amazing. And occasionally GPS is good too.
Alos, just to troll Annomander, everyone should use a disciple on thier krogans. ERVERYONE Posted Image

#52
tictactucrac

tictactucrac
  • Members
  • 2 137 messages
To be honnest, even if it's a troll, even if i love this weapon, the claymore IS borderline OP. But the problem isn't the claymore. The problem is smart choke and reload cancel. Smart choke should be nerfed to 30% accuracy. IMHO. Seriously, claymore has sniper range with smart choke + GI/destroyer/Marksman. This is not fair. And reload cancel is way too fast on the claymore.

This is what i think, i don't give a sh*t if it is not nerfed. (and seeing the last balance change, claymore could even be buffed, so.. ^^)

Modifié par tictactucrac, 16 janvier 2013 - 05:31 .


#53
Deerber

Deerber
  • Members
  • 16 870 messages

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.


Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:

#54
BridgeBurner

BridgeBurner
  • Members
  • 7 317 messages

Deerber wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.


Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:


I agree. TC needs nerfed immediately. BRING ME YOUR TEARS BSN....

MY BODY IS READY FOR ITS THIRST TO BE QUENCHED!

#55
UnknownMercenary

UnknownMercenary
  • Members
  • 5 547 messages

HolyAvenger wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.

Yes, yes, now we're talking. Claymore, TC and Harrier nerf, all in one set of balance changes.

For the meltdown to end all meltdowns. Posted Image


It will be the last set of balance changes to get us to buy ME4.

/tinfoil hat

#56
RoundedPlanet88

RoundedPlanet88
  • Members
  • 1 671 messages

Deerber wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.


Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:



What gets me is how illogical people are over it, nobody even TRIES arguing for it to not be nerfed logically, which really says alot, about the power, and about the BSN Posted Image

#57
Beerfish

Beerfish
  • Members
  • 23 870 messages
I hate the claymore. I can't reload cancel worth shi*.

#58
UnknownMercenary

UnknownMercenary
  • Members
  • 5 547 messages

RoundedPlanet88 wrote...

Deerber wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.


Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:



What gets me is how illogical people are over it, nobody even TRIES arguing for it to not be nerfed logically, which really says alot, about the power, and about the BSN Posted Image


Truthfully I think Cloak needs a total overhaul. All they can do is tweak numbers without a patch, and I don't see them radically changing the power a year after release, but the discussions have been done to death (with mostly immature responses).

#59
Deerber

Deerber
  • Members
  • 16 870 messages

RoundedPlanet88 wrote...

Deerber wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.


Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:



What gets me is how illogical people are over it, nobody even TRIES arguing for it to not be nerfed logically, which really says alot, about the power, and about the BSN Posted Image


To be honest, nothing they can do can ever nerf TC enough. That's the reason I don't go around crying for a nerf, I am resigned to the fact that playing infiltrator isn't as fun as playing other class. They're my least played class now, even less than engineer. By far...

#60
BACON4BREAKFAST

BACON4BREAKFAST
  • Members
  • 2 935 messages

Invader Nemesis wrote...

Nerf it.


Posted Image

Aww, you made Wrex Jr. cry    :(

#61
RoundedPlanet88

RoundedPlanet88
  • Members
  • 1 671 messages

UnknownMercenary wrote...

RoundedPlanet88 wrote...

Deerber wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.


Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:



What gets me is how illogical people are over it, nobody even TRIES arguing for it to not be nerfed logically, which really says alot, about the power, and about the BSN Posted Image


Truthfully I think Cloak needs a total overhaul. All they can do is tweak numbers without a patch, and I don't see them radically changing the power a year after release, but the discussions have been done to death (with mostly immature responses).


It really does need a total overhual. But good luck getting a logical, or even tempered response to THAT. The most even headed response that I`ve seen so far was, direct quote "you`re stupid".

#62
HolyAvenger

HolyAvenger
  • Members
  • 13 848 messages

UnknownMercenary wrote...

RoundedPlanet88 wrote...

Deerber wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.


Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:



What gets me is how illogical people are over it, nobody even TRIES arguing for it to not be nerfed logically, which really says alot, about the power, and about the BSN Posted Image


Truthfully I think Cloak needs a total overhaul. All they can do is tweak numbers without a patch, and I don't see them radically changing the power a year after release, but the discussions have been done to death (with mostly immature responses).

Yes the entire mechanic needs an overhaul. The basically ported it from SP to MP, without really considering the need to balance it appropriately.

There are several things you could easily do that would let infiltrators keep their "feel" without letting them dominate the metagame, sure enough.

#63
INVADERONE

INVADERONE
  • Members
  • 3 474 messages
I am almost positive that since BioWare has not nerfed it is because no one uses it. It takes a lot of skill to use it on console and on pc although they claim to use it often its probably not as often as you'd think.

The gun is powerful but it needs to be being a one shot weapon and ....its KROGAN! It should be a beast. If they nerf such a balanced weapon then why continue playing this game?

#64
cronshaw

cronshaw
  • Members
  • 4 997 messages
Have all the claymorephiles started telling everyone how much skill it takes to use yet?

#65
Ziegrif

Ziegrif
  • Members
  • 10 095 messages
Should I make a well thought out argument against the OP?

... Nah I'm just gonna keep beating the OP to death with this crowbar. BWAHAHAHAH!!!

Posted Image

Modifié par Ziegrif, 16 janvier 2013 - 05:50 .


#66
RoundedPlanet88

RoundedPlanet88
  • Members
  • 1 671 messages

modok8 wrote...

Have all the claymorephiles started telling everyone how much skill it takes to use yet?

The only responses Against the nerf that I`ve seen so far are the usual "nerfduck" criers responses. Everyone who actually uses it apparently is laughing thier ass off at the fact this even got a thread, and havn`t bothered posting one of the many reasons it`s more balanced than a lot of things. I could have missed something though

#67
Beerfish

Beerfish
  • Members
  • 23 870 messages

Ziegrif wrote...

Should I make a well thought out argument against the OP?

... Nah I'm just gonna keep beating the OP to death with this crowbar. BWAHAHAHAH!!!

Posted Image


Can we have a crowbar as a melee weapon in ME3 multiplayer please?  If it is good enough for Gordon Freeman....

#68
Perkocet13

Perkocet13
  • Members
  • 312 messages
lets see slow to reload, one shot, and very heavy, I know its a troll thread, but there's no logic behind nerfing the claymore, even if it can kill stuff with one shot, I prefer the wraith

#69
HolyAvenger

HolyAvenger
  • Members
  • 13 848 messages
Crowbar is OP, needs a nerf.

#70
RoundedPlanet88

RoundedPlanet88
  • Members
  • 1 671 messages

HolyAvenger wrote...

Crowbar is OP, needs a nerf.


It`s not even out yet, its already starting to sound like another krysae Posted Image

#71
Oni Changas

Oni Changas
  • Banned
  • 3 350 messages
Yeah, GL op, Claymoar is the most balanced gun in the game. Derek Hollan (IIRC) once stated as much when some whining n00b made a nerf (or nuthin!) thread months back.

#72
Zero132132

Zero132132
  • Members
  • 7 916 messages

RoundedPlanet88 wrote...

Deerber wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.

Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:

What gets me is how illogical people are over it, nobody even TRIES arguing for it to not be nerfed logically, which really says alot, about the power, and about the BSN Posted Image

That isn't true. You may have missed rational responses because you kind of wanted to, but there are a list of things people use when claiming TC is brutally overpowered.

1. It can deflect aggro, increasing survivability.
2. It means that infiltrators don't have to care about weight capacity at all, because you can get a constant 3 second cooldown.
3. It can globally boost damage for 2.5 seconds, so that means you get boosted damage nearly 50% of the time WTF!

Nobody notes that point 1 is absolutely in contradiction with 2 and 3. If you use an infiltrator with -200% cooldown speed, then you have to decloak immediately or run the risk of getting a 20+ second cooldown, so instead of survivability, you just get an interruption of shield regeneration. The same's true if you want the nearly constant damage boost implied by 3. You also ignore that if you miss cancelling cloak by portions of a second on -200% cooldown speed, you get a pretty big departure from 3 seconds.

People promoting a TC nerf have also said bizarre things like "if we replaced it with submission net on every infiltrator, they'd all be teh suck!" I won't distort your position by claiming that's absolutely everyone that wants a TC nerf, because that would be stupid. Please don't do the same. And don't go claiming it's my personal crutch class. The only Infiltrator I really like is the Human anyways, so I can avoid playing them very easily. I prefer adepts and vanguards, truthfully. Nerf away. I won't get mad. I just don't think people are realistic in how they argue over TC's strengths and weaknesses.

This isn't a discussion about TC nerfing, though. Something about the Claymore?

Yeah, what a beast of a weapon.

Modifié par Zero132132, 16 janvier 2013 - 06:00 .


#73
llandwynwyn

llandwynwyn
  • Members
  • 3 801 messages
I know it's a joke thread, but if any shotgun needs to be nerfed it's the reegar. At least, remove headshot dmg.

tictactucrac wrote...
Seriously, claymore has sniper range with smart choke + GI/destroyer/Marksman. This is not fair. And reload cancel is way too fast on the claymore.


So you would make life harder for other classes because of 3?

#74
RoundedPlanet88

RoundedPlanet88
  • Members
  • 1 671 messages

Zero132132 wrote...

RoundedPlanet88 wrote...

Deerber wrote...

Annomander wrote...

I think tactical cloak should be nerfed if its tears we are looking for.

Nothing gets BSN's panties in a bunch like talk of tactical cloak nerfs.

Because then me and Feneckus would just sit back and laugh our asses off as BSN explodes.

Harrier / claymore nerfs would create tears on the BSN, but nothing would stir up a gargantuan sh*tstorm like nerfing every n00bs favourite crutch.

Yes, but that should not be a joke, but a true nerf :happy:

What gets me is how illogical people are over it, nobody even TRIES arguing for it to not be nerfed logically, which really says alot, about the power, and about the BSN Posted Image

That isn't true. You may have missed rational responses because you kind of wanted to, but there are a list of things people use when claiming TC is brutally overpowered.

1. It can deflect aggro, increasing survivability.
2. It means that infiltrators don't have to care about weight capacity at all, because you can get a constant 3 second cooldown.
3. It can globally boost damage for 2.5 seconds, so that means you get boosted damage nearly 50% of the time WTF!

Nobody notes that point 1 is absolutely in contradiction with 2 and 3. If you use an infiltrator with -200% cooldown speed, then you have to decloak immediately or run the risk of getting a 20+ second cooldown, so instead of survivability, you just get an interruption of shield regeneration. The same's true if you want the nearly constant damage boost implied by 3. You also ignore that if you miss cancelling cloak by portions of a second on -200% cooldown speed, you get a pretty big departure from 3 seconds.

People promoting a TC nerf have also said bizarre things like "if we replaced it with submission net on every infiltrator, they'd all be teh suck!" I won't distort your position by claiming that's absolutely everyone that wants a TC nerf, because that would be stupid. Please don't do the same. And don't go claiming it's my personal crutch class. The only Infiltrator I really like is the Human anyways, so I can avoid playing them very easily. I prefer adepts and vanguards, truthfully. Nerf away. I won't get mad. I just don't think people are realistic in how they argue over TC's strengths and weaknesses.

This isn't a discussion about TC nerfing, though. Something about the Claymore?

Yeah, what a beast of a weapon.

Read my post again. Theres a "not" modifier. I actually SUPPORT a Tac cloak overhaul. If you`d actually READ my post, youd have seen that.
And heres is what I said "nobody even TRIES arguing for it to not be nerfed logically"

#75
kipac

kipac
  • Members
  • 3 350 messages
What is this? What am I reading? Am I reading it right? Am I indoctrinated? Am I seeing star child's space sorcery right now?