86 réponses à ce sujet

[dorktainian]

dayron669 wrote...

Sure. Then a video showing how the rubble is the exact material from the Citadel surfaced.

Also is the mere idea that FALLING FROM SPACE would leave a person ... you know... dead.

 


yep.  dead.

if you do a slow mo on the rubble scene you will see that the concrete (yes it's concrete) has markings on it.  markings very similar to....... and behind shepard in the distance is one of those..............nah why spoil it for you.  

[IMNOTCRAZYiminsane]

Cthulhu42 wrote...

Shepards's in the magical land of speculation and imagination.

You there yeah you! YOU R AMAZING!

[Peranor]

I think that Bioware's intention is that Shepard is still on the Citadel in the breath scene.
But it doesn't matter. Earth or Citadel. He still should be torn to pieces and dead as a doornail.

Modifié par anorling, 27 janvier 2013 - 08:46 .

[GreyLycanTrope]

anorling wrote...



I think that Bioware's intention is that Shepard is still on the Citadel in the breath scene.
But it doesn't matter. Earth or Citadel. He still should be torn to pieces and dead as a doornail.

Or at the very least not be breathing for much longer.

[Han Shot First]

CynicalShep wrote...

Pretty sure one of the Bioware employees (was it Merizan?) said that he was "still on the Citadel"

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

We won't know until the last DLC.

[vandalDX]

Wayning_Star wrote...

I dunno OP, seems to me Shep cannot be in two places at once and in a different set of armor.

I vote on the ground myself, communing with the Catalyst somehow, like with the Levi.

This.  That's what I thought the second I played Leviathan, and saw that the Catalyst's dialogue was different.

[EpicBoot2daFace]

TheCrazyHobo wrote...

When ME3 first came out, people were completely confused to what the breath scene meant. In the scene we saw Shepherd in what looks exactly like concrete and rebar and we heard the wind howling in the background. Those two elements lead people to believe he was not on the Citadel, but rather on the war-torn Earth were wind and destroyed concrete are common place.

It's possible he was transported back to London whe the beam was. Granted, I don't know how, but... this is science fiction.

[SirLugash]

I don't know where Shepard is, I only know that being on the Citadel seems ridiculous. After shooting the tube in the destroy ending, you can somewhat see that after the explosion that blows Shepard backwards (followed by the activation of the Crucible) there is no more Shepard (in fact, with Flycam you can see scorch marks where Shepard stood but I wouldn't count this in).
But even when Shepard somehow survived that (you know, heavily wounded, damaged armor, no shields) I'm sure he can't possibly survive that 13+ km wide explosion that follows the beam discharge (not counting any radiation in).
Also I can't wrap my head around how EMS should affect this.

[Peranor]

Han Shot First wrote...

CynicalShep wrote...

Pretty sure one of the Bioware employees (was it Merizan?) said that he was "still on the Citadel"

It was she who said that, yes.

[Vrin]

There is one Theory which explains this perfectly but discussing it will get the thread locked soooooo.....

[iOnlySignIn]

Of course she's still.

A person as close to death as that had better stay still.

[CoolioThane]

He's on Earth.

[N7Keller]

SirLugash wrote...

I don't know where Shepard is, I only
know that being on the Citadel seems ridiculous. After shooting the tube
in the destroy ending, you can somewhat see that after the explosion
that blows Shepard backwards (followed by the activation of the
Crucible) there is no more Shepard (in fact, with Flycam you can see
scorch marks where Shepard stood but I wouldn't count this in).
But
even when Shepard somehow survived that (you know, heavily wounded,
damaged armor, no shields) I'm sure he can't possibly survive that 13+
km wide explosion that follows the beam discharge (not counting any
radiation in).
Also I can't wrap my head around how EMS should affect this.

Higher
EMS means that more of the crucible is intact, making it more
controlled. It means that the explosion from the beam wasn't as strong
if you have a more intact crucible.

On Topic:

The citadel
doesn't explode. The Death Star explodes, the Citadel breaks apart.
There is a huge difference. Like with the relays, they don't exploded,
they just break apart.

The reason people say Earth, is because
the rubble looks like concrete. It could have been an over site. Maybe
they thought it would look better.

You have to suspend logic for
this scene. Just like when Shepard was brought back to life after being
spaced and colliding with a planet.

[noobcannon]

IT. yeah i said it.

Modifié par noobcannon, 27 janvier 2013 - 11:54 .

[BansheeOwnage]

Vrin wrote...

There is one Theory which explains this perfectly but discussing it will get the thread locked soooooo.....

I know right. I thought this was a forum, where we could discuss things. I also thought Casey Hudson wanted us to speculate. Apparently, the BSN's mods feel differently.

[noobcannon]

Vrin wrote...

There is one Theory which explains this perfectly but discussing it will get the thread locked soooooo.....

yeah but if you start it off with "my shepard..." then you're okay.

a) my shepard chose synthesis because he is a leprechaun - CORRECT

I chose synthesis because shepard is a leprechaun - INCORRECT

Modifié par noobcannon, 27 janvier 2013 - 11:58 .

[Haargel]

You're talking about Commander Shepard, I'm pretty sure he could survive the epicenter of a Nuclear Blast.

[BleedingUranium]

Earth.

[Steelcan]

It defies logic but I think he's on the Citadel

[katamuro]

before ec the citadel was in pieces some of it falling to earth. Since ec came out the citadel is still in one piece.

[noobcannon]

anorling wrote...

Han Shot First wrote...

CynicalShep wrote...

Pretty sure one of the Bioware employees (was it Merizan?) said that he was "still on the Citadel"

It was she who said that, yes.

merizan is not part of the development team, she's a community manager. when she said that she was no more knowlegable on the plans, future, or meaning of mass effect than we were.

Modifié par noobcannon, 28 janvier 2013 - 12:28 .

[spirosz]

And we're back to 101.

[Peranor]

Haargel wrote...

You're talking about Commander Shepard, I'm pretty sure he could survive the epicenter of a Nuclear Blast.

Apparently he can. Don't ask me how, but the breath scene is there to show it :happy:

[Reorte]

Look, he's on the Citadel, he's alive. Of course it all falls apart if you actually think about it (you really have to try hard not to think about it yetyou also need to think "this scene wouldn't be here otherwise") and so, like everything ME3 ending related it's a hopeless badly thought out mess where you're supposed to go on what the authors intended instead of what they actually showed, but yeah, Citadel.

Modifié par Reorte, 28 janvier 2013 - 01:04 .