396 réponses à ce sujet

[Seboist]

dreamgazer wrote...

Meh.

She should have had more to do with the Cerberus side of the plot in ME3, simply from a story standpoint, but she did little for me as a character from the get-go. Interesting idea, limp execution.

It's pretty peculiar how the hardest to kill squadmate in ME2 just gets a bit role in 3 unlike Tali and Garrus and in spite of the large focus on Cerb.

[Steelcan]

But we HAD to have the VS and Liara back

[spirosz]

StreetMagic wrote...

You know it's bad when a Jack fan (like myself and some here) are bemoaning Miranda's role (or lack thereof).

Were you hear when some Jackolytes back in the day were fullout defending her character for a while?  T'was good times.  

I love Miranda, but viewing it from a certain perspective - you can see certain "dull" aspects of her character, but if you look past that and really want to (that's the key) - you can find very interesting character development throughout her character, like any other character Bioware developed.  It really all depends on how you relate to them too, that's why I find certain characters more interesting than others, I see apart of myself in them.   

[spirosz]

You can easily say - all her development was related to her "daddy issues" sure, especially the writing in ME3, pre-Citadel DLC and that is fine, but I find it unfair to her character.

[themikefest]

I like Miranda. She is more interesting than a few other squadmates.

I used her all the time in ME2. She is very tough.

Its unfortunate she wasn't a squadmate in ME3

[dreamgazer]

Steelcan wrote...

But we HAD to have the VS and Liara back

Well, yeah. 

[dreamgazer]

StreetMagic wrote...

You know it's bad when a Jack fan (like myself and some here) are bemoaning Miranda's role (or lack thereof).

I think, at the very least, she should have subbed (been an option to sub) for EDI at Cronos had she been alive. 

[ImaginaryMatter]

Liara and VS were bound to be back as they were the only two previous squadmates who couldn't be killed off at any point. I also suspect this is partly why Liara's role in the game is so massive.

Having said that I'm surprised Miranda's role wasn't bigger. I could be wrong but I believe that she is the hardest ME2 squadmate to bump off during the Suicide Mission.

[ImaginaryMatter]

dreamgazer wrote...

StreetMagic wrote...

You know it's bad when a Jack fan (like myself and some here) are bemoaning Miranda's role (or lack thereof).

I think, at the very least, she should have subbed (been an option to sub) for EDI at Cronos had she been alive. 

Shepard: "Hey, Miranda, aka the-only-person-we-know-who-has-visited-Cerberus-HQ. Mind going with us on the most important mission ever? Your sister can wait."

[jtav]

The problem isn't squad status or lack thereof. The problem is that I find ME3 Miranda pathetic and rather selfish. I have no particular reason to think that would change if she were on the squad and I wouldn't just get more of what I hate.

[dreamgazer]

ImaginaryMatter wrote...

Liara and VS were bound to be back as they were the only two previous squadmates who couldn't be killed off at any point. I also suspect this is partly why Liara's role in the game is so massive.

I don't think that requires much suspicion: she's a concrete factor in a unique position. 

Modifié par dreamgazer, 13 janvier 2014 - 10:51 .

[Axdinosaurx]

dreamgazer wrote...

StreetMagic wrote...

You know it's bad when a Jack fan (like myself and some here) are bemoaning Miranda's role (or lack thereof).

I think, at the very least, she should have subbed (been an option to sub) for EDI at Cronos had she been alive. 

Right? I mean she has been to chronos before, why the hell couldn't she take us there? She could have just told us where it was without needing to put a tracer on Kai lame.

[spirosz]

Remember broskies, the squad has no "permanence" in ME3.

[Br3admax]

Axdinosaurx wrote...

dreamgazer wrote...

StreetMagic wrote...

You know it's bad when a Jack fan (like myself and some here) are bemoaning Miranda's role (or lack thereof).

I think, at the very least, she should have subbed (been an option to sub) for EDI at Cronos had she been alive. 

Right? I mean she has been to chronos before, why the hell couldn't she take us there? She could have just told us where it was without needing to put a tracer on Kai lame.

The space station moves and it is in front of a giant radioactive star. No thanks. 

[dreamgazer]

spirosz wrote...

Remember broskies, the squad has no "permanence" in ME3.

I actually sympathize with this problem quite a bit, but not in that situation.  

Just about every task that EDI accomplishes, Miranda could have.  Tweak the Illusive Man convo at the end of the mission, and bam. 

[spirosz]

dreamgazer wrote...

spirosz wrote...

Remember broskies, the squad has no "permanence" in ME3.

I actually sympathize with this problem quite a bit, but not in that situation.  

Just about every task that EDI accomplishes, Miranda could have.  Tweak the Illusive Man convo at the end of the mission, and bam. 

But Jack.  

[dreamgazer]

spirosz wrote...

dreamgazer wrote...

spirosz wrote...

Remember broskies, the squad has no "permanence" in ME3.

I actually sympathize with this problem quite a bit, but not in that situation.  

Just about every task that EDI accomplishes, Miranda could have.  Tweak the Illusive Man convo at the end of the mission, and bam. 

But Jack.  

What about her, spispi? 

[Br3admax]

I let Jack turn into a phantom, to be honest.

[spirosz]

She deserved to see that cabin one more time!