Steelcan wrote...
. You'd have to ask someone with an active moral compass. Mine's broken. I don't give two ****s about killing the geth or EDIJadebaby wrote...
Strangely enough, that's my favourite ending to the trilogy. How terrible is that?
Jadebaby wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
. You'd have to ask someone with an active moral compass. Mine's broken. I don't give two ****s about killing the geth or EDIJadebaby wrote...
Strangely enough, that's my favourite ending to the trilogy. How terrible is that?
I already knew that about you... Guess I'll have to choose Synthesis and reprogram you..
Davik Kang wrote...
Yeah but what could we have had then? Shep building a house with Tali? What if I wanted Shep to go hunt down Kasumi instead? How about a retirement shack on a beach somewhere? But my Sheoard would never retire!! etc. etc.LineHolder wrote...
Well since this thread is about the breath scene, people want an adequate elaboration on it because all other endings are unambiguous about Sheps fate. I admit that I'd like that too.
Especially when the EC talks about the Geth and Quarians returning to Rannoch and Grunt and Wrex returning to Tuchanka which keeping the state of the relays in mind means that a lit of time has passed. Wouldnt the fate of the savior of the galaxy be determined by these people if he was alive? And if he isnt going to survive or be found what is the point of that scene? That is where you are being asked to headcanon.
Thats what the criticism is about as far as I can tell.
The straightforward implication of the scene is that Shepard lives on, but if it makes a more poetic ending to your journey that Shepard perished there, knowing the Reapers were finally defeated, or whatever, it's fine. It's cool. You can't expect Bioware to come out and say that people who thought that are wrong. Of course they will dodge questions like this. Trying to read something into CP's (or anyone else's) comments is entirely pointless. And he even came into this thread to reiterate that!
. Whatever you say:devil:fiendishchicken wrote...
Well, I look at the deaths of EDI and the Geth, and balance that with the deaths of the Reapers.Jadebaby wrote...
I already knew that about you... Guess I'll have to choose Synthesis and reprogram you..Steelcan wrote...
. You'd have to ask someone with an active moral compass. Mine's broken. I don't give two ****s about killing the geth or EDIJadebaby wrote...
Strangely enough, that's my favourite ending to the trilogy. How terrible is that?
Also Steelcan, I wouldn't say you have a broken moral compass. I'd just say that you aren't quite to the point to have really realized the real ethics and morality behind actions yet.
iakus wrote...
The scene is simply too vague. For a lot of people you have to metagame to understand that this means Shepard lives.
Modifié par CronoDragoon, 08 février 2013 - 06:50 .
CronoDragoon wrote...
iakus wrote...
The scene is simply too vague. For a lot of people you have to metagame to understand that this means Shepard lives.
It's not vague at all. Sorry. When someone takes a breath that means they are alive. People claiming otherwise are the ones meta-gaming, either as justification for a reunion scene or because their preferred ending includes Shepard dying.
CronoDragoon wrote...
iakus wrote...
The scene is simply too vague. For a lot of people you have to metagame to understand that this means Shepard lives.
It's not vague at all. Sorry. When someone takes a breath that means they are alive. People claiming otherwise are the ones meta-gaming, either as justification for a reunion scene or because their preferred ending includes Shepard dying.
fiendishchicken wrote...
BW wants us to speculate.
We don't want to speculate.
only because no one was validating Casey and Mac's pet endings......Captain_Obvious wrote...
fiendishchicken wrote...
BW wants us to speculate.
We don't want to speculate.
This, this and this. 1000 times this.
you are being obtuse as I have a dev quote stating that that IS the Shepard lives ending....and that dev got it from the project lead so....BEFORE the ec btwjfeth713 wrote...
The breathe scene was an easter egg, a bonus, whatever you want to call it before the EC. There were not enough war assets to get the scene Pre-EC without playing MP. If people weren't upset about the ending, if the EC had never been created, the breath scene would still be locked behind mp.
Bioware was not lying when they said before the game's release that everything could be obtained and seen without mp. The breath scene was not originally meant to be part of any ending. When they said ME3 would be the end of Shepard's story they meant it. Shepard was dead in all endings Pre-EC. They only changed it because people complained that choices and colors aside the endings were too bleak because Shepard was dead in all of them.
Modifié par crimzontearz, 08 février 2013 - 08:23 .
The scene was originally only obtainable through playing mp. I beat the game twice prior to the EC, picking destroy both times. Having damn near maxedd out the war assets I never got the breath scene. So if they're to be believed that nobody would get punished for not playing mp then the scene was a bonus I couldn't get because i didn't play MP and prior to the EC my Shepard was dead through no fault of my own.crimzontearz wrote...
you are being obtuse as I have a dev quote stating that that IS the Shepard lives ending....and that dev got it from the project lead so....BEFORE the etc btw
but whatever
The dev in question told me also everyone was told (within the team) the scene was obtainable with SP alone and that NG+ would make it easier. yes I have direct quotes of that toojfeth713 wrote...
The scene was originally only obtainable through playing mp. I beat the game twice prior to the EC, picking destroy both times. Having damn near maxedd out the war assets I never got the breath scene. So if they're to be believed that nobody would get punished for not playing mp then the scene was a bonus I couldn't get because i didn't play MP and prior to the EC my Shepard was dead through no fault of my own.crimzontearz wrote...
you are being obtuse as I have a dev quote stating that that IS the Shepard lives ending....and that dev got it from the project lead so....BEFORE the etc btw
but whatever
Modifié par crimzontearz, 08 février 2013 - 08:46 .
CronoDragoon wrote...
iakus wrote...
The scene is simply too vague. For a lot of people you have to metagame to understand that this means Shepard lives.
It's not vague at all. Sorry. When someone takes a breath that means they are alive. People claiming otherwise are the ones meta-gaming, either as justification for a reunion scene or because their preferred ending includes Shepard dying.
I know I amBirdsallSa wrote...
Funny that some of you have the audacity to speak of moral compasses. If you picked anything other than Synthesis you're morally bankrupt. How dare you try and lecture others chicken.
BirdsallSa wrote...
We need Synthesis to stop people like the destroyers from tearing society apart. People who would charge blindly to destroy the Reapers and The Intelligence who have done nothing but dedicate themselves to preserving life.
Modifié par fiendishchicken, 08 février 2013 - 08:54 .
get it right....it is a bridge not a holefiendishchicken wrote...
BirdsallSa wrote...
We need Synthesis to stop people like the destroyers from tearing society apart. People who would charge blindly to destroy the Reapers and The Intelligence who have done nothing but dedicate themselves to preserving life.
Useless troll is useless.
Go back to your hole, troll.
Useless poster is useless. Do you ever have anything interesting to discuss or do you just cry troll whenever someone disagrees with your nonsense?fiendishchicken wrote...
BirdsallSa wrote...
We need Synthesis to stop people like the destroyers from tearing society apart. People who would charge blindly to destroy the Reapers and The Intelligence who have done nothing but dedicate themselves to preserving life.
Useless troll is useless.
Go back to your hole, troll.
BirdsallSa wrote...
Funny that some of you have the audacity to speak of moral compasses. If you picked anything other than Synthesis you're morally bankrupt. How dare you try and lecture others chicken.
crimzontearz wrote...
get it right....it is a bridge not a holefiendishchicken wrote...
BirdsallSa wrote...
We need Synthesis to stop people like the destroyers from tearing society apart. People who would charge blindly to destroy the Reapers and The Intelligence who have done nothing but dedicate themselves to preserving life.
Useless troll is useless.
Go back to your hole, troll.
BirdsallSa wrote...
Useless poster is useless. Do you ever have anything interesting to discuss or do you just cry troll whenever someone disagrees with your nonsense?fiendishchicken wrote...
BirdsallSa wrote...
We need Synthesis to stop people like the destroyers from tearing society apart. People who would charge blindly to destroy the Reapers and The Intelligence who have done nothing but dedicate themselves to preserving life.
Useless troll is useless.
Go back to your hole, troll.
Retour en haut