713 réponses à ce sujet

[D1ck1e]

Best


Worst


^^ Too bad, I was into her

Modifié par D1ck1e, 14 février 2013 - 06:52 .

[Tootles FTW]

Best for FemShep:
Garrus

Best for MaleShep:
Bromance with Garrus

[Abraham_uk]

I guess "Bromances" count too.
In which case so do "sistermances".

[BizkitRebellion]

These are my honest opininons so please don't be mean :innocent:

Best
1. Liara Romance from ME1 to ME3 Faithful (Don't care what ANYBODY saids, also in my opinion her romance felt right as canon. oh I almost forgot she is one of the romances that wants to settle down in peace and have kids) *plus I only romance with her as Male Shep, sorry Fem Shep fans
2. Tali Romance from ME2 to ME3 (I wish she was a squadmate in the beginning of ME3 to extend the romance)
3. Kaidan with Fem Shep Romance from ME1 to ME3 Faithful (I was amazed his romance was done VERY WELL)
4. Garrus Romance from ME2 to ME3 (I wish there were more romance scenes)

Neutral
Thane Romance from ME2 to ME3 (it was good but it left me wanting more)
Ash Romance from ME1 to ME3 Faithful (I may hate her but I have to admit her romance was good but I wish she showed more caring and more Romance scenes in ME3) 

Worst
1. Jacob Romance from ME2 to ME3 (Do I really have to explain it?)
2.. Kelly Romance from ME2 to ME3 (She did not gave me a reason to romance with her to begin with)
3. Jack Romance from ME2 to ME3 (I miss Paragon romanceing Jack in ME2, it felt like you really mean something to her and it felt you can change her life for the better but in ME3 she only cares about getting Laid.)
4. Miranda Romance from ME2 to ME3 (I might get hate for this but let me explain. When I romance with her in ME2 I try to get to know her but al I hear is "Sister this, Father that". After I did her loyalty I was disapointed at how you "lock in" to her romance because the scene makes it look like Miranda just want sex. In ME3 I thought I can finally get to know her more but AGAIN "Sister this, Father that").
5. Morinth Romance (SHE KILLS YOU, WHAT THE ****)

I never romance:
Kaidan as Male Shep
Cortez
Diana

Wow thats alot of typing 
[/b]

Modifié par BizkitRebellion, 14 février 2013 - 07:03 .

[Abraham_uk]

Mark Alarton wrote...

Favourites: Miranda

Worst: Diana, is that even a romance? You know what I mean! She is the worst one anyways...

That one doesn't feature in my worst romances

She literally made no impression on me.
Just some journalist who (trying to think of a character trait). Nope can't think of any.

Still I didn't hate her.

I liked being interviewed on what I did.
I liked being able to justify my actions in a renegade or paragon way.
But Diana Allers is just bland.

[happy_daiz]

Favorite:
Kasumi and Keiji
Zaeed, even if it was only in my mind.

Least Favorite:
Jacob, in retrospect.

[Abraham_uk]

Cthulhu42 wrote...

Mouton_Alpha wrote...

I generally dislike romances in ME games, most of them felt kind of forced.

Morrigan, on the other hand...

Morrigan is win.

Morrigan on the other hand belongs on this thread.

[Mr.House]

Best:
Liara
Kaidan
Steve

Worst:
Jacob
Miranda
Jack
Thane
Jacob
Sam
Allers
Kelly

[Revenant147]

D1ck1e wrote...

Best

[Mouton_Alpha]

Abraham_uk wrote...

Cthulhu42 wrote...

Mouton_Alpha wrote...

I generally dislike romances in ME games, most of them felt kind of forced.

Morrigan, on the other hand...

Morrigan is win.

Morrigan on the other hand belongs on this thread.

No, she belongs on Normandy. Tent, fireplace, cauldron and all that.

[Gorwath-F]

Best: Gaby and Ken

Worst: Every single one with Shepard. Bioware romances are usually awkward. For the life of me, I can't understand why they seem to be the main selling point for many people.

[RZIBARA]

FOX216BC wrote...

 
Best as Malshep (my fav  shep by the way)


best as femshep



worst as male shep

I like Jack but in me2...
I felt raped and needed a shower asap.


Worst as femshep

We think alike lol! I dont play as femshep, but from what ive watched of them, i would agree on the female romances too

[stonbw1]

By the time I got to ME3, I'd say that Liara's connection to Shepard worked better as a dear friend, rather than a LI. Tali connection to Shepard seemed to grow from squadmate to friendship to an unquestionable love moreso than all the other LI. That romance seemed the most genuine/organic to me because of that growth.

[darthnick427]

Best Romances in the Game in terms of content and quality:

Liara, Tali, Garrus, Kaidan.

One's that needed more fleshing out in ME3 but were good in ME1/ME2 and very enjoyable:

Ash, Jack, Miranda, Thane.

Just suck in general. The Worst:

Jacob

Indifferent:

Kelly, Samantha, Cortez

Modifié par darthnick427, 14 février 2013 - 07:20 .

[Gfletch]

Best:
Femshep & Liara - canon or not, it just felt right throughout all three games.
Gabby & Ken - finally getting them together was nice.
Joker & EDI - I hated myself when I used Destroy. Joker's face while they fled the Citadel blast was... not nice to see.
Morinth. Hilarious.

Worst:
Jacob. He's just a disappointment throughout both games.
Kelly. It's fun, but in the end, she's just a big tease. Shepard wouldn't stand for that.
Miranda. Wasted potential.

Wishlist:
Samara - why the hell not, she even states in ME3 she's somewhat reformed and back to "normal".
EDI - I don't see why Joker gets to have all the fun.
James - quite a boring character unless you actually use him, then he becomes rather interesting. It's a shame that this was dropped.
Hackett. If only for the scene where he quits cuddles and strides off in his boxers, saying "Hackett out".

Modifié par Gfletch, 14 février 2013 - 07:24 .

[john-in-france]

I only play femshep...I just don't like playing male characters.

Best: Garrus and Thane are the best romances for me. Sad that the Thane romance was treated so badly in ME3.

Worst: Kaidan (First that **** on Horizon and then all the 'I don't trust you' cr4p at the beginning of ME3. No trust = No relationship. I now kill him on Virmire.

[Revenant147]

....ok, now that I've finished vomiting from OP's "best" romance...

Personal Favourites.

ME1: Liara
ME2: Miranda
ME3: Liara

Worst.

Jack.
Samara.
Jacob.

Indifferent to all of femsheps as I do not play as her.

Ones that I wish existed:

Dr Michel.
Kate Bowman.

[wright1978]

My favourite: Miranda

Worst
Jacob or Allers.

Ones i wish existed
Kasumi/Shiala

[CynicalShep]

wright1978 wrote...

My favourite: Miranda

Worst
Jacob or Allers.

Ones i wish existed
Kasumi/Shiala

This

[sr2josh]

Favorites
Tali - best personality of anyone in the trilogy and drunk dialing Javik was priceless
Liara - though I like Tali better, I kind of consider her to be my headcanon LI
Garrus - either as femShep or bromance with maleShep

Least Favorites
Miranda - the best LI in ME2 and the worst in ME3.  then she dumps you just before the final battle!
Ashley - in all three games she's just so childish and xenophobic.
EDI - her body was just ridiculous and Joker actually having a relationship with a robot is kinda creepy.

Wanted LI's
Kasumi - no explanation needed.
Shiala - green Asari!
Traynor - as a maleShep

[NeroonWilliams]

 I'd rank the Shepard Romances that I've completed like this (best to worst):

Tali                -  Felt like the most natural progression from squadmate to romance.
Garrus           -  The interaction was so sweet (except after all the cutscenes have played out).
Jack              -   I was truly touched by the vulnerability.
Liara              -  Not my favorite, but the (developers) work that went in pushes it higher.
Ashley           -  My first.  You never forget your first.
HeteroKaiden-  Good, all the way to the end.
Thane           -  This would be higher if just a little more had been done with it.
Samantha     -  Made even better by how she shoots down HetShep.
Miranda         -  Sorry, Mirimancers.  I personally never got past the Cerberus mistrust.
HomoKaiden -  Played an entire trilogy just to try this out and still creeped me out in the end.  It did bring a new                                      meaning to the ME1 conversations though.
Steve            -  Sweet and disturbing at the same time.  Being the rebound guy just didn't feel like a good thing.
Jacob            -  Cheater, cheater, pumpkin eater.  Plus dull the first time around.
Diana            -  Meh.
Morinth         -  You're special Shepard.  Flatline.

Honorable Mention: Mordin - My Kaiden seeking HomoShep talked almost exclusively with Mordin (in an effort to not lock anyone in) and got tactfully turned down by the good doctor a couple of missions before the end.  Hillarious.

Modifié par NeroonWilliams, 14 février 2013 - 07:55 .

[Cainhurst Crow]

Best romance - Depends
Worst romance - Jacob and Mornith.

[Little Princess Peach]

worst romance for me was Jacob, best kaidan

[BeastSaver]

Best:
Garrus - best content.
Thane - could have been better with more content. The goodbye scene at Huerta Memorial was lacking and would have liked more overall conversation before the coup.
Samantha - very sincere.
Kaidan

Worst:
Jacob - didn't actually romance. I couldn't get past my Shepard parking her hip on the table and flirt, "I just want to talk for a bit" or something like that. Ugh! He generally dies in ME2 anyway...
Kenneth and Gabby - Gabby is too good for Kenneth!