202 replies to this topic

[Whybother]

She was speechless that I took the renegade interrupt to make sure an Ardat Yakshi didn't escape from the monastery.

[o Ventus]

I would be too. There is literally zero reason to kill Falere.

[Whybother]

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

[Dean_the_Young]

o Ventus wrote...

I would be too. There is literally zero reason to kill Falere.

Well, there is, but it's the one the game pretends not to remember.

After all, what we players do if it was actually acknowledged that the Asari sent Shepard to carry out some ethnic cleansing in exchange for war assets?

[o Ventus]

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

She makes it clear as day that she doesn't intend for the Reapers to take her alive.

[MacroSpamMK]

o Ventus wrote...

I would be too. There is literally zero reason to kill Falere.

I agree. Killing Falere is murder.

[MegaSovereign]

Lol Killing Falere is as Renegade as you can get. It effectively makes Samara's suicide even more pointless.

[Whybother]

o Ventus wrote...

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

She makes it clear as day that she doesn't intend for the Reapers to take her alive.

I'm sure every Batarian and Human and Turian said the same thing before being converted into some nightmare.

[o Ventus]

Whybother wrote...

o Ventus wrote...

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

She makes it clear as day that she doesn't intend for the Reapers to take her alive.

I'm sure every Batarian and Human and Turian said the same thing before being converted into some nightmare.

Dead Ardat Yakshi don't make for good Banshees. Have you ever killed a Banshee?

[Seifer006]

HMMMMMM

maybe I should choose this option and see if she leaves my ship.......oh wait, I haven't played SP since EC

[Whybother]

The-Biotic-God wrote...

Lol Killing Falere is as Renegade as you can get. It effectively makes Samara's suicide even more pointless.

Is not preventing Samara's suicide renegade, or just being lazy?

[MacroSpamMK]

Whybother wrote...

o Ventus wrote...

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

She makes it clear as day that she doesn't intend for the Reapers to take her alive.

I'm sure every Batarian and Human and Turian said the same thing before being converted into some nightmare.

You'd probably find that most of them were civillians who had no idea what the "Ascension" meant. Falere has firsthand witnessed what happens to Ardat-Yakshi who get turned into Banshees. I'm sure if everyone was well enough informed on that matter, they'd all take their own lives instead of being converted.

[Mouton_Alpha]

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

Why not kill all the Krogan and Turians you meet as well? Brutes are pretty nasty.

[Whybother]

MacroSpamMK wrote...

You'd probably find that most of them were civillians who had no idea what the "Ascension" meant. Falere has firsthand witnessed what happens to Ardat-Yakshi who get turned into Banshees. I'm sure if everyone was well enough informed on that matter, they'd all take their own lives instead of being converted.

Which is exactly why I let Javik give his speech on the Citadel

[Whybother]

Mouton_Alpha wrote...

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

Why not kill all the Krogan and Turians you meet as well? Brutes are pretty nasty.

You mean like sabotaging the Genophage? :innocent:

[anmiro]

Whybother wrote...

MacroSpamMK wrote...

You'd probably find that most of them were civillians who had no idea what the "Ascension" meant. Falere has firsthand witnessed what happens to Ardat-Yakshi who get turned into Banshees. I'm sure if everyone was well enough informed on that matter, they'd all take their own lives instead of being converted.

Which is exactly why I let Javik give his speech on the Citadel

Ah, but everyone on the citadel dies anyway, so it really doesnt matter either way; your just scaring the crap out of people who are going to be blown up.

[Mouton_Alpha]

Whybother wrote...

Mouton_Alpha wrote...

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

Why not kill all the Krogan and Turians you meet as well? Brutes are pretty nasty.

You mean like sabotaging the Genophage? :innocent:

No, Genophage is irrelevant as it only prevents making more of them in a few years time. You have to kill each and every one you meet, or they will be turned into Brutes. Kill all humans too, just to be sure.

[crimzontearz]

I don't want any human to turn into husks

I don't want any turian to be turned into a marauder/brute

I don't want any rachni to be turned into a ravager

I don't want any krogan to be turned into a brute


I should kill everyone then

[dirtdiver32318]

o Ventus wrote...

I would be too. There is literally zero reason to kill Falere.

There is literally zero reason not to kill Falere

[davishepard]

anmiro wrote...

Ah, but everyone on the citadel dies anyway, so it really doesnt matter either way; your just scaring the crap out of people who are going to be blown up.

Not everyone dies on the Citadel.

[Whybother]

dirtdiver32318 wrote...

o Ventus wrote...

I would be too. There is literally zero reason to kill Falere.

There is literally zero reason not to kill Falere

"Why are Rila's eyes all black and why does she try to choke me? MOTHER?!?!?"

[eddieoctane]

o Ventus wrote...

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

She makes it clear as day that she doesn't intend for the Reapers to take her alive.

A lot of the colonists on Eden Prime looked pretty dead sitting on those Dragon's Teeth, yet they still became husks. Who says an Asari has to be alive to be Reaperized?

[o Ventus]

dirtdiver32318 wrote...

o Ventus wrote...

I would be too. There is literally zero reason to kill Falere.

There is literally zero reason not to kill Falere

Are you challenged?

[o Ventus]

eddieoctane wrote...

o Ventus wrote...

Whybother wrote...

Sure there is. You don't want her to be turned into a Banshee.

She makes it clear as day that she doesn't intend for the Reapers to take her alive.

A lot of the colonists on Eden Prime looked pretty dead sitting on those Dragon's Teeth, yet they still became husks. Who says an Asari has to be alive to be Reaperized?

Have you see killed a Banshee? Do you know why they dematerialize?

[cmessaz]

LOL, I just don't get this whole "amg why do you do such evil things in your game"... thing. I can totally understand personally not liking an option like this and never choosing to do it (I have done it for science), but to run around and say "that is murder" etc, that's an opinion, and people are entitled to their opinion, as is the op. I got the same crap when I hurt Alibear's feelings in DAO when I spared Loghain, and from many others when they find out I play renegade Shepard, and one of my playthroughs I sabotage the genophage. I find myself trying to defend that Shepard. Am I the only one who is able to RP just about anything depending on the situation? I like trying all the options in the games, then I kinda choose what to stick with in my canon.
For the one playthrough that I killed Felere, Samara had died in ME2 so obviously there was no suicide or attempted suicide. Shepard doesn't know Felere and Samara isn't there to help explain, so it honestly was not too bad to kill her. Shepard clearly feels like **** afterwards, but the Ardat Yakshi are dangerous even without the reapers, and without metagaming how do you know Felere isn't already indoctrinated. For me it was kind of the same as killing that scientist Asari in the first game (I forget her name) and that turned out to be a smart choice.
As for Liara's reaction, I didn't have her with Shep so I didn't see it. I imagine it would freak her out, that seems in character to me.