133 réponses à ce sujet

[Darth Death]

...Be killed by the main protagonist in DA3, would you do it? Would the choice be difficult to make?

[JCAP]

For moments I thought you would ask if he/she could be a romance option.

And no... I didn't really develop a bond with my Hawke but I would not kill him.

[Liamv2]

No

[Teddie Sage]

I refuse to kill my Hawke, fine if you hated him so much but I don't see the point in killing every NPCs you meet in this franchise. This is getting ridiculous.

[SurelyItsJames]

I think it'd be cool if he/she was a companion and it imported their personality from DA2

[Bob Garbage]

 I tend to play my first character as more of an extension of myself, meaning relatively good natured and someone who tries to ultimately do the right thing. So unless Hawke is trying to rape someone or is stealing candy from a child, I'd say he is safe from my wrath. Future playthroughs result in a lot of role playing, and I'd glady make a character who would kill Hawke without a second thought.

As for you people wondering why someone would role play a role playing game....well I never.

[Dhiro]

Since I don't subscribe to the idea that we should hate Hawke for no other reason than them not being the Warden, probably not.

[Darth Death]

Is it safe to say that Hawke was played diplomatically to those responding "No"? Has your Hawke in any playthrough killed his/her sibling or committed any other heinous acts? Retribution?

[Sanunes]

Personally, I rather Hawke not appear at all, for I think it will be a disappointment compared to what people are going to expect. As far as killing them, it will depend on the situation and story of the game, for if they are just walking down the street I wouldn't.

[Edit to fix my grammer]

Modifié par Sanunes, 19 février 2013 - 02:37 .

[ForThessia]

 Hell no. Dat Lady Hawke hipsway.

[Teddie Sage]

Darth Death wrote...

Is it safe to say that Hawke was played diplomatically to those responding "No"? Has your Hawke in any playthrough killed his/her sibling or committed any other heinous acts? Retribution?

I played a sarcastic and charming rogue male Hawke. Never killed his siblings, never did heinous acts. No retribution. My Hawke was a neutral good character and always helped people even if he didn't agree with the law all the time. He romanced Anders, didn't kill him because he would've supported him anyways. That world was due for a change and the templars needed to be punished. The chantry only had priests in it, for my personal headcanon, while the rest were hiding in their homes, already fled Kirkwall or hid in the Viscount's Keep.

Modifié par Teddie Sage, 19 février 2013 - 02:41 .

[Sith Grey Warden]

Teddie Sage wrote...

Darth Death wrote...

Is it safe to say that Hawke was played diplomatically to those responding "No"? Has your Hawke in any playthrough killed his/her sibling or committed any other heinous acts? Retribution?

I played a sarcastic and charming rogue male Hawke. Never played his siblings, never did heinous acts. No retribution. My Hawke was a neutral good character and always helped people even if he didn't agree with the law all the time. He romanced Anders, didn't kill him because he would've supported him anyways. That world was due for a change and the templars needed to be punished. The chantry only had priests in it, for my personal headcanon, while the rest were hiding in their homes, already fled Kirkwall or hid in the Viscount's Keep.

My Inquisitor would kill such a Hawke for his complicity in starting the war, probably assuming that he was
 in fact involved in blowing up the Chantry. After all, he didn't execute Anders for it.

[Sol Downer]

I played a sarcastic, charming rogue male Hawke (with brown skin, white eyes, and white hair). He put his family and friends above all else, but he was far from morally right. He killed for money, and only pretended to be an idiot because of the tactical advantage. In the end, he stood with his sister and the mages, even though he's technically dark side, he will not die. He does what's right when it counts, and does whatever suits him when it doesn't count.

[Teddie Sage]

Let's not start a war over who you would kill. This is just being immature.

[Cutlasskiwi]

Never. Despite Act III lacking a lot Hawke is one of my favorite protagonists in a game.

[Fast Jimmy]

This is a silly question.

Asking "would you kill Hawke" is like asking "would you kill Shale or Allistair?" You are giving us no context. Are we just slaughtering Hawke to be spiteful and for the lolz, or are we blocked from achieving a better goal by Hawke's presence? Has Hawke been corrupted or turned to the dark side? If not, is our character SERVING the dark side?

If you are asking if people would have a problem killing a former character they've played, if they had good reason, then maybe flesh the scenario out a little. As of right now, all I'm imagining is if the first time we see Hawke doing nothing at all, but for some reason are given a Murder Knife option, would we take it... to which I would say no, because I don't usually just Murder Knife people all willy nilly. I would be no more likely to Murder Knife Hawke than I would be to Murder Knife any other random character.

[Darth Death]

Ultimashade wrote...

I played a sarcastic, charming rogue male Hawke (with brown skin, white eyes, and white hair). He put his family and friends above all else, but he was far from morally right. He killed for money, and only pretended to be an idiot because of the tactical advantage. In the end, he stood with his sister and the mages, even though he's technically dark side, he will not die. He does what's right when it counts, and does whatever suits him when it doesn't count.

I really like this post since it illustrates a bunch of gray areas in your experience with Hawke. Thanks for sharing. 

[Leo]

No Way! I really liked Hawke, and honestly I'd rather Hawke only get a mention instead of a cameo.

[Dominus]

As mentioned above, the concept without any context is going to feel contrived. Perhaps it's a case of "I support Templars, you support Mages, let's duke it out". As far as the question of would I do it, I explore every option for plot branches*. So naturally, yes.

*And if not, I can always YouTube it later or something. Hurray to the internet.

Modifié par DominusVita, 19 février 2013 - 02:55 .

[Sir George Parr]

I just would be incapable of killing lady hawke.

[Renmiri1]

Never!

[Felya87]

depends on "why would I kill Hawke?" I really don't love her very much, even with all the good will to give her a chance, I really don't find her to be my character.
But I would not kill her just for fun. If given a good reason to do so. example: she is arrested to have helped Anders and the mage and is condamned to death. we as inquisitor should decide her fate.
I think I would save her or not only depending on the kind of character I'm playng.
a chance like others. nothing more, and nothing less. Just like Zevran in DA:O. you can let him live or kill him.

even if a lot af time I would like to see one of my Wardens kill her just for the residual rage I still have about DA2, i don't think she would be dead too many time.

[Darth Death]

DominusVita wrote...

As mentioned above, the concept without any context is going to feel contrived. Perhaps it's a case of "I support Templars, you support Mages, let's duke it out". As far as the question of would I do it, I explore every option for plot branches*. So naturally, yes.

*And if not, I can always YouTube it later or something. Hurray to the internet.

Both Ultimashade & Sith Grey Warden supplied the context without my intervention. This is what I wanted from the start. I wanted to see who would think outside the box with little to go on. 

EDIT: Actually now that I look back, I've supplied the context in my second post. Some failed to read it. 

Modifié par Darth Death, 19 février 2013 - 03:25 .

[Sol Downer]

Darth Death wrote...

Ultimashade wrote...

I played a sarcastic, charming rogue male Hawke (with brown skin, white eyes, and white hair). He put his family and friends above all else, but he was far from morally right. He killed for money, and only pretended to be an idiot because of the tactical advantage. In the end, he stood with his sister and the mages, even though he's technically dark side, he will not die. He does what's right when it counts, and does whatever suits him when it doesn't count.

I really like this post since it illustrates a bunch of gray areas in your experience with Hawke. Thanks for sharing. 

You're quite welcome.