Aller au contenu

Photo

Is the majority of the ME community still hurt from ME3 debacle?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
205 réponses à ce sujet

#201
Benchpress610

Benchpress610
  • Members
  • 823 messages

GiarcYekrub wrote...

No what I'm saying why get angry about your own personal head canon? Why blame Bioware for inconsistencies in your head canon? What I'm saying may not be true but nothing in the game contradicts it as far as I'm aware

LOL, So you believe its word? Even if you do lets take a look those statements:

“The Citadel is part of me”,
This would be true of a VI, Avina could even use this statement

“I created the Reapers” &“they are MY solution”
Its not unusual for VI's to use the first person when refering to its imprinter, both Vigil and the Thessia VI refer to the actions of the Protheans in the first person. Even the Shepard VI on the citadel says "I am commander Shepard"  and refers to Shepards exploits as its own.

“I control them”
If the Citadel is part of him, then he is in fact saying  the Citadel can control them,  this is the essence of the
control choice however it requires Shepard to issue the commands. The fact the Citadel/Crucible/Shepard combo can control them is not in dispute and clearly shown in game.

Where was he in ME1? For me inactive waiting to be pluged into the crucible.
The keepers maintained the citadel and were supposed to repond to Soveriegn signal to open the relay to dark space but were prevented by the Protheans from Ilos. I don't see how contradicts anything.


First: who’s angry?...I’m certainly not…are you? Second: I’m not head-cannoning (gee…we are making a verb out this crap), I’m taking whatever drivel came out of the writers' head at face value. Up to that moment ME was a straight-forward linear story. There is no reason to assume anything other that what’s being said. Any inconsistencies came out of BW’s writers, not my head.  
 
You even admit your assumptions may not be true. If it suits your head-cannon that start-brat is a VI with no real input in the endgame, go ahead, it’s your prerogative…Hey, I can head-cannon that I own this company and I can come and go as I please. However, my boss might have a different idea…Image IPB
 
Again, your answers to my questions are all conjecture and speculation. Nothing based in solid facts as per game story and lore. Because you are speculating, don’t assume everybody else is. If you can’t comprehend this basic point, I’m afraid we are thinking in completely different levels and thus there is no use to keep arguing. Besides it’s off topic.  
 

#202
nevar00

nevar00
  • Members
  • 1 395 messages
"Hurt"? Eh not exactly. The game as a whole was extremely disappointing though and I've basically given up on the series. Haven't bought any DLC and have no interest in ME 4.

#203
Benchpress610

Benchpress610
  • Members
  • 823 messages

SpamBot2000 wrote...


I'm still hurt by it. And still offended. Because it seems obvious that the ending was not made in good faith, as a lawyer might put it. Just a cynical torch job designed to terminate the setting, sold with a campaign of lies and misrepresentations. This is how little they thought of their audience. And some have indeed proven worthy of that estimation.

Indeed.

#204
AlanC9

AlanC9
  • Members
  • 35 618 messages

GiarcYekrub wrote...

SpamBot2000 wrote...

I'm still hurt by it. And still offended. Because it seems obvious that the ending was not made in good faith, as a lawyer might put it. Just a cynical torch job designed to terminate the setting, sold with a campaign of lies and misrepresentations. This is how little they thought of their audience. And some have indeed proven worthy of that estimation.


Think you played a completely different game to me


In the end, we all play completely different games.

#205
Reth Shepherd

Reth Shepherd
  • Members
  • 1 437 messages

AlanC9 wrote...

GiarcYekrub wrote...

SpamBot2000 wrote...

I'm still hurt by it. And still offended. Because it seems obvious that the ending was not made in good faith, as a lawyer might put it. Just a cynical torch job designed to terminate the setting, sold with a campaign of lies and misrepresentations. This is how little they thought of their audience. And some have indeed proven worthy of that estimation.


Think you played a completely different game to me


In the end, we all play completely different games.


No, in the end we all play completely identical games. It's the middle that has a few pieces of minor variations.

#206
Cobretti ftw

Cobretti ftw
  • Members
  • 548 messages
HUrt? nope. Just disapointed.

I replaced ME for Star trek online after that disapointment.

Modifié par Cobretti ftw, 21 février 2013 - 06:25 .