Jonny_Evil wrote...
Darth Obvious wrote...
But within the English language (in other words, comparing two or more English language accents) it doesn’t really make sense to say “English accent”. We ALL have an English accent, so to speak. So we differentiate: it could be an American accent, or an Irish one, or an Australian one, or a “British” one. It may not be the most accurate term, but that doesn’t matter. It represents something within our culture, and that’s precisely what language is supposed to do.
Again, it just seems like you are missing the entire point of my obviously harmless statements.
*sigh*
I'm not missing your point, I understand completely where you're coming from and I don't think you're out to annoy, but I'm just trying to get across to you what your argument says to an English person.
My country is England, my language is English and my accent is an English one. The above quote says to me "America is a country, Ireland is a country, Australia is a country, but England doesn't exist."
I'm not offended by being called British, I'm not arguing points with you for the hell of it. An English accent is an English accent no matter where you're from in the English speaking world. England and Britain are no longer synonymous, there is literally no such thing as a British accent no matter how misinformed anyone may be. All you're doing to me is repeatedly denying my country's right to it's own accent, on the basis of "that's what we've always called it".
Tell me, do you still call people from Russia Soviets?
There is no argument here. Several English people have grumbled about the accent being called a British accent. Every time before now when I've corrected the use of the term people have just said "Sorry, I didn't know", you're the first I've ever encountered that's tried to argue it's use. The bottom line is an English person has asked you to stop using it, so why are you arguing for it's use?
Yeah I know it seems petty to you, but just imagine your annoyance if the next ethnic monitoring form you have to fill out has Canada, Mexico and North America as it's only choices. I'm not even joking with that, I recently filled one in where the choices were Scottish, Irish, Welsh and White British.<_<soteria wrote...
It actually makes pretty good sense to
call it an English accent. The country has been known as England for a
long time, right? Britain is the land, and doesn't really refer to the
English specifically.
England has been called that for 1500 years nearly. Britain is only slightly older than America and refers to the Isles as a whole, adopted after England and Scotland signed the Act of Union.
Okay, please let this go. A few pages back I made a comment about using a British accent when playing the game. At the time I almost used the term "Scottish" accent until I realized that it wasn't really Scottish but more of a hodge podge of accents used from the British Isles. I then used the term "British." As a resident of the U.S., I can see the original point, however, in lieu of the discussion I would say that to be more specific would be the way to go. As a resident of the United States South, I don't like stereotypical accents. I don't like hearing a bunch of Georgian accents placed in Louisiana. So just let England be England with all of their varying accents (Staffordshire, Manchester, cockney, Scouse...whatever. I mean no offense to my English brethren in my ignorance if I got something wrong there.) Just let it lie at Scottish, Irish, Welsh, whatever. Out of curiosity, I skipped a page in this thread..So to all the people of Spain, does the Spanish/Catalonian difference come into play?





Retour en haut







