Aller au contenu

Photo

Citadel DLC - Post your feedback and thoughts here


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1382 réponses à ce sujet

#576
PinkToolTheater

PinkToolTheater
  • Members
  • 151 messages
I have finished the conspiracy and am currently gathering people for the party.

So far:
- Really funny. Some stuff made me laugh really loud.
- Really awesome, just feels cool stealthing with a pistol and hacking stuff.
- The ending of the conspiracy kinda made me feel sad ;( with clone Shep having no friends... damn

Biggest disadvantage:
- No ME2 squad mates during the conspiracy mission as far as I can tell? Couldn't use Jack, Miranda, Samara etc... :|

Overall: Still great

#577
StElmo

StElmo
  • Members
  • 4 997 messages
Excellent overall 10/10

I presume all of the mystery yet to be uncovered from ME3 (origin of the citadel, keepers, how the catalyst couldn't implement his solution without shepard, who created the cruciable etc.) would be for future games to explain.

Which is fine :) Nothing wrong with a bit of mystery I suppose :) great twists in the DLC itself though, so great job BioWare 10/10!

Modifié par StElmo, 07 mars 2013 - 05:50 .


#578
Teddie Sage

Teddie Sage
  • Members
  • 6 754 messages
You know what I regret the most from the Clone's part of the Citadel DLC? Not being able to convince it to stay with you as a twin. I would've loved that my Shepard asked him/her to stay with him as his brother/sister. I think that would've been cute and would've gave purpose to the new Shepard to be part of somebody's life. Cheesy, I know. But I think my Shepard would've loved to have a sibling.

#579
ebevan91

ebevan91
  • Members
  • 1 511 messages
Am I missing something? I haven't been able to invite Garrus, Jacob, Zaeed, Grunt, or Kasumi over, yet, not even my LI, Ashley.

I keep leaving the Citadel (going to the Normandy) and coming back to see if I have new messages or invites, but I'm not getting any.

#580
DeepChild

DeepChild
  • Members
  • 181 messages
Loved the DLC.  It gave me some amazing moments, and I thank you for creating them for me.  However, I think it got away with the RIDICULOUS change in narrative tone because most people, myself included, simply loaded up a legacy save and played from there.  When I do my next full play of ME3, Citadel will stand out like a sore thumb.  

I don't understand why this couldn't have been made into post ending DLC.  It would fit there perfectly as the most amazingly playable ending of all time.  What a send off it would be!!  Yeah, the Reapers are defeated, the galaxy is saved, but here's a loose end you wouldn't have seen coming!  

At the very least, there could have been a bit more information given to the player on why it's CRITICAL to the war effort that the Normandy return to the Citadel IMMEDIATELY and remain in dry dock for days upon days.  The need for R&R doesn't cut it when my crew mate just discovered the coordinates of Cerberus' secret base of operations.  Maybe the transition will seem a little less jarring if I start Citadel earlier, but that will certainly diminish what I consider the DLC's primary function which is to serve as a substitute ending to the series.

Compaints aside, I'm very glad this DLC was produced, and I was happy to pay for it.  Also, Grunt is my hero too.

EDIT:

ebevan91 wrote...

Am I missing something? I haven't been able to invite Garrus, Jacob, Zaeed, Grunt, or Kasumi over, yet, not even my LI, Ashley.

I keep leaving the Citadel (going to the Normandy) and coming back to see if I have new messages or invites, but I'm not getting any.

Run through all the invites and meetings you can do at the moment.  As you complete them new ones will be made available.

Modifié par DeepChild, 07 mars 2013 - 06:15 .


#581
CronoDragoon

CronoDragoon
  • Members
  • 10 413 messages

ebevan91 wrote...

Am I missing something? I haven't been able to invite Garrus, Jacob, Zaeed, Grunt, or Kasumi over, yet, not even my LI, Ashley.

I keep leaving the Citadel (going to the Normandy) and coming back to see if I have new messages or invites, but I'm not getting any.


You don't invite them over unless for Garrus you have a romance scene. They have scenes that activate in the Sunset strip hub.

#582
TOMCAT101

TOMCAT101
  • Members
  • 5 messages
 i'll pass on all dlc, i still one of many not happy with ending, citadel dlc why celebrate have party in middle of a global slaughter 

#583
LilyasAvalon

LilyasAvalon
  • Members
  • 5 076 messages
I'm not going to lie, I haven't been overly happy with Bioware, with the ME team, with a lot of the decisions you made, especially the endings of ME3.

But this DLC is one of the BEST DLCs I've ever played, the jokes, the drama, the characters, the moments, everything. It's the ending the series should've gotten, that it deserved. No glowing kids, no idiotic philosophy, no red, green, blue. It ends with a party, with us getting drunk off our arses, celebrating a victory and waking up with a turian next to you.

It is the ending we should've gotten... but it is the goodbye we deserved.

Thank you.

#584
Teddie Sage

Teddie Sage
  • Members
  • 6 754 messages
"It is the ending we should've gotten... but it is the goodbye we deserved."

I could see the party part perfectly fit after the game's Destroy Ending, a few months later. But yeah, even though the game was far from perfect, this DLC made up for the lack of humour and lighthearted scenes in it.

#585
k8ee

k8ee
  • Members
  • 592 messages
I already posted that the DLC was great, and I have been enjoying it almost nonstop for two days... but one thing that really got to me was when you are fighting femshep's clone, if you melee her she makes a male cerberus grunt of pain instead of a femshep grunt of pain.

It takes away some of the fun in slapping yourself to death. :|

#586
Neizd

Neizd
  • Members
  • 859 messages
Citadel DLC is good, it is something that you don't call a game but "art". It had the one thing that is most important and what Bioware was known for always giving the players: Quality.

On the good side:
- A lot of interactions with characters, and we all know that it's the heart of the series that people care about
- Well written dialoque (even if it had A LOT autodialoque) it was so great that I personally loved it.
- It was VERY funny to play, loved pizza delivery guy, dancing vorcha and Javing meeting up... xD
- A lot of effort put into making. I know that tali VA does a great job but SINGING?! It was great and natural, not overly perfected. It sounded just like a normal girl singing and I loved the natural feeling it gave.
- Decent amount of shooting. Not too much not to little.
- Boss fight (finally a boss without plot armor). I loved it, even if the idea was not 100% original it did fill up the hole that was missing in this game.
- A lot of touching moments...too many to count.
- Arena... FINALLY a way to get cash, buy all of the weapons without having to play the whole game again and again and again.

On the bad side:
- Still no harbringer. Ignoring the villain that was build up in all of ME2 is not going to resolve it.
- Still badly photoshoped Tali face...Bioware should do something for people that waited 6 years.
- No Legion content. He is the only squadmate that was left...
- Not ending related - I mean it didn't add even one line of dialogue to it and thus it does not add any replay value.
- Not many furniture for the apartment...It would benefit from more customization.

Overall rating 8/10

Even it it didn't do much about existing in-game problems it still was a very high quality product that is totally worth it :)
While not most origingal, a little predictible and short it did fill some holes. Most of all this DLC showed that Bioware can still make good quality content. I must say personally that after DA2, ME3 (without EC) I was wondering if maybe the company will continue to fail their fanbase.
Now I think that MAYBE ME4 will have good quality like this DLC. I will not preorder it, but I will wait for it because it may have this something that only BW could create.

Pointers to BW:
- Keep making RPG, not shooters. Wider audience is good but your games were always about great story that we could interact with while being accompanied by great characters. A game like that is indeed art, because it's like a book or movie but compared to them you can interact...and this interaction is the most vital part of your games.
- A lof of your players love romances. Keep writting them
- A lot of players love EPIC moments. Don't do overly dark themed games, because a lof of people like to play epic content if their real lives are not so great.
- Don't say that something is "too video gamey" it's a game.


One last wish?

Give us one more story about the Shepard (of course I mean mine not yours ;) ). And finally adress those big things that anger your fans. You create this content for them, always remember that :)

#587
Gilbert Salarian

Gilbert Salarian
  • Members
  • 84 messages
On a critical note, I enjoyed Citadel very much and while I wouldn't call it the best DLC ever, it's definitely near the top of that list.  

PROs

-the dialogue was great; so many comical moments (using Joker as bait, the batarian/vorcha confrontation with Ash, Blasto!, Sam sacrificing her toothbrush for Shep) to break up an otherwise bleak game.

-the ambient dialogue was fantastic!  Hearing the different classes in universe have the discussions we've had on the forums was nice (Tech armor, the turian wishing he could roll, shields down? Charge!)

-background into the characters' lives (Anderson, squadmates from all three games, even NPCs like Sha'ira)

-side games, especially the return of QUASAR!!!

-length and amount of content was fantastic


CONs

-Combat.  I did not enjoy ME3s combat at all, and the fighting in the DLC was probably some of the most annoying/frustrating in the game.

-The Arena.  This was like multiplayer with training wheels for those who prefer SP.  I tried it because, hey why not, but I'll definitely not be going back with any kind of gusto.  As I said, I hated the combat and the rewards simply aren't worth doing it.  (Alas, there's another 2 Achievements I won't be getting unles my OCD gets out-of-control)

-Limited utility of the apartment once the DLC is completed.  This is more like 'I wish there was more...' rather than a 'zomg rage!'   Like Shepard's ME1 apartment, or the Shadow Broker Base in ME2, Shepard's ME3 apartment serves it's purpose, but doesn't beckon for more.  I understand the limitations and all, but it would have been nice to, say, call your LI to the apartment (like post-Suicide Mission ME2) or even have PMs show up at your apartment (in other words, integrating the Datapad app into the ME3 game proper)



LilyasAvalon wrote...

It is the ending we should've gotten... but it is the goodbye we deserved.


This.

Thanks for the ride, Bioware!  It was the best (even if it wasn't perfect)

Modifié par Gilbert Salarian, 07 mars 2013 - 07:34 .


#588
BeauRoger

BeauRoger
  • Members
  • 141 messages
Fantastic piece of DLC. Best in the series, better than shadow broker.

#589
Blue Liara

Blue Liara
  • Members
  • 418 messages
Loved it thought it was awesome. Has done a lot to restoring SOME of my confidence in Bioware.

This really was fan service and I commend bioware for that. A lot of fun and purely focused on getting to say goodbye to your characters.

This shows that Bioware cares about its fans. Or at the very least are tying to show that they care about their fans and are trying to mend fences.

This really seems to me like a very positive step. I think that it is likely that this DLC was not originally planed by Bioware as a DLC release.

I still have reservations about ME4 because CASEY HUDSON is still managing it. Hopefully he won't rule like a dictator and get final say on the ending.

I still don't understand why Hudson has been given ME4 based purely on ME3 and the resulting debacle.

The fact that Bioware thought they needed to do this DLC to try and mend fences with the fans shows how badly Hudson messed up.

Going to finish on a positive note. I was VERY VERY angry and upset with the whole ending debacle. The ending itself, the way that the fans were treated and belittled for daring to voice their opinions. I had pretty much made up my mind to never buy another Bioware or EA game (i still have yet to open my Star Wars the Old Republic which i pre-ordered).

However I feel that with this DLC Bioware are trying to show that they care and that in the future things may be better. Hopefully this turns out to be the case.

#590
Killdren88

Killdren88
  • Members
  • 4 650 messages
I'll. Be brief. The interaction with the crew was wonderful I laughed and got teary eyed at a few points. It great. Then I became extremely depressed. Because it was not post ending. After seeing such lovely touching moments, I realize what comes afterwards. This made the my final feelings to be a mix of sadness.,frustration and anger. Kinda how I felt. After seeing the endings for the first time. Not the sort of thing I want to feel. Now if this DLC was after high EMS destroy, it.would.have been perfect. As it stands now it only stands now as incredibly depressing scenario. As for the clone, I found unneeded. I mean if you wanted to add more in the villain department, why not more Harbinger? That conflict was building since ME 2.and that was tossed aside for reasons I'll never know. All in all it was very good. But I felt the artistic. Integrity defense should have been abandoned and place this dlc at the end.

#591
Blue Liara

Blue Liara
  • Members
  • 418 messages
On another note if Bioware decide to do a prequel I.E. First contact war you can retract everything I said as being hopeful for a good game in the future etc. A prequel would in my opinion just demonstrate how bad the ending of ME3 was.

I will certainly not be purchasing a prequel game. I think the vast majority of fans do NOT want the next series of Mass Effect to be a prequel.

Please Bioware/EA do not wipe out any chance of redemption that this DLC has given you with a really bad prequel series. Such as the first contact war which you strongly hinted at in this DLC.

Please PLEASE NO PREQUEL!!

#592
Trauma3x

Trauma3x
  • Members
  • 811 messages
The DLC was and is awesome with 1 drawback. They (BW) shouldve had an archievment for recruiting a former squad from ME2 back onto the Normandy. had they done that this dlc would be out of this stratosphere

#593
Seival

Seival
  • Members
  • 5 294 messages
The DLC is awesome :)

Finished conspiracy part yesterday. Looking forward to the rest of content.

#594
Brightspoon

Brightspoon
  • Members
  • 39 messages

Seival wrote...

The DLC is awesome :)

Finished conspiracy part yesterday. Looking forward to the rest of content.


Oh, the best is yet to come! The awesome part starts after the mission, in my opinion.

#595
Massa FX

Massa FX
  • Members
  • 1 930 messages
The Citadel DLC keeps on giving.... I don't like MP, but the new DLC allows me to play arena with my squadmates. I play with Wrex and Grunt! Broke the Arena's scoreboard with my over 9999 score. LOL!

A reward was Phantom armor! Sweet! I may never leave The Citadel. Ever.

Also, just had Cortez and Vega over for some sports TV. Thanks Bioware for the nod to Seattle! (my home town! Wooohoo!)

So glad I'm not working this week! Having too much fun playing Mass Effect 3 now. Seriously hope for more time with Kaidan. When my legacy Shepard is finished, I'll start folding in all the others that are lined up waiting their turn.

Can't thank you enough Bioware! Cheers!

PS: That Traynor. What is wrong with that girl? Stay out of my bathroom already!

#596
BronzTrooper

BronzTrooper
  • Members
  • 5 022 messages
What's up with the crazy amount of lag I get when I do the Armax Arena? There is so much lag that I have to let my squaddies do all the work. I get lag when I'm on the Strip but nowhere near as much lag as I get in the Arena. It's just in the DLC areas. The rest of the game has no lag at all. Am I the only one with this problem?

#597
Massa FX

Massa FX
  • Members
  • 1 930 messages

Killdren88 wrote...

I'll. Be brief. The interaction with the crew was wonderful I laughed and got teary eyed at a few points. It great. Then I became extremely depressed. Because it was not post ending. After seeing such lovely touching moments, I realize what comes afterwards. This made the my final feelings to be a mix of sadness.,frustration and anger. Kinda how I felt. After seeing the endings for the first time. Not the sort of thing I want to feel. Now if this DLC was after high EMS destroy, it.would.have been perfect. As it stands now it only stands now as incredibly depressing scenario. As for the clone, I found unneeded. I mean if you wanted to add more in the villain department, why not more Harbinger? That conflict was building since ME 2.and that was tossed aside for reasons I'll never know. All in all it was very good. But I felt the artistic. Integrity defense should have been abandoned and place this dlc at the end.


Forget the ending! Let Citadel DLC be your end. HeadCannon the rest. We have our party! We have friendships. We have lots of beer. We have tipsy Quarian hiccups and Zaeed -> Samara pickup lines (major fail). We have Turian dating awkwardness. We have gambling! We are better actors than Blasto!

Forget the yuck ending. Don't dwell on it. Stay at the Citadel. Don't do Cronas. Be happy. :P

#598
Malanek

Malanek
  • Members
  • 7 838 messages
After purchasing for Citadel PC it is giving me a "redeem online pass" message. Now waiting in queue for it to be resolved. No one know of an easier way of fixing this?

#599
Darth Wraith

Darth Wraith
  • Members
  • 559 messages
I thought it was excellent. Loved the new weapons, especially the pistol. I also enjoyed the different flavour of the first part of the mission, after the restaurant. Having the whole squad together was a blast, and seeing Wrex again was terrific. The party was definite high point, with lots of banter and interaction. Loved it.

The biggest letdown for me was the lack of a new bonus power. I would have really loved one, like Wrex' stimpack ability.

As for gripes with the gameplay, I noticed a couple of issues. One was that the combat areas were too cramped and cluttered for my taste - I like it a little more open. The stealth aspects of the early parts was also disappointing, as enemies not only saw me through cover and started shooting, but they could also easily see me and target me while I was cloaked. Annoying. Oh, and even though my companion power use is set to None, Wrex kept spamming his stimpack ability until he ran out, every single combat encounter.

#600
Ned Starks Head

Ned Starks Head
  • Members
  • 343 messages
Got to say I loved this dlc. This was bioware's best in my opinion. Even better than the shadow broker dlc. Interesting mystery, cool james bond type scenes, SHEPARD CLONE FTW, very funny and touching as well. The party was great, all squadmates were brilliant, the arena was fun and I'm really sad there's no more dlc for mass effect 3 after this. Amazing job bioware, mass effect 3 with all its dlc packages feels like such a complete experience that I doubt I'll play a better game ever.

Unless Mass effect 4 beats it :D