Aller au contenu

Photo

With All the DLCs Out. (With Poll)


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
137 réponses à ce sujet

#76
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages
1)Citadel
2)Lair of the Shadow Broker
3)Leviathan
4)From Ashes (due to massive amount of content in core game from Javik)
5)Overlord
6)Kasumi Stolen Memory
7)Zaeed The Price of Revenge
8)Bring Down the Sky
9)Arrival
10)Omega
11)Extended Cut
12)Normandy Crash Site
13)Firewalker Pack
14)Pinnacle Station

Modifié par Dragoonlordz, 10 mars 2013 - 08:39 .


#77
Plejadenwolf

Plejadenwolf
  • Members
  • 47 messages
1) Lair of the Shadow Broker (Great)
2) Citadel (Great, but doesn't fit into story line)
3) Arrival (Great)
4) Kasumi Stolen Memory (Great)
5) Overlord (Great)
6) Bring Down the Sky (Great)
7) Leviathan (Great)
8) Normandy Crash Site (Great)
9) Zaeed The Price of Revenge (Good)
10) From Ashes (Good)
11) Firewalker Pack (Rather Good)
12) Omega (...)
[...]
Somewhere in an unknown realm I've never wanted to hear off and which just doesn't exist) Extended Cut

Modifié par Plejadenwolf, 10 mars 2013 - 08:59 .


#78
bryan12112

bryan12112
  • Members
  • 323 messages

what was Pinnacle Station? An ME1 DLC? My disk came with BDTS so I assumed that was the only DLC for that one.


Yeah.

http://masseffect.wi...innacle_Station

#79
Sovereign330

Sovereign330
  • Members
  • 640 messages

Plejadenwolf wrote...

1) Lair of the Shadow Broker (Great)
2) Citadel (Great, but doesn't fit into story line)
3) Arrival (Great)
4) Kasumi Stolen Memory (Great)
5) Overlord (Great)
6) Bring Down the Sky (Great)
7) Leviathan
8) Normandy Crash Site
9) Zaeed The Price of Revenge (Good)
10) From Ashes (Good)
11) Firewalker Pack (Rather Good)

[...]
Somewhere in an unknown realm I've never wanted to hear off and which just doesn't exist) Extended Cut




Elaborate on number 2. Since I tend to disagree

#80
DeinonSlayer

DeinonSlayer
  • Members
  • 8 441 messages

Sovereign330 wrote...

Plejadenwolf wrote...

1) Lair of the Shadow Broker (Great)
2) Citadel (Great, but doesn't fit into story line)
3) Arrival (Great)
4) Kasumi Stolen Memory (Great)
5) Overlord (Great)
6) Bring Down the Sky (Great)
7) Leviathan
8) Normandy Crash Site
9) Zaeed The Price of Revenge (Good)
10) From Ashes (Good)
11) Firewalker Pack (Rather Good)

[...]
Somewhere in an unknown realm I've never wanted to hear off and which just doesn't exist) Extended Cut




Elaborate on number 2. Since I tend to disagree

Narratively, it fits best between Rannoch and Thessia - the crew is riding high after a major victory, the Citadel just got word of the Miracle of Palaven, things are looking good, then after shore leave things fall apart again. That's where I'd think it best. Unfortunately, you can't invite Miranda until after Horizon.

#81
Plejadenwolf

Plejadenwolf
  • Members
  • 47 messages
[quote]DeinonSlayer wrote...

[quote]Sovereign330 wrote...

[quote]Plejadenwolf wrote...

1) Lair of the Shadow Broker (Great)
2) Citadel (Great, but doesn't fit into story line)
3) Arrival (Great)
4) Kasumi Stolen Memory (Great)
5) Overlord (Great)
6) Bring Down the Sky (Great)
7) Leviathan
8) Normandy Crash Site
9) Zaeed The Price of Revenge (Good)
10) From Ashes (Good)
11) Firewalker Pack (Rather Good)

[...]
Somewhere in an unknown realm I've never wanted to hear off and which just doesn't exist) Extended Cut



[/quote]

Elaborate on number 2. Since I tend to disagree.

[/quote]

I accept your opinion. I don't want to repeat myself another time, so I just refer to Koobismo's review (www.koobismo.com/2013/03/the-pinnacle-of-fanservice-a-citadel-dlc-review/) which rather sums up my opinion. ;)

Modifié par Plejadenwolf, 10 mars 2013 - 09:15 .


#82
Sovereign330

Sovereign330
  • Members
  • 640 messages

DeinonSlayer wrote...

Sovereign330 wrote...

Plejadenwolf wrote...

1) Lair of the Shadow Broker (Great)
2) Citadel (Great, but doesn't fit into story line)
3) Arrival (Great)
4) Kasumi Stolen Memory (Great)
5) Overlord (Great)
6) Bring Down the Sky (Great)
7) Leviathan
8) Normandy Crash Site
9) Zaeed The Price of Revenge (Good)
10) From Ashes (Good)
11) Firewalker Pack (Rather Good)

[...]
Somewhere in an unknown realm I've never wanted to hear off and which just doesn't exist) Extended Cut




Elaborate on number 2. Since I tend to disagree

Narratively, it fits best between Rannoch and Thessia - the crew is riding high after a major victory, the Citadel just got word of the Miracle of Palaven, things are looking good, then after shore leave things fall apart again. That's where I'd think it best. Unfortunately, you can't invite Miranda until after Horizon.


Could easily argue that when times are hitting hard (Thessia), you need to take time to blow off steam and then refocus so that you're in peak condition. Plus there are some great lines if you wait until before Cronos like when you tell off T'Suza or when you're trashtalking the clone.

Something like

"I earned my scars on Feros and Noveria and Virmire and Ilos. On the Collector Base and Tuchanka and Rannoch and Thessia. You got yours from a petri dish"

#83
AchesOfDoom

AchesOfDoom
  • Members
  • 169 messages
1. Citadel DLC
2. Lair of the Shadow Broker
3. Omega DLC

#84
Plejadenwolf

Plejadenwolf
  • Members
  • 47 messages
I don't doubt that, but when I think to much about it it's like this: Grunt, Miranda, Zaeed, Wrex... they all pause their missions to make party with Shepard and none of them is in a real bad or nasty or malevolent situation. That's just my point of it.

Addendum:

Ok, the Grunt part is described in the Citadel DLC.

Modifié par Plejadenwolf, 10 mars 2013 - 09:13 .


#85
Sovereign330

Sovereign330
  • Members
  • 640 messages

Plejadenwolf wrote...

I don't doubt that, but when I think to much about it it's like this: Grunt, Miranda, Zaeed, Wrex... they all pause their missions to make party with Shepard and none of them is in a real bad or nasty or malevolent situation. That's just my point of it.


Well Wrex is there to deal with the Council so while he's there...
Grunt is in a Citadel hospital and gets busted out so there's that
Zaeed's on the Citadel anyway
Miranda content isn't available till after Sanctuary stuff I believe.

They even said that content unlocks over the course of the game.

Their plots are tied up by the time content with them is available last I checked.

#86
Plejadenwolf

Plejadenwolf
  • Members
  • 47 messages

Sovereign330 wrote...

Plejadenwolf wrote...

I don't doubt that, but when I think to much about it it's like this: Grunt, Miranda, Zaeed, Wrex... they all pause their missions to make party with Shepard and none of them is in a real bad or nasty or malevolent situation. That's just my point of it.


Well Wrex is there to deal with the Council so while he's there...
Grunt is in a Citadel hospital and gets busted out so there's that
Zaeed's on the Citadel anyway
Miranda content isn't available till after Sanctuary stuff I believe.

They even said that content unlocks over the course of the game.

Their plots are tied up by the time content with them is available last I checked.


And in none of the three/four endings you have a benefit of your apartement at all, because it get's destroyed or you're dead. It's just the way they put it in, not how. See link above.  

Modifié par Plejadenwolf, 10 mars 2013 - 09:29 .


#87
Sovereign330

Sovereign330
  • Members
  • 640 messages

Plejadenwolf wrote...

Sovereign330 wrote...

Plejadenwolf wrote...

I don't doubt that, but when I think to much about it it's like this: Grunt, Miranda, Zaeed, Wrex... they all pause their missions to make party with Shepard and none of them is in a real bad or nasty or malevolent situation. That's just my point of it.


Well Wrex is there to deal with the Council so while he's there...
Grunt is in a Citadel hospital and gets busted out so there's that
Zaeed's on the Citadel anyway
Miranda content isn't available till after Sanctuary stuff I believe.

They even said that content unlocks over the course of the game.

Their plots are tied up by the time content with them is available last I checked.


And in none of the three/four endings you have a benefit of your apartement at all, because it get's destroyed or you're dead. It's just the way they put it in, not how. See link above.  



Wouldnt want it anywhere else in the game tbh...post ending sh*ts on the other endings...which is fine and dandy if you're biased. But if one is to be unbiased and objective as possible...one can see the issue with that.

#88
Starschwar

Starschwar
  • Members
  • 69 messages
Citadel
Extended Cut
From Ashes
Leviathan
Omega
Kasumi - Stolen Memory
Zaeed - The Price Of Revenge
Lair of the Shadow Broker
Arrival
Overlord
Bring Down The Sky
Firewalker Pack
Normandy Crash Site
Pinnacle Station

#89
Owlowiscious

Owlowiscious
  • Members
  • 214 messages
I am just going to list the top 5:

1: Citadel(Duuh)
2: Overlord.
3: Leviathan.
4: LOTSB.
5: Omega.

(I count the Extended cut as part of the original game)

I don't know why so many people throw cigar shaped objects at omega, I found it quite enjoyable.

Modifié par Kellleth, 10 mars 2013 - 11:53 .


#90
Sovereign330

Sovereign330
  • Members
  • 640 messages

Kellleth wrote...

I am just going to list the top 5:

1: Citadel(Duuh)
2: Overlord.
3: Leviathan.
4: LOTSB.
5: Omega.

(I count the Extended cut as part of the original game)

I don't know why so many people throw cigar shaped objects at omega, I found it quite enjoyable.

as did i

#91
jstme

jstme
  • Members
  • 2 008 messages
1.LotSB
2.Citadel
3.From Ashes
4.Overlord
5.Katsumi
6.Arrival
7.Zaeed
8 Firewalker
9 EC
10 Normandy crash site

Did not play the rest.

#92
Spartas Husky

Spartas Husky
  • Members
  • 6 151 messages
1. Lair of the shadow Broker,
2.Overlord

The rest were good but not worth the money. Hence why I got them when they are half off :P

#93
xtal84

xtal84
  • Members
  • 54 messages
1) Extended Cut ..because Traynor..and because one last look at my crew
2) Citadel
3) Shadow Broker
4) Kasumi
5) Leviathan
6) Normandy Crash Site .. wasn't really dlc but was a nice fifteen minutes of reflection. That music.

..then the rest

#94
DeinonSlayer

DeinonSlayer
  • Members
  • 8 441 messages

Sovereign330 wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...

Sovereign330 wrote...

Plejadenwolf wrote...

1) Lair of the Shadow Broker (Great)
2) Citadel (Great, but doesn't fit into story line)
3) Arrival (Great)
4) Kasumi Stolen Memory (Great)
5) Overlord (Great)
6) Bring Down the Sky (Great)
7) Leviathan
8) Normandy Crash Site
9) Zaeed The Price of Revenge (Good)
10) From Ashes (Good)
11) Firewalker Pack (Rather Good)

[...]
Somewhere in an unknown realm I've never wanted to hear off and which just doesn't exist) Extended Cut




Elaborate on number 2. Since I tend to disagree

Narratively, it fits best between Rannoch and Thessia - the crew is riding high after a major victory, the Citadel just got word of the Miracle of Palaven, things are looking good, then after shore leave things fall apart again. That's where I'd think it best. Unfortunately, you can't invite Miranda until after Horizon.


Could easily argue that when times are hitting hard (Thessia), you need to take time to blow off steam and then refocus so that you're in peak condition. Plus there are some great lines if you wait until before Cronos like when you tell off T'Suza or when you're trashtalking the clone.

Something like

"I earned my scars on Feros and Noveria and Virmire and Ilos. On the Collector Base and Tuchanka and Rannoch and Thessia. You got yours from a petri dish"

I think Koobismo described it pretty well as follows:

Image IPB

#95
Sovereign330

Sovereign330
  • Members
  • 640 messages

DeinonSlayer wrote...

Sovereign330 wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...

Sovereign330 wrote...

Plejadenwolf wrote...

1) Lair of the Shadow Broker (Great)
2) Citadel (Great, but doesn't fit into story line)
3) Arrival (Great)
4) Kasumi Stolen Memory (Great)
5) Overlord (Great)
6) Bring Down the Sky (Great)
7) Leviathan
8) Normandy Crash Site
9) Zaeed The Price of Revenge (Good)
10) From Ashes (Good)
11) Firewalker Pack (Rather Good)

[...]
Somewhere in an unknown realm I've never wanted to hear off and which just doesn't exist) Extended Cut




Elaborate on number 2. Since I tend to disagree

Narratively, it fits best between Rannoch and Thessia - the crew is riding high after a major victory, the Citadel just got word of the Miracle of Palaven, things are looking good, then after shore leave things fall apart again. That's where I'd think it best. Unfortunately, you can't invite Miranda until after Horizon.


Could easily argue that when times are hitting hard (Thessia), you need to take time to blow off steam and then refocus so that you're in peak condition. Plus there are some great lines if you wait until before Cronos like when you tell off T'Suza or when you're trashtalking the clone.

Something like

"I earned my scars on Feros and Noveria and Virmire and Ilos. On the Collector Base and Tuchanka and Rannoch and Thessia. You got yours from a petri dish"

I think Koobismo described it pretty well as follows:

Image IPB


If you agree that little pieces of what Citadel DLC was like were in those ME3 patches....like garrus shooting contest, normandy banter, and purgatory....i think the citadel and its placement is good right where it is...the third game was very dark...it needed a bit of a lift to it....and i think citadel delivered in many ways.. I like koobismo and his writing, but I think he sometimes stabs a little too hard at Mass Effect 3 DLC...probably because he has a biased opinion that favors his own work.

#96
Spartas Husky

Spartas Husky
  • Members
  • 6 151 messages

DeinonSlayer wrote...


Image IPB


Perfect lol

#97
Jere85

Jere85
  • Members
  • 1 542 messages
1. LoTSB
2. Citadel
3. Overlord
4. Arrival
5. Zaeed

#98
TheRevanchist

TheRevanchist
  • Members
  • 3 647 messages
1.LotSB
2.Overlord
3.Leviathan
4.BDts
5.Arrival
6.From Ashes
7.Kasumi
8.Normady Crash Site
9.Extended Cut
10.Omega
11.Citadel
12.Zaeed
13.Firewalker
14.Pinnacle Station

Thats right, Citadel is at 11, deal with it.

Modifié par kylecouch, 11 mars 2013 - 02:05 .


#99
Slayer299

Slayer299
  • Members
  • 3 193 messages
1. Lair of the Shadow Broker
2. Overlord
3. Bring Down the Sky
4. Kasumi - Stolen Memory
5. Normandy Crash Site
6. Zaeed - Price of Revenge
7. Pinnacle Station
8. From Ashes
9. Alternate Appearance Pack 2
10. Arrival

Those are my top 10 for the ME 1 - 3 DLC's.

edit - forgot 10 by accident

Modifié par Slayer299, 11 mars 2013 - 02:09 .


#100
Sovereign330

Sovereign330
  • Members
  • 640 messages

kylecouch wrote...

1.LotSB
2.Overlord
3.Leviathan
4.BDts
5.Arrival
6.From Ashes
7.Kasumi
8.Normady Crash Site
9.Extended Cut
10.Omega
11.Citadel
12.Zaeed
13.Firewalker
14.Pinnacle Station

Thats right, Citadel is at 11, deal with it.


That's fine...just curious why