137 réponses à ce sujet

[TheRevanchist]

Sovereign330 wrote...

kylecouch wrote...

1.LotSB
2.Overlord
3.Leviathan
4.BDts
5.Arrival
6.From Ashes
7.Kasumi
8.Normady Crash Site
9.Extended Cut
10.Omega
11.Citadel
12.Zaeed
13.Firewalker
14.Pinnacle Station

Thats right, Citadel is at 11, deal with it.

That's fine...just curious why

Because I agree totally with Koobismo as far as Citadel is concerned. Also this...

[alsonamedbort]

1. From Ashes (not the mission itself, but Javik's presence throughout the game)
2. EC
3. Citadel (my favorite one to play through, obviously the 2nd half more than the 1st)
4. LotSB
5. Leviathan
6. Stolen Memory
7. Omega
8. Overlord
9. Arrival
10. Zaeed

[TheRevanchist]

P.S. Absolutely nothing in Citadel can possibly top THIS moment for me. Citadel has nothing on this in my opinion.

[Spartas Husky]

kylecouch wrote...

P.S. Absolutely nothing in Citadel can possibly top THIS moment for me. Citadel has nothing on this in my opinion.

hence why LOTSB was the cream of the crop . At first I honestly thought he was an oversized chubby like volus.

Then he stood up and  O.O

[TheRevanchist]

Spartas Husky wrote...

kylecouch wrote...

P.S. Absolutely nothing in Citadel can possibly top THIS moment for me. Citadel has nothing on this in my opinion.

hence why LOTSB was the cream of the crop . At first I honestly thought he was an oversized chubby like volus.

Then he stood up and  O.O

I thought it was a chair turned around so the Broker was faceing away from you, so he could turn around in it slowly all cliche style. Then it zoomed in and I was like "O.O da fuc..."

[Kaidan Fan]

1. Citadel
2. BDtS
3. EC
4. Overlord
5. Leviathan
6. From Ashes
7. LotSB
8. Kasumi
9. Zaeed
10. Normandy Crash Site
11. Omega
12. Pinnacle Station
13. Arrival
14. Firewalker

Modifié par Kaidan Fan, 11 mars 2013 - 10:44 .

[TheRevanchist]

wow...Pinnacle Station above Arrival? that's something you never expect to see lol.

[Village_Idiot]

1. Citadel
2. Leviathan
3. From Ashes
4. LotSB
5. BDtS

I don't consider the EC to be a DLC in the traditional sense, so it's omitted.

Edited: I forgot about Javik. I am a bad person.

Modifié par Shadrach 88, 11 mars 2013 - 10:51 .

[MegaSovereign]

1. Citadel
2. LotSB
3. Leviathan
4. From Ashes
5. Kasumi
6. Arrival
7. Overlord
8. Bring Down the Sky

[Kaidan Fan]

kylecouch wrote...

wow...Pinnacle Station above Arrival? that's something you never expect to see lol.

I guess I just didn't like the story 

Firewalker would be above it if I didn't have to deal with the Hammerhead and jumping 

[HooblaDGN]

LotSB was excellent in every way. Citadel has the feels but the narrative itself is bad.

[ManOfSteel]

Top 5, from least favourite to favourite.

5) Arrival
4) Bring Down the Sky
3) Lair of the Shadow Broker
2) Leviathan
1) Citadel

[TheRevanchist]

Kaidan Fan wrote...

kylecouch wrote...

wow...Pinnacle Station above Arrival? that's something you never expect to see lol.

I guess I just didn't like the story 

Firewalker would be above it if I didn't have to deal with the Hammerhead and jumping 

wow...thats actually really scarey...how could you hate Arrival more than both Firewalker and Pinnacle Station??...this does not compute.

[cactusberry]

1)Citadel
2)Lair of the Shadow Broker
3)Overlord
4)Leviathan
5)Extended Cut
6)Omega
7)Arrival
8)From Ashes
9)Kasumi
10)Bring Down the Sky
11)Zaeed
12)Normandy Crash Site
13) Firewalker

All the ones I have played.

[dointime85]

1) Lair of the Shadow Broker
2) Citadel
3) Kasumi Stolen Memory
4) Overlord
5) Leviathan
6) Arrival
7) Bring Down the Sky
8) Omega
9) Zaeed The Price of Revenge
10) From Ashes
11) Normandy Crash Site
12) Firewalker Pack

I haven't played Pinnacle Station and tend to see the Extended Cut as a patch rather than a DLC.

[Kelwing]

1. LotSB
2. Leviathan
3. Arrival
4. Omega
5. Citidel
6. Overlord
7. BDtS
8. Kasumi Stolen Memory
9. Zaeed The Price of Revenge
10. From Ashes
11. Normandy Crash Site
12. Fire Walker Pack

Never played Pinnacle Station and EC really didn't do much to help the game much.

[Deadpool9]

The top 4 (and only 4) DLC's to balance great story/dialogue with great gameplay:

1. Citadel
2. Lair of the Shadow Broker
3. Leviathan
4. Kasumi - Stolen Memory


I can't manage a top 5, so here's all the rest:

Omega--great gameplay and maps, but I didn't care for the story or unlikeable Aria or choking Petrovsky

Arrival--great gameplay, but I didn't care for the story

Overlord--I resented having to use the nauseating, tissue-paper-armored Hammerhead, and the harder sci-fi wasn't my thing

Bring Down the Sky--taking out several maps of missile silos is too tedious, and I didn't care for the unlikeable Batarian antagonists

Zaeed - The Price of Revenge--just as plain as From Ashes, but with slightly better gameplay and characterization and choices

From Ashes--the mission was just too plain, and Javik didn't exactly come to life, yet, so to speak

Normandy Crash Site--nothing fun about picking up all the dog tags, and this hardly qualifies as a "mission" 

Extended Cut--I can't quite rate this as it's just cinematics, not new gameplay, like a revamped Earth 2 with war assets mission

Firewalker pack/Pinnacle Station--would not bang

[Yestare7]

1. Lotsb - lotsa Liara!!
2. Citadel - hilarious!
3. EC - sigh...
4. Javik
5. Kasumi

[Andrew Bourne]

1. Citadel
2. Lair Of The Shadow Broker
3. Extended Cut
4. Kasumi: Stolen Memory
5. Omega
6. Bring Down The Sky
7. Overlord
8. Arrival
9. Normandy Crash Site
10. Zaeed: The Price Of Revenge

Really enjoyed playing all of these missions, Citadel and LOTSB are the best missions of the whole series, and the EC made the ending tolerable for me.

[Terraforming2154]

1. Leviathan
2. Citadel
3. Bringing Down the Sky
4. Lair of the Shadow Broker
5. Extended Cut
6. Overlord
7. Kasumi Stolen Memory
8. Zaeed The Price of Revenge
9. Omega
10. Firewalker Pack
11. From Ashes
12. Arrival
13. Normandy Crash Site

Pinnacle Station is the only one I haven't played.

Modifié par Terraforming2154, 16 mars 2013 - 03:19 .

[Mastone]

Sovereign330 wrote...

Mastone wrote...

I like none of them simply because all of them should have been in the main game, the only one I find acceptable as a DLC is Arrival not because it had great quality or anything but simply because it is being used to connect ME2 to ME3 and not adds vital information for ME2 itself

Another beef I have with all of the DLC is that they are somehow canon in ME3 without explanation..Liara as the shadowbroker, Shepard being in jail because of Arrival.
If you haven't bought or played any of these ME3 doesn't make sense from the getgo...it screams design flaw!

Didnt play LotSB?
Liara hired a bunch of mercs and took the ship
Didn't play Arrival?
A bunch of Alliance soldiers destroyed the relay and Shep instead gets locked up for affiliating with Cerberus, a terrorist organization.

My point is not that it is unexplained, my point is that it is ungratifying for someone who did play ME2 but not the DLC, which in essence is what is wrong with ME3 all the choices you have made in the games amount to nothing( which means an email, a mention in the journal or a higher number in the war assets) I call it design flaw
I mean in ME2 you were helping your squadmates with their daddy issues( I still find the whole loyalty mechanic retarded) while you could be doing something real, that furthers the plot ( finding the shadowbroker, stopping the reapers from entering through batarian space).

Also if you think it is impossible to incorporate choice in a meaningful manner  in a game, have a look at the witcher2.

[TJBartlemus]

 This article pretty much sums up my opinions about the Citadel DLC. I sorta have mixed feelings about it. I love the DLC itself, but overall to the game/series it shouldn't even place in the top 10.

http://www.gamefront...for-the-future/

[favoritehookeronthecitadel]

1. Citadel - I'm not even finished with this and it's already my favorite DLC by far.

2. Lair of the Shadow Broker - Really fun and well-written. 

3. Extended Cut - A pretty good ending. A little half-assed with the comic books panels, but that gives the advantage of showing exactly what they need to show with the characters without taking too much time. I ****ing hated Shepard's first name not being on the wall. Hated that, with a passion.

4. From Ashes - Pretty flawless. When I played it, it almost felt like the quality of a recruiting mission from ME2. A good amount of shooting Cerberus troops here and there without too much of it, some good references to ME1(obvsiouly) and an overall fun introduction to Javik, the best and most relevant sqaudmate, imo. Only problem was, way too pricey. Should've been in the game already, and the bastards know it. After they charged money for Kasumi and Zaeed and so many people payed for them, I guess Bioware knew that the fans would buy squadmates no matter what.

5. Leviathan - I would say that it's almost actually good, but Shepard's ****ing auto dialogue under water really hurt it, which I know is a small thing, but it was 15 minutes of my Shepard being completely out of character and it was just. so. stupid, considering I paid for it.

6. Zaeed - Fun but I thought it was stupid that I had to have more than 90% paragon to make the choice I wanted.

7. Kasumi - Again fun but kinda hollow and unsatisfying, didn't make much of an impression.

8. Omega - Crap. Don't have the time on my hands to play that ****. I'm sorry, but I didn't even finish it. Hours and hours of shooting repetitive Cerberus troops that doesn't really gain anything is not my idea of "fun". Wait, that's most of the game. But yeah, way too long, way too boring, I don't give a **** about Aria no matter how much the writing tries to make me, and I feel like an idiot for buying it. 

Modifié par favoritehookeronthecitadel, 17 mars 2013 - 04:49 .

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

1) Lair of the Shadow Broker
2) Citadel
3) Bringing Down the Sky
4) Leviathan
5) Kasumi: Stolen Memory
6) Omega
7) Overlord
8) Zaeed: Price of Revenge
9) From the Ashes
10) Arrival
11) Pinnacle Station
12) Firewalker
13) Normandy Crash Site
14) Extended Cut

I still go with LOTSB as my favorite, it was outstanding all the way through. The Citadel was a lot of fun, though. It's close to a tie for first.

[Legion of 1337]

Only counting "real" DLCs, not tacked on **** or stuff that was cut to make a quick buck.

1. Lair of the Shadow Broker
2. Citadel
3. Bring Down the Sky
4. Leviathan
5. Arrival
6. Omega