173 réponses à ce sujet

[shepskisaac]

At the end when Brooks abandons him and Shep (in Paragon option) extends his hand to pull him and he just looks this sad with those Clone-Shep eyes

Modifié par IsaacShep, 11 mars 2013 - 12:52 .

[Jonathan Sud]

Yeah, I felt bad. He's like that one kid who never got the attention his older brother/sister got from his parents.

[nrobbiec]

It was a very difficult decision, but even though he was Brooks' pawn "there can be only one" besides he said he'd have let Kaidan die on Virmire so...

I let Brooks live though, killing her would've been too merciful.

[Yestare7]

I felt bad. Then I killed her.




Y

[CptData]

Me.
My first thought was, clone!Shep had the same memories of Shepard from the time of ME1, but no later stuff. That's why I thought that poor guy was going back and looking at his friends and, obviously, his LI (Ashley in my case). Since she was part of my squad in that scene, that idea felt legit.

Well, I reviewed that situation later and watched a vid on youtube as well: clone!Shep doesn't have memories at all of Shepard. Which makes my idea obsolete. Still - that poor guy. I still feel bad for him.

[xBUMMx]

Jonathan Sud wrote...

Yeah, I felt bad. He's like that one kid who never got the attention his older brother/sister got from his parents.

When suddenly, I realized that CloneShep is the fanatical version of.......
....
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...Carver.

[ruggly]

I did as well, she looks at Brooks for help, who then just walks off. I wanted to actually save her, though I don't know what they could do after...you saved her. She disappears?

[Babydel]

Felt good watching her die and I play paragon.

[xBUMMx]

Seriously though, no. I saw it as another one of Cerberus's ****-ups that I had to handle. Just like the entire Cerberus plot of ME1, just like Overlord. It tried to kill me. It tried to take over my life. It tried to take my ship. It tried to kill my hamster. But worst of all, it tried to kill my crew. It insulted them, it labeled them as a cult, it tried to compare that worthless **** to Miri. It felt good killing that thing.

Modifié par xBUMMx, 11 mars 2013 - 01:04 .

[shepskisaac]

ruggly wrote...

I did as well, she looks at Brooks for help, who then just walks off. I wanted to actually save her, though I don't know what they could do after...you saved her. She disappears?

She's arrested.

[ruggly]

IsaacShep wrote...

ruggly wrote...

I did as well, she looks at Brooks for help, who then just walks off. I wanted to actually save her, though I don't know what they could do after...you saved her. She disappears?

She's arrested.

Or that.

Edit: we talking about Brooks or the clone. I know Brooks is arrested, but I guess the clone would be as well.

Modifié par ruggly, 11 mars 2013 - 01:12 .

[Jere85]

I felt bad i couldnt save him either way, left me with no choice again. Theres been alot of that. I wanted to use him for my stunt double with the whole ending debacle, but no worries, im sure theres a bunch of em left

[Jonathan Sud]

xBUMMx wrote...

Jonathan Sud wrote...

Yeah, I felt bad. He's like that one kid who never got the attention his older brother/sister got from his parents.

When suddenly, I realized that CloneShep is the fanatical version of.......
....
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...Carver.

Holy crap, exactly O_O

[PnXMarcin1PL]

IsaacShep wrote...

ruggly wrote...

I did as well, she looks at Brooks for help, who then just walks off. I wanted to actually save her, though I don't know what they could do after...you saved her. She disappears?

She's arrested.

I kill her then Joker calles for maintenance asap to the Cargo Hold xD

[Rip504]

Of course I felt bad for such a good looking guy. lol

[Wayning_Star]

actually when the clwonshep appeard, the nurse was actually the culprit..I went around fuming for while..the story lost me completely at that point.. oh I kept on clicking on stuff and tried to humor myself with hidious absolutes'n stuff..but it was over for me at that point..the deal was done and ME was finished..er..ended abruptly.

and as others suggest, more cerberusness.. four gigs of cerberusness..

(was heartset on more information,etc. sci fy stuff..wasn't gonna happen.. oh well, some stuff never happens.)

[The Night Mammoth]

I kinda felt bad.

Obviously there was this whole thing about cloneshep being pushed to take Shepard's place, repeatedly feeling inadequate and having only one person to rely on, who ends up just betraying her.

I also kinda thought "wait, is that it?" Yeah I know, the Citadel is a largely tongue in cheek fan service romp which isn't meant to be consistent or meaningful, but I really don't see why there couldn't have been some amount of depth where the clone was concerned.

[Wayning_Star]

The Night Mammoth wrote...

I kinda felt bad.

Obviously there was this whole thing about cloneshep being pushed to take Shepard's place, repeatedly feeling inadequate and having only one person to rely on, who ends up just betraying her.

I also kinda thought "wait, is that it?" Yeah I know, the Citadel is a largely tongue in cheek fan service romp which isn't meant to be consistent or meaningful, but I really don't see why there couldn't have been some amount of depth where the clone was concerned.

but we're supposed to BE shep, how can a clone shep be if not us? That confused me, even IF cloned, the association was lost in a way, between the US shep and the WHOEVER cloned shep...

I felt like someone literally punched me in the head when that 'came to light' of day...as the basis of the DLC.

Then to top it off, the dumbshepclwon commits suicide instead of remaining around?  That couldn't even be a cloned shepard. Genes have more power on a personality than that..unless it were 'altered' in some fashion, but that's never explored. (We're to buy into the girly girl to indoctrinated cloneshep, bent on control of the universe as it knows it.. Nah, never happen..)

[CHARK19]

I loved it. 100 points to Griffindor!
Just awesome cutscene-fights! I play as a Vanguard, so it was really cool!

I wanted the crew to stop me before I kicked him out of my ship so that they could deliver their own one-liners! Like, Garrus kneels over and says, "Looks like your flights been CANCELED!" and Tali says, "Don't forget to write/Wright" (lol, human history pun).
Joker gets on the line, "Time to spread those wings, flyboy!" Another bursts into the bay but is hushed when the clone shepard remains to be seen. "Aww, I had a good one, why'd you-"
Shepard turns away, "I didn't. He let himself go."

[Wayning_Star]

CHARK19 wrote...

I loved it. 100 points to Griffindor!
Just awesome cutscene-fights! I play as a Vanguard, so it was really cool!

I wanted the crew to stop me before I kicked him out of my ship so that they could deliver their own one-liners! Like, Garrus kneels over and says, "Looks like your flights been CANCELED!" and Tali says, "Don't forget to write/Wright" (lol, human history pun).
Joker gets on the line, "Time to spread those wings, flyboy!" Another bursts into the bay but is hushed when the clone shepard remains to be seen. "Aww, I had a good one, why'd you-"
Shepard turns away, "I didn't. He let himself go."

oh great terminator humor..lol

[Billea]

I felt sorry for the clone, who as someone else pointed out, is kinda like Carver.

I think it was kinder to kill her because theoretically, if she had survived, she would have lived in the real Shepard's shadow all her life. That's no way to live. 

Besides, she threatened Tali. I couldn't just let that go 

Modifié par Billea, 11 mars 2013 - 01:23 .

[CHARK19]

Wayning_Star wrote...

CHARK19 wrote...

I loved it. 100 points to Griffindor!
Just awesome cutscene-fights! I play as a Vanguard, so it was really cool!

I wanted the crew to stop me before I kicked him out of my ship so that they could deliver their own one-liners! Like, Garrus kneels over and says, "Looks like your flights been CANCELED!" and Tali says, "Don't forget to write/Wright" (lol, human history pun).
Joker gets on the line, "Time to spread those wings, flyboy!" Another bursts into the bay but is hushed when the clone shepard remains to be seen. "Aww, I had a good one, why'd you-"
Shepard turns away, "I didn't. He let himself go."

oh great terminator humor..lol

Pre-mortem one-liners are the best!!!
If Mordin was still with us, he'd have said something like, "Human evolution- no wings...your survivability....Problematic."

[Wayning_Star]

Billea wrote...

I felt sorry for the clone, who as someone else pointed out, is kinda like Carver.

I think it was kinder to kill her because theoretically, if she had survived, she would have lived in the real Shepard's shadow all her life. That's no way to live. 

Besides, she threatened Tali. I couldn't just let that go 

heck, legion threatens Tali.. dating threatened Tali...

the keyword is 'survival' and what is Shep the best at? Even picked to save the MEU because of?...

The DLClone was to 'unplug' The Shepard conundrum in the extraMEU...(here on old earth

[o Ventus]

Billea wrote...

I think it was kinder to kill her because theoretically, if she had survived, she would have lived in the real Shepard's shadow all her life. That's no way to live.  

Not necessarily. They would be in Shepard's shadow in the same sense that Shepard's crew is in his/her shadow, and the crew isn't seen like that. Brooks (as much a backstabbing liar she is) even says that the Normandy and her crew are legends in the galaxy. 

The Shepard clone would have a lot to contribute. I know my own Shepard would share in the glory wih him.