497 réponses à ce sujet

[GimmeDaGun]

kylecouch wrote...

GimmeDaGun wrote...

john_sheparrd wrote...

OP is a troll lock this thread

Yeah, expressing opinions is trolling, but when many of you have been feeling the constant urge to express your thoughts about the ending in every single thread (the topic didn't really matter), that was completely ok. "**** please!"


It's funny to see how people who hate the endings love this and call it quality writing and vice versa (I'm in the latter group). It shows how wildly tastes can differ from each other. 

You realize I hate the Endings, AND dislike the direction of this DLC? 

What you and the Prothean say further justifies my point: It shows how wildly tastes can differ from each other. 

But usually based on my personal observation I can say that most people who hated the endings love this, and many who liked it do not like it so much... 

Modifié par GimmeDaGun, 12 mars 2013 - 10:35 .

[Jassu1979]

Well, it just goes to show that people who like the ending have HORRIBLE taste.

[Jamie9]

I loved the cheese but only as a sendoff to a great trilogy. I wouldn't want this density of it in a game proper or in every DLC.

That's why Shadow Broker remains my favourite DLC - I can't place Citadel above it because it's just a little fun, not meant to be taken seriously.

[Lars10178]

Are you trolling OP? This was probably the best DLC because of the humor

[tonnactus]

Mr.House wrote...
But project Lazarus and a plant crapping out fully armed asari clones didn't kill ME and ME2 for oyu?

For anyone who watched or read Solaris the Thorian isnt anything to bother about.

[Si-Shen]

Jassu1979 wrote...

Well, it just goes to show that people who like the ending have HORRIBLE taste.

How so?  Personally I disliked the endings but thought this DLC was fun and enjoyable.

Generalization is bad.

[TheProtheans]

GimmeDaGun wrote...

kylecouch wrote...

GimmeDaGun wrote...

john_sheparrd wrote...

OP is a troll lock this thread

Yeah, expressing opinions is trolling, but when many of you have been feeling the constant urge to express your thoughts about the ending in every single thread (the topic didn't really matter), that was completely ok. "**** please!"


It's funny to see how people who hate the endings love this and call it quality writing and vice versa (I'm in the latter group). It shows how wildly tastes can differ from each other. 

You realize I hate the Endings, AND dislike the direction of this DLC? 

What you and the Prothean say further justifies my point: It shows how wildly tastes can differ from each other. 

But usually based on my personal observation I can say that most people who hated the endings love this, and many who liked it do not like it so much... 

 I doubt they like it for what it adds to the story.
From what I seen they only like it because of the ridiculous things the characters do during a dooming war and how it is a way to say goodbye before the final battle or something, some even pretend it is after the final battle.
Most probably only like those bits, I myself would probably like them and pretend it is after the final mission.

I imagine pro-enders don't like it so much because it somewhat gives closure to the characters.

[Rip504]

Add it to everything with a BW/EA label on it. That much/type of interaction between the squad was amazingly awesome. Epic.

[Bill Casey]

Si-Shen wrote...

Jassu1979 wrote...

Well, it just goes to show that people who like the ending have HORRIBLE taste.

How so?  Personally I disliked the endings but thought this DLC was fun and enjoyable.

Generalization is bad.

HagarIshay liked the endings but thought this DLC was bad...

Modifié par Bill Casey, 12 mars 2013 - 11:01 .

[Holger1405]

GimmeDaGun wrote...


Oh, I know that. Here I'm definitely in the minority when it comes either to the ending or the Citadel dlc. That's not the point. Point is that one can have an opinion regardless what others say, and it does not make him or her a "peasant", Jim. 

Yes, you are right, as I agree with you on the ending, but the DLC was imho pure Gold.
So yah, different taste.   

[Linkenski]

I don't care if they do it in future games or not. My problem with it is that it breaks immersion if the tone of the game is broken, and the self-referential, 4th-wall breaking jokes in the vanilla game really did this. It was cool for this last piece of DLC but only because it's optional and because it feels like it's part of something on the other side of the narrative border of the trilogy.

I hated the calibration jokes when they appeared in-game in the vanilla ME3. They were fun as a meme (but basically as lame as the "arrow in the knee" jokes from skyrim), i hated the "i will destroy you!" joke, which was a joke of another joke (rodriguez from ME3 imitating jack from ME2 imitating generic human female enemy lines from ME1)

Bioware can do whatever they want in my opinion, but only as long as they do everything in style.

[Si-Shen]

Bill Casey wrote...

Si-Shen wrote...

Jassu1979 wrote...

Well, it just goes to show that people who like the ending have HORRIBLE taste.

How so?  Personally I disliked the endings but thought this DLC was fun and enjoyable.

Generalization is bad.

HagarIshay liked the endings but thought this DLC was bad...

Ah... also note I miss-read the post I quoted... one should not post while hungry lol

Personally I do think linking the endings but not the DLC is odd but then again I also have no real complaint about any of the DLC.

Also, on topic of the thread... Cheese is good... seriously could have used more lol

[Sejborg]

For a special side mission/DLC it was fine, and it was nice to see the writers have a bit of fun before moving on. But for a whole game it would be way too much. Just look at DA2.

Modifié par Sejborg, 12 mars 2013 - 11:30 .

[Versus Omnibus]

Allan Schumacher wrote...

I loved the cheese. It was pure camp and I was in stitches the entire time I played it. I loved it and feel they really hit the ball out of the park with Citadel.

I agree. The humor in this DLC is fanastic and I hope for more laughs like this in the future.

[GimmeDaGun]

TheProtheans wrote...

GimmeDaGun wrote...

kylecouch wrote...

GimmeDaGun wrote...

john_sheparrd wrote...

OP is a troll lock this thread

Yeah, expressing opinions is trolling, but when many of you have been feeling the constant urge to express your thoughts about the ending in every single thread (the topic didn't really matter), that was completely ok. "**** please!"


It's funny to see how people who hate the endings love this and call it quality writing and vice versa (I'm in the latter group). It shows how wildly tastes can differ from each other. 

You realize I hate the Endings, AND dislike the direction of this DLC? 

What you and the Prothean say further justifies my point: It shows how wildly tastes can differ from each other. 

But usually based on my personal observation I can say that most people who hated the endings love this, and many who liked it do not like it so much... 

 I doubt they like it for what it adds to the story.
From what I seen they only like it because of the ridiculous things the characters do during a dooming war and how it is a way to say goodbye before the final battle or something, some even pretend it is after the final battle.
Most probably only like those bits, I myself would probably like them and pretend it is after the final mission.

I imagine pro-enders don't like it so much because it somewhat gives closure to the characters.

Yeah, a very clever thought indeed. It's because the people who like the ending usually hate anything which might be good... I've just heard that all pro-enders drink infant blood as apatiser before lunch... you take this whole pro-ender vs. anti-ender thing way too seriously. It's still just a game: a product which aims to entertain us. And as such it can be a success or a failure to each individual person, since we all have different tastes and our opinions are all subjective. This dlc is cheesy, but it aims to be cheesy. The ending is darkish and gritty, because it aims to be that... it's all up to us whether we like it or not. 

But back to your remark: no, it's not the closure for those characters what irks me... actually to me there was enough closure in the main game itself... I didn't feel the need for more, but I do not dislike the things I dislike about this dlc, because "oh nooos" it gives more closure to those who hate the ending. I dislike it because I find it ridiculously cheesy, out of place and goofy. 

Modifié par GimmeDaGun, 13 mars 2013 - 12:19 .

[Holger1405]

GimmeDaGun wrote...

I've just heard that all pro-enders drink infant blood as apatiser before lunch...

Damn! How did they found out about this?   

[JosieFrances]

Totally agree with this!

Allan Schumacher wrote...

I loved the cheese. It was pure camp and I was in stitches the entire time I played it. I loved it and feel they really hit the ball out of the park with Citadel.

[Argentoid]

HagarIshay wrote...

Argentoid wrote...

Buenos Aires -> 13h -> skipped college

I'm mean!

What?


EDIT: It's really annoying we've been talking about a lockdown for about 2.5 pages and still no Ninja.

WHERE IS OUR NINJA!?!

Oh, sorry. Bad english...

I was just saying that: I was at Buenos Aires, it was like 01:00 PM in the afternoon and that... I skipped college because I was too lazy to attend classes.

So, meanwhile, I was having fun at this thread.

Modifié par Argentoid, 13 mars 2013 - 01:20 .

[nrobbiec]

I enjoy the ending and absolutely loved Citadel.

[Heimdall]

I'm... neutral leaning positive on the endings. I enjoyed the DLC very much. Yeah, cheese galore, but the purpose of the DLC was a send off for all the characters we've known over the years. Once I got past the dubious decision for Shepard to take shore leave, though at least they had the excuse of Normandy repair, I couldn't get enough of it.

[Getorex]

I enjoyed the Citadel DLC quite a bit, despised the ending so much I never completed the original game and don't give a flying monkey crap for the extended ending. So, the perfect game to me, given the bones we have, is to install the MEHEM and the DLC and take THAT as the real ending of the series.

[Knubbsal]

If you are undecided, it is not too late to throw her out of the airlock.

[Grand Admiral Cheesecake]

Wayning_Star wrote...

IC-07 wrote...

Hm... There's still smth missing in the title... I suggest you change it again.

maybe 'cheesecake' in the title...

<_<

[Cainhurst Crow]

The hell? Why is this turning into an ending thread?

[Funkdrspot]

HagarIshay wrote...

 "This is brought to you by random acts of violence"
"They've got a Prothean over there!" "And that's a future corpse over there!"
"What do you have that I don't?" *CloneShep asks right before Shepard's friends rescue him/her while Brooks bails on Clony*
"I should go. I SHOULD go. I should GO"
*Calibration jokes that got old in the vanila game*
"You've seen that Brooks? This is how legands do it!"
"We had an old saying in my cycle: Kill her"
"How can you say biotics are better than pysichal strength when you have me in front of you?"
"You think you are clever. And maybe you are. But clever doesn't stop a bullet" (And a bullet helps when you are behind a bulletproof field...)
And many, many more that I don't remember right now.

Cheesy lines are cheesy BioWare. Please don't use them in any future game. Please tone it down for future games/ DLCs.

Yeah. it was ridiculously cheesy and WAAAAAAAAAAAAAY  too much of it. I think it was meant to be purposely cheesy though.