Aller au contenu

Photo

Duncan in City Elf Origin WTF


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
163 réponses à ce sujet

#51
Guest_Faerunner_*

Guest_Faerunner_*
  • Guests

Bhryaen wrote...

The point I was making though was that Duncan thought of Daveth and Jory as Warden material without them really demonstrating any darkspawn-killing potential- not by simply winning a tournament or failing a pickpocket attempt.


Firstly, "simply winning a tournament" is not as easy as picking a pocket. Secondly, you don't think demonstrating enough skill in combat to defeat dozens of very skilled fighters demonstrates darkpawn-killing potiential? Thirdly, as Ser Jory himself says, he fought hard to impress Duncan.

Not just with his skill with a blade, no doubt, but with his character. Duncan considers character as well as skill when determining. Alistair competed in a tournment to impress Duncan too, but he didn't even come close to winning. Regardless, Duncan picked him for his cheerful personality and humor, on the grounds that one needs to have a positive attitude in order not to be discouraged by the daunting, sometimes hopeless task of fighting darkspawn. (Well, that's his public reason, though many fans have alternate theories.)

What I find telling is that most people can tell after talking to Ser Jory for 30 seconds that he is NOT Grey Warden material. Just his overall attitude, demeanor, and way of talking about the Grey Wardens shows that he is not psychologically prepared or suitable for the job; yet Duncan recruited him. Why? I suspect that Ser Jory's perseverence in impressing Duncan as well as his skill in winning the tournament convinced him to give him a chance. (Plus, you know, pressure to find recruits ASAP). I'm guessing that Duncan figured that if Ser Jory could channel the passion he put into joining the Wardens into defeating the Blight, he would be a suitable candidate. Little did Duncan know, Jory was only in it for the glory... 

But while he could apparently discern the potential of Daveth and Jory from a pickpocketing and a tournament- complete strangers otherwise- he requires his good friend Adaia's kid CE to endure, well, all (s)he does- if (s)he does- to merit his endorsement for worthy inductee? Surely doing some serious sparring in the alley- during which he'd have her totally outmatched but would observe her ingenuity at overcoming the gap- might reveal the CE's potential better than merely failing a pickpocket. And, mind you, all my CE's have been pickpockets who have failed on him, though the guard wasn't called on them like they were on Daveth.


I think it has more to do with character than skill. Like I said, Duncan considers people's characters as well as their skills when determining who would make a Grey Warden. When you try to get him to leave the alienage, he is impressed by your chutzpah in being an unarmed elf refusing to back down from an armed human. If you talk to him before the wedding ceremony, he mentions how Adaia was a fiery woman who would have made an excellent Grey Warden, then mentions how he heard she passed her training onto her kid.

I'm guessing Duncan knew that Adaia had both the personality and skill for the job, but wasn't yet sure of her child. My guess is that he intended to keep guaging your personality and prowess (making pleasantries at a wedding isn't exactly ideal), and probably would have kept weighing your suitability versus the need for a recruit versus the importance of your future... until Vaughan struck. By then, I'm guessing he couldn't officially get involved without bringing the wrath of Ferelden nobility down on the Grey Wardens, so he decided to make the best of the situation by throwing a lifesaver and seeing how well you could swim on your own. For all we know, Duncan would have only needed some back alley sparring to decide if you were suitable, but Vaughan's party-crashing put a wrench in that. 

As for Daveth, Duncan apparently used to be a pickpocketing street thief with no home to call his own as well. It's possible that Duncan saw a lot of himself in Daveth, and figured that he too could rise to the challenge and make a decent Grey Warden if given the opportunity. As we see just before the Joining Ritual, he was on the nose with Daveth... too bad he didn't survive. =(

Also, Daveth didn't just fail a pickpocket attempt; he ran like the dickens and got chased down by some guards. For all we know, Daveth displayed some decent skill during his attempted flee and attitude toward the guards. Plus his life was pretty much over then anyway, as he was about to be hanged, so maybe Duncan decided give him a chance at surviving the Joining versus certain death by the noose, on top of what he saw already.

So is it some prejudice vs elves on his part that he has such a miserable double-standard, requiring elves to do much more to impress him before he gives a damn? Not clear, though he does praise the last Archdemon-slayer who was an elf, so not likely. In any case the double-standard looms there conspicuously, making it unclear what rationale Duncan would use to stand aside for a drunk noble's rape party.


Hey now, I'm as sensitive to human prejudice against elves as they come, but even I don't think there's some alternate racist motive here. He doesn't make the City Elf undergo anything that he doesn't make any other PC from any Origin undergo. He also hears of Cousland's, Aeducan's, and the Mages (both Elf and Human)'s skill before meeting them, considers them for a while, decides not to press it, then only decides "Yep, you're the one" after disaster unexpectedly strikes and they impress him with their reactions.

I'm guessing that Duncan's "rationale" for standing aside is the reason he gives. The Grey Wardens can't get involved politically, Ferelden numbers and support are too few, there's nothing he could have done to make Vaughan back down without jeopardizing the Ferelden Grey Wardens' welcome in the country (and their chance at continuing to fight the Blight), so he had to make the best of the situation.

#52
Bhryaen

Bhryaen
  • Members
  • 1 082 messages
@Faerunner
Well, you answer your "but a tournament is a good test" in your next paragraph- Ser Jory still isn't GW material despite winning it... So it isn't much of a test- even though it sufficed for Duncan. And again the point I was making was- if Ser Jory (a married guy with kids who might just have other priorities) only had to win a tournament and half-heartedly offer his services in order to "pass muster" for Duncan, then why would Duncan acquiesce entirely to Vaughan as his test of the CE? Duncan's tests are demonstrably not requiring of any major effort.

And, as you say, he may have recruited Daveth simply because the pickpocket was better off trying for Wardenhood than hung for petty theft (though Daveth is a lot more promising as a recruit- would've been great having him the entire game)- in which case there is no real character or talent test at all, just desperation and the ability to fight. And why not just go to every prison and gallows for new recruit material if that's all that's needed? (Why not indeed?) But the CE has no such luxury as a "test" because Duncan requires the Vaughan test instead.

And if Duncan is going on Daveth's street cred and defiance-tendency as sufficient, the CE has just the same given that she's Adaia's protege with a penchant for standing up for kin. So why accede to subjecting her to be such a cruel battery of "tests" at that point? She's already a shoo-in.

I'm just saying I can't see the "mettle-testing" argument as explaining why Duncan doesn't speak up at all as Adaia's kid is hauled off for an orderly raping and murdering.

And that's really all the OP's point is: Duncan doesn't do anything to intervene. There's no reason to make a violent stand if he can change the outcome merely by speaking up- and if the violent option is out for political reasons (and it does appear so), the option of diplomacy still remains, whatever the likelihood of success. A drunk spoiled "noble" intent on dirty deeds isn't the most likely to show backbone against an intimidation or persuasion check by the formidable Gray Warden Leader Duncan, so the chances of coersion aren't nil. And if a violent threat is all Duncan gets in response, fine, he acquiesces and later sneaks in a sword and crossbow, hoping that's enough... But until such time other alternatives exist. He had nothing to lose by at least trying to dissuade Vaughan before slinking off to spectator status- even if Adaia's kid wasn't in the abducted group or even if he'd decided already that she wasn't GW material... but especially if she was.

#53
Guest_Faerunner_*

Guest_Faerunner_*
  • Guests

Bhryaen wrote...

@Faerunner
Well, you answer your "but a tournament is a good test" in your next paragraph- Ser Jory still isn't GW material despite winning it... So it isn't much of a test- even though it sufficed for Duncan. And again the point I was making was- if Ser Jory (a married guy with kids who might just have other priorities) only had to win a tournament and half-heartedly offer his services in order to "pass muster" for Duncan, then why would Duncan acquiesce entirely to Vaughan as his test of the CE? Duncan's tests are demonstrably not requiring of any major effort.


You missed my point entirely. Ser Jory said "I fought hard to impress Duncan," which I suspect to have a double-meaning. Not just that he fought hard with his sword to show his skill in battle against potential darkspawn, but that he fought hard to show his dedication to joining the Wardens. It's possible that he had to work to convince Duncan that he had good character material as well as fighting material. I suspect Duncan agreed because he thought that Jory was earnest and/or if he channeled the dedication he used to joining the Wardens into stopping the Blight, he would make a decent potential Grey Warden. (And he might have. Again though, turns out he joined for the wrong reasons.)

Also, unless you've ever fought in a tournament, you can quit saying how it doesn't require "any major effort." In fact, I dare you to sign up for the nearest tournament to your home. Doesn't matter what kind; sports, martial arts, archery, barrel racing, Yu-Gi-Oh! cards. Just sign up and compete in a tournament and tell me how easy it is. 

And, as you say, he may have recruited Daveth simply because the pickpocket was better off trying for Wardenhood than hung for petty theft (though Daveth is a lot more promising as a recruit- would've been great having him the entire game)- in which case there is no real character or talent test at all, just desperation and the ability to fight. And why not just go to every prison and gallows for new recruit material if that's all that's needed? (Why not indeed?) But the CE has no such luxury as a "test" because Duncan requires the Vaughan test instead.


I also said that he probably recruited Daveth because he saw something in his character from first-hand observation and interaction. I did not at all say that he only recruited him because he was about to be killed, so might as well see if he survives the Joining,  and I don't appreciate you putting words in my mouth.

Also, Duncan does not "require" the Vaughan test. Please read for context before responding. I'm saying that Duncan was already considering the City Elf but did not have enough information yet because the two literally only had one conversation. He likely would have only needed to speak further and see a demonstration of her fighting ability before making up his mind. However, Vaughan's party crash interupted. He could not get directly involved without bringing serious repercussions on Ferelden Grey Wardens (and jeopardize their chance of stopping the Blight), so he threw her a lifesaver and watched her swim.

It's like a talent scout planning to see how well a potential candidate can swim by watching them paddle around in the shallow end, only for them to get grabbed and thrown into the deep end. Might as well use that opportunity to observe their skill there. Which ends up being even more suitable since the job he's offering involves a lot of high-stress swimming in deep water anyway.

And if Duncan is going on Daveth's street cred and defiance-tendency as sufficient, the CE has just the same given that she's Adaia's protege with a penchant for standing up for kin. So why accede to subjecting her to be such a cruel battery of "tests" at that point? She's already a shoo-in.


The difference between Daveth and the City Elf is that he sees Daveth's "street cred" and "defiance-tendency" firsthand before deciding to recruit him (thus seeing his potential in the process), whereas he only knows about the City Elf's from hearsay when he first meets her (thus not fully seeing the potential yet). He is clearly impressed and seriously considering the CE, but probably wanted to see more firshand (rather than hearsay) before making a final decision. Then Vaughan shows up.

It's implied too that he's considering the City Elf's future. You are literally moments away from getting married. He doesn't know how skilled you are just yet. He likely has other candidates in mind (like the dwarves, mages and Cousland if the other Origins are any indication). It's likely he wants to see more of your spirit and skill in action, and judge your suitability versus those of other potential candidates. However, Vaughan's party put a stop to that.

I'm just saying I can't see the "mettle-testing" argument as explaining why Duncan doesn't speak up at all as Adaia's kid is hauled off for an orderly raping and murdering.


And if Adaia's kid can't rescue herself from a few guards the way her mother most likely could have, how would she fair against hordes of darkspawn?

And that's really all the OP's point is: Duncan doesn't do anything to intervene. There's no reason to make a violent stand if he can change the outcome merely by speaking up- and if the violent option is out for political reasons (and it does appear so), the option of diplomacy still remains, whatever the likelihood of success.


That's the problem. I don't think he could have made a difference by simply speaking up. The Grey Wardens are too new, few, distrusted and restricted in Ferelden for his words to carry any weight. Anyway, the CE gets knocked out in the middle of the ceremony, remember? For all we know, Duncan did try to speak up and Vaughan simply shrugged him off. Considering how he also shrugs off Mother Boann, who actually does have influence in Ferelden Andriastian society as a head Ferelden priestess, I doubt he would listen to a Grey Warden who is not allowed to say boo to the local law.

A drunk spoiled "noble" intent on dirty deeds isn't the most likely to show backbone against an intimidation or persuasion check by the formidable Gray Warden Leader Duncan, so the chances of coersion aren't nil. And if a violent threat is all Duncan gets in response, fine, he acquiesces and later sneaks in a sword and crossbow, hoping that's enough... But until such time other alternatives exist. He had nothing to lose by at least trying to dissuade Vaughan before slinking off to spectator status- even if Adaia's kid wasn't in the abducted group or even if he'd decided already that she wasn't GW material... but especially if she was.


Again, Grey Wardens have no legal or political authority in Ferelden, Vaughan has already been shown to scoff at authority, and the PC gets knocked out for a good portion of the kidnapping. Whether or not you believe Duncan could have had any verbal influence (I don't think he could have), we simply don't see the whole thing and don't know for sure if he tried it or not.

#54
Bhryaen

Bhryaen
  • Members
  • 1 082 messages
Well, that's true. The initial wedding crash is only a matter of seconds and the actual abduction doesn't take place until after the CE is unconscious- that backhand being when the actual crime (which would otherwise be most compelling to a concerned Duncan) started occurring, so it's not fair to assert that Duncan did nothing. He only certainly did nothing up to the point that the CE gets the slapdown. I'll grant that- so not much more to say on it... The OP (and I) overlooked that possibility... You and I already agree that Duncan was in no position to, well, do what we usually do: rampage through the governor's estate as saviors- as we do again later to "save" Anora, delicate GW standing in Ferelden or no.

On joining a tournament- oh, I've always shied from the tournaments even though I know it would be a good way to adjust my skills to (more or less) real situations. It's the same thing with weight lifting- a difference between the strength needed for barbell lifts and the strength needed to actually lift heavy objects. But I wasn't saying that tournaments are easy- either to win or simply to face. I was saying that winning a tournament is a cake walk compared to being abducted by far more than merely "a few soldiers"- and the very Arl of Denerim's soldiers at that, including lieutenants- intent on actually raping or killing you (or making sure one and/ or the other happens to you). I'll gladly join a tournament instead where my competitors aren't trying to rape and kill me, where if I get injured the match is stopped and medics can aid me, where I have all the equipment I need and time to prepare, where the odds aren't stacked overwhelmingly against me, etc. If the two "tests" are equivalent for Duncan, well, that just shows something of his character. And again there's Daveth who underwent no such test at all, just had his street rep and humor- and OK, the (perhaps) brilliant chase (though I won't mention that Daveth doesn't come with pickpocket skills in vanilla). But, yes, as I said, the tournament or chase themselves weren't the ticket- whatever that ticket even is.

(Another point might be that Daveth faced the worst challenge since those soldiers may have been likely to kill him. He was destined for the gallows anyway. So Duncan had to intervene or Daveth would be dead for sure. The CE female mostly faces a rape- which one does survive- with "only" the possibility of being murdered. But Vaughan did have a reputation for more than mere promiscuity regarding elves, so...)

So I had understood your point- which is why I responded that Jory's impressing Duncan during the Redliffe tournament wasn't a demonstration of actual GW potential (something you'd already asserted), something Duncan was mistaken about regarding more dead GW wannabe's than Jory and Daveth. It's a gamble anyway apparently. You can't actually know if it's a fit until the delicious chalice-full o' nummies is presented. But Duncan is wrong more often than right, tallying our GW and Alistair's account.

I also didn't put these words in your mouth:

Faerunner wrote...
Plus his life was pretty much over then anyway, as he was about to be hanged, so maybe Duncan decided give him a chance at surviving the Joining versus certain death by the noose, on top of what he saw already.


I recognize that you'd made a number of different arguments why Duncan might've recruited Daveth, not just this one (it was a "plus" and "on top of" after all), but this was one of them, and thus, no, you weren't saying that Daveth's facing the gallows was sufficient reason for Duncan all alone, but it was potentially the decisive one. Regardless of anything else, Daveth was facing certain death anyway, so... why not snatch him up? True, Duncan's not likely to intervene to recruit someone he doesn't think can handle the tasks at all- why bother?- and Daveth was apparently promising enough from the all-too-brief encounter Duncan had had with him, but it wasn't an offer made at a tavern where Daveth had safely hidden out after escaping the guards. It wasn't an offer made without duress. The choice is made to give Daveth a different option for his neck.

And really why not? Riordan makes it clear in defense of Loghain that the GW's recruit all sorts of social rejects in pursuit of the defeat of darkspawn. The gallows holding cells might be a great place to look for recruits, particularly as a blight rears its head...

As to Duncan's word holding no weight... I balk every time I hear that about the GW's having no power in Ferelden. The lore may tout that out, but... really? GW's are given the royal ear of Cailan; GW's are given welcome and esteem in no lower manor than the Cousland castle itself; GW's stop the whole of casted Orzammar from coming down on my DC's head with a simple "whoa, horsey!"; the Dalish lose all their caution when one merely states to them that one is a GW whereupon they escort you directly to their leader; GW's stop the very leader of the Circle Tower Templars from arresting the demonstrated accomplice of a blood mage who had just shamed him, no blood magic charm required; GW's stop the guards of Denerim from arresting my knife-ears murderer of the very son of the Arl of Denerim himself plus about 25 soldiers and the estate dogs (not to mention the looting of the place) with yet another magic GW Command; despite their apparently already-weak standing, GW's are accused of regicide by the Queen and the original Hero of Ferelden but still walk openly in the streets of Denerim with the guards turning a blind eye (unless you fail a pickpocket, of course) and no harassment other than Ser Landry (who you can persuade otherwise) and the slavers who, well, are slavers. Even the Lothering Templar leader offers a nice helm, the Lothering "mother" just shoos you off out of fear of repercussions, and the Lothering thugs just want the ransom cash not revenge. Not a single Crow would take the contract on a GW except for the suicidal Zevran. And that respect can come potentially after you poison the Sacred Ashes, kill the Dalish elves, turn your back on Redcliffe, make a deal with Connor's and Honnleath's and Avernus' demons, etc. Not until you've killed Howe do Loghain's soldiers show up to nab the supposedly infamous Wardens, and not to arrest the already-disgraced GW's for the outstanding accusation of regicide, no: for killing Howe. Then after my GW (entirely lacking Duncan's reputation, mind you) slaughters all the occupants of Fort Drakon itself, the Landsmeet goes over in a landslide "for the Warden!" It'd be interesting to know what DAO would look like if GW's actually had no influence or authority in Ferelden, no Right of Conscription, the Warden Treaties treated like toilet paper, their word ignored and defied, mistrust everywhere. I mean, Daveth's guards (in yet another Ferelden town that respects GW's) didn't even know for sure Duncan would make Daveth a GW when they released him to Duncan's "custody" (though Duncan isn't an official officer of any Ferelden order owing loyalties to the crown), just trusted outright in his GW Command to suffice.

Arl of Denerim: "Did you catch that evil knife-ears criminal who managed to slaughter my son and all the guards in my estate? Not to mention Fido, my favorite hound! She's gonna be hung by her throat until-"
Arresting Guard: "Uh, no, ser. A Gray Warden came along, said he'd take the elf off our hands, so I said, 'Sure.'"
Arl of Denerim: "Oh... good enough then." *shrugs* "Carry on..."

So, yes, Duncan's word would've held weight as a GW- though regardless of intervening as a GW, he's a powerful fighter or rogue who could clearly take Vaughan and the little group Vaughan came with, so that too would've weighed into the exchange. Duncan could've intervened to at least try, and, no, as I also agree, the chances wouldn't have been good given how devoted to lowlifehood Vaughan was, but there was nothing stopping him from giving persuasion/ intimidation of the drunken malevolent ****** a shot... And for all we know he did.

#55
Get Magna Carter

Get Magna Carter
  • Members
  • 1 542 messages
Duncan's primary purpose is to recruit grey wardens and stop the blight. He seems to dismiss other matters as unimportant.
Interfering in politics in Ferelden got the Grey Wardens kicked out earlier. Interfering in the actions of nobles and their families could be considered to be more of the same compromising the Grey Wardens position within Ferelden.
What's more important -saving a few elves or saving a country?

Admittedly, when I played it I came up with a theory that Duncan had staged the whole thing as a test and regarded him with suspicion afterwards (so I wasn't too bothered when he bought it)- but that's probably not intended and just a reflection of how deviously my mind can work..

#56
Get Magna Carter

Get Magna Carter
  • Members
  • 1 542 messages
I will add that the grey wardens are still controversial in HUMAN society (Dwarves and Dalish elves don't care about the wardens meddling in human politics) and there are limitations to what Duncan can do when dealing with humans in authority without invoking the "right of conscription".
He's not going to use that right on everyone in trouble - just the ones he think can help the Wardens deal with the blight.

#57
Guest_Faerunner_*

Guest_Faerunner_*
  • Guests

Bhryaen wrote...

Well, that's true. The initial wedding crash is only a matter of seconds and the actual abduction doesn't take place until after the CE is unconscious- that backhand being when the actual crime (which would otherwise be most compelling to a concerned Duncan) started occurring, so it's not fair to assert that Duncan did nothing. He only certainly did nothing up to the point that the CE gets the slapdown. I'll grant that- so not much more to say on it... The OP (and I) overlooked that possibility... You and I already agree that Duncan was in no position to, well, do what we usually do: rampage through the governor's estate as saviors- as we do again later to "save" Anora, delicate GW standing in Ferelden or no.


It's something to consider.

But I wasn't saying that tournaments are easy- either to win or simply to face.

You put it in the same category as a failed pickpocket attempt, which is far from true.

I was saying that winning a tournament is a cake walk compared to being abducted by far more than merely "a few soldiers"- and the very Arl of Denerim's soldiers at that, including lieutenants- intent on actually raping or killing you (or making sure one and/ or the other happens to you).

Both involve a lot of physical exercsion, combat prowess, and perseverance against overwhelming odds. Just saying.

I'll gladly join a tournament instead where my competitors aren't trying to rape and kill me, where if I get injured the match is stopped and medics can aid me, where I have all the equipment I need and time to prepare, where the odds aren't stacked overwhelmingly against me, etc. If the two "tests" are equivalent for Duncan, well, that just shows something of his character. And again there's Daveth who underwent no such test at all, just had his street rep and humor- and OK, the (perhaps) brilliant chase (though I won't mention that Daveth doesn't come with pickpocket skills in vanilla). But, yes, as I said, the tournament or chase themselves weren't the ticket- whatever that ticket even is.

The two are not equivalent in form, but Duncan seems like the kind of guy that just needs to see someone's personality and prowess firsthand before choosing them. Daveth, Jory and the CE are all different people who meet Duncan in different circumstances, and show their mettle in different ways (depending on the challenge in front of them when they meet him), but he still evaluates their mettle in however they happen to show when he meets them.

So I had understood your point- which is why I responded that Jory's impressing Duncan during the Redliffe tournament wasn't a demonstration of actual GW potential (something you'd already asserted)

Jory himself is not GW potential, but I am arguing that he likely demonstrated GW potential.

Grey Wardens need to show excellent fighting prowess for battling darkspawn, perseverence against overwhelming odds (as the job can be overwhelming), and show a willingness to do and sacrifice whatever is needed to accomplish their goals. Ser Jory shows his prowess and perseverence during the tournament, both in fighting and likely in trying to convince Duncan, so I would say that, yes, he probably slid through on technical GW potential. (Unfortunately, it was misplaced.)

I recognize that you'd made a number of different arguments why Duncan might've recruited Daveth, not just this one (it was a "plus" and "on top of" after all), but this was one of them, and thus, no, you weren't saying that Daveth's facing the gallows was sufficient reason for Duncan all alone, but it was potentially the decisive one.[/qote Regardless of anything else, Daveth was facing certain death anyway, so... why not snatch him up? True, Duncan's not likely to intervene to recruit someone he doesn't think can handle the tasks at all- why bother?- and Daveth was apparently promising enough from the all-too-brief encounter Duncan had had with him, but it wasn't an offer made at a tavern where Daveth had safely hidden out after escaping the guards. It wasn't an offer made without duress. The choice is made to give Daveth a different option for his neck.

Bingo. He wouldn't have extended the offer if he didn't already believe Daveth had it in him. He most likely wouldn't have already believed Daveth had it in him if he didn't see him in action. 

And really why not? Riordan makes it clear in defense of Loghain that the GW's recruit all sorts of social rejects in pursuit of the defeat of darkspawn. The gallows holding cells might be a great place to look for recruits, particularly as a blight rears its head...

The Grey Wardens need the best of the best, not just people who happen to be in one particular situation. You seem to want to latch onto one particular characteristic or recruiting method to be applied to all potential recruits, but that's just not how it goes. They need an even balance people with various skills, talents, and personality traits to bring to the table, but who still underneath all display formidable skill, perseverance, willingness to fight against impossible odds and sacrifice whatever is needed to accomplish their goals.

Just as adventuring parties don't function as well if they're all tank warriors versus an even balance of tanks, archers, melee DPS, skill monkeys, offensive mages, healers, etc. Notice that Duncan mentions they can use more mages in their ranks since magic is so useful against darkspawn, and mentions how they can use more dwarves since they're accustomed to fighting darkspawn (like how templar skills are useful against darkspawn magic). However, not all mages or dwarves display the "best of the best" skills and spirits to fight darkspawn, so it would be a waste of time and resources to simply search for a bunch of recruits in one particular situation.

As to Duncan's word holding no weight... I balk every time I hear that about the GW's having no power in Ferelden. The lore may tout that out, but... really? GW's are given the royal ear of Cailan; GW's are given welcome and esteem in no lower manor than the Cousland castle itself; GW's stop the whole of casted Orzammar from coming down on my DC's head with a simple "whoa, horsey!"; the Dalish lose all their caution when one merely states to them that one is a GW whereupon they escort you directly to their leader; GW's stop the very leader of the Circle Tower Templars from arresting the demonstrated accomplice of a blood mage who had just shamed him, no blood magic charm required; GW's stop the guards of Denerim from arresting my knife-ears murderer of the very son of the Arl of Denerim himself plus about 25 soldiers and the estate dogs (not to mention the looting of the place) with yet another magic GW Command;

Stop right there. Grey Wardens are given respect from some people but not others, but they can't make people who don't respect them listen to them (except in matters involving darkspawn). As for sparing the Warden, those were all the Right of Conscription, which is all they can do. The Wardens only have authority in doing what is needed to prevent and fight against Blights. If it isn't darkspawn-related, they aren't allowed to do it. I doubt he could just walk up and say, "Unhand those maidens!" and expect to be obeyed. Maybe he tried, but Vaughan doesn't have to listen to him because he likely knows that Duncan can't enforce that command/request. He can't get involved with local politics.

And all the things your Warden does is in the interest of stopping the Blight. 

Modifié par Faerunner, 08 mai 2013 - 01:22 .


#58
thats1evildude

thats1evildude
  • Members
  • 10 976 messages
Yes, Duncan can conscript criminals. That doesn't equate to holding influence with the guard. Duncan can't stop the captain from arresting Soris or purging the Alienage, which he threatens to do if Vaughan's killer does not surrender.

As for other members of the guard, Sergeant Kylon makes it clear that even if he believed the official reports from the teryn, he would not try to arrest you because his men are useless and he's not feeling suicidal.

Modifié par thats1evildude, 07 mai 2013 - 05:01 .


#59
LadyRaena13

LadyRaena13
  • Members
  • 262 messages
Ok having just played through this game for like the 16th or 17th time. My 3rd as a city elf, let me explain it too you. He is a Grey Warden, Vaughn is a LORDLING meaning if Duncan got involved directly he would be actively damaging his "grey-ness" his neutrality. But by giving your cousin and fiance weapons to save you, not only is he helping indirectly anyone who comes back is skilled in something obviously so he has his recruit.

#60
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 400 messages

Ferretinabun wrote...

I know where OP is coming from, and just because I want to like Duncan, I headcannoned that he wasn't actually at the wedding. He does appear before the ceremony, but he is specially respectful about not wanting to intrude. And you don't actually see him during the wedding, so I assumed he'd just retired off to one side to let the elves have their private rituals in peace. Rather than actually standing right there watching the entire kidnap drama take place and doing naff all to stop it. That WOULD make him an ass.

I don't have too much of an issue with Duncan in the mage, or Dwarven origins. Sure, he will conscript you even against your wishes, but in practically all cases he is still saving you from obvious death. The Dalish origin doesn't sit quite so easily, because it feels a bit more like Duncan is conscripting you JUST to save you, rather than because he thinks you'd genuinely make a good warden, but that's not so much of an issue,

He DOES, however, come across as an ass in the Human Noble origin. One of the main reasons that is my least played origin.


Honestly only origins I found him not to be a douchecanoe in were DC, DN and DE. Probably because in those origins there's no way to avoid death without being conscripted.

HN especially made me gladly take that "he got what he deserved" dialogue choice. Don't even care if it loses me 20 approval.

#61
Guest_Challenge Everything_*

Guest_Challenge Everything_*
  • Guests
I really never saw Duncan as bad. Probably because I never was forced. The only one where I ever said I didn't want to be a Warden was as a Dwarf Commoner, and Duncan was pretty much like: sure, that's fine, I won't force you, but they might execute you.
I'm really interested in seeing what the forced Human Noble recruitment is like, now.
But as a City Elf, meh, I don't see him as that bad. City Elf is probably my favorite Origin.
Then it's also a matter of Warden stuff. Is it a jerk move for a Warden to walk through a town and ignore the fact that innocents are getting killed because they're not supposed to get involved in these sort of things? Yes. But it's what a Warden is supposed to do.

#62
Bhryaen

Bhryaen
  • Members
  • 1 082 messages
@Faerunner
1. Failed pickpocketing and tournaments are in the same category: not in the category of Easy Things To Perform, but in the category of Things That Don't Necessarily Make One Cut Out To Be A Warden. Quite true- and demonstrated in the game. They also fall into the category of Things That Impressed Duncan That Nevertheless Didn't Demonstrate Them As Sufficent For Gray Wardenhood.
2. Tournaments happen in relatively perfect safety. Forced abduction to the wealthy estate of armed men intent on rape and/or murdering you... not happening in any safety whatsoever. Only one option has a high chance of you ending up dead, and only one option has a high chance of being a festive event full of friends and family out enjoying themselves. Just saying.
3. "Well, I like to test people out first, see how they do in a challenge, so I think I'll just step aside silently to let this 1st level character get raped, maybe murdered, see how she fares..." isn't the thought process of someone who's earnestly interested in getting a living recruit to the Gray Wardens.
4. I've not "latched on" to the idea of recruiting from the gallows/ prisons as the only method of recruitment or only population from which to recruit. But it's a valid idea, and in a time of a blight, maybe a prudent one.
5. The Right of Conscription is power. It puts the Gray Wardens above the law- able to tell the Denerim police "Unhand that City Elf maiden!" despite that that maiden just murdered the mayor's son and all the mayor's mansion- pull people out of their everyday lives- and on the flimsiest of pretexts, having no proof whatsoever that you're even going to actually subject them to the Joining. And what proof is there that you're even a GW? They just accept it. And how? What force has Duncan got to back up this "right"? What stops people from just saying, "Yeah, Mr. 'Warden', we know about your kind. That old 'Warden' command stuff might impress lasses at the pub, but around here we got laws to enforce. Now outta the way before we gotta hurt ya." Instead they say, "Oh, well, OK. Whatever you say. We'll ignore our own laws and popular sentiment because you who claim to be a Gray Warden say so. Anything for you's guys, you know that." But he can't simply try to persuade Vaughan to back down and look out for people the way Riordan describes the duties of a Gray Warden? Nug-droppings. Doing the right thing by standing up to Vaughan in such a way could easily help the Gray Wardens cause and likely win them a great deal of respect from the Alienage elves watching, potentially inspiring interest. Not doing so just makes them look like an order that cowtows to nobility and does nothing of particular worth to anyone else.

@Others
How many times do I...? The OP's point was never that Duncan had to slaughter Vaughan and all his soldiers there on the spot, just that during the scene when Vaughan returns and breaks up the wedding, Duncan was conspicuously absent when instead he could've at least said something in protest- even if it were written so that Vaughan told Duncan off and forced him to accede. It would've shown Duncan as a good guy- or at least worthy of the hero title he tends to be afforded throughout the rest of the game. But it's also been made apparent that our CE is unconscious for a good portion of that scene, so it's also possible that Duncan did say at least something- i.e., it's not fair to assume he didn't, whether we wish he had or we think it was his pragmatic Warden duty to be a cowardly lackey.

#63
Lavaeolus

Lavaeolus
  • Members
  • 744 messages
Vaughan is a noble's son. Were he just some random ruffian, maybe he would've helped -- but imagine the backlash. I think that noble is actually fighting in Ostagar as they speak, do you really want to make an enemy of him? Vaughan's a prat, even a simple telling off could anger him. The Wardens need all the allies they need, all the soldiers they need. Duncan's not exactly condoning elf rape, but the darkspawn come first.

Fact is, giving that sword was already way more than he should've done. But it was subtle, and didn't really attach him to the scene of the crime. He could get away with it, and, at the same time, find a possible new recruit in time when recruits are desperately needed.

Modifié par Mr Maniac, 09 mai 2013 - 12:43 .


#64
Guest_Faerunner_*

Guest_Faerunner_*
  • Guests

Mr Maniac wrote...

Vaughan is a noble's son. Were he just some random ruffian, maybe he would've helped -- but imagine the backlash. I think that noble is actually fighting in Ostagar as they speak, do you really want to make an enemy of him? Vaughan's a prat, even a simple telling off could anger him. The Wardens need all the allies they need, all the soldiers they need. Duncan's not exactly condoning elf rape, but the darkspawn come first.

Fact is, giving that sword was already way more than he should've done. But it was subtle, and didn't really attach him to the scene of the crime. He could get away with it, and, at the same time, find a possible new recruit in time when recruits are desperately needed.


Thank you. I'm tired of arguing semantics, so I'm just going to point to this and call it a day.

#65
Guest_Faerunner_*

Guest_Faerunner_*
  • Guests
No, you know what? I'm arguing semantics. This is ridiculous.

Bhryaen wrote...

1. Failed pickpocketing and tournaments are in the same category: not in the category of Easy Things To Perform, but in the category of Things That Don't Necessarily Make One Cut Out To Be A Warden. Quite true- and demonstrated in the game. They also fall into the category of Things That Impressed Duncan That Nevertheless Didn't Demonstrate Them As Sufficent For Gray Wardenhood.


One died from drinking from the cup and the other died before he could drink from it. Had either or both of them survived, who's to say they couldn't have risen to the challenge and made decent Grey Wardens? The Joining Ritual is a gamble for everyone, including the player character. S/he happened to survive, but, as Darkspawn Chronicles points out, could have easily not. Grey Wardens can't see into the future, can't know who is going to work out and who isn't (though I'm sure they would love the ability) and so just make the best decisions they can with the information they have at the time. Using meta knowledge to show how OMG RONG! they were in hind sight doesn't make it clear to people going through it at the time.

2. Tournaments happen in relatively perfect safety. Forced abduction to the wealthy estate of armed men intent on rape and/or murdering you... not happening in any safety whatsoever. Only one option has a high chance of you ending up dead, and only one option has a high chance of being a festive event full of friends and family out enjoying themselves. Just saying.

What does it matter? Duncan didn't plan the abduction but he wasn't in any position to directly prevent it after it started without seriously jeopardizing the Grey Wardens' welcome in Ferelden and freedom to keep fighting the Blight, so he simply made the best of a bad situation (something Grey Wardens do), provided the maidens with rescuers and weapons so they had a fighting chance, and simultanously observed the capabilities of a potential recruit. Three birds with one stone. 

I'm as sensitive to rape and assault as the next person, but Adaia's daughter is not a delicate little flower that is incapable of taking care of herself and I'm sure Duncan knows it. He might not be sure if she is exactly Grey Warden material yet, but he doesn't exactly throw a babe in a wolf den with nothing but an arrow head and say, "Well, good luck."

3. "Well, I like to test people out first, see how they do in a challenge, so I think I'll just step aside silently to let this 1st level character get raped, maybe murdered, see how she fares..." isn't the thought process of someone who's earnestly interested in getting a living recruit to the Gray Wardens.

Or maybe he had faith that Adaia's child's ability to handle it with a rescue party and borrowed weapons at her disposal. Also consider that if he had to rescue her, then she wouldn't have been Grey Warden material. Or are you going to start arguing that a few guards per room is so much more deadly than hordes of darkspawn bum rushing you regularly, also trying to kill (and potentially also drag underground to violate) you?

Also, do you really think they have level numbers floating over their heads in this world?

4. I've not "latched on" to the idea of recruiting from the gallows/ prisons as the only method of recruitment or only population from which to recruit. But it's a valid idea, and in a time of a blight, maybe a prudent one.

So is recruiting people with raw abilities like mages for fire power, dwarves for hardiness and experience, etc. They need the strongest and the brightest during the Blight more than ever, and the Right of Constription makes joining mandatory even without consent anyway.

5. The Right of Conscription is power. It puts the Gray Wardens above the law-

Only for recruiting people for fighting darkspawn. If they're not recruiting, they can't get involved.

able to tell the Denerim police "Unhand that City Elf maiden!" despite that that maiden just murdered the mayor's son and all the mayor's mansion- pull people out of their everyday lives- and on the flimsiest of pretexts, having no proof whatsoever that you're even going to actually subject them to the Joining. And what proof is there that you're even a GW? They just accept it. And how? What force has Duncan got to back up this "right"? What stops people from just saying, "Yeah, Mr. 'Warden', we know about your kind. That old 'Warden' command stuff might impress lasses at the pub, but around here we got laws to enforce. Now outta the way before we gotta hurt ya." Instead they say, "Oh, well, OK. Whatever you say. We'll ignore our own laws and popular sentiment because you who claim to be a Gray Warden say so. Anything for you's guys, you know that."

And if they went around abusing this one privilege of power, do you think people would allow them to keep it? If random people who were supposed to be recruited into the Grey Wardens started turning up in random places, living new lives away from the situations the Grey Wardens used the Right to get them out of, do you think anyone would trust or allow the Grey Wardens to use the Right of Conscription again?

Has it not occured to you that potential abuses in power like that are the reasons Grey Wardens are not allowed to get involved with local politics, and the reason they don't abuse their power is because they could very easily lose all credibility? 

In fact, the Dragon Age Wiki even says, "Should they need to, the Grey Wardens possess the Right of Conscription. However — especially in Ferelden — this right is used sparingly for fear of political reprisal."

Modifié par Faerunner, 09 mai 2013 - 06:28 .


#66
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
Regarding Jory's fitness, we never meet any other wardens aside from Alistair, and in Alistair's opinion, Jory IS warden material, but he doesn't get why Daveth was recruited. That may say more about Alistair than anything else...

As far as Duncan? Face it, Shianni gets raped no matter what -- the CE gets there too late. Vaughn makes no pretense -- these women are going to be raped, violently (they may be a little worse for the wear I think is how he put it). That Duncan doesn't say one word is pretty telling.

Even the Chantry mother who's officiating the ceremony speaks up to Vaughn.

But even if Duncan had spoken up then, and even if Vaughn had capitulated, it's not like he wouldn't come back later either. The one he was most angry with was Shianni, and he would have hurt her no matter what.

I still think he should have said something. The GWs have enough clout that he may have been listened to. But then, of course, the CE would have gotten married, bad things still would be happening, and he most likely wouldn't have his recruit.

Modifié par ejoslin, 10 mai 2013 - 12:00 .


#67
luna1124

luna1124
  • Members
  • 7 649 messages
Often, while playing a CE, I think of Duncan and why he could not "get involved". Yet through most of the game, the Warden is getting involved with everything. So, is the Warden doing wrong by "getting involved" with every quest they do? :P

#68
Lavaeolus

Lavaeolus
  • Members
  • 744 messages
@above: The Warden is breaking so many Warden-codes it's unbelievable. If it hadn't worked out so perfectly -- a Blight, which by all reason should've destroyed Ferelden entirely after the fiasco at Ostagar and maybe even if they had won, being defeated in a single year spectacularly -- the Warden would've been told off very much.

Desperate times call for desperate measures, and that gamble paid off. But, usually, such sort of risky actions being taken all the time would lead to the Wardens getting no recruits and being exiled from the whole of Thedas.

Alistair mentions how the Grey Wardens are kind of unhappy about the whole thing if he's a Warden in DAII.

ejoslin wrote...

I still think he should have said something. The GWs have enough clout that he may have been listened to.

"Warden, stick your nose out of this. Do you know who I am?"

Scenario 1: *Duncan backs down, Vaughan goes ahead with it unchanged*

Scenario 2: "I'm telling my father about this." *tells father, father withdraws support, darkspawn almost certainly win battle of Ostagar, darkspawn destroy Ferelden, possibly make a bunch of elves brood mothers."

The Grey Wardens draw great respect  from certain people -- hell, a lot of people outright hate them (Duncan is just fortunate concerning Denerim's elven elder) -- and Vaughan is most certainly not one of those people. He would not have been swayed to stop.

Modifié par Mr Maniac, 10 mai 2013 - 03:02 .


#69
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
I'm not sure father would have done that seeing as he was at Ostagar I would imagine -- it would have taken some time for the Arl to get word that the GW had dared backtalk his son, which of course would make him go against his king. Actually, not.

But I think you snipped out quite a few of the relevant points -- like when I said I doubt that Vaughn would have changed his course, and even if he did, he just would have come back later.

Would it have made Duncan look bad? No worse than when the Provings Master still incarcerated the casteless dwarf after Duncan tried to intervene there. It's not the impression that he would have made on Vaughn -- in fact, that's aside the point. Vaughn is obviously a sociopath. But saying nothing at all, when the only other human in the place at least told him to stop? The Chantry Mother certainly didn't look bad for saying something.

At least trying to diffuse a situation that was going to end up in horrible violence is something, successful or not.

Modifié par ejoslin, 10 mai 2013 - 03:20 .


#70
luna1124

luna1124
  • Members
  • 7 649 messages
Yes, and the Grey-Wardens do what ever is necessary. I wondered why he did not want to recruit Soris. LOL He wasn't totally useless! :)

#71
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
I think recruiting Soris would have been pushing things. The guard was already pretty ticked off that one of them was getting away (or as far as they knew, the only one -- but only if the CE is the warden and decides to take all the blame). Either Soris is off the hook, or the second suspect -- either way, recruiting him could be problematic.

ETA: Actually, without Duncan there, Soris goes on his own to rescue his bride, doesn't he.  Does the CE join him?  Without the stolen sword, things don't turn out too well :/

Modifié par ejoslin, 10 mai 2013 - 03:29 .


#72
Lavaeolus

Lavaeolus
  • Members
  • 744 messages

ejoslin wrote...

I'm not sure father would have done that seeing as he was at Ostagar I would imagine -- it would have taken some time for the Arl to get word that the GW had dared backtalk his son, which of course would make him go against his king. Actually, not.

I'll admit the chances of the Arl immediately hearing word and running out is unlikely, but I'm not sure Ostagar would've been the last battle fought. Remember: there's an unsighted archdemon about and loads of darkspawn still in the Deep Roads. It might've taken a bit of time had they won the battle, but another fight would come up quickly. And they were already probably going to lose this one, troops or no.

We don't really see much of Vaughan's father's character, so it's hard to make a judgement. Or his mother, for that matter. But people like Vaughan don't pop out of thin-air, so his father is probably doing something to stroke that ego. I'd rather not take the risk, personally. Let the nobles be nobles, if you cannot influence them. Help from behind-the-scenes.

But I think you snipped out quite a few of the relevant points

Fair enough.

like when I said I doubt that Vaughn would have changed his course, and even if he did, he just would have come back later.

Would it have made Duncan look bad? No worse than when the Provings Master still incarcerated the casteless dwarf after Duncan tried to intervene there. It's not the impression that he would have made on Vaughn -- in fact, that's aside the point. Vaughn is obviously a sociopath. But saying nothing at all, when the only other human in the place at least told him to stop? The Chantry Mother certainly didn't look bad for saying something.

Oh, sure, he'd seem nicer if he interveened. But it would've accomplished nothing, so not raising a pointless objection hardly makes him a bad man.

Actions speak louder than words, and he later goes on to pass along a sword that saves both possibly the Warden and possibly everyone but Shianni.

At least trying to diffuse a situation that was going to end up in horrible violence is something, successful or not.

Considering what he was planning to do, being as detatched from the crime scene as can be was better. Raise a pointless objection now and raise suspicion, or actually work to save them?

And gain a possible recruit in the process. Warden and darkspawn come first, of course.

#73
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
And I think the Arl committing treason and rebelling against his king over a trivial incident involving his son being psychotic wouldn't happen either. Especially if Vaughn isn't harmed. If Duncan slit his throat or something, I can see the Arl wanting the King to intervene, but I don't see Duncan being that stupid.

And yes, it would have made him seem a bit more decent. If Vaughn had instead just killed a few elves with Duncan standing right there, do you still think the silence would be appropriate, or maybe a "my lord, do you think..." may be in order.  Keep in mind, as soon as the women were incarcerated, one was murdered by a guard -- he slit her throat for no reason whatsoever.

And again, a woman did end up raped and another murdered. Duncan gave a couple of elves, whom he had no idea if they were trained or not, a sword, and wished them luck. If you're playing a female, he doesn't even give the sword to the recruit and it's stupid lucky that Soris was able to get the sword to her (to the point of unbelievable, actually, but would give you a lot of respect for Soris using the element of surprise).

And your last line I agree with and even said to begin with, though you snipped the part you agreed with :)

"I still think he should have said something. The GWs have enough clout that he may have been listened to. But then, of course, the CE would have gotten married, bad things still would be happening, and he most likely wouldn't have his recruit."

ETA: It has been a couple of years since I played this origin, so I'm looking up a few things to make sure I have them right :D

Edit: Okay, I was wrong about the Mother being the one to say something.  It was a female elf, and she got slapped down for it.  And it wasn't about the intended rape -- it was that he was doing it at a wedding.

Another edit: I've never played that as a male elf, and looking this over, it is completely emasculating.  I think it hits all the wrong nerves for males.  Hmmm.  Yeh, I don't see how the city elf could have done anything but try, same with Soris.  I knew the female city elf was powerful, but this may even be moreso.  AND leads more into the argument that rape is being used as a plot device.

Last edit: See, I think the problem I have wtih Duncan comes in is as a woman.  This man comes and lets everyone know he is planning on raping the women he takes, and kidnaps a few, and the person doesn't make one sound that this could possibly be a wrong thing to do.  

And it's not only Duncan. The ONLY one who speaks up is a female and the City Elf.  I mean, there's not much anyone can do, and that's the most chilling part about it.  It's not unexpected, apparently, because there is NO outrage expressed, which is pretty horrible to think about.  

Modifié par ejoslin, 10 mai 2013 - 03:57 .


#74
Lavaeolus

Lavaeolus
  • Members
  • 744 messages

ETA: It has been a couple of years since I played this origin, so I'm looking up a few things to make sure I have them right :D

Yeah, I'll admit I'm not too familiar with the origin, especially the male version. I go dwarves or mages, generally.

God of destruction or midgetty bloke -- either way's fine.

Edit: Okay, I was wrong about the Mother being the one to say something. It was a female elf, and she got slapped down for it.

I thought 'twas the Mother as well. Well, shame on her, then. :P

Duncan gave a couple of elves, whom he had no idea if they were trained or not, a sword, and wished them luck.

I think Duncan mentions something about the elf's mother at one point, who trained the City Elf in the warrior/rogue ways. Don't quote me on that, though.

And I think the Arl committing treason and rebelling against his king over a trivial incident involving his son being psychotic wouldn't happen either. Especially if Vaughn isn't harmed.

Well, yeah, but if Vaughan isn't harmed, it accomplishes nothing. I think Duncan is a cold man, sometimes.

I mean, there's not much anyone can do, and that's the most chilling part about it. It's not unexpected, apparently, because there is NO outrage expressed, which is pretty horrible to think about.

Ah, the City Elf origin. This makes me remember why I made my City Elf such a hateful person.

though you snipped the part you agreed with :)

I'm a snippy person; I snip a lot. Snip, snip, snip and so on.

#75
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
*grin* Yeh, in the female city elf origin, Duncan gives the sword to Soris and Nelaros. Soris manages to find the room the women are being held in, after all the women but the CE are taken away, appears behind the two guards who are left, and slides the sword on over while the guards are still all, "Who are you?"

The worst part about it, on my over-reflection on it today, is that the kidnappings probably were not that unusual an occurrence.

Modifié par ejoslin, 10 mai 2013 - 05:12 .