Bhryaen wrote...
The point I was making though was that Duncan thought of Daveth and Jory as Warden material without them really demonstrating any darkspawn-killing potential- not by simply winning a tournament or failing a pickpocket attempt.
Firstly, "simply winning a tournament" is not as easy as picking a pocket. Secondly, you don't think demonstrating enough skill in combat to defeat dozens of very skilled fighters demonstrates darkpawn-killing potiential? Thirdly, as Ser Jory himself says, he fought hard to impress Duncan.
Not just with his skill with a blade, no doubt, but with his character. Duncan considers character as well as skill when determining. Alistair competed in a tournment to impress Duncan too, but he didn't even come close to winning. Regardless, Duncan picked him for his cheerful personality and humor, on the grounds that one needs to have a positive attitude in order not to be discouraged by the daunting, sometimes hopeless task of fighting darkspawn. (Well, that's his public reason, though many fans have alternate theories.)
What I find telling is that most people can tell after talking to Ser Jory for 30 seconds that he is NOT Grey Warden material. Just his overall attitude, demeanor, and way of talking about the Grey Wardens shows that he is not psychologically prepared or suitable for the job; yet Duncan recruited him. Why? I suspect that Ser Jory's perseverence in impressing Duncan as well as his skill in winning the tournament convinced him to give him a chance. (Plus, you know, pressure to find recruits ASAP). I'm guessing that Duncan figured that if Ser Jory could channel the passion he put into joining the Wardens into defeating the Blight, he would be a suitable candidate. Little did Duncan know, Jory was only in it for the glory...
But while he could apparently discern the potential of Daveth and Jory from a pickpocketing and a tournament- complete strangers otherwise- he requires his good friend Adaia's kid CE to endure, well, all (s)he does- if (s)he does- to merit his endorsement for worthy inductee? Surely doing some serious sparring in the alley- during which he'd have her totally outmatched but would observe her ingenuity at overcoming the gap- might reveal the CE's potential better than merely failing a pickpocket. And, mind you, all my CE's have been pickpockets who have failed on him, though the guard wasn't called on them like they were on Daveth.
I think it has more to do with character than skill. Like I said, Duncan considers people's characters as well as their skills when determining who would make a Grey Warden. When you try to get him to leave the alienage, he is impressed by your chutzpah in being an unarmed elf refusing to back down from an armed human. If you talk to him before the wedding ceremony, he mentions how Adaia was a fiery woman who would have made an excellent Grey Warden, then mentions how he heard she passed her training onto her kid.
I'm guessing Duncan knew that Adaia had both the personality and skill for the job, but wasn't yet sure of her child. My guess is that he intended to keep guaging your personality and prowess (making pleasantries at a wedding isn't exactly ideal), and probably would have kept weighing your suitability versus the need for a recruit versus the importance of your future... until Vaughan struck. By then, I'm guessing he couldn't officially get involved without bringing the wrath of Ferelden nobility down on the Grey Wardens, so he decided to make the best of the situation by throwing a lifesaver and seeing how well you could swim on your own. For all we know, Duncan would have only needed some back alley sparring to decide if you were suitable, but Vaughan's party-crashing put a wrench in that.
As for Daveth, Duncan apparently used to be a pickpocketing street thief with no home to call his own as well. It's possible that Duncan saw a lot of himself in Daveth, and figured that he too could rise to the challenge and make a decent Grey Warden if given the opportunity. As we see just before the Joining Ritual, he was on the nose with Daveth... too bad he didn't survive. =(
Also, Daveth didn't just fail a pickpocket attempt; he ran like the dickens and got chased down by some guards. For all we know, Daveth displayed some decent skill during his attempted flee and attitude toward the guards. Plus his life was pretty much over then anyway, as he was about to be hanged, so maybe Duncan decided give him a chance at surviving the Joining versus certain death by the noose, on top of what he saw already.
So is it some prejudice vs elves on his part that he has such a miserable double-standard, requiring elves to do much more to impress him before he gives a damn? Not clear, though he does praise the last Archdemon-slayer who was an elf, so not likely. In any case the double-standard looms there conspicuously, making it unclear what rationale Duncan would use to stand aside for a drunk noble's rape party.
Hey now, I'm as sensitive to human prejudice against elves as they come, but even I don't think there's some alternate racist motive here. He doesn't make the City Elf undergo anything that he doesn't make any other PC from any Origin undergo. He also hears of Cousland's, Aeducan's, and the Mages (both Elf and Human)'s skill before meeting them, considers them for a while, decides not to press it, then only decides "Yep, you're the one" after disaster unexpectedly strikes and they impress him with their reactions.
I'm guessing that Duncan's "rationale" for standing aside is the reason he gives. The Grey Wardens can't get involved politically, Ferelden numbers and support are too few, there's nothing he could have done to make Vaughan back down without jeopardizing the Ferelden Grey Wardens' welcome in the country (and their chance at continuing to fight the Blight), so he had to make the best of the situation.





Guest_Faerunner_*
Retour en haut






