175 réponses à ce sujet

[ThatDancingTurian]

I mean, if you like them together then that's fine, but if having the same chirality and being in the general vicinity of Shepard is the only thing required for romantic compatibility, then Kaidan is soulmates with everyone on the ship.

Modifié par Aris Ravenstar, 14 mars 2013 - 01:51 .

[Kesak12]

Only-Twin wrote...

Because Tali is mine

Seriously though, if Tali wasn't my love interest I'd be fine with them together. 

[Khelish]

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

I mean, if you like them together then that's fine, but if having the same chirality and being in the general vicinity of Shepard is the only thing required for romantic compatibility, then Kaidan is soulmates with everyone on the ship.

SPACE HAMSTER AND HUSK HEAD FOR ROMANCE PARTNERS!!! 

[Soul Tumor]

Garrus is busy making Talibrations

[Twilight_Princess]

I prefer bar turian/Garrus .

[EnvyTB075]

chmarr wrote...

Both have dextro DNA

That means utterly nothing in the grand scheme of things.

chmarr wrote...

both
eveolved from an avian speices

Thats headcanon, not canon. Grissom merely noted the similarities between, there is nothing to confirm that Turians evolved from avian species. And the Quarians absolutely did not either.

chmarr wrote...

both have 2 toes and 3 fingers,

So do Krogans, Salarians, Volus and Vorcha, meaningless.

chmarr wrote...

Even without the helmuts the quarians have that vibrating voice noise.

No they don't, on Rannoch when Tali takes her helmet off its quite clear she has a single toned voice.

[ThatDancingTurian]

Hyrule_Gal wrote...

I prefer bar turian/Garrus .

I thought they were cute too. I liked that scene better than the one my romanced Shepard got. Not for the same situation, obviously, but I thought it was well done.

[Alex101Crusader]

Only-Twin wrote...

Because Tali is mine

This.
Also, i think that their sort of "relationship" in a playthrough in which Shepard has not romanced one of them is nothing more than an Easter Egg.
Just like Grunt seems to have a crush on Liara at the end of the party in the Citadel DLC.

On a side note: I felt bad when a friend of mine shown me for the first time that scene during his playthrough (he had a FemShep loyal to Liara), he knew i'm really attached to Mass Effect, especially to Tali and everything that involves her, and he kept that savegame just to show me the scene.
I remember he said, smiling mockingly at me, "Hey, check this out!" (yep, exactly like Xzibit from "Pimp my Ride").
A couple of seconds later, i was about to kill him and jump into the screen of his PC, screaming "Get away from her, you Turian!"  XD
Aaaand... i guess that's basically why i try to keep ME for myself, it's way too personal...  way too much feelings. That's why this game is so unique.

Modifié par Alex101Crusader, 14 mars 2013 - 02:18 .

[Khelish]

EnvyTB075 wrote...

chmarr wrote...

Both have dextro DNA

That means utterly nothing in the grand scheme of things.

This one, understands! 

[Only-Twin]

Tali and Garrus should be dating because of their DNA in the same way that I should be dating a rosemary plant.

[Khelish]

Only-Twin wrote...

Tali and Garrus should be dating because of their DNA in the same way that I should be dating a rosemary plant.

QFT.

DNA is meaningless.

You don't date someone because they are a levo based organism.

[Legion of 1337]

 I've got no issue with it. Garrus has spent the past three games being distant and introverted - I want my wingman to have company, no one likes seeing their best buddy all by their lonesome. Who better than an only slightly less awkward Quarian?

It's the classic "everyone hooks up at the end" thing, where all the characters hook up at the end. Garrus and Tali, Vega and Ashley (as last minute and shallow as it may be), Joker and EDI; hell, if you defy Bioware's pressure and don't go for Liara (who, if this were a movie, would obviously be the love interest), there's something implied between her and Javik.

Of course, I only let them hook up in the Liara-loyal run through because I avoided Tali after the loyalty mission - I can't bear to turn her down if I actually enter that conversation, she sounds so let down:crying:

[EnvyTB075]

chmarr gives his permission to date your dog.

[Khelish]

Ragabul the Ontarah wrote...

 

Eh, when Garrus made that petty joke about Quarian suits, that was a deal breaker IMO. 

I just don't see anything that would keep Vakarian and Tali together post ME3. Just my view on it.

[Only-Twin]

So more of a relationship brought together by conflict, but doesn't hold together after.
Sort of what happened with my Shep in ME1 with Liara.

[Only-Twin]

Eh, when Garrus made that petty joke about Quarian suits, that was a deal breaker IMO.

You'll have to refresh my memory on that.

[Khelish]

Ragabul the Ontarah wrote...

Khelish wrote...
Eh, when Garrus made that petty joke about Quarian suits, that was a deal breaker IMO. 

I just don't see anything that would keep Vakarian and Tali together post ME3. Just my view on it.

Considering they hook up post petty suit comment, it doesn't seem to be a deal breaker to Tali. 

You're right, it's just more proof the whole romance between them makes no sense.

[Khelish]

Ragabul the Ontarah wrote...

Only-Twin wrote...
So more of a relationship brought together by conflict, but doesn't hold together after.
Sort of what happened with my Shep in ME1 with Liara.

This implies it's brought about by the desperation of conflict rather than the permanent character changes they both went through because of conflict. 

I think it's the later. 

I think it's the prior, and I don't see them staying together in a post ME3 universe.

[Brass_Buckles]

I will point out that relationships made during high-stress situations, like the Reaper Wars, rarely last.

While I can see Garrus and Tali getting together, I'm with the group who can't see it lasting. Although, they both seem to be nerdy and into tech, so who knows?

But I've always thought the same of Shepard's romances. While Garrus or Tali are definitely more into Shepard than each other, given the chance, that doesn't mean that a relationship with Shepard would work out in the end. Being identical isn't necessary, but finding things in common and working to stay interested and find more things to do together and talk about--and staying friends once the passion dies down--are important.

In that light, the Garrus/Shepard tango date was pretty awesome, because it looked like Garrus went out of his way to learn something new to teach Shepard, so that they could have fun dancing together. And yes, I actually looked at it that way: "Aww, he wanted to find something fun for the two of them to do. He must be really serious about this." I would have liked to see more along those lines for the other relationships. Tali's nerdy movie does not seem to have impressed my Femshep, and I doubt it impressed the male Shepard either. Now imagine you spend ten years re-watching a film you don't even like every weekend. You might think you could do it, that it would never bother you, but sooner or later you'd be in a bad mood and hurt her feelings over it.

[Khelish]

Ragabul the Ontarah wrote...

Well, we seem to be at the standard "this is just my opinion" impasse which forbids any kind of meaningful analysis of the situation.

Is Tali really the kind of character to throw herself into someone's arms in desperation?

Who knows.

As I said, it is clear Tali has more feelings for Maleshep (She goes for him first ).

Her fling with Garrus seems out of place. I always got a bro-sis vibe from them, so seeing them together really makes me uncomfortable, not to mention tacked on...