551 réponses à ce sujet

[BeauRoger]

Which one did you prefer in the end, within the context of the entire trilogy? Its probably one of the most content changing choices one makes in the trilogy. I havent replayed ME with Kaidan, since i play a male shepard and always want to romance ash in ME1, so i never got the kaidan experience so to speak. To those who have played through both developments, which one did you prefer content wise through the trilogy?

[garrusfan1]

I liked ash better in ME1 but in ME3 kaiden is much better

[Trentest0]

Both.

Though I feel like the only one.

I like Ashley as a romance the most, and Kaiden as a pal, so I actually have her dead in 5 of my six Shepard's. Just never felt right not romancing her. She's the romance of my main Shepard.

[CaIIisto]

Kaiden, easily. ME3 ruined Ash for me.

[The Night Mammoth]

Most content changing choices? Eh... I suppose, even though the content barely changes at all.

But anyway, I like Kaidan better. He's less stupid and oblivious about the whole Cerberus allegiance thing, in ME2 and the early parts of ME3, than Ashley is.

[Si-Shen]

After playing through the game with both characters... Kaiden, Ash can stay and baby-sit that nuke from now on with me.

[Only-Twin]

I ended up liking Kaidan more by the end. He felt like a good friend to my male Shepard. Then again, his death is more tragic, so the sense of loss is more realistic...

[Wulfram]

Dunno. I think Ashley is more interesting in ME1, but to me less useful from a gameplay point of view, but I prefer Kaidan in ME3. So it's kind of complicated.

Maybe the best option is to run with Ash a lot until Virmire, then continue on with Kaidan for the rest of the series.

[Nykara]

I always choose Kaidan!

[Mr.House]

Kaidan. Ash was great in ME and her sacrifice on Virmire is still sad.

[AFGM_Alpha]

Kaidan all the way, what a bro.

Modifié par AFGM_Alpha, 14 mars 2013 - 10:46 .

[Battlebloodmage]

Kaidan, bros before hoes. Although in my case, wouldn't Kaidan be the hoes and Ash the bros? 

http://t0.gstatic.co...medTSWN5cqK39DJ

Modifié par Battlebloodmage, 14 mars 2013 - 10:52 .

[IntelligentME3Fanboy]

 I don't like Kaidan very much but i certainly don't dislike him.Ashley..forget it

[DeinonSlayer]

garrusfan1 wrote...

I liked ash better in ME1 but in ME3 kaiden is much better

[Mulluns]

Considering my relationship to both of them was professional, I did not consider them friends and will not refer to them on a first name basis.

I prefered Alenko more, he survived Virmire only to be shipped to the front lines in ME3 after the Cerberus coup.

Modifié par Mulluns, 14 mars 2013 - 11:02 .

[Budgier]

I actually prefer Ashley (unpopular opinion, I know) I think her character is more interesting than Kaidan whether you enjoy her stubborn personality quirks or not. She gets on my nerves plenty but I appreciate that she stands out from the rest of the crew with her constant headbutting with Shepard and unwilling to blindly follow like most of the crew.

[jijeebo]

Kaidan all the way... He's awesome.

[Battlebloodmage]

Budgier wrote...

I actually prefer Ashley (unpopular opinion, I know) I think her character is more interesting than Kaidan whether you enjoy her stubborn personality quirks or not. She gets on my nerves plenty but I appreciate that she stands out from the rest of the crew with her constant headbutting with Shepard and unwilling to blindly follow like most of the crew.

DIdn't a survey show that most people save Ash? 

[Steelcan]

I prefer Kaidan. Ashley just grinds my gears in every way.

[Calibrations52]

They both annoyed me quite a bit. I'd probably say Ashley, but just barely.

[Steelcan]

Battlebloodmage wrote...

Budgier wrote...

I actually prefer Ashley (unpopular opinion, I know) I think her character is more interesting than Kaidan whether you enjoy her stubborn personality quirks or not. She gets on my nerves plenty but I appreciate that she stands out from the rest of the crew with her constant headbutting with Shepard and unwilling to blindly follow like most of the crew.

DIdn't a survey show that most people save Ash? 

. It's an unpopular opinion on BSN

[BeauRoger]

Wulfram wrote...

Dunno. I think Ashley is more interesting in ME1, but to me less useful from a gameplay point of view, but I prefer Kaidan in ME3. So it's kind of complicated.

Maybe the best option is to run with Ash a lot until Virmire, then continue on with Kaidan for the rest of the series.

Interesting.. how far can you get with ash before virmire?

[Budgier]

Battlebloodmage wrote...

Budgier wrote...

I actually prefer Ashley (unpopular opinion, I know) I think her character is more interesting than Kaidan whether you enjoy her stubborn personality quirks or not. She gets on my nerves plenty but I appreciate that she stands out from the rest of the crew with her constant headbutting with Shepard and unwilling to blindly follow like most of the crew.

DIdn't a survey show that most people save Ash? 

I'm not sure, it's possible. But in terms of on BSN it seems that Kaiden is much more preferred than Ashley. Ash seems like one of the more hated squadmates along with Jacob from what I've seen. 

[Minttymint]

Kaidan, definitely. As much as I love Ash too, her character was spoiled in ME3 for me thus she rarely makes it past Virmire...

[pawswithclaws]

Kaidan. Although to be honest I really like Ash in ME1. One of these days I'm going to get her off Virmire alive. Maybe.