146 réponses à ce sujet

[Drone 5]

I'm not exactly certain how it could be handled, but it could be interesting seeing such a feature influence NPC and companion relationships. It could be a cool way of giving the player new methods of controlling the friendship/rivalry meter.

As long as it is handled tastefully and isn't viewed strictly as a black/white 'thing', I think entertaining the concept could be worthwhile. Whaddya think?

[rrtda]

discosuperfly wrote...

"Tasteful" rape. WTF is wrong with you?

Modifié par rrtda, 17 mars 2013 - 03:40 .

[Sutekh]

Drone 5 wrote...
[...]

As long as it is handled tastefully and isn't viewed strictly as a black/white 'thing', I think entertaining the concept could be worthwhile. Whaddya think?

There's no way rape committed by the PC can be handled tastefully. This is crossing a line into highly triggering territory, and, seriously, rape as a game mechanic is in itself tasteless.

And I really don't think you can mitigate it in any way in order to have it non "black and white".

[Knight of Dane]

Don't feed tha troll peeps.

[Drone 5]

Um, sorry?

[Giubba]

Crhist again?!

[sandalisthemaker]

*In before lock*
Didn't you make one of these already?

Modifié par sandalisthemaker, 17 mars 2013 - 03:44 .

[Drone 5]

Sutekh wrote...

Drone 5 wrote...
[...]

As long as it is handled tastefully and isn't viewed strictly as a black/white 'thing', I think entertaining the concept could be worthwhile. Whaddya think?

There's no way rape committed by the PC can be handled tastefully. This is crossing a line into highly triggering territory, and, seriously, rape as a game mechanic is in itself tasteless.

And I really don't think you can mitigate it in any way in order to have it non "black and white".

I disagree. Quick example: X group of bandits kills the PC's LI. Your character rapes their leader. It's not black and white.

[Thrillian]

Wow, give it up already! Not going to happen! This would be the one thing that would make me NOT buy the game were it implemented.

[Drone 5]

Knight of Dane wrote...

Don't feed tha troll peeps.

Very constructive. Thanks for your input.

[TJPags]

Drone 5 wrote...

Sutekh wrote...

Drone 5 wrote...
[...]

As long as it is handled tastefully and isn't viewed strictly as a black/white 'thing', I think entertaining the concept could be worthwhile. Whaddya think?

There's no way rape committed by the PC can be handled tastefully. This is crossing a line into highly triggering territory, and, seriously, rape as a game mechanic is in itself tasteless.

And I really don't think you can mitigate it in any way in order to have it non "black and white".

I disagree. Quick example: X group of bandits kills the PC's LI. Your character rapes their leader. It's not black and white.

You've lost your mind, or you're drunk, or you've just got no sense of right or wrong.

Rape is black and white - rape is wrong.

End of conversation.

[Drone 5]

TJPags wrote...

Drone 5 wrote...

Sutekh wrote...

Drone 5 wrote...
[...]

As long as it is handled tastefully and isn't viewed strictly as a black/white 'thing', I think entertaining the concept could be worthwhile. Whaddya think?

There's no way rape committed by the PC can be handled tastefully. This is crossing a line into highly triggering territory, and, seriously, rape as a game mechanic is in itself tasteless.

And I really don't think you can mitigate it in any way in order to have it non "black and white".

I disagree. Quick example: X group of bandits kills the PC's LI. Your character rapes their leader. It's not black and white.

You've lost your mind, or you're drunk, or you've just got no sense of right or wrong.

Rape is black and white - rape is wrong.

End of conversation.

What about raping rapists then?

[philippe willaume]

TJPags wrote...

Drone 5 wrote...

Sutekh wrote...

Drone 5 wrote...
[...]

As long as it is handled tastefully and isn't viewed strictly as a black/white 'thing', I think entertaining the concept could be worthwhile. Whaddya think?

There's no way rape committed by the PC can be handled tastefully. This is crossing a line into highly triggering territory, and, seriously, rape as a game mechanic is in itself tasteless.

And I really don't think you can mitigate it in any way in order to have it non "black and white".

I disagree. Quick example: X group of bandits kills the PC's LI. Your character rapes their leader. It's not black and white.

You've lost your mind, or you're drunk, or you've just got no sense of right or wrong.

Rape is black and white - rape is wrong.

End of conversation.

+ 1

[sandalisthemaker]

Drone 5 wrote...


I disagree. Quick example: X group of bandits kills the PC's LI. Your character rapes their leader. It's not black and white.

omg!

[loungeshep]

The hell? I don't even...

See it's threads like this make the general public view gamers as deginerates and freaks.

Modifié par loungeshep, 17 mars 2013 - 03:52 .

[Volus Warlord]

This will not end well..

and "tasteful rape" may be a bit of an oxymoron. All things considered..

[Drone 5]

Jeez, is this the fabled Western puritanism I've heard so much about? My requests are not that crazy... go look up Sylvius the Mad if you want crazy.

[Anthadlas]

Lmao, just when I thought BSN had hit rock bottom

Just for the sake of it they should add beastiality aswell, Gang raping the Archdemon would have had so much more impact than simply stabbing it 

Modifié par Wraith 02, 17 mars 2013 - 03:53 .

[Sutekh]

Drone 5 wrote...

I disagree. Quick example: X group of bandits kills the PC's LI. Your character rapes their leader. It's not black and white.

Yes, it is. There's other ways to get revenge. Doesn't make sense psychologically either.

Anyway, you seem to forget there's human beings playing the game, some of whom might be rape survivors or related to some. Having such a "game mechanics" would be beyond appalling, completely gratuitous, and wouldn't bring anything but grief and disgust. What would be the point?

btw, I don't think you're trolling - not really - but you sound very, very clueless.

[loungeshep]

And we wonder why games are blamed for violence.

Next on the news Games are blamed for rape!

[TJPags]

Drone 5 wrote...

Jeez, is this the fabled Western puritanism I've heard so much about? My requests are not that crazy... go look up Sylvius the Mad if you want crazy.

No, this is people with a moral compass that you've apparently not heard of.

[Anthadlas]

Sutekh wrote...

Drone 5 wrote...

I disagree. Quick example: X group of bandits kills the PC's LI. Your character rapes their leader. It's not black and white.

Yes, it is. There's other ways to get revenge. Doesn't make sense psychologically either.

Anyway, you seem to forget there's human beings playing the game, some of whom might be rape survivors or related to some. Having such a "game mechanics" would be beyond appalling, completely gratuitous, and wouldn't bring anything but grief and disgust. What would be the point?

btw, I don't think you're trolling - not really - but you sound very, very clueless.

Not trying to throw a spanner into this arleady considerable **** storm but I wonder why rape in videogames and even sex is considered taboo whilst murdering people, even if the player might know a real life person that got killed is perfectly justifiable

Modifié par Wraith 02, 17 mars 2013 - 03:57 .