137 réponses à ce sujet

[duckley]

Carver please

[Mello]

Nope, hate all the Amells.

[Iakus]

I wouldn't want them. Not because I dislike them, but because I do like them.

And I don't want to have the inevitable comparisons between the DA2 versions and the DA3, how they were changed or 'ruined" or whatever.

Exhibit A: Anders

[RobRam10]

Cameos only!

[Kalas Magnus]

Bethany. 

Modifié par BioWareMod03, 09 juin 2013 - 12:01 .

[wiccame]

I absolutely loved Carver, pain in the backside, but stood by you when it mattered most. But I see no real place for him. He was a barely a companion, a minor warden or a minor templar. His only real connection would be to hawke and no significance to anyone else, imo.

[wright1978]

Prefer Carver as a character over Bethany. That said i'd probably prefer them not to turn up in DAI.

[Tinxa]

They would make no sense without Hawke so no, I don't want to see them.

[Sjpelke]

Carver and Bethany are Hawke's sibblings and a part of DA2. Depending on choices made both of them could be dead at the end of the game.

So no, see no place for them in DAI. As stated above their role was very minor; only related to Hawke and no influence on the whole picture.

[cogsandcurls]

The endless permutations of their story arcs/high chance of being dead knock the twins straight out the the running when it comes to any sort of substantial role in DA3. That said - I'd love a cameo for each, providing it was fitting. I thought they were both interesting characters and I'd love to see how they fit in the world going forward.

[Cespar]

Everyone keep saying their roles was minor, but looking back on Merrill, her role was smaller than theirs. Plus on Mass Effect Tali and Garrus can die and still be full companions in the last one. And they both was minor in DA2 maybe for a reason, so maybe you can get to know them better as a Protagonist that is not related to them, (hence DA:I protagonist).

[gonzalez.melissa53]

OMG>They dead! My mother... and my brother... They dead!


Sister bit the dust at the start of the game /cry!

Modifié par gonzalez.melissa53, 09 juin 2013 - 04:25 .

[Saberchic]

Absolutely LOVE Carver. Having said that.... no, I do not wish for any Hawke to show up in my game. It's good to move on.

[Knight of Dane]

Tinxa wrote...

They would make no sense without Hawke so no, I don't want to see them.

Why not?

[BombThatDeadGuy]

It would be better if we didn't see these any of the Hawke siblings or his cousin for that matter unless we went back to play as Hawke which is not likely for a long time if ever.

[Shasow]

Bonte15 wrote...

Everyone keep saying their roles was minor, but looking back on Merrill, her role was smaller than theirs. Plus on Mass Effect Tali and Garrus can die and still be full companions in the last one. And they both was minor in DA2 maybe for a reason, so maybe you can get to know them better as a Protagonist that is not related to them, (hence DA:I protagonist).

Merill's role was minor? If you've done her quests, I don't think so. What did Bethany and Carver ever do? One died and the other joined the templars. Okay, what else? Because I can't think of any other significant thing they've done.

Modifié par Shasow, 09 juin 2013 - 07:24 .

[Cespar]

Shasow wrote...

Bonte15 wrote...

Everyone keep saying their roles was minor, but looking back on Merrill, her role was smaller than theirs. Plus on Mass Effect Tali and Garrus can die and still be full companions in the last one. And they both was minor in DA2 maybe for a reason, so maybe you can get to know them better as a Protagonist that is not related to them, (hence DA:I protagonist).

Merill's role was minor? If you've done her quests, I don't think so. What did Bethany and Carver ever do? One died and the other joined the templars. Okay, what else? Because I can't think of any other significant thing they've done.

In DAO, Merrill's role was minor and she became a full major character in Da2, and yea your right, they didn't get to prove theirselves, but DA:I is a whole new game. <_<

[berelinde]

BombThatDeadGuy wrote...

It would be better if we didn't see these any of the Hawke siblings or his cousin for that matter unless we went back to play as Hawke which is not likely for a long time if ever.

That is exactly the reason I would like to see Carver again. He did a lot of growing up during the course of DA2, and I would love to meet him as an adult, independent from his brother or sister. I doubt I'll get my wish, for a number of reasons.

[BombThatDeadGuy]

berelinde wrote...

BombThatDeadGuy wrote...

It would be better if we didn't see these any of the Hawke siblings or his cousin for that matter unless we went back to play as Hawke which is not likely for a long time if ever.

That is exactly the reason I would like to see Carver again. He did a lot of growing up during the course of DA2, and I would love to meet him as an adult, independent from his brother or sister. I doubt I'll get my wish, for a number of reasons.

You still might be able to see Carver in DA3 and if he does show up then with luck his role is done well and was worth putting in the game. I'm not the biggest fan of both the siblings but it won't really ruin the game if they showed up. That said don't see them having a huge role in the game like being a companion, I see a cameo at best out of the siblings.

[Muddle]

Carver

[Newschmoo]

I wouldn't mind seeing Carver in some role in DA3. It would be good to see how he is getting along independent of Hawke. He became a Grey Warden in my play through, so he could in effect pop up anywhere in Thedas.

[frankf43]

Not gonna happen. One's definitely dead and the other could be dead. Way too many people would complain about ruining head cannon.

[BackdoorPaco]

frankf43 wrote...

Not gonna happen. One's definitely dead and the other could be dead. Way too many people would complain about ruining head cannon.

Isn't this similar to the VS or suicide mission deaths? It worked there, could work here.

[frankf43]

can"t see it myself which is a shame because I really like Bethany.