148 réponses à ce sujet

[Auras_Mendalla]

This was fascinating and enjoyable. It was really interesting to see where my opinions converged and diverged with the rest of the community. As it turns out I fall more into the "mainstream" of opinion than I would have believed.

[Aeronomo]

I really am just curious why 25% of people consider the BF3 Soldier underwhelming while the Human is only at 6%. They are essentially the same character except the BF3 Soldier has a higher weight capacity. Why all the hate?

[megawug]

Very interesting survey and results. Thanks you everyone!

[Mad Mattt]

Jaison1986 wrote...

Surprised how the paladin won against the turian sentinel.

Actually this is the only thing the BSN can agree upon, apparently. No other class has been endorsed so strongly. He detains the highest mark in "Best power synergy" and "Best kit" ever.

I am personally amused that some class manage to score first in both "Most under-rated" and "Worst power synergy", for example the QFI. I would say this deserves some sort of new category, such as "Most divisive".

And, last but not least, 1% of voters think the Fury is the most under-rated adept. Seriously? I mean, is there at least one of us voters here who thinks the Fury is under-rated? To those who said Fury, I would give a badge saying "I'm not good at noticing what people like and rate".

Modifié par Mad Mattt, 23 avril 2013 - 11:47 .

[lightswitch]

The results for Soldiers turned my stomach.

[BridgeBurner]

How did I miss this post?

Awesome work OP, was really interesting reading through the results.

[kipac]

Look at the adept and sentinel charts.

Fury and Paladin are dominating...

[coelacyanth]

Ziegrif wrote...

Data! Numbers! TOO MANY NUMBERS! YEAAAARRRGHHH!!!

Actually it was almost dawn as I compiled the results manually from that stupid website, was in no condition/state for the intellectual analysis. But I did put a green marker on the highest percentage votes.. Will it be enough for my exoneration?

[coelacyanth]

Jeremiah12LGeek wrote...

They may not think she's powerful, but people apparently think the Shadow is fun.  

I had a feeling that id see your comment on shadow

[coelacyanth]

Annomander wrote...

How did I miss this post?

Awesome work OP, was really interesting reading through the results.

Thanks!

[coelacyanth]

Tupari wrote...

Thanks for compiling all of this, it was an interesting read.

With one exception BSN really doesn't like Voluses.

Thanks! Yeah it seems that BSN sure doesn't like Voluses..... Also, I find it a bit weird to not see any reaction to Vanguard results... I mean Kroguard getting most over-rated kit and Slayer getting the favorite kit was not what I had expected..... I mean this was BSN after all, giving its feedback.....

[Clayless]

Aeronomo wrote...

I really am just curious why 25% of people consider the BF3 Soldier underwhelming while the Human is only at 6%. They are essentially the same character except the BF3 Soldier has a higher weight capacity. Why all the hate?

Because you can spam Concussive Shot which ruins mooks and just AR Claymore anything that blocks it or shrugs it off. BF3 Soilder can't.

I cannot believe people go to the GE before the Demolisher, or think the Ghost is more OP than the GI. Not surprised that people still haven't realised the Collector can one clip bosses though.

Modifié par Robosexual, 24 avril 2013 - 07:14 .

[coelacyanth]

Robosexual wrote...

I cannot believe people go to the GE before the Demolisher, or think the Ghost is more OP than the GI. Not surprised that people still haven't realised the Collector can one clip bosses though.

GE thing was a surprise to me also... cause I could swear seeing countless grenade lovers(fanatics) posting here.... 

[coelacyanth]

[Clayless]

Come to think of it you should have asked who people play on Gold and Platinum too. That probably explains the weird results in some cases, as maybe people play Silver highest.

[coelacyanth]

Robosexual wrote...

Come to think of it you should have asked who people play on Gold and Platinum too. That probably explains the weird results in some cases, as maybe people play Silver highest.

True.... but not many people play gold and platinum to be honest...  that's why I framed the question as "default kit for highest difficulty you play" since I thought that anyone venturing into the highest difficulty that they can handle would choose a kit that they think is "ez-mode"/most comfortable with (perhaps wrong word to use here, but you get what I am trying to say).

[najzere]

I guess I should try out the Geth Trooper. Thanks for putting this together.

[the slynx]

Thanks for running this survey. I find stuff like this fascinating.

[your-friendly-noggin]

torudoom wrote...

Thanks for running this survey. I find stuff like this fascinating.

Same here, it's fun seeing what people think of these things, I hope they do a similar results page for the official map survey.

Although I'm a little bit dissapointed Cabal didn't get worst power combination/synergy, I mean seriously going through her powers is embarrassing:
-poison strike has awful hit detection, similar range to the fury/slayer dodge and even if you do hit anything the damage is just not worth the effort.

-nightshade blades are AoE grenades with terrible range, weak armour damage and worst of all a 3 mob target limit. Off the top of my head the only offensive grenade powers with a target limit similar are the Omni-bow powers and an AP shot with a strength enhancer can almost two shot a gold ravager from a ridiculous distance away.

-Biotic focus is ok, but combined with the other powers and the turian passives she ends up being a poor mans 'any other turian in the game'

I hate to say this but poison strike should have been target based, with damage applied to any enemies you pass through on your way to the target.

[nrcrane]

still surprises me how people see the quarian marksman. These numbers make me think people don't really know how to use the class

[PaunchyCyclops]

I like the marksman, but the class really lacks in power synergy to the point where it's pretty much a one-trick pony in every match.

[lightswitch]

I don't think people know what 'power synergy' means.

Modifié par lightswitch, 24 avril 2013 - 04:51 .

[your-friendly-noggin]

nrcrane wrote...

still surprises me how people see the quarian marksman. These numbers make me think people don't really know how to use the class

He is a good kit, but the only thing he does better than the TSol is dodging, as a weapon platform the TSol does more damage with far higher stability, allowing him to take the RoF evo in marksman so he can rock with a smg/assault rifle and while using a 'sniper' shotgun. There is barely any reason to take the QM over the TSol, which is just dissapointing.

lightswitch wrote...

I don't think people know what 'powers synergy' means.

It was power combination/synergy actually, probably because some kits don't necessarily have the best synergy between powers but the individual powers had their own individual uses.

Modifié par your-friendly-noggin, 24 avril 2013 - 04:48 .