Aller au contenu

Photo

The most dire title the Reapers deserve is "Terrible Natural Disaster".


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
883 réponses à ce sujet

#326
Seival

Seival
  • Members
  • 5 294 messages

xlegionx wrote...

Seival wrote...

xlegionx wrote...

Oh, a Seival thread. This should be interesting.

Synthesis is not inevitable. Why would the Leviathans seek to impose Synthesis on the galaxy? With such few numbers of their own, could they even if they wanted to? Is the Citadel even capable of activating Synthesis in its damaged/repaired state? there are too many ifs with that situation that you are filling in with your own un-proved assumptions to figure out a plausible answer.


Leviathans obviously have stable population. Why do I think so? They survived all those countless Cycles, which is impossible without stable population. Leviathan said they controlled some lesser races for their own needs during all those Cycles, which is also impossible without stable population. Once Reaper threat is over - Leviathans will recover to full strength fast enough.

Leviathan said they observe each Cycle very carefully. They will learn everything about Synthesis and Crucible's purpose. It's even quite possible that Crucible was Leviathans' idea. They could invent it (who else could?) and built the first one using thralls. Makes sense... Anyway, we can state that Leviathans already know (or about to know) Synthesis concept, and the way to achieve it.

Destroy slides show us peace and rebuilt Citadel - both impossible in universe full of derelict Reapers and primitive survivors. Only Leviathans can help galactic civilization. As before, Leviathans will remain above lesser races' concerns. They will rule the galaxy, and no one will even notice that. And Synthesis beginning will be just a matter of time. It is inevitable, even in case of Destroy.



...I believe that was initial plan - to make a sequel based on Synthesized universe. You think pro-Synthesis ending bias was just for show? Inevitable Synthesis is the only way to make a sequel without canonizing one of ways to stop the Reapers. No inevitable Synthesis = no successful sequel, I'm afraid. If BioWare is not going to make Synthesis inevitable, then we will get prequel or "mediquel" no matter what the most fans asked for.


I doubt that Bioware is never doing a sequel, but they would never retcon to force the least-liked option of the core fanbase onto the entire game. The Citadel DLC is proof enough that they would now prefer to avoid rocking the boat. And even then, I'm sure they could make an effective sequel without canonizing an abomination

As it has been stated before in this thread, the derelict Reapers in Destroy would not be an issue. Pieces of Sovereign are all around the Citadel, yet there are not throngs of indoctrinated agents, just a select few. The only reason the derelict Reaper in ME2 indoctrinated the scientists was because its mass effect core was still in contact, therefore it wasn't truly dead. the Reapers in Destroy are 100% destroyed, no chance for indoctrination from the wreckage.

And the survivors are not primitive, at least not with high EMS Destroy (which is probably 80-90% of all Destroy endings). In a High EMS ending, Destroy only targets Reaper Tech, so only the Reapers, the mass relay system (citadel included), the geth (reaper code), and EDI (made w/ fragments from Sovereign) are affected. THis is how Shepard is able to survive.

As for the Leviathans, they explicitly stated that the Crucible's outxome is unknown. Therefore, they do not know of Synthesis, nor have any opinions on it. And why would they want to improve other species? they already consider themselves the apex race, so they wouldn't want anyone getting too close to their mantle. even their ability to learn of it is limited, As one of the entities that knew of it (The Catalyst) is gone in Destroy) and they were only able to enter Shepard's mind when they came into direct proximity of their own body. No one else knows about Synthesis (you *could* speculate that Shepard shared information about Synthesis, but speculation is all that it is)

As for their population size, we have extremely little info about their physiology. they could live for millions of years at a time. They could be like Fallout's Super Mutants and be biologically immortal, immune to death by natural causes. We just don't know. You are making way too many guesses, but treating them as fact to support your opinions


Synthesis is less-liked choice, but not less-liked long-term outcome.

Nazara remains did their work quite well, don't you worry. We know that only very small parts can be shielded. And you can't shield even those from power-hungry individuals who will do everything to get a part of Reaper tech to study it make something based on it.

In ME2 mass effect core only kept derelict Reaper on the orbit. Indoctrination abilities do not depend on mass effect core. Indoctrination comes from organic part of a Reaper. Back to Nazara remains: small human-sized part of it had to be sealed to prevent indoctrination, remember Leviathan DLC? There are no power sources in these tiny parts. Also, if you remember Destroy epilogue well, then you know that Reaper ships were mostly intact after red explosion. Only husks were vaporized.

Survivors are primitive compared to Leviathans, not in general. Primitive enough to start contacting with derelict Reapers and become insane soon after that.

Do you remember how the Leviathan replied about the Crucible? It was clear it doesn't tell everything. Primitive races couldn't invent Crucible without full understanding of Reaper tech. I'm sure that Crucible is Leviathan's idea.

A lot of Fragments were delivered on Earth as a part of war asset, so Leviathans could help in the final battle. Shepard became Leviathans' thrall, remember? Leviathans can see and hear everything Shepard sees and hears. Even dialogue with the Catalyst. And even if Shepard didn't contact Leviathans, they have everything to discover Synthesis possibility. No one can interrupt them after the Reapers were stopped. They will keep searching for the solution.

Without stable population Leviathans couldn't survive for so long.

Modifié par Seival, 27 avril 2013 - 12:32 .


#327
Peranor

Peranor
  • Members
  • 4 003 messages
I've said it before. But a sequel where synthesis is canonized makes perfect sense!



The story could be about Shepards surviving crew roaming the galaxy looking for dormant relays to activate and travel through, looking for civilizations unaffected by the magic beam.
The missions could be about the crew either manage to convince whatever civilization that lies behind the relay to embrace synthesis and the legacy of Shepard or be exterminated.

If the civilization refuse we can either chose the renegade route and flag the civilization for extermination and let our new Reaper buddies know where they can find the infidels so they can make quick work of them.
Or we take the more paragon route and place agents amongst them that can slowly begin to indoctrinate the population, and have them accept the "final solution" over time.

If we manage to persuade the civilization to accept Synthesis right away without indoctrination, or the threat of being turned in to reaper soup we are granted +50 additional EMS that no one really know the purpose of. Or why we even got it in the first place.

At the end of the game we can be shown an old man promoting the benefits of eugenics for his grandson.

It is inevitable

Modifié par anorling, 27 avril 2013 - 12:32 .


#328
GreyLycanTrope

GreyLycanTrope
  • Members
  • 12 709 messages

Argolas wrote...

Greylycantrope wrote...

Seival wrote...
Synthesized universe. Such game would be unique and awesome. Something we've never seen before.


*snip*

Just paint it green and add spaceships


Since I am really bored right now...

Posted Image

:lol: Well played good sir.

#329
MassivelyEffective0730

MassivelyEffective0730
  • Members
  • 9 230 messages

Seival wrote...
In case of Destroy this will not be your Shepard's choice, because Synthesis will happen long after her/his death.


Sure it will. 

I posted this once before, but I'll post it again.

It will happen hundreds (possibly thousands) of years in the future. It will be consistent with biology, science, and logic. It won't require running into a green beam and dying to invoke an irreversable change. It won't placate the Reapers or the Catalyst (since they'll be long forgotten nightmare machines that were destroyed long before). It will not involve the Reapers at all. It will be completely voluntary among the galactic denizens. It won't be used as the solution to a crap cycle that never should have happened. It will happen as people wish to expand their scope physically and bring evolution to a new level. It will occur on the galaxy's own terms, not some ideal of readiness on the Catalyst's part. It will not be called Synthesis. And it won't be green.

See, we can agree on some things.

Modifié par MassivelyEffective0730, 27 avril 2013 - 12:46 .


#330
xlegionx

xlegionx
  • Members
  • 496 messages

Seival wrote...

xlegionx wrote...

I doubt that Bioware is never doing a sequel, but they would never retcon to force the least-liked option of the core fanbase onto the entire game. The Citadel DLC is proof enough that they would now prefer to avoid rocking the boat. And even then, I'm sure they could make an effective sequel without canonizing an abomination

As it has been stated before in this thread, the derelict Reapers in Destroy would not be an issue. Pieces of Sovereign are all around the Citadel, yet there are not throngs of indoctrinated agents, just a select few. The only reason the derelict Reaper in ME2 indoctrinated the scientists was because its mass effect core was still in contact, therefore it wasn't truly dead. the Reapers in Destroy are 100% destroyed, no chance for indoctrination from the wreckage.

And the survivors are not primitive, at least not with high EMS Destroy (which is probably 80-90% of all Destroy endings). In a High EMS ending, Destroy only targets Reaper Tech, so only the Reapers, the mass relay system (citadel included), the geth (reaper code), and EDI (made w/ fragments from Sovereign) are affected. This is how Shepard is able to survive.

As for the Leviathans, they explicitly stated that the Crucible's outxome is unknown. Therefore, they do not know of Synthesis, nor have any opinions on it. And why would they want to improve other species? they already consider themselves the apex race, so they wouldn't want anyone getting too close to their mantle. even their ability to learn of it is limited, As one of the entities that knew of it (The Catalyst) is gone in Destroy) and they were only able to enter Shepard's mind when they came into direct proximity of their own body. No one else knows about Synthesis (you *could* speculate that Shepard shared information about Synthesis, but speculation is all that it is)

As for their population size, we have extremely little info about their physiology. they could live for millions of years at a time. They could be like Fallout's Super Mutants and be biologically immortal, immune to death by natural causes. We just don't know. You are making way too many guesses, but treating them as fact to support your opinions


Synthesis is less-liked choice, but not less-liked long-term outcome.

Nazara remains did their work quite well, don't you worry. We know that only very small parts can be shielded. And you can't shield even those from power-hungry individuals who will do everything to get a part of Reaper tech to study it make something based on it.

In ME2 mass effect core only kept derelict Reaper on the orbit. Indoctrination abilities do not depend on mass effect core. Indoctrination comes from organic part of a Reaper. Back to Nazara remains: small human-sized part of it had to be sealed to prevent indoctrination, remember Leviathan DLC? There are no power sources in these tiny parts. Also, if you remember Destroy epilogue well, then you know that Reaper ships were mostly intact after red explosion. Only husks were vaporized.

Survivors are primitive compared to Leviathans, not in general. Primitive enough to start contacting with derelict Reapers and become insane soon after that.

Do you remember how the Leviathan replied about the Crucible? It was clear it doesn't tell everything. Primitive races couldn't invent Crucible without full understanding of Reaper tech. I'm sure that Crucible is Leviathan's idea.

A lot of Fragments were delivered on Earth as a part of war asset, so Leviathans could help in the final battle. Shepard became Leviathans' thrall, remember? Leviathans can see and hear everything Shepard sees and hears. Even dialogue with the Catalyst. And even if Shepard didn't contact Leviathans, they have everything to discover Synthesis possibility. No one can interrupt them after the Reapers were stopped. They will keep searching for the solution.

Without stable population Leviathans couldn't survive for so long.


The mass effect core still being intact on the Reaper is indicative of there still being an active power source, as something being used to keep such a massive shp up in orbit must use significant amount of power. that power would probably then power the electromagnetic field, infrasound and ultrasound used to initate indoctrination (this is stated on the ME Wiki and some codex entry somewhere).

And the Leviathans aren't actively controlling Shepard, he doesn't have a Leviathan orb stuffed in his back pocket. Leviathan Enthrallment requires that the subject remain relatively close to the orb. so as long as there's no orb on the Normandy (which there is isn't) Shepard won't be enthralled. So without Shepard enthralled, how will the Leviathans discover Synthesis? there is no evidence of its existence besides in Shepard's memories, the Catalyst and the machinery to impose Synthesis were destroyed when Destroy is chosen.

And their solution is much more along the lines of Control, take over the galaxy and use overwhelming force to rule with an iron fist, not Synthesis's "let's have everyone work together as equals to make the galaxy a better place"

As for their knowledge on the Crucible, why would they hold back? at that point in the conversation, the Leviathans had no intention of ever leaving that ocean alive, and had planned on keeping him there to study. It would be a wasted effort to hide info from someone who can't do anything with it

#331
Seival

Seival
  • Members
  • 5 294 messages

xlegionx wrote...

Seival wrote...

xlegionx wrote...

I doubt that Bioware is never doing a sequel, but they would never retcon to force the least-liked option of the core fanbase onto the entire game. The Citadel DLC is proof enough that they would now prefer to avoid rocking the boat. And even then, I'm sure they could make an effective sequel without canonizing an abomination

As it has been stated before in this thread, the derelict Reapers in Destroy would not be an issue. Pieces of Sovereign are all around the Citadel, yet there are not throngs of indoctrinated agents, just a select few. The only reason the derelict Reaper in ME2 indoctrinated the scientists was because its mass effect core was still in contact, therefore it wasn't truly dead. the Reapers in Destroy are 100% destroyed, no chance for indoctrination from the wreckage.

And the survivors are not primitive, at least not with high EMS Destroy (which is probably 80-90% of all Destroy endings). In a High EMS ending, Destroy only targets Reaper Tech, so only the Reapers, the mass relay system (citadel included), the geth (reaper code), and EDI (made w/ fragments from Sovereign) are affected. This is how Shepard is able to survive.

As for the Leviathans, they explicitly stated that the Crucible's outxome is unknown. Therefore, they do not know of Synthesis, nor have any opinions on it. And why would they want to improve other species? they already consider themselves the apex race, so they wouldn't want anyone getting too close to their mantle. even their ability to learn of it is limited, As one of the entities that knew of it (The Catalyst) is gone in Destroy) and they were only able to enter Shepard's mind when they came into direct proximity of their own body. No one else knows about Synthesis (you *could* speculate that Shepard shared information about Synthesis, but speculation is all that it is)

As for their population size, we have extremely little info about their physiology. they could live for millions of years at a time. They could be like Fallout's Super Mutants and be biologically immortal, immune to death by natural causes. We just don't know. You are making way too many guesses, but treating them as fact to support your opinions


Synthesis is less-liked choice, but not less-liked long-term outcome.

Nazara remains did their work quite well, don't you worry. We know that only very small parts can be shielded. And you can't shield even those from power-hungry individuals who will do everything to get a part of Reaper tech to study it make something based on it.

In ME2 mass effect core only kept derelict Reaper on the orbit. Indoctrination abilities do not depend on mass effect core. Indoctrination comes from organic part of a Reaper. Back to Nazara remains: small human-sized part of it had to be sealed to prevent indoctrination, remember Leviathan DLC? There are no power sources in these tiny parts. Also, if you remember Destroy epilogue well, then you know that Reaper ships were mostly intact after red explosion. Only husks were vaporized.

Survivors are primitive compared to Leviathans, not in general. Primitive enough to start contacting with derelict Reapers and become insane soon after that.

Do you remember how the Leviathan replied about the Crucible? It was clear it doesn't tell everything. Primitive races couldn't invent Crucible without full understanding of Reaper tech. I'm sure that Crucible is Leviathan's idea.

A lot of Fragments were delivered on Earth as a part of war asset, so Leviathans could help in the final battle. Shepard became Leviathans' thrall, remember? Leviathans can see and hear everything Shepard sees and hears. Even dialogue with the Catalyst. And even if Shepard didn't contact Leviathans, they have everything to discover Synthesis possibility. No one can interrupt them after the Reapers were stopped. They will keep searching for the solution.

Without stable population Leviathans couldn't survive for so long.


The mass effect core still being intact on the Reaper is indicative of there still being an active power source, as something being used to keep such a massive shp up in orbit must use significant amount of power. that power would probably then power the electromagnetic field, infrasound and ultrasound used to initate indoctrination (this is stated on the ME Wiki and some codex entry somewhere).

And the Leviathans aren't actively controlling Shepard, he doesn't have a Leviathan orb stuffed in his back pocket. Leviathan Enthrallment requires that the subject remain relatively close to the orb. so as long as there's no orb on the Normandy (which there is isn't) Shepard won't be enthralled. So without Shepard enthralled, how will the Leviathans discover Synthesis? there is no evidence of its existence besides in Shepard's memories, the Catalyst and the machinery to impose Synthesis were destroyed when Destroy is chosen.

And their solution is much more along the lines of Control, take over the galaxy and use overwhelming force to rule with an iron fist, not Synthesis's "let's have everyone work together as equals to make the galaxy a better place"

As for their knowledge on the Crucible, why would they hold back? at that point in the conversation, the Leviathans had no intention of ever leaving that ocean alive, and had planned on keeping him there to study. It would be a wasted effort to hide info from someone who can't do anything with it


As I said before, small human-sized Reaper parts can indoctrinate, and they have no mass effect cores. Confirmation of that is in the Leviathan DLC. And in the Arrival DLC by the way.

The orb is called Fragment. And Leviathans war asset is actually tones of that Fragments delivered on Earth. In Leviathan DLC we see that orbs have very large area of effect (the Reaper was shot down high above the planet's surface). Leviathans can reach Shepard easily. But even without listening to Shepard Leviathans will have access to all Reaper remains. Discovery of Synthesis is just a matter of time. Leviathans don't have to fear indoctrination. They own mental abilities are much stronger.

Controlled Synthesis (i.e. Synthesis performed long after Control) is possible and very probable. Shepard-Catalyst has everything needed to apply Synthesis. Shepard's essence is already harvested. Crucible can be re-fueled.

Why not telling truth about the Crucible? Lesser races don't have to know about it more than they already know. Crucible is not only a part of solution, it's also the test, obviously. Only the ones who are truly ready can make the magic happen.

#332
Grand Admiral Cheesecake

Grand Admiral Cheesecake
  • Members
  • 5 704 messages

Seival wrote...

Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...

Oh Seival you so crazy.

We should really just get you and Wulfie together.

You two would be an adorable crazy couple!


Believe me, if you will try to think about inevitable Synthesis without unneeded emotions - you will like the idea very much.


Nah I'm good, and since the pro-synthesis people get to make all the silly endgame headcanon they want I'm going to do the same.

Dead Reapers, victory party, exterminated Leviathans, and everything was awesome forever the end.

Suck it Catalyst!

#333
TK514

TK514
  • Members
  • 3 794 messages

Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...

Oh Seival you so crazy.

We should really just get you and Wulfie together.

You two would be an adorable crazy couple!


Believe me, if you will try to think about inevitable Synthesis without unneeded emotions - you will like the idea very much.


Nah I'm good, and since the pro-synthesis people get to make all the silly endgame headcanon they want I'm going to do the same.

Dead Reapers, victory party, exterminated Leviathans, and everything was awesome forever the end.

Suck it Catalyst!


Cheesecake knows the score; Dead Reapers is how we win this.

Modifié par TK514, 27 avril 2013 - 05:26 .


#334
sH0tgUn jUliA

sH0tgUn jUliA
  • Members
  • 16 812 messages

Seival wrote...

Wynterdust wrote...

Hmm..an interesting perspective.
The only problem really is there is very little information as to how it alters everything. I can understand the synthetic side to it but what does it do to organics?
Does it alter the way they think? For example: Would Wreav still be the same or would he suddenly become peaceful? If it changes how everyone thinks that is destroying their free will and individuality. Without individuality, free will or emotion then one is not truly alive. Just a tranquil husk, a machine in other words. I cannot speak for all but the vast majority of people would not want that. It would be ethically difficult to force that onto people. In theory it would be nice to have peace but would anyone know any better if they had no emotion.


Synthesis epilogue shows that synthetics became more... hmm animated (remember EDI's human-like emotions?). Synthesis means that synthetics gain full understanding of organic life, as if they were organics themselves. Organics at their turn gain some physical synthetic capabilities without need to have implants. This establish direct connection between organics and synthetics as well, as between different organics. They all become very interrelated to each other... Closer, to be more correct. Closer on all possible levels. Smarter. Stronger. The persistent community, as if they all are the same race. And still keeping some of their own unique properties.


You forced implants on them at a molecular level. ... oh that. <_<

I guess the only choice will be Windows or OSxxx for the operating system, then. Android children or iChildren? And they get to keep some of their unique properties.

Do me a favor and put a bullet in my head while I'm still me.

#335
Yestare7

Yestare7
  • Members
  • 1 340 messages

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

Seival wrote...
In case of Destroy this will not be your Shepard's choice, because Synthesis will happen long after her/his death.


 It will be completely voluntary among the galactic denizens.




hello Foundation!!;)

#336
Wynterdust

Wynterdust
  • Members
  • 403 messages
I still don't understand why having no emotion is a good thing.
You would be like the tranquil mages from Dragon Age....
You wouldn't be alive... you would just exist.

#337
SpamBot2000

SpamBot2000
  • Members
  • 4 463 messages

Wynterdust wrote...

I still don't understand why having no emotion is a good thing.
You would be like the tranquil mages from Dragon Age....
You wouldn't be alive... you would just exist.


Reminds me of dismissals of emotion as "bourgeois sentimentalism" standing in the way of Progress... some truly evil **** in that direction. See 20th century.

Modifié par SpamBot2000, 27 avril 2013 - 10:31 .


#338
robertthebard

robertthebard
  • Members
  • 6 108 messages

Seival wrote...

As I said before, small human-sized Reaper parts can indoctrinate, and they have no mass effect cores. Confirmation of that is in the Leviathan DLC. And in the Arrival DLC by the way.

The orb is called Fragment. And Leviathans war asset is actually tones of that Fragments delivered on Earth. In Leviathan DLC we see that orbs have very large area of effect (the Reaper was shot down high above the planet's surface). Leviathans can reach Shepard easily. But even without listening to Shepard Leviathans will have access to all Reaper remains. Discovery of Synthesis is just a matter of time. Leviathans don't have to fear indoctrination. They own mental abilities are much stronger.

Controlled Synthesis (i.e. Synthesis performed long after Control) is possible and very probable. Shepard-Catalyst has everything needed to apply Synthesis. Shepard's essence is already harvested. Crucible can be re-fueled.

Why not telling truth about the Crucible? Lesser races don't have to know about it more than they already know. Crucible is not only a part of solution, it's also the test, obviously. Only the ones who are truly ready can make the magic happen.

Except that the tech in the Arrival DLC is not a Reaper ship fragment.  It is a probe, set to open the Relay to let the Reapers in.  Isn't that what the countdown is for?  Isn't that why the Relay gets destroyed?  It's one thing to hold onto rationale for a choice, it's another to try to change the lore to "fit" your rationale.  If you have to change the nature of the evidence, it's not the evidence that's at fault.  While I do think that any active Reaper tech can indoctrinate, we actually have no cases of shrapnel, which would be bits of Sovereign, indoctrinating anyone.  In Leviathan, the indoctrination via the orbs was done by the Leviathans, not the piece of Sovereign, and shielding potentially dangerous fragments, given what we don't know about the Reapers is a logical step, even if it would be, in and of itself harmless. 

The Indoctrination of the Batarians was through an entire Reaper ship, which was originally referred to by them as the Leviathan of Dis.  Really, that's essentially all we know, we don't know how much of the tech on the ship was still active.  This is what happens to the Cerberus team on the derelict Reaper, the ship still has power, and it still has enough power to indoctrinate.  However, since it still had power, we can see that that is indeed how it indoctrinated.

#339
Yestare7

Yestare7
  • Members
  • 1 340 messages

TK514 wrote...

Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...

Dead Reapers, victory party, exterminated Leviathans, and everything was awesome forever the end.

Suck it Catalyst!


Cheesecake knows the score; Dead Reapers is how we win this.


^ 2 smart krogan

#340
Seival

Seival
  • Members
  • 5 294 messages

Wynterdust wrote...

I still don't understand why having no emotion is a good thing.
You would be like the tranquil mages from Dragon Age....
You wouldn't be alive... you would just exist.


Why are you talking about "no emotions"? Where in the Synthesis epilogue did you find that? Synthesis epilogue shows nothing like that. But it shows that even robots and husks became more natural - they started to show emotions truly understandable by organics.

http://www.youtube.c...vTacJpcQ#t=231s
http://www.youtube.c...vTacJpcQ#t=694s

#341
Ledgend1221

Ledgend1221
  • Members
  • 6 456 messages
Synthesis is incredibly stupid.
I mean it's an insult to anything that actually exists.

#342
Argolas

Argolas
  • Members
  • 4 255 messages
Robots? Yes. Husks? No. Husks are way past the "mental decay" of indoctrination. Husks will be the slaves that will make post-Synthesis society possible. They will do the work that Synthetics don't have to do anymore.

#343
Wayning_Star

Wayning_Star
  • Members
  • 8 016 messages

Argolas wrote...

Robots? Yes. Husks? No. Husks are way past the "mental decay" of indoctrination. Husks will be the slaves that will make post-Synthesis society possible. They will do the work that Synthetics don't have to do anymore.


slaves bad, free thinking good..

#344
Argolas

Argolas
  • Members
  • 4 255 messages

Wayning_Star wrote...

Argolas wrote...

Robots? Yes. Husks? No. Husks are way past the "mental decay" of indoctrination. Husks will be the slaves that will make post-Synthesis society possible. They will do the work that Synthetics don't have to do anymore.


slaves bad, free thinking good..



They are not more intelligent than machines we use today. If you call that slavery, than we are pretty much f**ked. Our society can't work without 'slavery'.

#345
Wayning_Star

Wayning_Star
  • Members
  • 8 016 messages

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

Seival wrote...
In case of Destroy this will not be your Shepard's choice, because Synthesis will happen long after her/his death.


Sure it will. 

I posted this once before, but I'll post it again.

It will happen hundreds (possibly thousands) of years in the future. It will be consistent with biology, science, and logic. It won't require running into a green beam and dying to invoke an irreversable change. It won't placate the Reapers or the Catalyst (since they'll be long forgotten nightmare machines that were destroyed long before). It will not involve the Reapers at all. It will be completely voluntary among the galactic denizens. It won't be used as the solution to a crap cycle that never should have happened. It will happen as people wish to expand their scope physically and bring evolution to a new level. It will occur on the galaxy's own terms, not some ideal of readiness on the Catalyst's part. It will not be called Synthesis. And it won't be green.

See, we can agree on some things.




reaperships don't necessarily want to be synthesized, they don't 'want' anything that the catalyst doesn't provide for them. It controls them. Organics makes for the inevitability of synthesis, as they demand it, apparently. Through their evolution. Otherwise, there would be NO MEU.

simple really.

#346
Argolas

Argolas
  • Members
  • 4 255 messages
How can you synthesize Reapers? They already are organic-synthetic hybrids.

#347
Wayning_Star

Wayning_Star
  • Members
  • 8 016 messages

Argolas wrote...

Wayning_Star wrote...

Argolas wrote...

Robots? Yes. Husks? No. Husks are way past the "mental decay" of indoctrination. Husks will be the slaves that will make post-Synthesis society possible. They will do the work that Synthetics don't have to do anymore.


slaves bad, free thinking good..



They are not more intelligent than machines we use today. If you call that slavery, than we are pretty much f**ked. Our society can't work without 'slavery'.


shhhh, that's a trade secret.. don't tell anyone.

really tho, I'd wager that synthetic life forms would understand the problems and rigors of being organic, as the threats to organics is immunity for synthetic life forms. So they wouldn't mind doing that stuff out of their own free will, if need be. No Indentured servant  needed..

yay!


edit: husks and other victims needs extensive medical care...

Modifié par Wayning_Star, 27 avril 2013 - 03:48 .


#348
Wayning_Star

Wayning_Star
  • Members
  • 8 016 messages

Argolas wrote...

How can you synthesize Reapers? They already are organic-synthetic hybrids.


its molecular..

I could explain the concept, but it's very technical..


Posted Image

#349
Seival

Seival
  • Members
  • 5 294 messages

robertthebard wrote...

Seival wrote...

As I said before, small human-sized Reaper parts can indoctrinate, and they have no mass effect cores. Confirmation of that is in the Leviathan DLC. And in the Arrival DLC by the way.

The orb is called Fragment. And Leviathans war asset is actually tones of that Fragments delivered on Earth. In Leviathan DLC we see that orbs have very large area of effect (the Reaper was shot down high above the planet's surface). Leviathans can reach Shepard easily. But even without listening to Shepard Leviathans will have access to all Reaper remains. Discovery of Synthesis is just a matter of time. Leviathans don't have to fear indoctrination. They own mental abilities are much stronger.

Controlled Synthesis (i.e. Synthesis performed long after Control) is possible and very probable. Shepard-Catalyst has everything needed to apply Synthesis. Shepard's essence is already harvested. Crucible can be re-fueled.

Why not telling truth about the Crucible? Lesser races don't have to know about it more than they already know. Crucible is not only a part of solution, it's also the test, obviously. Only the ones who are truly ready can make the magic happen.

Except that the tech in the Arrival DLC is not a Reaper ship fragment.  It is a probe, set to open the Relay to let the Reapers in.  Isn't that what the countdown is for?  Isn't that why the Relay gets destroyed?  It's one thing to hold onto rationale for a choice, it's another to try to change the lore to "fit" your rationale.  If you have to change the nature of the evidence, it's not the evidence that's at fault.  While I do think that any active Reaper tech can indoctrinate, we actually have no cases of shrapnel, which would be bits of Sovereign, indoctrinating anyone.  In Leviathan, the indoctrination via the orbs was done by the Leviathans, not the piece of Sovereign, and shielding potentially dangerous fragments, given what we don't know about the Reapers is a logical step, even if it would be, in and of itself harmless. 

The Indoctrination of the Batarians was through an entire Reaper ship, which was originally referred to by them as the Leviathan of Dis.  Really, that's essentially all we know, we don't know how much of the tech on the ship was still active.  This is what happens to the Cerberus team on the derelict Reaper, the ship still has power, and it still has enough power to indoctrinate.  However, since it still had power, we can see that that is indeed how it indoctrinated.


In Arrival it is a Reaper tech fragment. It doesn't matter if it comes from a ship or not. Any pieces of Reaper tech eradiate the same thing. Any lesser race that will try to study it will become influenced eventually.

Remember Sanctuary? They just studied husks to understand how to control the Reapers, and ended up indoctrinated. All of them. Do you think they didn't bother to shield their personnel somehow? Any contact with Reaper tech, no matter dead or alive, ends up like that. And without Catalyst no one will direct influenced people. They will just become mad.

Derelict Reaper in ME2 was in much worse condition than Reaper ships after red explosion. Still that Reaper indoctrinated hundreds of people in matter of weeks. What about millions of derelict Reapers within all habitable places of this galaxy? How damaged galactic civilization will survive that without Leviathans help? Why do Leviathans want to help galactic civilization in case of Destroy at all? The answer is inside the Leviathan DLC.

#350
Argolas

Argolas
  • Members
  • 4 255 messages
Ooooh, so you rely on them doing vital tasks for us out of generosity? Well, I guess anything's possible in Utopia.

Medical Care? I doubt you could even pull a Lazarus on a husk. At least Shepard's brain was still intact, in a husk there does not seem to be anything left other than the hull itself. Kinda what "husk" means, no?

'course Synthesis is molecular. As is creating a reaper.

Posted Image

Your organic energy, the essence of who and what you are, will be broken down and then dispersed.

Posted Image

Your organic energy, the essence of who and what you are, will be broken down and then dispersed pumped into a reaper hull.

That different?