161 réponses à ce sujet

[MassivelyEffective0730]

David7204 wrote...

That's not true. Shepard has to go after Saren. S/he has to work with Cerberus and defeat the Collectors. S/he has to spend the Reaper invasion uniting the galaxy.

But why is the question. What drives your Shepard to do what he does? That is something that each of us makes for our Shepards. 

My Shepard has a different reasoning than yours, and your is different from somebody elses.

Unless your Auld Wulf, that shouldn't be a problem right?

This isn't a challenge to your claim. This is an expansion to your idea, or how I saw it.

Modifié par MassivelyEffective0730, 30 avril 2013 - 07:35 .

[Metallica93]

No one has posted a reply to my question: Why is Shepard alive if the Catalyst said he'd be destroyed, as well? He IS partly synthetic.

Hell, might as well say the geth and EDI survived, as well! Why not!? -__-

[Enhanced]

Metallica93 wrote...

No one has posted a reply to my question: Why is Shepard alive if the Catalyst said he'd be destroyed, as well? He IS partly synthetic.

Hell, might as well say the geth and EDI survived, as well! Why not!? -__-

The Catalyst didn't say that Shepard would be destroyed.

Modifié par Enhanced, 30 avril 2013 - 08:35 .

[BizkitRebellion]

All I can say is this:
The more you think about that question, the more you realize that the "Breath Scene" is stupid & pointless.

[Metallica93]

Enhanced wrote...

Metallica93 wrote...

No
one has posted a reply to my question: Why is Shepard alive if the
Catalyst said he'd be destroyed, as well? He IS partly synthetic.

Hell, might as well say the geth and EDI survived, as well! Why not!? -__-

The Catalyst didn't say that Shepard would be destroyed.

The hell do you think would happen if Shepard's synthetic parts were to suddenly shut down? You cannot honestly believe that he'd live let alone survive the destruction of the Citadel. In short, this:

BizkitRebellion wrote...

All I can say is this:
The more you think about that question, the more you realize that the "Breath Scene" is stupid & pointless.

[KaiserShep]

They make it pretty clear that they don't shut down, otherwise there'd be no breath at all, but then there's still the issue of other inconsistencies with the red wave that passes over everything. If all "synthetics" are going to be destroyed, I guess this begs the question as to what these synthetics are. Like, do other, more mundane pieces of technology disappear? Will my DVD player no longer be programmable? Why do the husks get vaporized, but the reapers themselves just topple over? A lot of questions with the imagery beyond something as simple as the breath scene, so I'm just going to assume that it's only things that are augmented by reaper tech somehow, which we have no mention of as being part of Shepard's implants. We also don't know to what extent Shepard is synthetic. He/She may have some synthetic protein to cover the scars, and some augmentation here and there, but from what I saw in the reconstruction, a lot of it was reviving dead tissue and replacing others with prosthetics. 

Modifié par KaiserShep, 30 avril 2013 - 09:10 .

[Enhanced]

Metallica93 wrote...

Enhanced wrote...

Metallica93 wrote...

No
one has posted a reply to my question: Why is Shepard alive if the
Catalyst said he'd be destroyed, as well? He IS partly synthetic.

Hell, might as well say the geth and EDI survived, as well! Why not!? -__-

The Catalyst didn't say that Shepard would be destroyed.

The hell do you think would happen if Shepard's synthetic parts were to suddenly shut down? You cannot honestly believe that he'd live let alone survive the destruction of the Citadel. In short, this:

BizkitRebellion wrote...

All I can say is this:
The more you think about that question, the more you realize that the "Breath Scene" is stupid & pointless.

We don't know how much of Shepard is synthetic, how much of it is damaged, or how much he/she relies on it.

Modifié par Enhanced, 30 avril 2013 - 09:16 .

[Metallica93]

The man was brought back to life after almost burning up in atmospheric entry and hitting the ground at terminal velocity.

I'm going to go watch the "Lazarus" cutscene again, but a decent chunk of him has to be synthetic. Enough to the point where he'd be dead if his synthetic parts stopped working.

And that's completely ignoring the fact that he "survived" the Citadel's destruction somehow.

Modifié par Metallica93, 30 avril 2013 - 10:01 .

[008Zulu]

It's Schrodinger's Shepard.

Until Bioware declare a canon ending, Shepard can be thought of as both dead and alive.

[008Zulu]

Metallica93 wrote...

The man was brought back to life after almost burning up in atmospheric entry and hitting the ground at terminal velocity.

I'm going to go watch the "Lazarus" cutscene again, but a decent chunk of him has to be synthetic. Enough to the point where he'd be dead if his synthetic parts stopped working.

And that's completely ignoring the fact that he "survived" the Citadel's destruction somehow.

Don't put much stock in Bioware's "science." After about 6 minutes without oxygen the brain suffers permenant and irreverasble damage. Shep was without oxygen for several months. They never explained how they were able to overcome this little immutable factoid.

[Kel Riever]

008Zulu wrote...

It's Schrodinger's Shepard.

Until Bioware declare a canon learns how to write an ending, Shepard can be thought of as both dead and alive.

But basically, this is the best response I've seen so far.  Nice.