83 réponses à ce sujet

[Hazegurl]

Xilizhra wrote...

Very few will answer this properly. All have an emotional investment in trying to get everyone to choose Destroy because their own egos demand it, or something. These threads are utterly pointless as a result.

This isn't a "let's b*tch about players perceptions of their comrades" thread. Just state what you think they would choose.

[Hazegurl]

S.A.K wrote...

Hazegurl wrote...

sH0tgUn jUliA wrote...

Liara - Destroy
Garrus - Destroy
Ashley - Destroy
Kaidan - Destroy
Javik - Destroy
Wrex - Destroy
Grunt - Destroy Accidential refuse
Tali - Destroy
Zaeed - Fry, you sons of a b**ches
Jack - Destroy
Miranda - Destroy
Thane - Destroy
Mordin - Destroy
Samara - Destroy - I'm sure the sutras don't allow her to assume power. The Geth aren't innocents, and it is unclear anyway.
Kasumi - Destroy
EDI - Destroy -- She had proper rearing by Shepard
Joker - Destroy
Dr. Chakwas - Destroy
Jacob - Destroy

Pretty much all this.

Yep. Legion wouldn't take Destroy. But it's dead right?

Poor Legion would probably choose Sync. Thanks a lot you damn machine

Oh yeah and I have to change my vote on Grunt, like someone mentioned, he would probably choose refuse by accident, damn Krogan.

[Bizinha]

sH0tgUn jUliA wrote...

Liara - Destroy
Garrus - Destroy
Ashley - Destroy
Kaidan - Destroy
Javik - Destroy
Wrex - Destroy
Grunt - Destroy
Tali - Destroy
Zaeed - Fry, you sons of a b**ches
Jack - Destroy
Miranda - Destroy
Thane - Destroy
Mordin - Destroy
Samara - Destroy - I'm sure the sutras don't allow her to assume power. The Geth aren't innocents, and it is unclear anyway.
Kasumi - Destroy
EDI - Destroy -- She had proper rearing by Shepard
Joker - Destroy
Dr. Chakwas - Destroy
Jacob - Destroy

This! 
Principally, The Garrus, Liara and Tali, who accompanied the three games, choose to destroy.The EDI would make a backup before.

[ZeCollectorDestroya]

Liara would most likely pick Control because of how she thinks, not Synthesis. But she equally could pick Destroy as well. People that have a strong relationship to synthetics would only pick Synthesis.

Modifié par ZeCollectorDestroya, 30 avril 2013 - 02:05 .

[MassivelyEffective0730]

I have a very strong relationship with synthetics. I trust the Geth and EDI with my life. I still destroy. Without even considering synthesis or control.

[KaiserShep]

Finn the Jakey wrote...

Let's be realistic here, would any of the squadmates actually demand Shepard to commit suicidde for the greater good?

This is what I was thinking. If I was able to get Shepard's entire squad (Liara and Garrus) up to the Crucible and talked to the catalyst, neither character is going to support an option that involves Shepard leaping into a giant beam of light to be dissolved, or grab onto the sparking handlebars, to be dissolved, when a third option that promises to be rid of the reapers is available. They'd both walk alongside you to shoot at the conduit. Sucks to lose the synthetics, but as Javik's people would put it: Their sacrifice will be honored in the coming empire. 

Modifié par KaiserShep, 30 avril 2013 - 03:02 .

[Xilizhra]

KaiserShep wrote...

Finn the Jakey wrote...

Let's be realistic here, would any of the squadmates actually demand Shepard to commit suicidde for the greater good?

This is what I was thinking. If I was able to get Shepard's entire squad (Liara and Garrus) up to the Crucible and talked to the catalyst, neither character is going to support an option that involves Shepard leaping into a giant beam of light to be dissolved, or grab onto the sparking handlebars, to be dissolved, when a third option that promises to be rid of the reapers is available. They'd both walk alongside you to shoot at the conduit. Sucks to lose the synthetics, but as Javik's people would put it: Their sacrifice will be honored in the coming empire. 

Shepard's almost certainly doomed in Destroy as well, it only changes with high EMS. If they're too squeamish to actually ask for another choice, fine, but I doubt they'd try to stop me, or object that hard, if I chose to definitely die to save so many other lives.

[Han Shot First]

Yestare7 wrote...

Liara is EXREMELY intelligent, she'd choose destroy even faster than Shep.

Agreed. Liara would totally be a Destroyer.


Liara: Poor Rila... but I'm glad she set off that bomb, Shepard.

Shepard: You're not upset the monastery was destroyed?

Liara: No, not after what I saw. I don't care that they were Ardat-Yakshi. To be turned into such creatures? Nobody deserves that.

Modifié par Han Shot First, 30 avril 2013 - 08:41 .

[Yestare7]

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

I have a very strong relationship with synthetics. I trust the Geth and EDI with my life. I still destroy. Without even considering synthesis or control.

group hug!!

[Yestare7]

Han Shot First wrote...

Yestare7 wrote...

Liara is EXREMELY intelligent, she'd choose destroy even faster than Shep.

Agreed. Liara would totally be a Destroyer.


Liara: Poor Rila... but I'm glad she set off that bomb, Shepard.

Shepard: You're not upset the monastery was destroyed?

Liara: No, not after what I saw. I don't care that they were Ardat-Yakshi. To be turned into such creatures? Nobody deserves that.

Hug hug

[Xilizhra]

Han Shot First wrote...

Yestare7 wrote...

Liara is EXREMELY intelligent, she'd choose destroy even faster than Shep.

Agreed. Liara would totally be a Destroyer.


Liara: Poor Rila... but I'm glad she set off that bomb, Shepard.

Shepard: You're not upset the monastery was destroyed?

Liara: No, not after what I saw. I don't care that they were Ardat-Yakshi. To be turned into such creatures? Nobody deserves that.

That's taken unbelievably out of context; I don't want to pull Auld Wulf about assumptions of other people's intelligence, but it's frankly tempting. Banshees have nothing to do with either Control or Synthesis.

[Han Shot First]

Xilizhra wrote...

Han Shot First wrote...

Yestare7 wrote...

Liara is EXREMELY intelligent, she'd choose destroy even faster than Shep.

Agreed. Liara would totally be a Destroyer.


Liara: Poor Rila... but I'm glad she set off that bomb, Shepard.

Shepard: You're not upset the monastery was destroyed?

Liara: No, not after what I saw. I don't care that they were Ardat-Yakshi. To be turned into such creatures? Nobody deserves that.

That's taken unbelievably out of context; I don't want to pull Auld Wulf about assumptions of other people's intelligence, but it's frankly tempting. Banshees have nothing to do with either Control or Synthesis.

The Reapers are murderous abominations created from sapient organic beings that have been robbed of their free will, just like the Banshees.

Liara's feelings regarding Reaper abominations are quite clear in that dialogue. She would choose Destroy.

[Enhanced]

"There is power in control. There is wisdom in harnessing the strengths of your enemy"

Liara would agree with that statement. Since she's a scientist, she seems least likely to destroy something that the galaxy's civilizations could learn so much from. For example, rather than destroying the Shadow Broker's base and letting access to all of that information go to waste, she decides to become the new Shadow Broker.

Modifié par Enhanced, 01 mai 2013 - 03:00 .

[Killdren88]

Good luck picking either Control or Synthesis without Javik trying to put a bullet in your head with him doing it himself. I imagine you having to put him down before picking anything but destroy.

[jtav]

Ashley-Destroy
Kaidan-Destroy
Liara-Control (essentially what she did with the SB resources)
Garrus-Control (could plausibly make any choice, but I think a quick rebuild of Palavan would be tempting)
Wrex-Synthesis (for krogan improvement)
Tali-Synthesis (she'ss living it if peace was chosen
Miranda-Either Destroy or Synthesis (Destroy if we're focusing on the risk-averse aspect, but the ambitious "advancement of humanity side would be tempted by Synthesis)
Jacob-Destroy
Mordin-Control (one of the only team members to advocate geth rewrite)
Grunt-Destroy
Jack-Destroy
Thane-Synthesis (putting good in the world and all that)
Samara-Refuse (all choices have some ethical downside, she'd commit suicide rather than compromise)
Morinth-Destroy (only chance of survival)
Legion-Synthesis (basically what he was trying to achieve in 3)
Zaeed-Destroy
Kasumi-Destroy
James-Destroy
EDI-Synthesis (narrates the epilogue)
Javik-Destroy

[Hadeedak]

Javik: Destroy
Garrus: Control. Mostly because he mega-approves whenever Shepard makes peace, and says she'll be making peace with the Reapers as a joke. Also, the whole archangel thing. Though I can see him being a destroy man, too.
Tali: Synthesis or destroy, probably depending on the Shepchoices.
Liara: Control. Come on, y'all saw the Shadow Broker DLC. That's the easiest of the lot.
Vega: Seems like a destroy man to me.
EDI: Synthesis. Maybe control if you renegaded the blazes out of her.
Kaidan: I actually think he'd go synthesis. If nothing else, because it seems like he has a real self-sacrificing streak. Maybe destroy if romanced because he's a sap.
Ash: Boom, boom, Reapers go bye bye.

...Actually, you know what? I bet this'd go like ME1, where everyone had their opinions, and you can even get Liara to advocate ditching the council if you bring the right person. I think it'd be two choices.

[Kel Riever]

I'm sure my LI would have also chosen to throw the ending(s) in the garbage and write some that made sense.

[Hadeedak]

Finn the Jakey wrote...

Let's be realistic here, would any of the squadmates actually demand Shepard to commit suicidde for the greater good?

Hah, it'd be like DAO all over again. OH WELL, KNOCKING OUT ALISTAIR WAS FUN THEN AND IT'S FUN NOW.

It is a far, far greater thing that I do now then I have ever done!
*knocks Garrus out of the way, grabs rods* 


In the silly side of things (because my posts are so ever-living serious), I know what my LI chose. He chose destroy, screamed when he realized he blew up EDI, and reloaded, replayed London (pre EC) to choose synthesis. Since then, he's played a Shep for every ending. I know what my LI would choose.

ALL OF THEM.

Modifié par Hadeedak, 01 mai 2013 - 04:02 .

[Steelcan]

Anybody who thinks the squadmates would pick anything but Destroy, with the possible exception of EDI and Legion for Synthesis is mistaken. All other squadmates express their complete desire to exterminate the Reapers.

[Enhanced]

Steelcan wrote...

Anybody who thinks the squadmates would pick anything but Destroy, with the possible exception of EDI and Legion for Synthesis is mistaken. All other squadmates express their complete desire to exterminate the Reapers.

So does Shepard before realizing that there is more than one possiblity.

Modifié par Enhanced, 01 mai 2013 - 04:30 .

[o Ventus]

Enhanced wrote...

Steelcan wrote...

Anybody who thinks the squadmates would pick anything but Destroy, with the possible exception of EDI and Legion for Synthesis is mistaken. All other squadmates express their complete desire to exterminate the Reapers.

So does Shepard before realizing that there is more than one possiblity.

My Shepard shot down both Control and Synthesis.

[Hadeedak]

Steelcan wrote...

Anybody who thinks the squadmates would pick anything but Destroy, with the possible exception of EDI and Legion for Synthesis is mistaken. All other squadmates express their complete desire to exterminate the Reapers.

You sure about that? Remember, they don't know there's other choices. The whole control thing sounds crazy until we see it happened. And there's more than a few comments and choices they make that might suggest otherwise. For instance. Liara. Hates the Shadow Broker. Really hard. She's apperantly determined to burn it down. Until she's there, and then she steps into the role. That's why I think our littlest asari would be all for control -- in a very similar situation, she chose it.

[Killdren88]

Makes me wonder. Are the controllers and synthesizers prepared to kill their crew if they were all against anything that was not destroy and are will try to stop you from doing so LI included?

[Hadeedak]

Killdren88 wrote...

Makes me wonder. Are the controllers and synthesizers prepared to kill their crew if they were all against anything that was not destroy and are will try to stop you from doing so LI included?

Probably not. After all. I'm in this for minimal sacrifice.

Are the destroyers willing to kill their whole crew for the same?