617 réponses à ce sujet

[spernus]

DeathCultArm wrote...

IGN usually do high pro-file reivews a week early, I wonder what they'll give it...

IGN is quite hated these days,so I dunno if they can win whatever score they give to Mass effect 2.

I am fearing a 10/10 score from IGN(game which earn a 10 with big sites are usually on the receiving end of a massive backlash),since they are huge fans of the first.

[DigitalMaster37]

Please add this review to the list please:

http://www.computera...e.php?id=232013

90/100 90%

XBOX WORLD 360 Magazine

someone else mentioned it too, but it would help if it was on the front page.

Modifié par Deltaboy37-1, 19 janvier 2010 - 05:14 .

[TheRastapopolous]

Br0th3rGr1mm wrote...

There are far too many 10/10 scores being tossed about recently. From what i hear (I have never played it longer than 10 min), Uncharted 2 was the only game that deserved it last year. There are also FAR too few 5/10 scores EVER given out. The game industry seems to EXPECT a 6-10 / 10 scale these days and most reviewers oblige them. It's sad.

The only thing sadder is seeing bllind game fans stating they were "expecting" all 10/10s and are "confused" or "angry" about a 9/10 score for their favorite title. Very sad indeed.

you see the connection?

[Sovereign 666]

DeathCultArm wrote...

Demon souls was hardly GOTY worthy. IGN is pretty much the only site I trust. I seem to agree with them more often than any other review.

ha ha! You would agree with those morons.
GTA4=10/10 amirite?!

[ExarKun00720]

Deltaboy37-1 wrote...

Please add this review to the list please:

http://www.computera...e.php?id=232013

90/100 90%

XBOX WORLD 360 Magazine

someone else mentioned it too, but it would help if it was on the front page.

thank ya, need a link of some kind, will add it now

[Br0th3rGr1mm]

TheRastapopolous wrote...
you see the connection?

I also see a possible chicken or  egg analogy in there.  Which is responsible for the other trend (if they are, in fact, releated).

[Wynne]

I just take the score as enthusiasm or a quality rating, not a "everyone will like this!!!!" declaration.



I take the actual stuff said in the review as being more important than anything else.

[ExarKun00720]

Wynne wrote...

I just take the score as enthusiasm or a quality rating, not a "everyone will like this!!!!" declaration.

I take the actual stuff said in the review as being more important than anything else.

as most people should see them as such, I have read a great many reviews that made the game sound amazing and fun with little complaints, yet the game get a 7 or so, which seemed strange with such high praises.

[ExarKun00720]

ZAP 2 it - no score (positive review) new review found, no score just a text review

[Funkcase]

ExarKun00720 wrote...

ZAP 2 it - no score (positive review) new review found, no score just a text review

Text is better to find than a score, atleast we can hear there real views on the game.

[ExarKun00720]

Funkcase wrote...

ExarKun00720 wrote...

ZAP 2 it - no score (positive review) new review found, no score just a text review

Text is better to find than a score, atleast we can hear there real views on the game.

It does force people to read to try and figure out was the person means.  I hear a many times someone reads a good review then goes it get an 8.5 it's a crappy game.

[CannonO]

Well 10/10 as some have mentioned is not the same as how you would understand it if someone graded your correct answers on a test. A 10/10 on reviews means it is a guaranteed classic/masterpiece of a title that hits the highest points of greatness around. It can lack technically and even have several flaws, but it earns its place undeniably as one of the best. Not perfect, just up there with the select few best titles made.

[ExarKun00720]

CannonLars wrote...

Well 10/10 as some have mentioned is not the same as how you would understand it if someone graded your correct answers on a test. A 10/10 on reviews means it is a guaranteed classic/masterpiece of a title that hits the highest points of greatness around. It can lack technically and even have several flaws, but it earns its place undeniably as one of the best. Not perfect, just up there with the select few best titles made.

Which is what I think many feel is the case with ME2, least it's not getting a 21/20 score... I mean when you give a game an above perfect score you are just being a fanyboy.

[ExarKun00720]

IGN - 9.6

Here is IGN's review.

[Wolverfrog]

360 magazine (UK) -

5/5 stars.

[Cris Shepard]

IGN had almost nothing bad to say.. For us ME1 players, it looks like we'll be getting the better experience, that's how it should be anyways..

[ExarKun00720]

Wolverfrog wrote...

360 magazine (UK) -

5/5 stars.

You have a link for me to post at the top?  Maybe a cover or something?

[Major Alenko]

yeah only 4 reviews on metacritic atm... but how damn sexy does that over all 98 look, lets hope it stays that high http://www.metacriti...360/masseffect2

[Wolverfrog]

ExarKun00720 wrote...

Wolverfrog wrote...

360 magazine (UK) -

5/5 stars.

You have a link for me to post at the top?  Maybe a cover or something?

www.360magazine.co.uk/magazine-issues/360-issue-62-out-now/

Sure. It was a good, six page long read.

[ExarKun00720]

Commodore Q wrote...

yeah only 4 reviews on metacritic atm... but how damn sexy does that over all 98 look, lets hope it stays that high http://www.metacriti...360/masseffect2

I can use that for the Xbox 360 UK mag...

X360 Magazine (UK) - 5/5

Modifié par ExarKun00720, 23 janvier 2010 - 12:58 .

[Major Alenko]

9.8<3 http://xbox-360.nowg...7/mass-effect-2

[ExarKun00720]

NOW Gamer - 9.8

another one

[ExarKun00720]

Commodore Q wrote...

9.8<3 http://xbox-360.nowg...7/mass-effect-2

ya beat me to it

[Major Alenko]

ExarKun00720 wrote...

Commodore Q wrote...

9.8<3 http://xbox-360.nowg...7/mass-effect-2

ya beat me to it

Also from the review..."The most easily justified perfect score we have ever given, one that
carelessly gate-crashes our top five games of all time party. BioWare,
we love you."  9.8 is not a perfect score, 10/10 would be, so this has me thinking wether the it was dumped down by the editors its happend before with nowgamer.

[ExarKun00720]

Commodore Q wrote...

ExarKun00720 wrote...

Commodore Q wrote...

9.8<3 http://xbox-360.nowg...7/mass-effect-2

ya beat me to it

Also from the review..."The most easily justified perfect score we have ever given, one that
carelessly gate-crashes our top five games of all time party. BioWare,
we love you."  9.8 is not a perfect score, 10/10 would be, so this has me thinking wether the it was dumped down by the editors its happend before with nowgamer.

Yeah, when I saw Fallout 3 was a 10/10 game there I shurged a bit, I like Fallout 3 a lot, just don't think I can call it a 10/10 game.