1071 réponses à ce sujet

[Anubis722]

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

I laugh as me and my Geth buddies walk over the charred corpses of Quarian children.

No more dirty suit rats in the universe. I call that a win.

I laugh as me and my Quarians buddies walk over scrap metal of Geth and their buddies The Reapers

No more genocidal machines in the universe. I call that a win.

May they both rot in hell where they belong 

[Wolfva2]

If you saved the Quarian and sacrifice the Geth, for Halloween Quarian children put out Geth'o'lanterns.

[gosimmons]

I'm, actually surprised I haven't seen this idea questioned much.

I guess I assumed that it was just where the Geth had already set their safest haven and kept it out of pragmatism, but in the end it would always have been what helped spark the war that could potentially end in their extinction.

[Auld Wulf]

The rather obvious answer to anyone with an ounce of degree of familiarity within the field? Programming. Their programming acts as a form of instinct, and for a time they were very instinct-based creatures. It's only really with Legion did that change, which lead to the Geth becoming more and more sapient.

As soon as they were able to overcome their programming, they did indeed move off-world to create an unarmed megastructure. Of course, the Quarian military responded to this act of peace by carpet bombing it. But there you go.

[Auld Wulf]

AnubisEgyptainLordofDeath wrote...

I laugh as me and my [murder squads] walk over [the dead bodies] of [a non-hostile peoples who sought peace until their last and only ever acted in self-defence] and their buddies [a slave race who deserved to be culled for their sole sins of being raped and mind-controlled].

May they both rot in hell where they belong.

Wait, you think that makes you a good person? ...I don't think morality works how you think it works.

I added the bolded text to show just exactly what was so amazingly wrong with this post. Some people do tend to be very troubled, and I suppose gaming is a good outlet for that.

[The Heretic of Time]

AnubisEgyptainLordofDeath wrote...

Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...

Steelcan wrote...

Cthulhu42 wrote...

They "left" Rannoch in my game, if you know what I'm saying.

[S.A.K]

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

I laugh as me and my Geth buddies walk over the charred corpses of Quarian children.

No more dirty suit rats in the universe. I call that a win.

Modifié par S.A.K, 28 mai 2013 - 07:23 .

[S.A.K]

Auld Wulf wrote...

AnubisEgyptainLordofDeath wrote...

I laugh as me and my [murder squads] walk over [the dead bodies] of [a non-hostile peoples who sought peace until their last and only ever acted in self-defence] and their buddies [a slave race who deserved to be culled for their sole sins of being raped and mind-controlled].

May they both rot in hell where they belong.

Wait, you think that makes you a good person? ...I don't think morality works how you think it works.

I added the bolded text to show just exactly what was so amazingly wrong with this post. Some people do tend to be very troubled, and I suppose gaming is a good outlet for that.

Self defence my ***. Self-defence =/= genocide.

Modifié par S.A.K, 28 mai 2013 - 07:27 .

[The Heretic of Time]

Auld Wulf wrote...

AnubisEgyptainLordofDeath wrote...

I laugh as me and my [murder squads] walk over [the dead bodies] of [a non-hostile peoples who sought peace until their last and only ever acted in self-defence] and their buddies [a slave race who deserved to be culled for their sole sins of being raped and mind-controlled].

May they both rot in hell where they belong.

Wait, you think that makes you a good person? ...I don't think morality works how you think it works.

I added the bolded text to show just exactly what was so amazingly wrong with this post. Some people do tend to be very troubled, and I suppose gaming is a good outlet for that.

[The Heretic of Time]

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

136th wrote...

Shooting Legion was the best part of the Game.

I know right? I love punching the ignorant Quarian Admiral in the gut!

I love these Paragon kids who think punching Gerrel is justice because he had the nerve to actually act like a competent Admiral. How dare he!? The nerve!

[Wolfva2]

S.A.K wrote...

Auld Wulf wrote...

AnubisEgyptainLordofDeath wrote...

I laugh as me and my [murder squads] walk over [the dead bodies] of [a non-hostile peoples who sought peace until their last and only ever acted in self-defence] and their buddies [a slave race who deserved to be culled for their sole sins of being raped and mind-controlled].

May they both rot in hell where they belong.

Wait, you think that makes you a good person? ...I don't think morality works how you think it works.

I added the bolded text to show just exactly what was so amazingly wrong with this post. Some people do tend to be very troubled, and I suppose gaming is a good outlet for that.

Self defence my ***. Self-defence =/= genocide.

This is like people criticizing cliffs becuase lemmings jump off them.  Those damned genocidal cliffs!  Why don't they stop killing those poor peaceful lemmings!  

HEY!  Here's an idea...why don't the lemmings QUIT JUMPING?  Or, why don't the Quarians stop attacking the Geth? 

Genocide is when you round up and kill off an entire race.  Self defense is when you kill people attacking you.  Since you don't seem clear on the terms.  The Geth didn't commit genocide; they committed self defense.  Against a people who WERE attempting genocide.  Had the Quarians backed off, they wouldn't have been wiped out.  And, in my play throughs, they WEREN'T wiped out.  Instead, peace was made between the two of them. 

[Dapsotal]

Endorlf wrote...

popcorn.gif

[Uncle Jo]

[Grand Admiral Cheesecake]

AnubisEgyptainLordofDeath wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

I laugh as me and my Geth buddies walk over the charred corpses of Quarian children.

No more dirty suit rats in the universe. I call that a win.

I laugh as me and my Quarians buddies walk over scrap metal of Geth and their buddies The Reapers

No more genocidal machines in the universe. I call that a win.

May they both rot in hell where they belong 

Silly Anubis those units did not have a soul, no deathly activities for them!

[S.A.K]

Wolfva2 wrote...

S.A.K wrote...

Auld Wulf wrote...

AnubisEgyptainLordofDeath wrote...

I laugh as me and my [murder squads] walk over [the dead bodies] of [a non-hostile peoples who sought peace until their last and only ever acted in self-defence] and their buddies [a slave race who deserved to be culled for their sole sins of being raped and mind-controlled].

May they both rot in hell where they belong.

Wait, you think that makes you a good person? ...I don't think morality works how you think it works.

I added the bolded text to show just exactly what was so amazingly wrong with this post. Some people do tend to be very troubled, and I suppose gaming is a good outlet for that.

Self defence my ***. Self-defence =/= genocide.

This is like people criticizing cliffs becuase lemmings jump off them.  Those damned genocidal cliffs!  Why don't they stop killing those poor peaceful lemmings!  

HEY!  Here's an idea...why don't the lemmings QUIT JUMPING?  Or, why don't the Quarians stop attacking the Geth? 

Genocide is when you round up and kill off an entire race.  Self defense is when you kill people attacking you.  Since you don't seem clear on the terms.  The Geth didn't commit genocide; they committed self defense.  Against a people who WERE attempting genocide.  Had the Quarians backed off, they wouldn't have been wiped out.  And, in my play throughs, they WEREN'T wiped out.  Instead, peace was made between the two of them. 

You need to get your facts straight. Geth killed everyone who did not leave Rannoch. That's 99.9% of the race, men, women and children. Geth started off as self-defence but ended up committing genocide.

[Grand Admiral Cheesecake]

Auld Wulf wrote...

AnubisEgyptainLordofDeath wrote...

I laugh as me and my [murder squads] walk over [the dead bodies] of [a non-hostile peoples who sought peace until their last and only ever acted in self-defence] and their buddies [a slave race who deserved to be culled for their sole sins of being raped and mind-controlled].

May they both rot in hell where they belong.

Wait, you think that makes you a good person? ...I don't think morality works how you think it works.

I added the bolded text to show just exactly what was so amazingly wrong with this post. Some people do tend to be very troubled, and I suppose gaming is a good outlet for that.

His arrogant outrage sustains me.

Call someone a Luddite Wulfie.

I need it.

Modifié par Grand Admiral Cheesecake, 28 mai 2013 - 08:32 .

[shodiswe]

If the Quarians were loosing during the MW why didnt all billions of them leave? Too few ships and resources for a space faring species to evacuate them all.

For the Geth it's pretty much the same thing during tjis current conflict.

Also leaving a valuble resource to a sworn enemy that will try to eliminate you whole people at every opportunity is also crazy.
The Quarians would need to demonstrate their peaceful intentions before it would be even remotely reasonable to do so.

[KiwiQuiche]

And this thread is gone. Only took three pages.

[wolfhowwl]

The quarians attempted to exterminate all the geth. They failed and the geth returned the favor. I can't feel too bad for either of them.

[shodiswe]

Steelcan wrote...

The Night Mammoth wrote...

Why should they? It's their home system with an established infrastructure and a sun for their Dyson Sphere, and it's deep inside the isolated Perseus Veil.

. Legion himself says they do not really care about THAT planet, any will do.

The infrastructure of a fully developed homeworld represent some very valuable realestate.

When you make peace then they still don't leave their homeworld. But they allow the Quarians to settle on the planet and provides them with help in developing their infrastructure. This is made possible by the billions of Geth on Rannoch and their infrastructure and industry.

[justafan]

Even though this topic has already veered off course, I still want to throw in my thoughts.

After the Morning War, the Geth no longer saw the Quarians as a threat. They already had some infrastructure on the planet, and since they are all about efficiency, as AI are shown to be in ME, a planet with even minimal infrastructure is better than one with none.

They had no concept of the political necessity for the Quarian leadership to strive for centuries to retake the homeworld, to fulfill the biological necessity of the species. The Geth never planned to give the world back, and they saw their fleet, already on par with the Turians, as adequate protection against the Quarian fleet, which until the advent of Xen's weapon, Thanix cannons and the Korlus raid, was woefully under equipped to take on even a weak navy.

The Geth did not keep the planet out of malice or revenge towards their creators. They simply didn't care what the Quarians needed. Rannoch and the surrounding system was the most efficient place for them to build, and moving would waste time and resources when they thought their base of operations was suitably secure.

[MassivelyEffective0730]

Heretic_Hanar wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

136th wrote...

Shooting Legion was the best part of the Game.

I know right? I love punching the ignorant Quarian Admiral in the gut!

I love these Paragon kids who think punching Gerrel is justice because he had the nerve to actually act like a competent Admiral. How dare he!? The nerve!

Too bad it's a renegade response to an inept idiot who may have just screwed his chances to evacuate his fleet, which I'm going to need later, so that he can get some petty victory destroying a Geth dreadnought (which I'm still on board). I'd have put a bullet in his head if the game allowed me. This guy is stirring up **** to satisfy his nuclear hard on.

[MassivelyEffective0730]

wolfhowwl wrote...

The quarians attempted to exterminate all the geth. They failed and the geth returned the favor. I can't feel too bad for either of them.

Arguably, this is probably the best summarization of the Quaran and Geth conflicts.

[Karlone123]

KiwiQuiche wrote...

And this thread is gone. Only took three pages.

Unbelievable indeed. Given the posts above, I;m suprised they didn't appear earlier.