415 réponses à ce sujet

[Dextro Milk]

David7204 wrote...

But why what?

Your entire post. I need more information to make a decision on whether I agree with you or not.

[S.A.K]

Ryzaki wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

I guess I'm the only person here who's a destroyer and actually likes the Geth more than the Quarians.

You are not alone. I pick the Geth over the Quarians every time. Much much prefer the Geth (even ME3 Geth) over the Quarians.

Now if the question was sacrifice the Quarians for the Geth...I'd do that every time.

Alas I have to make due with destroyed Rannoch slide because go go contrived all synthetics must die garbage.

Sorry, I couldn't help it. If you like dead Geth better(like me), you might actually enjoy the ending.

[David7204]

I wasn't making any definitive point. I was just speculating on the reactions of people on the BSN on the geth.

[Ravensword]

Ryzaki wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

I guess I'm the only person here who's a destroyer and actually likes the Geth more than the Quarians.

You are not alone. I pick the Geth over the Quarians every time. Much much prefer the Geth (even ME3 Geth) over the Quarians.

Now if the question was sacrifice the Quarians for the Geth...I'd do that every time.

Alas I have to make due with destroyed Rannoch slide because go go contrived all synthetics must die garbage.

I like the pre-ME3 Geth before the writers ruined the Geth in ME3. So in my headcanon, the Reapers haven't showed up at Rannoch yet and Shepard just gets there as the Quarians are fighting a losing war against the Geth and Shepard has an opportunity to make peace, but chooses the Geth instead.

Tali attempts suicide on Rannoch; she does a sweet backwards swan dive off that cliff. Shepard thinks she's dead and departs. Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds a spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

Modifié par Ravensword, 08 juin 2013 - 07:12 .

[DeinonSlayer]

@Phatose

Lots of people see them as life. Even me. I've only ever had a problem with them on account of the things they've done. If I didn't already view these particular synthetics as criminals, I'd have a harder time answering this. It comes down to what minimizes losses (a touchy issue in itself - how many Krogan lives is the last Rachni Queen worth before the cost is too high to save her, if you are so inclined?).

[Phatose]

DeinonSlayer wrote...

@Phatose

Lots of people see them as life. Even me. I've only ever had a problem with them on account of the things they've done. If I didn't already view these particular synthetics as criminals, I'd have a harder time answering this. It comes down to what minimizes losses (a touchy issue in itself - how many Krogan lives is the last Rachni Queen worth before the cost is too high to save her, if you are so inclined?).

Ah, wait, you're talking about the one beore that.

Yes, they've done horrible things.  There's really no doubt about that.

But, functionally, that puts them in the same boat as everbody else.  There aren't any races in ME with a clear conscience.

Modifié par Phatose, 08 juin 2013 - 07:04 .

[Dextro Milk]

Ravensword wrote...

Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds an spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

I would help her. Your Shepard would die a slow death... 

[Ravensword]

Dextro Milk wrote...

Ravensword wrote...

Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds an spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

I would help her. Your Shepard would die a slow death... 

[Dextro Milk]

Ravensword wrote...

Dextro Milk wrote...

Ravensword wrote...

Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds an spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

I would help her. Your Shepard would die a slow death... 

<3 Dat sexy revenge...

[Phatose]

Dextro Milk wrote...

Ravensword wrote...

Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds an spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

I would help her. Your Shepard would die a slow death... 

Well, based on history here, I'll suggest you might want to rethink that plan.  People who make themselves Shepard's enemies have a way of dying.  And people who are Tali's allies when Shepard's not around....also have a way of dying.

[Dunabar]

Phatose wrote...

Dextro Milk wrote...

Ravensword wrote...

Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds an spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

I would help her. Your Shepard would die a slow death... 

Well, based on history here, I'll suggest you might want to rethink that plan.  People who make themselves Shepard's enemies have a way of dying.  And people who are Tali's allies when Shepard's not around....also have a way of dying.

Soo a double K.O? Well, better to die taking your enemy with you than not killing them at all lol.

[Dextro Milk]

Phatose wrote...

And people who are Tali's allies when Shepard's not around....also have a way of dying.

Well see, this would be when she meets mah OC, then we plot our revenge. Shepard would be killed in his cabin. Traynor would give up the codes to the SR2, then we kill her just in case... 

/very evil mode off

Modifié par Dextro Milk, 08 juin 2013 - 07:12 .

[DeinonSlayer]

Phatose wrote...

Dextro Milk wrote...

Ravensword wrote...

Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds an spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

I would help her. Your Shepard would die a slow death... 

Well, based on history here, I'll suggest you might want to rethink that plan.  People who make themselves Shepard's enemies have a way of dying.  And people who are Tali's allies when Shepard's not around....also have a way of dying.

Same can be said of Garrus (Omega)... and Ashley (Eden Prime)... and Wrex (Jarod)... and Zaeed (everything, ever)... and Shepard, even, considering the incidents in the three service histories there are to choose from (even War Hero).

It's practically a meme.

[S.A.K]

Phatose wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...

@Phatose

Lots of people see them as life. Even me. I've only ever had a problem with them on account of the things they've done. If I didn't already view these particular synthetics as criminals, I'd have a harder time answering this. It comes down to what minimizes losses (a touchy issue in itself - how many Krogan lives is the last Rachni Queen worth before the cost is too high to save her, if you are so inclined?).

Ah, wait, you're talking about the one beore that.

Yes, they've done horrible things.  There's really no doubt about that.

But, functionally, that puts them in the same boat as everbody else.  There aren't any races in ME with a clear conscience.

I too consider the Geth as living being. It comes down to whether you are willing to over look what the Geth have done and consider them worthy of saving. Personally, I see Geth have done more damaged and commited more atrocities than any other race in the galaxy apart from the Reapers. So I will never let the Geth live.

[Slayer299]

No. Why not have the Normandy, entire Human, Asari, Hanar, Volus and every other species except the Yahg and the Raloi? What kind of a ridiculous choice is that you gave us???

[MassivelyEffective0730]

Slayer299 wrote...

No. Why not have the Normandy, entire Human, Asari, Hanar, Volus and every other species except the Yahg and the Raloi? What kind of a ridiculous choice is that you gave us???

It's jtav. It's something you learn to deal with.

[Ravensword]

Slayer299 wrote...

No. Why not have the Normandy, entire Human, Asari, Hanar, Volus and every other species except the Yahg and the Raloi? What kind of a ridiculous choice is that you gave us???

It's only Shepard.

[IntelligentME3Fanboy]

lol geth living beings?unbelievamble

[Ryzaki]

Ravensword wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

I guess I'm the only person here who's a destroyer and actually likes the Geth more than the Quarians.

You are not alone. I pick the Geth over the Quarians every time. Much much prefer the Geth (even ME3 Geth) over the Quarians.

Now if the question was sacrifice the Quarians for the Geth...I'd do that every time.

Alas I have to make due with destroyed Rannoch slide because go go contrived all synthetics must die garbage.

I like the pre-ME3 Geth before the writers ruined the Geth in ME3. So in my headcanon, the Reapers haven't showed up at Rannoch yet and Shepard just gets there as the Quarians are fighting a losing war against the Geth and Shepard has an opportunity to make peace, but chooses the Geth instead.

Tali attempts suicide on Rannoch; she does a sweet backwards swan dive off that cliff. Shepard thinks she's dead and departs. Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds a spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

I liked them in both games though the whole "let's be more like everyone the hell else!" hit all my zzzzz buttons.

Heh. I don't see that going well for her with my Shep. Hard to get revenge on dead men.

[Phatose]

S.A.K wrote...

Phatose wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...

@Phatose

Lots of people see them as life. Even me. I've only ever had a problem with them on account of the things they've done. If I didn't already view these particular synthetics as criminals, I'd have a harder time answering this. It comes down to what minimizes losses (a touchy issue in itself - how many Krogan lives is the last Rachni Queen worth before the cost is too high to save her, if you are so inclined?).

Ah, wait, you're talking about the one beore that.

Yes, they've done horrible things.  There's really no doubt about that.

But, functionally, that puts them in the same boat as everbody else.  There aren't any races in ME with a clear conscience.

I too consider the Geth as living being. It comes down to whether you are willing to over look what the Geth have done and consider them worthy of saving. Personally, I see Geth have done more damaged and commited more atrocities than any other race in the galaxy apart from the Reapers. So I will never let the Geth live.

Really?

More then the Asari?  Who hid important valuable prothean data, gave the Salarians the AOK to raise up the Krogans for genoicide on Rachni.  Gave the Salarians AOK to neuter the entire Krogan race?  Gave Saren Atrius his spectre status which damn near caused the extinction of all races?  Who, after being shown that Saren was a traitor, proceeded to tell Shepard it was his problem and stick their thumbs up their bum?

Or the Salarians, who all of the above save the first are true?  Or the Krogans, who actually commited that first genocide and actually joined the Reapers through Saren (remember why Wrex pulled a gun on you on Virmire?)  Or the Turians, who dispersed that neutering bomb and produced Saren Atrius who nearly got us all killed?  Or the Batarians, who spent the entire series raiding and taking slaves?

I mean, you're absolutely entitled to decide that if you choose, but I have to say that does not seem to be the case to me, or even close to the case.

[Ravensword]

Ryzaki wrote...

Ravensword wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

I guess I'm the only person here who's a destroyer and actually likes the Geth more than the Quarians.

You are not alone. I pick the Geth over the Quarians every time. Much much prefer the Geth (even ME3 Geth) over the Quarians.

Now if the question was sacrifice the Quarians for the Geth...I'd do that every time.

Alas I have to make due with destroyed Rannoch slide because go go contrived all synthetics must die garbage.

I like the pre-ME3 Geth before the writers ruined the Geth in ME3. So in my headcanon, the Reapers haven't showed up at Rannoch yet and Shepard just gets there as the Quarians are fighting a losing war against the Geth and Shepard has an opportunity to make peace, but chooses the Geth instead.

Tali attempts suicide on Rannoch; she does a sweet backwards swan dive off that cliff. Shepard thinks she's dead and departs. Tali is washed ashore several hours later, finds a spaceworthy aircraft, then leaves on a quest for vengeance against Shepard.

I liked them in both games though the whole "let's be more like everyone the hell else!" hit all my zzzzz buttons.

Heh. I don't see that going well for her with my Shep. Hard to get revenge on dead men.

I agree.

Well, that's not gonna stop her from not kicking his corpse or remains. I'd like to think that this is more of a parallel story during the events of ME3.

[S.A.K]

Phatose wrote...

S.A.K wrote...

Phatose wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...

@Phatose

Lots of people see them as life. Even me. I've only ever had a problem with them on account of the things they've done. If I didn't already view these particular synthetics as criminals, I'd have a harder time answering this. It comes down to what minimizes losses (a touchy issue in itself - how many Krogan lives is the last Rachni Queen worth before the cost is too high to save her, if you are so inclined?).

Ah, wait, you're talking about the one beore that.

Yes, they've done horrible things.  There's really no doubt about that.

But, functionally, that puts them in the same boat as everbody else.  There aren't any races in ME with a clear conscience.

I too consider the Geth as living being. It comes down to whether you are willing to over look what the Geth have done and consider them worthy of saving. Personally, I see Geth have done more damaged and commited more atrocities than any other race in the galaxy apart from the Reapers. So I will never let the Geth live.

Really?

More then the Asari?  Who hid important valuable prothean data, gave the Salarians the AOK to raise up the Krogans for genoicide on Rachni.  Gave the Salarians AOK to neuter the entire Krogan race?  Gave Saren Atrius his spectre status which damn near caused the extinction of all races?  Who, after being shown that Saren was a traitor, proceeded to tell Shepard it was his problem and stick their thumbs up their bum?

Or the Salarians, who all of the above save the first are true?  Or the Krogans, who actually commited that first genocide and actually joined the Reapers through Saren (remember why Wrex pulled a gun on you on Virmire?)  Or the Turians, who dispersed that neutering bomb and produced Saren Atrius who nearly got us all killed?  Or the Batarians, who spent the entire series raiding and taking slaves?

I mean, you're absolutely entitled to decide that if you choose, but I have to say that does not seem to be the case to me, or even close to the case.

None of them actually joined the Reapers. Geth did that twice and damn near killed everyone. Not to mention the billions Geth have killed before. Plus the whole Geth race is responsible for what they've done. Only a few individuals are to blame in the matters you mentioned.

[Silcron]

Destroy me and my crew or the toeasters? Is this really a question? If people feel so sad about the geth I bet Admiral Xen just from the Normandy display has data on the reaper upgrades, and she has plenty of data on the Me3 geth. If the quarians and others want the geth back after destroy they will get them. I bet they'll be even something they weren't before, friendly to organics.

[MassivelyEffective0730]

S.A.K wrote...

Phatose wrote...

DeinonSlayer wrote...

@Phatose

Lots of people see them as life. Even me. I've only ever had a problem with them on account of the things they've done. If I didn't already view these particular synthetics as criminals, I'd have a harder time answering this. It comes down to what minimizes losses (a touchy issue in itself - how many Krogan lives is the last Rachni Queen worth before the cost is too high to save her, if you are so inclined?).

Ah, wait, you're talking about the one beore that.

Yes, they've done horrible things.  There's really no doubt about that.

But, functionally, that puts them in the same boat as everbody else.  There aren't any races in ME with a clear conscience.

I too consider the Geth as living being. It comes down to whether you are willing to over look what the Geth have done and consider them worthy of saving. Personally, I see Geth have done more damaged and commited more atrocities than any other race in the galaxy apart from the Reapers. So I will never let the Geth live.

I consider other races, like the Asari, the Salarians, the Krogan, the Turians, Humans, and Rachni, and certainly the Protheans of having caused more damage.

I believe the Quarians are progenitors of the entire problem with the Geth, and are unwilling to really alter their view (and repear history). If Shepard didn't need the Quarian fleet, he'd have left them to their demise at the whim of the Geth. 

[Ravensword]

Silcron wrote...

Destroy me and my crew or the toeasters? Is this really a question? If people feel so sad about the geth I bet Admiral Xen just from the Normandy display has data on the reaper upgrades, and she has plenty of data on the Me3 geth. If the quarians and others want the geth back after destroy they will get them. I bet they'll be even something they weren't before, friendly to organics.

Thanks for sharing your headcanon w/ us. 

Modifié par Ravensword, 08 juin 2013 - 08:39 .