Do you think DAII Anders is the same Anders from Awakening? (read for elaboration)

Now before people start saying "No s**t Sherlock", let me elaborate:
I've always thought of DAII Anders as the same Anders from Awakening, albeit more of a downer. However, I've heard some people say that they don't think this is the same Anders at all. 
We know DAII Anders has "a combination of their personalities, plus a general darkening of both of them because the merger went so poorly" and all that jazz, but if that's the case - is this actually a different character altogether? Is it Anders when we're in the regular world and Justice when we're in the Fade (like in Night Terrors) or is it a whole new entity altogether (sort of like if you help Dog and God learn to accept each other in Fallout: New Vegas - Dead Money)? I know of one person who thought this was the case, claiming that DAII Anders is in fact "Janders". 
I am now confused and don't know who's Janders and who's Anders and who's Justice and who's Vengeance.  ...More importantly, who the hell am I?
This rant has been brought to you by me watching too many episodes of The Twilight Zone.
The end.

Modifié par DeadlyHaven, 06 juillet 2013 - 08:22 .