I spent more medi-gel on her than anyone else. Never used her.KaiserShep wrote...
Liara is trained in using a firearm and has powerful biotics. There's no point in arguing whether or not she had training. Her abilities speak for themselves.
David7204 wrote...
It doesn't have to be shown. It's a perfectly plausible explanation that makes the most sense. Liara is not a warrior. She becomes one. The sensible explanation is that she received training. That's called 'deductive reasoning.' Maybe you should try it some time.Darth Brotarian wrote...
David7204 wrote...
Liara was doubtless trained in combat by Shepard during the events of the first game.
Never shown. Never mentioned in codex. Never brought up in any conversation. Never writien in any part of the game.
Try harder.
Try harder.
David7204 wrote...
Slight gameplay and story segregation. Besides, the game doesn't show how much time actually passes between missions. Given that the events of the game probably take months, likely considerable time.
It doesn't need to have basis in the game or codex. It just needs to have basis in logic. And it does.
David7204 wrote...
It doesn't have to be shown. It's a perfectly plausible explanation that makes the most sense. Liara is not a warrior. She becomes one. The sensible explanation is that she received training. That's called 'deductive reasoning.' Maybe you should try it some time.
Modifié par CronoDragoon, 20 août 2013 - 12:05 .
Right. I'm sure the Normandy actually has a shooting range on level 7, above the bowling alley, but below the theatre.David7204 wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
Is there a shooting range on the Normandy? Or sufficient room to practise biotics?David7204 wrote...
Slight gameplay and story segregation. Besides, the game doesn't show how much time actually passes between missions. Given that the events of the game probably take months, likely considerable time.
It doesn't need to have basis in the game or codex. It just needs to have basis in logic. And it does.
First of all, considering the Normandy doesn't have a bathroom, we should consider the size of the Normandy we see in the game as only semi-canonical.
Secondly, I'm sure they could rig something up. And besides, the Normandy spends time docked at the Citadel, Feros, Noveria.
Steelcan wrote...
Again, not impossible, but she makes no mention of any training.Lizardviking wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
That is true, but Liara makes no mention of any sort of martial trainingKaiserShep wrote...
A school teacher can learn martial arts despite it having nothing to do with their profession.
She is the daughter of a high ranking asari matriach, maybe she learned as a means of self-defence.
Soldiers in Would War II were often trained from scratch in as little as three weeks in large groups.Darth Brotarian wrote...
Deductive reasoning requires evidence to allow a point A to point B logical path. For example, you can deduce that because liara was the daughter of a important political figure, she'd recieve training to protect herself. You can deduce that because she was an asari of important lineage, and daughter of a powerful biotic, she'd recieve training in honing her biotic skills.
But assuming that she got her training because shepard was her squad leader? In the short span of less than a year between mass effect 1 and the begining of mass effect 2? That's a damn pretty big strech. That doesn't even explain her level of skill in combat being beyond that of a basic solider when using a gun, which seems odd for a archeologist who didn't work in the terminus system.
I wasn't aware Thessia was a war torn apocalyptic wasteland where survival is paramount to any sort of familial bond or sense of loyalty.Lizardviking wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
Again, not impossible, but she makes no mention of any training.Lizardviking wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
That is true, but Liara makes no mention of any sort of martial trainingKaiserShep wrote...
A school teacher can learn martial arts despite it having nothing to do with their profession.
She is the daughter of a high ranking asari matriach, maybe she learned as a means of self-defence.
I find it to be a minor point, I don't need to know where Wrex trained either, especially when there is a reasonable answer right in front of the player.
huh.. thats probably because you suck. I used her and wrex on insanity, without much difficulty (ME1). They just ripped things apart.Steelcan wrote...
I spent more medi-gel on her than anyone else. Never used her.
Worst squadmate ever
David7204 wrote...
Soldiers in Would War II were often trained from scratch in as little as three weeks in large groups.Darth Brotarian wrote...
Deductive reasoning requires evidence to allow a point A to point B logical path. For example, you can deduce that because liara was the daughter of a important political figure, she'd recieve training to protect herself. You can deduce that because she was an asari of important lineage, and daughter of a powerful biotic, she'd recieve training in honing her biotic skills.
But assuming that she got her training because shepard was her squad leader? In the short span of less than a year between mass effect 1 and the begining of mass effect 2? That's a damn pretty big strech. That doesn't even explain her level of skill in combat being beyond that of a basic solider when using a gun, which seems odd for a archeologist who didn't work in the terminus system.
Shepard and Liara could easily have had six months, training one on one.
It's not a stretch at all.
Agreed.Steelcan wrote...
I spent more medi-gel on her than anyone else. Never used her.KaiserShep wrote...
Liara is trained in using a firearm and has powerful biotics. There's no point in arguing whether or not she had training. Her abilities speak for themselves.
Worst squadmate ever
Steelcan wrote...
I wasn't aware Thessia was a war torn apocalyptic wasteland where survival is paramount to any sort of familial bond or sense of loyalty.Lizardviking wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
Again, not impossible, but she makes no mention of any training.Lizardviking wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
That is true, but Liara makes no mention of any sort of martial trainingKaiserShep wrote...
A school teacher can learn martial arts despite it having nothing to do with their profession.
She is the daughter of a high ranking asari matriach, maybe she learned as a means of self-defence.
I find it to be a minor point, I don't need to know where Wrex trained either, especially when there is a reasonable answer right in front of the player.
David7204 wrote...
Deductive reasoning does not require a logically 'certain' answer. And I'm not suggestion this as a certainty. But it is the most sensible explanation. Liara was not a warrior, and she received training.
Steelcan wrote...
I wasn't aware Thessia was a war torn apocalyptic wasteland where survival is paramount to any sort of familial bond or sense of loyalty.Lizardviking wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
Again, not impossible, but she makes no mention of any training.Lizardviking wrote...
Steelcan wrote...
That is true, but Liara makes no mention of any sort of martial trainingKaiserShep wrote...
A school teacher can learn martial arts despite it having nothing to do with their profession.
She is the daughter of a high ranking asari matriach, maybe she learned as a means of self-defence.
I find it to be a minor point, I don't need to know where Wrex trained either, especially when there is a reasonable answer right in front of the player.
Training doesn't make someone a warrior, if you took a scientist, or someone with a job that requires little or no physcial training, like Liara's, and trained that person to fight, it would take a fair bit of time, including her biotics, you have quite the job to do.David7204 wrote...
Deductive reasoning does not require a logically 'certain' answer. And I'm not suggestion this as a certainty. But it is the most sensible explanation. Liara was not a warrior, and she received training.
Is there any evidence of that outside of gameplay, which shouldn't count due to gameplay and story segregation?AresKeith wrote...
Liara was trained to shoot a gun long before she met Shepard
She mostly uses her biotics anyway so why start a random argument
David7204 wrote...
Deductive reasoning does not require a logically 'certain' answer. And I'm not suggestion this as a certainty. But it is the most sensible explanation. Liara was not a warrior, and she received training.
Modifié par CronoDragoon, 20 août 2013 - 12:12 .
The kind of biotic ability she displays is on par with asari commandos whon spend centuries honing their skills (and still suck)Lizardviking wrote...
No, Thessia was not a war torn apocalyptic wasteland where survival is paramount to any sort of familial bond or sense of loyalty, but she was the daughter of a high ranking matriach and therefor it is not unreasonable to assume she learned self defence in the form of her biotics.
doozer12 wrote...
huh.. thats probably because you suck. I used her and wrex on insanity, without much difficulty (ME1). They just ripped things apart.Steelcan wrote...
I spent more medi-gel on her than anyone else. Never used her.
Worst squadmate ever
Retour en haut