156 réponses à ce sujet

[shirespartan]

Liara

[SiniisteR]

Sparse wrote...

SiniisteR wrote...

ThisOnesUsername wrote...

Sparse wrote...

The best in each game I would say:

Liara in ME1
Tali in ME2
Traynor in ME3

Although a romanced Tali's visit to the apartment in the Citadel DLC for ME3 is the most laugh out loud weird moment in the entire trilogy.

To be honest I thought the continured romances with characters in your party for ME3 didn't really work, as the it made very little sense that they blew so hot and cold and had so little to say.

My ears. They bled.

Seems to be a very love/hate moment, I actually liked that scene.

I'm not sure that I liked it, but it was very weird. I prefer weirdness to pathos in games any day.

I found it cute, which is probably the same reason as to why those who prefer her romance anyway.

[felipejiraya]

Last year a thread like this would already have more than 400 pages and be a pitched battle between fandoms.

ME1: Liara
ME2: Liara
ME3: Liara

[Sir DeLoria]

Br3ad wrote...

SiniisteR wrote...

Han Shot First wrote...

SiniisteR wrote...
Already posted my choice of Tali before, but also wanted to add that she seems to show more concern for Shepard at certain moments, including the first meet up in Citadel as well as after completing Leviathan, than the other LIs do which I like.

Those scenes are identical for other squadmate LIs, and not Tali-specific.

I mean right after the LI kills the two soldiers in the car dealer. Tali asks if Shepards alright, while every other LI just says "Having a bad day, Shepard?"

As for Leviathan, if you speak to the LIs after the last mission for the DLC, they'll mention different thngs about Leviathan, while Tali just seems concerned that she almost lost Shepard.

At this point, what else does she really have to live for?

As cynical as that comment was, it does hold a little bit of truth, Tali doesn't really have anyone but Shep(maybe buddy Garrus). Especially evident when she tragically beggs Shep to come back to her in the extraction scene.

[MstrJedi Kyle]

ME1 - No one
ME2 - Tali
ME3 - Tali

[CDR David Shepard]

pablodomi wrote...

You can do Ashley-Miranda-Ashley (importing savegames) and not have Miranda die in ME3. It has been explained numerous times, so I'll be brief. If Shepard isn't a jerk to her and says "I want you in my life" the first time you meet in the Citadel, if Shepard gives her the heads-up on Kai Leng with the info sent by Anderson and finally grant her access to Alliance 'resources' (while not locking her as a paramour when she talks to you about the control chip) she will survive and become a war asset.

I know all about that.

However, I never metagame. I don't pick options that I wouldn't pick simply because I know I can get a different outcome.

Shepard is truthful to Miranda in ME3...even though I know she will die because I said it.

[CDR David Shepard]

Necanor wrote...

I'll never ever understand how people can say "Ash's romance is the most realistic" or "it only makes sense if Shep goes with Miranda". No romance is "the most realistic", every Shep has a different personality. My Shep always romances Tali, because the two match perfectly. Still I don't go around proclaiming that Tali is the only realistic romance option and all others are badly done or don't make sense.

Everyone has a different taste, I find both Miranda and Ash to be ugly and I don't like their personalities. Some people hate Tali because she's too emotional and has "dog legs". 

To each their own:?

Calm down.

I apologize for not clearly stating that it was only my opinion.

My opinion is based off if I was watching this as a movie or tv series. Ashley and Miranda are the two that I could see Shepard becoming romantically involved with. They both just work perfectly for the storyline...IN MY OPINION.

To each their own.

Modifié par CDR David Shepard, 26 août 2013 - 02:58 .

[Br3admax]

Necanor wrote...

Br3ad wrote...

SiniisteR wrote...

Han Shot First wrote...

SiniisteR wrote...
Already posted my choice of Tali before, but also wanted to add that she seems to show more concern for Shepard at certain moments, including the first meet up in Citadel as well as after completing Leviathan, than the other LIs do which I like.

Those scenes are identical for other squadmate LIs, and not Tali-specific.

I mean right after the LI kills the two soldiers in the car dealer. Tali asks if Shepards alright, while every other LI just says "Having a bad day, Shepard?"

As for Leviathan, if you speak to the LIs after the last mission for the DLC, they'll mention different thngs about Leviathan, while Tali just seems concerned that she almost lost Shepard.

At this point, what else does she really have to live for?

As cynical as that comment was, it does hold a little bit of truth, Tali doesn't really have anyone but Shep(maybe buddy Garrus). Especially evident when she tragically beggs Shep to come back to her in the extraction scene.

I'm not saying it to be "cynical", it's just being real. She's often trusted, for some reason, with positions that everyone knows she can't handle, due mostly to a lack of experience with leadership, and it always goes awry. If Tali is in a relationship with Shepard, she makes it really clear that she really doesn't care about anything else at all. My point.

[thehomeworld]

Garrus x fshep

Tali x mshep

team dextro wins in battle and love!

[Lawrence0294]

o Ventus wrote...

I romanced: Miranda
Favorite: Miranda

My canon goes Ashley --> Miranda --> staying loyal to Miranda.

Honestly, I think that Miranda's romance is certainly the most real of the main cast, and has the most organic flow. She starts out skeptical of Shepard (even outright hostile), but she eventually opens up to him as they work together. Later on, she finds herself in need and asks Shepard to help rescue her sister. Seeing Shepard go out of his way to help her save Oriana (without asking for anything in return), Miranda learns that she can trust Shepard on a personal level. Eventually, Shepard cracks open her icy facade and figures out that Moranda is actually quite warm and loving to those to earn her friendship and respect.

Acknowledging that Shepard is one of the very few people who is on her level, Shepard intrigues Miranda. Despite being "normal", Shepard is still capable of doing things that even Miranda herself is incapable of doing. She is both envious of this and admires it in Shepard. Through Shepard, Miranda finds that her accomplishments ARE her own, in spite of her gifts. Shepard himself is a testament to this. Truly, Shepard (mine, at least, the way I RP him) considers his death to be the best thing that's happened to him, because it led to him meeting Miranda.

Miranda eventually finds herself falling for Shepard, and at first dismisses it as "blowing off steam" before a big suicide mission, but comes to realize that her feelings are genuine, and that Shepard is the first person she's felt this way for.

Of all the romances, I would say that Miranda's is the most rewarding. I love the development of her character along the romance path in 2 (it was kind of dumbed down and retread in 3 though), and her romance content in the Citadel DLC is fantastic.:

Exactly this.

[ViciousChaos516]

I romanced everyone with different playthroughs. But I have 2 cannons.

ME1: Ashley
ME2: Miranda
ME3: Ashley

and

ME1: Liara
ME2: Liara (Shadow Broker)
ME3: Liara

[Elite Midget]

ME1/2/3 - Ashley

Stay loyal, cheaters are scum.

[Ryuji2]

ME1: No one.
ME2: Tali.
ME3: Tali.

[DarkDoz]

ME1: Ashley
ME2: Liara
ME3: Liara

[o Ventus]

Elite Midget wrote...

ME1/2/3 - Ashley

Stay loyal, cheaters are scum.

Except it's not really cheating.

[MassivelyEffective0730]

ME1: Ashley (my Shepard later regrets it)
ME2: Miranda
ME3: Miranda

[Sir DeLoria]

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

ME1: Ashley (my Shepard later regrets it)
ME2: Miranda
ME3: Miranda

But I hope you nuke Ash, right?

[Sir DeLoria]

Elite Midget wrote...

ME1/2/3 - Ashley

Stay loyal, cheaters are scum.

It's not cheating, it's breaking up after she turns out to be such a ***** on Horizon.

[Steelcan]

Necanor wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

ME1: Ashley (my Shepard later regrets it)
ME2: Miranda
ME3: Miranda

But I hope you nuke Ash, right?

He keeps her alive for teh dramaz

[MassivelyEffective0730]

Necanor wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

ME1: Ashley (my Shepard later regrets it)
ME2: Miranda
ME3: Miranda

But I hope you nuke Ash, right?

Better. I'd blow her away on the coup (it would eliminate a lot of problems), but she decides not to be stupid at the last second. 

That said, I have her bring up problems later on. And this time, she is blown away.

[Sir DeLoria]

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

Necanor wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...
ME1: Ashley (my Shepard later regrets it)
ME2: Miranda
ME3: Miranda

But I hope you nuke Ash, right?

Better. I'd blow her away on the coup (it would eliminate a lot of problems), but she decides not to be stupid at the last second. 

That said, I have her bring up problems later on. And this time, she is blown away.

I see. 

I kinda like Kaidan, so I always nuke her on Virmire. Kept her alive the first time and regreted it later.

[General TSAR]

Whoever annoys you the least.

[CannotCompute]

Definitely Garrus for FemSheps

[RZIBARA]

Necanor wrote...

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

ME1: Ashley (my Shepard later regrets it)
ME2: Miranda
ME3: Miranda

But I hope you nuke Ash, right?

i like having tali throw herself off a cliff, sooo satisfying

Modifié par RZIBARA, 02 septembre 2013 - 09:29 .