ComradeShepard7 wrote...
If you actually witness someo killing someone else or any other illegal activity you damn well better report it but standing around gawking while you call the cops is a really stupid thing to do as far as your personal safety is concerned.
As far as the context, it doesn't matter what so ever. The legal system is set up to be able to deal with cases of self defense and clear someone of wrong doing if it was justified. If you are actually involved in a case of self defense it is in your best legal interests to report the incident to authorities so that you can be cleared of any wrong doing. Failing to report it just makes it look like a case of murder / attempted murder.
And if it is a case of "retaliation for a past transgression" guess what, "an eye for an eye" has no place in modern society. If yo are a vicim of some transgression, you report the event to the authorities and the legal system sorts it out. Taking the matter into your own hands puts you on the wrong side of the law. The only reasons I see for people doing that are that they are either ignorant of the legal system or they would get busted for illegal activity themselves if they went to the authorities.
Your faith in the legal system leads me to believe you've never been tangled up in it. It's a nice thought, but to think the authorities handle every situation accurately, succinctly, and fairly is simply naive. The legal system hurts much more than it helps, at least in most of the united states that is (I can't speak for countries I don't have any experience in).
Not only does it aggresively prosecute small time offenders, but it can be extremely lax in situtations where it shouldn't. Compounded with the poor way that actual sentencing/follow through is handled and the subpar standards to which its employees are held it really just makes a giant mess.
The real issue is the human factor. Most of the people involved in legal processes are after power, money, or both, which is, frankly, understandable; They're only human, but they'll trample anyone and everyone they can for a boost up their ladder. Yes, there are a few good seeds in the system, but not enough to keep the harvest from being rotten.
On a side note:
@max crushmore - Just because I have nice things now doesn't mean I always did. And the "they" in that poem would be the "authority" figures, which he is defenseless against because he would not stand against them with others they prosecuted. It doesn't really correlate well with this debate (in my opinion) and if it did it would stand better on my side, against the "authorities," though im not so much saying "fight the authority" as I am saying "deal with your own problems and let others deal with theirs."