Aller au contenu

Photo

Reporting cheaters - is it worth the effort?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
79 réponses à ce sujet

#51
Samerandomscreennameidontcareabout

Samerandomscreennameidontcareabout
  • Members
  • 1 169 messages

LiL Reapur wrote...

Triple Nope. Why would you even care if anyone cheats, the game is done with DLC. No new content. It makes no sense.....


We don´t care if ANYONE cheats in a PRIVATE lobby. Go ahead, have your black widow XXXX. Seen plenty of people with ludicrously well staffed manifests just plain suck and I can guess where that comes from...

But if you come to a public game anyone should behave like he is supposed to and play the effing game instead of ruining it for everyone. Thank you.

#52
Chrome tater tot

Chrome tater tot
  • Members
  • 253 messages

cato_84 wrote...

Akire wrote...

I agree with the point you are trying to make, but I don't think people ignoring cheaters in an online game means those same people would ignore rape or attempted murder. I sure hope they wouldn't anyway.

"I would prefer even to fail with honor than win by cheating." -Sophocles


I agree with you about cheating in a video game being essentially unimportant. However, if you read Chrome Tater Tot's last post he actually does write that he would ignore a murder, that's the only reason I made the comparison to rape or attempted murder -

Chrome tater tot wrote...

A more extreme sense would be "Holy **** those guys just shot that dude!
I better tell the cops ASAP!" You have no idea what the context is for
their actions. Next thing you know the purple monkey gang (or whoever
the hell) finds out you ratted them out to the cops and they decide you
don't need your legs anymore. Worse they decide your mother's schedule
is too open and she needs something like her kids funeral preparations
to fill it up. Worse still they decide you spent too much time with your
mother as it is and you need to be planning her funeral.

You just don't know; It isn't your business; It's not worth it; Walk away.


That's why I said it was an extreme example. But are you going to tell me, in all honesty, that if you saw someone kill someone else (cold blood/broad daylight) you would really want to report that? Whoever they are obviously didn't care about that persons life and they sure as sh*t won't care about yours. I would also stand by what I said before about context. You don't know what's happening there. That could be a justified retaliatory response for a past transgression. Ultimately, in any case, I would soundly classify that as a "not worth it;walk away" situation. 

Back on topic, however, reporting someone for "cheating" in a strictly co-op game is so trivial I wouldn't even think it would be worth the effort. The only reason you would even want to in the first place is to toot your own halo in proudful self-satisfaction. What goes around comes around 99% of the time anyway and odds are they'll get themselves into trouble (ban, xp reset, etc.) without you snitching.

#53
joker_jack

joker_jack
  • Members
  • 3 801 messages
There's no point to reporting cheating anymore. No support and it's gone the plaid.
Image IPB

#54
Chrome tater tot

Chrome tater tot
  • Members
  • 253 messages

Samerandomscreennameidontcareabout wrote...

Chrome tater tot wrote...

I'm flabbergasted by all the indignation that gets posted on BSN regarding cheating. Where I'm from snitches are lucky if they end up with stitches; We were always taught to walk away when it wasn't our business.

And before someone throws their sanctimony at me with something like "obvious cheater is obvious" or some other asinine accusations I would advise they look at my N7rating:Ultra Rare weapon ratio; It's ****.


Nobody cares about your manifesto. But I commend you from refraining to ruin the game by cheating/glitching.

But your stance on "snitches" is just ludicrous. Glitchers in private lobbies? Fine by me. Do what you want.

But how can you say that it isn´t our business when we enter a public lobby and get hosed by someone cheating/glitching? Do you beat random people up on the streets and tell them they should´ve just backed up/stood at home, becuase they have no business on your street? <_<



I wasn't trying to flash my manifest at people, but I assumed people would accuse me of being a cheater if I defended not reporting them and that was the best evidence that I'm not. 

I can see what you're saying about public versus private though. It's a good point, and they should be doing it in private. Chances are, though, if they are cheating in the first place then they don't care enough to be private or public about it. Also, while I don't assault people just for being on my street, there are people who do, with reasoning similar to what you proposed. So really, it's not as farfetched as you might think.  

#55
Harbingerpromo

Harbingerpromo
  • Members
  • 400 messages
Deliver street justice.

If you have an objective that's running with the pizza, grab it and don't let it go until the time runs out.

Send the guy/gal to hell right when the times goes to 0.

#56
ComradeShepard7

ComradeShepard7
  • Members
  • 1 261 messages

Chrome tater tot wrote...

That's why I said it was an extreme example. But are you going to tell me, in all honesty, that if you saw someone kill someone else (cold blood/broad daylight) you would really want to report that? Whoever they are obviously didn't care about that persons life and they sure as sh*t won't care about yours. I would also stand by what I said before about context. You don't know what's happening there. That could be a justified retaliatory response for a past transgression. Ultimately, in any case, I would soundly classify that as a "not worth it;walk away" situation. 

Back on topic, however, reporting someone for "cheating" in a strictly co-op game is so trivial I wouldn't even think it would be worth the effort. The only reason you would even want to in the first place is to toot your own halo in proudful self-satisfaction. What goes around comes around 99% of the time anyway and odds are they'll get themselves into trouble (ban, xp reset, etc.) without you snitching.


If you actually witness someo killing someone else or any other illegal activity you damn well better report it but standing around gawking while you call the cops is a really stupid thing to do as far as your personal safety is concerned.

As far as the context, it doesn't matter what so ever. The legal system is set up to be able to deal with cases of self defense and clear someone of wrong doing if it was justified. If you are actually involved in a case of self defense it is in your best legal interests to report the incident to authorities so that you can be cleared of any wrong doing. Failing to report it just makes it look like a case of murder / attempted murder.

And if it is a case of "retaliation for a past transgression" guess what, "an eye for an eye" has no place in modern society. If yo are a vicim of some transgression, you report the event to the authorities and the legal system sorts it out. Taking the matter into your own hands puts you on the wrong side of the law. The only reasons I see for people doing that are that they are either ignorant of the legal system or they would get busted for illegal activity themselves if they went to the authorities.

#57
Kalas Magnus

Kalas Magnus
  • Members
  • 10 326 messages
lolno

just let it go. and find a new game

#58
NuclearTech76

NuclearTech76
  • Members
  • 16 229 messages

Chrome tater tot wrote...

That's why I said it was an extreme example. But are you going to tell me, in all honesty, that if you saw someone kill someone else (cold blood/broad daylight) you would really want to report that? Whoever they are obviously didn't care about that persons life and they sure as sh*t won't care about yours. I would also stand by what I said before about context. You don't know what's happening there. That could be a justified retaliatory response for a past transgression. Ultimately, in any case, I would soundly classify that as a "not worth it;walk away" situation. 

Back on topic, however, reporting someone for "cheating" in a strictly co-op game is so trivial I wouldn't even think it would be worth the effort. The only reason you would even want to in the first place is to toot your own halo in proudful self-satisfaction. What goes around comes around 99% of the time anyway and odds are they'll get themselves into trouble (ban, xp reset, etc.) without you snitching.

That mentality is why the world is **** now. A few bad people do not ruin the world unless all the "good" ones allow it to be done. Some people wrap up their cowardice in a package pretty enough for their ego to accept, I guess.

#59
BridgeBurner

BridgeBurner
  • Members
  • 7 317 messages

k1ngl1ves wrote...

Working as Annomander intended.


Modding is only equal to cheating when micro-transactions are involved.

Most games allow freely modding, for longeivity and fun... Games with micro-transactions don't like you doing that. Modding has caused many popular games to exist... CS started as a mod, KF started as a mod...

Cheating would imply you're making the game trivial. I most certainly did not make the game trivial. I have abominations, seeker swarms and swarmers that OHK players, rapid fire ravagers, geth primes with mini-guns, 250,000 health possessed praetorians, Collector Captain "Bosses" with vastly increased damage, health and movement speed, scions that throw 40 grenade shards at you....

...anyone who's faced 50 banshees on Firebase London will testify to the fact that my game is harder than the joke difficulty that is regular ME3. Yet, you mention my name in a thread regarding cheating.

Modding =/= cheating. In my honest opinion, people who aren't (by this stage) modding the game to actually make it interesting are cheating... cheating themselves out of some good honest fun by continuing to play the dull default difficulty.

:kissing:

#60
MaxCrushmore

MaxCrushmore
  • Members
  • 3 168 messages

Chrome tater tot wrote...

That's why I said it was an extreme example. But are you going to tell me, in all honesty, that if you saw someone kill someone else (cold blood/broad daylight) you would really want to report that? Whoever they are obviously didn't care about that persons life and they sure as sh*t won't care about yours. I would also stand by what I said before about context. You don't know what's happening there. That could be a justified retaliatory response for a past transgression. Ultimately, in any case, I would soundly classify that as a "not worth it;walk away" situation. 



OMG .. as a socially responsible person I cannot read this and not respond. This is not even a troll anymore. You would have to live in an incredibly socially and economically repressed society (which many people do) to really believe this. Since you are on a computer discussing a video game, that rules out that posibility  ...

Poet: Martin Niemoller had the best commentary on this exact situation with his "First they came ..."


"First they came for the communists

and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a communist.


Then they came for the socialists

and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a socialist.


Then they came for the trade unionists

and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a trade unionist.


Then they came for me,

and there was no one left to speak for me."

Modifié par MaxCrushmore, 23 août 2013 - 06:38 .


#61
Guest_Ghostknife72_*

Guest_Ghostknife72_*
  • Guests

NuclearTech76 wrote...

Chrome tater tot wrote...

That's why I said it was an extreme example. But are you going to tell me, in all honesty, that if you saw someone kill someone else (cold blood/broad daylight) you would really want to report that? Whoever they are obviously didn't care about that persons life and they sure as sh*t won't care about yours. I would also stand by what I said before about context. You don't know what's happening there. That could be a justified retaliatory response for a past transgression. Ultimately, in any case, I would soundly classify that as a "not worth it;walk away" situation. 

Back on topic, however, reporting someone for "cheating" in a strictly co-op game is so trivial I wouldn't even think it would be worth the effort. The only reason you would even want to in the first place is to toot your own halo in proudful self-satisfaction. What goes around comes around 99% of the time anyway and odds are they'll get themselves into trouble (ban, xp reset, etc.) without you snitching.

That mentality is why the world is **** now. A few bad people do not ruin the world unless all the "good" ones allow it to be done. Some people wrap up their cowardice in a package pretty enough for their ego to accept, I guess.


Whoa....So-Crates-Tech76.  

Image IPB

Modifié par Ghostknife72, 23 août 2013 - 06:38 .


#62
Guest_Ghostknife72_*

Guest_Ghostknife72_*
  • Guests
My two cents, which is probably worth less than that...

At this stage in the game, I personally do not care if people run modded games, etc. in private matches. Most of the people have done their time already, maxed their manifests legitimately, pay actual money for packs, DLC (SP), etc. Maybe even paid for the game twice or more on different platforms.

So if they are modding games to keep things fun and fresh within their group of friends. Go ahead. I seriously doubt anyone here can question players like Annomander in terms of skills and dues paid in the game already.

Only issue I would have is if newer players become exposed to this when they are unwilling participants. Then that isn't fair to the newer players.

Also, if people think modded games will make or break this game, they are sorely mistaken. This game was broken with glitches and hacks way back when it was released. Remember the Wave 10 credit glitchers? Etc, etc.

#63
ComradeShepard7

ComradeShepard7
  • Members
  • 1 261 messages

Ghostknife72 wrote...

Whoa....So-Crates-Tech76.  

Image IPB


Philosophize with him!

#64
RainbowDazed

RainbowDazed
  • Members
  • 789 messages

Carlina wrote...

Alijah Green wrote...

that would mean reporting the majority of BSN members and all PC players


Not all PC player's, some of us do have the skills and experience and can play without resorting to cheap tactics.


Word. I play mostly on PC and I never cheat. On any game. Cheating is lame-o.

And what the hell is this talk about people needing cheats for Disciple-challenge? Wut? I can understand a cheat for GPSMG - challenge. That **** is soooo boring. But Disciple with it's awesome-mundo sound effect is just too much fun to not play with. ^_^

#65
Alien Number Six

Alien Number Six
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

NuclearTech76 wrote...

Chrome tater tot wrote...

That's why I said it was an extreme example. But are you going to tell me, in all honesty, that if you saw someone kill someone else (cold blood/broad daylight) you would really want to report that? Whoever they are obviously didn't care about that persons life and they sure as sh*t won't care about yours. I would also stand by what I said before about context. You don't know what's happening there. That could be a justified retaliatory response for a past transgression. Ultimately, in any case, I would soundly classify that as a "not worth it;walk away" situation. 

Back on topic, however, reporting someone for "cheating" in a strictly co-op game is so trivial I wouldn't even think it would be worth the effort. The only reason you would even want to in the first place is to toot your own halo in proudful self-satisfaction. What goes around comes around 99% of the time anyway and odds are they'll get themselves into trouble (ban, xp reset, etc.) without you snitching.

That mentality is why the world is **** now. A few bad people do not ruin the world unless all the "good" ones allow it to be done. Some people wrap up their cowardice in a package pretty enough for their ego to accept, I guess.


And that is exactly what it is. That is why neighborhood get like that. No one has the guts to stand up for what is right. Everyone wants to say it's not their problem until it's their mom getting raped and murdered. Then they wish someone would have stopped and tried to help or call the police. I report all the fu+cked up sh+it that happens in my neighborhood. I also spent three years in Iraq own a 45. and know how to make bombs. Go ahead and fu+ck with me. Good luck opening up your mail box, your front door, your back door or starting you car :)

#66
Chrome tater tot

Chrome tater tot
  • Members
  • 253 messages

ComradeShepard7 wrote...
If you actually witness someo killing someone else or any other illegal activity you damn well better report it but standing around gawking while you call the cops is a really stupid thing to do as far as your personal safety is concerned.

As far as the context, it doesn't matter what so ever. The legal system is set up to be able to deal with cases of self defense and clear someone of wrong doing if it was justified. If you are actually involved in a case of self defense it is in your best legal interests to report the incident to authorities so that you can be cleared of any wrong doing. Failing to report it just makes it look like a case of murder / attempted murder.

And if it is a case of "retaliation for a past transgression" guess what, "an eye for an eye" has no place in modern society. If yo are a vicim of some transgression, you report the event to the authorities and the legal system sorts it out. Taking the matter into your own hands puts you on the wrong side of the law. The only reasons I see for people doing that are that they are either ignorant of the legal system or they would get busted for illegal activity themselves if they went to the authorities.

Your faith in the legal system leads me to believe you've never been tangled up in it. It's a nice thought, but to think the authorities handle every situation accurately, succinctly, and fairly is simply naive. The legal system hurts much more than it helps, at least in most of the united states that is (I can't speak for countries I don't have any experience in).

Not only does it aggresively prosecute small time offenders, but it can be extremely lax in situtations where it shouldn't. Compounded with the poor way that actual sentencing/follow through is handled and the subpar standards to which its employees are held it really just makes a giant mess.

The real issue is the human factor. Most of the people involved in legal processes are after power, money, or both, which is, frankly, understandable; They're only human, but they'll trample anyone and everyone they can for a boost up their ladder. Yes, there are a few good seeds in the system, but not enough to keep the harvest from being rotten.


On a side note:
@max crushmore - Just because I have nice things now doesn't mean I always did. And the "they" in that poem would be the "authority" figures, which he is defenseless against because he would not stand against them with others they prosecuted. It doesn't really correlate well with this debate (in my opinion) and if it did it would stand better on my side, against the "authorities," though im not so much saying "fight the authority" as I am saying "deal with your own problems and let others deal with theirs."

#67
Chrome tater tot

Chrome tater tot
  • Members
  • 253 messages

Alien Number Six wrote...
And that is exactly what it is. That is why neighborhood get like that. No one has the guts to stand up for what is right. Everyone wants to say it's not their problem until it's their mom getting raped and murdered. Then they wish someone would have stopped and tried to help or call the police. I report all the fu+cked up sh+it that happens in my neighborhood. I also spent three years in Iraq own a 45. and know how to make bombs. Go ahead and fu+ck with me. Good luck opening up your mail box, your front door, your back door or starting you car :)


See, to me the first half of your post contradicts the second. I would note that I agree with the second half.

#68
Chrome tater tot

Chrome tater tot
  • Members
  • 253 messages

NuclearTech76 wrote...

Chrome tater tot wrote...

That's why I said it was an extreme example. But are you going to tell me, in all honesty, that if you saw someone kill someone else (cold blood/broad daylight) you would really want to report that? Whoever they are obviously didn't care about that persons life and they sure as sh*t won't care about yours. I would also stand by what I said before about context. You don't know what's happening there. That could be a justified retaliatory response for a past transgression. Ultimately, in any case, I would soundly classify that as a "not worth it;walk away" situation. 

Back on topic, however, reporting someone for "cheating" in a strictly co-op game is so trivial I wouldn't even think it would be worth the effort. The only reason you would even want to in the first place is to toot your own halo in proudful self-satisfaction. What goes around comes around 99% of the time anyway and odds are they'll get themselves into trouble (ban, xp reset, etc.) without you snitching.

That mentality is why the world is **** now. A few bad people do not ruin the world unless all the "good" ones allow it to be done. Some people wrap up their cowardice in a package pretty enough for their ego to accept, I guess.

It's the other way around. The few good people cannot save the world unless all the bad ones allow it to be done.

I would also like to point out that almost every american citizen in 1940 held fast to the opinions I'm supporting right now. The holocaust was "not our problem" until some tycoons saw an opportunity to get even richer off war time profiteering and greased the president's pockets. Next thing you know they are playing Pearl Harbor on the people as a national tragedy that noone saw coming (oh please) and NOW it's our problem. Only once the japanese had transgressed against us did we deign to sully our hands with the rest of the world's conflict.

So don't act like I'm some lone ranger with a some crazy, unheard of philosophy, and don't confuse realism with cowardice. Cowards run to find some big brother to deal with the problems for them, the rest of us handle life all on our own.

#69
ComradeShepard7

ComradeShepard7
  • Members
  • 1 261 messages

Chrome tater tot wrote...

Your faith in the legal system leads me to believe you've never been tangled up in it. It's a nice thought, but to think the authorities handle every situation accurately, succinctly, and fairly is simply naive. The legal system hurts much more than it helps, at least in most of the united states that is (I can't speak for countries I don't have any experience in).

Not only does it aggresively prosecute small time offenders, but it can be extremely lax in situtations where it shouldn't. Compounded with the poor way that actual sentencing/follow through is handled and the subpar standards to which its employees are held it really just makes a giant mess.

The real issue is the human factor. Most of the people involved in legal processes are after power, money, or both, which is, frankly, understandable; They're only human, but they'll trample anyone and everyone they can for a boost up their ladder. Yes, there are a few good seeds in the system, but not enough to keep the harvest from being rotten.

On a side note:
@max crushmore - Just because I have nice things now doesn't mean I always did. And the "they" in that poem would be the "authority" figures, which he is defenseless against because he would not stand against them with others they prosecuted. It doesn't really correlate well with this debate (in my opinion) and if it did it would stand better on my side, against the "authorities," though im not so much saying "fight the authority" as I am saying "deal with your own problems and let others deal with theirs."


I'd rather place my faith in a system, that though it does have some flaws, is far better than just ignoring criminal acts. Thinking that the legal system hurts more than it helps is incredibly stupid and advocating that people ignore acts of violence is one of the most stupid things I have ever read on the internet and I have read some seriously stupid sh!t.

#70
ComradeShepard7

ComradeShepard7
  • Members
  • 1 261 messages

Chrome tater tot wrote...

It's the other way around. The few good people cannot save the world unless all the bad ones allow it to be done.

I would also like to point out that almost every american citizen in 1940 held fast to the opinions I'm supporting right now. The holocaust was "not our problem" until some tycoons saw an opportunity to get even richer off war time profiteering and greased the president's pockets. Next thing you know they are playing Pearl Harbor on the people as a national tragedy that noone saw coming (oh please) and NOW it's our problem. Only once the japanese had transgressed against us did we deign to sully our hands with the rest of the world's conflict.

So don't act like I'm some lone ranger with a some crazy, unheard of philosophy, and don't confuse realism with cowardice. Cowards run to find some big brother to deal with the problems for them, the rest of us handle life all on our own.


Care to provide citations for tycoons influencing the US entering WWII? Also, have you ever heard of ethical and moral obligations to intervene when there is the capability to do so? Bosnian War and Kosovo intervention ring a bell? Or the current discussion about the use of chemical weapons in Syria?

#71
Dunmer of Redoran

Dunmer of Redoran
  • Members
  • 3 107 messages
give me moanie ploss

I repart u

#72
Alien Number Six

Alien Number Six
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages

Chrome tater tot wrote...

Alien Number Six wrote...
And that is exactly what it is. That is why neighborhood get like that. No one has the guts to stand up for what is right. Everyone wants to say it's not their problem until it's their mom getting raped and murdered. Then they wish someone would have stopped and tried to help or call the police. I report all the fu+cked up sh+it that happens in my neighborhood. I also spent three years in Iraq own a 45. and know how to make bombs. Go ahead and fu+ck with me. Good luck opening up your mail box, your front door, your back door or starting you car :)


See, to me the first half of your post contradicts the second. I would note that I agree with the second half.



Yeah, and I have killed people before. And until you do I think you should be quiet and stop commenting on things you have no experience with. I have had neighbors come to my home and thank me for calling the police and getting them involved. I had a police officer tell me yesterday that since I moved into the neighborhood crime has decreased by 26% in the area. People have begun to stand up for themselves andget the police involved when these little punks who think they know what a real fight is roll onto our street. And if they try to bring the fight to me..........well.....god help them........they will need it......

#73
Chrome tater tot

Chrome tater tot
  • Members
  • 253 messages

ComradeShepard7 wrote...

Chrome tater tot wrote...

It's the other way around. The few good people cannot save the world unless all the bad ones allow it to be done.

I would also like to point out that almost every american citizen in 1940 held fast to the opinions I'm supporting right now. The holocaust was "not our problem" until some tycoons saw an opportunity to get even richer off war time profiteering and greased the president's pockets. Next thing you know they are playing Pearl Harbor on the people as a national tragedy that noone saw coming (oh please) and NOW it's our problem. Only once the japanese had transgressed against us did we deign to sully our hands with the rest of the world's conflict.

So don't act like I'm some lone ranger with a some crazy, unheard of philosophy, and don't confuse realism with cowardice. Cowards run to find some big brother to deal with the problems for them, the rest of us handle life all on our own.


Care to provide citations for tycoons influencing the US entering WWII? Also, have you ever heard of ethical and moral obligations to intervene when there is the capability to do so? Bosnian War and Kosovo intervention ring a bell? Or the current discussion about the use of chemical weapons in Syria?

Regardless of my ability to prove who influenced what during WWII the fact remains that the US populace maintained a "not our business" mentality up until the attack on pearl harbor made it U.S. business. 

I'm not familiar with Bosnian/Kosovo, but as far as I know regarding syria the U.K. does not support the President's ideas about intervening. They would prefer to stay out of it last I heard. 

#74
Supreme Leech

Supreme Leech
  • Members
  • 3 641 messages
I would like to come forward. Citizen's arrest.

#75
rassmert

rassmert
  • Members
  • 191 messages
No it does not worth the effort, BW doesnt care anymore, no ban waves since April? i dont even remember. I used to report cheaters but now it is just a waste of time