34 réponses à ce sujet

[AlanC9]

cap and gown wrote...

AlanC9 wrote...

What speculation? She's dead. OP was just too clueless to notice.

No, OP just didn't notice the name on the wall, dweeb.

So this thread's about you finally noticing something that you  expected to be there all along?

[shingara]

Necanor wrote...

shingara wrote...

not quite true, you can destroy and not destroy edi.

Nope. High ems destroy might only do minimal damage, but it still kills all synthetic life in the galaxy.

 If you kill evas body with the beam edi survives, edi and eva are different things, eva is just an extention of edi which is the normandy.

 So that just adds to the what ifs pile, could edi have gone down like she has in the past and evas body becomes none functional making the crew think edi is dead when she isnt.

Modifié par shingara, 03 septembre 2013 - 09:14 .

[cap and gown]

StreetMagic wrote...

It'd be cool if EDI survived and just resorted to her Normandy/ME2 form. I liked her that way. She was harder to read, and more smug. ME3 she seems like a little sister who I'm teaching "life" to. All so they can guilt me into choosing Synthesis.

The main problem for me was the writers could never decide how much of her was in the body, and how much in the ship. Mostly they went body-centric, which didn't make much sense, but occasionally they'd slip back. I would have much preferred not having to go all the way up to the cockpit to speak to her. Just give Shep an "EDI terminal" next to her message terminal like in ME2 (although EDI never had much to say in ME2).

[cap and gown]

AlanC9 wrote...

cap and gown wrote...

AlanC9 wrote...

What speculation? She's dead. OP was just too clueless to notice.

No, OP just didn't notice the name on the wall, dweeb.

So this thread's about you finally noticing something that you  expected to be there all along?

I put up the thread becasue there were "speculations" that EDI survived. I believe I even saw one poster claim they saw EDI on the Normandy (at the memorial?) after Destroy. I always assumed she died because I never saw her there, but seeing the name on the wall seemed to be proof that these "speculations" were wrong, so I posted.

[KaiserShep]

And this is why some things should not be left to the imagination. Watching EDI actually die would've prevented all of this lol. Maybe with Joker leaping out of his chair doing the Vader "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!"

[MegaSovereign]

AlexMBrennan wrote...

Also, given that 1.5. million died every day during the Reaper invasion it seems a bit, well, weird - Shepard is personally responsible for millions of preventable deaths because he delayed the deployment of the Crucible to play video games and party on the Citadel, but the one named person who died gets a spot on the memorial wall? How hypocritical is that?

The memorial wall is reserved for people who were part of the Normandy crew.

[cap and gown]

MegaSovereign wrote...

AlexMBrennan wrote...

Also, given that 1.5. million died every day during the Reaper invasion it seems a bit, well, weird - Shepard is personally responsible for millions of preventable deaths because he delayed the deployment of the Crucible to play video games and party on the Citadel, but the one named person who died gets a spot on the memorial wall? How hypocritical is that?

The memorial wall is reserved for people who were part of the Normandy crew.

Except Zaeed. For some reason he doesn't end up there. (Not that I care.)

[shingara]

cap and gown wrote...

StreetMagic wrote...

It'd be cool if EDI survived and just resorted to her Normandy/ME2 form. I liked her that way. She was harder to read, and more smug. ME3 she seems like a little sister who I'm teaching "life" to. All so they can guilt me into choosing Synthesis.

The main problem for me was the writers could never decide how much of her was in the body, and how much in the ship. Mostly they went body-centric, which didn't make much sense, but occasionally they'd slip back. I would have much preferred not having to go all the way up to the cockpit to speak to her. Just give Shep an "EDI terminal" next to her message terminal like in ME2 (although EDI never had much to say in ME2).

 Thats actualy covered in a subtle way. It requires you to have saved and released the 2 engineers from me2 and have them take there place on the normandy within 3, the 2 engineers donnely and kelly will talk with engineer adams and edi about what edi actualy is, you can chirp in and agree with one of there points but its covered that edi is the ship and everything else is an extention including eva.

 As is probably well known by all edi became self aware on the luna base in me1 and escaped via radiowaves via binary code which cerberus intercepted, when cerberus realised she was self aware they implanted reaper code into edi as a way to control her and to advance her cyberwarfare suit of programs.

 When jeff unlocked her during the collector attack in 2 edi gained a body which is the normandy which allowed her to have senses and awareness of a much greater enviroment of her surroundings, but as she was already self aware the normandy did little else then house her mind so she became a mind with a body. Edi herself cannot be apart from the normandy like eva was as she states when she takes over evas body and you get that cutscene of her walking out or should i say strutting out.

 When she is controling eva for example on a mission its no more then a remote controlled drone that edi takes control of.

Modifié par shingara, 06 septembre 2013 - 05:08 .