Master Warder Z wrote...
t0mm06 wrote...
Because when it comes down to it trusting Mages when they have shown themselves to be lustful of Power time and again is foolish.
But to address your own argument.
Do you blame the Senior Enchanters for supporting the Grand Enchanters bid for Independence from the chantry?
Do you think the Templars were wrong to disvow the Accord and Break from the chantry due to their lack of action and the Divine's support of the Mage element? You have groups judged based upon the actions of the majority of them, Should all mages be blamed for the actions of Anders? No but should they expect themselves to be looked upon as similarly dangerous?
Of course its just basic logic; You have a regional Chantry head assasinated by a Mage, you have an attempt on the Divine by a Mage. Time and again the Mages have flaunted their position to the Templars and then are surprised when the Templars declare war upon the remenants of the circles?
Personal choice is more then enough for most; Why wouldn't it be the case here? You have Mages swearing allegiance to the faction that is dragging the world into war, You claim it is worse for a man to wield a sword then to be born a mage?
Then i suggest looking to the choices Mages have made for themselves.
Some mages have been shown to be lustful of power, more to us the player but then it can be argued that as a player who is basically good (most of the time) we see more of the worst of everyone because we dont see the quiet nice ones, because they are not fighting.
You cant look at them as a group, its like when people look at any teenager and assume they are trouble because what we see on the new about them is amlost always bad.
I think the Grand enchatetress is a bad leader, I much prefered Rhys, he feels like the circle is needed, but that the templars and mages should work in a partnership for the better of EVERYONE not just the normal people or just the mages but EVERYONE.
But no i dont blame them, because throughout reading Asunder it became clearer and clearer to me that there was no changing the circle, it needsa to be destroyed BUT rebuilt, differently, not by thoes who fear magic or what it can do but by thoes who understand it and understand what it can do. (Through reading Asunder i cam to realise how little the templars understand of magic and that is aweful, they should know it as well as the mages if they want to protect people from it.
And i dont really have an opinion on the breaking of the accord, i mean if i think about it i suppose its better. I mean the Templars are going to hunt and war with the mages anyway, so at least by breaking the accord they have said 'We are no longer with the chantry' where as not breaking it would be like 'we are still with the chantry but we're doing what we want anyway'
And i think Lambert is worse then Meridith, she was driven mad by red lyrium, and an abundance of Bloodmages in kirkwall (some who became bloodmages because of her restrictions, BUT i agree a lot were already bloodmages before her, and some were just dicks) But you're right in earlier comments, Meridth never hated mages, she feared what they could do but never hated them.
Lambert however has a clear hatred, and is paranoid. Also he jumps to conclusions without sufficent evidence and then refuses to beleive he could have been wrong. A good leader shouldn't be like that, he should be ready to admit his mistakes and see the truth when it is presented to him. He should also listen to his Captians rather then hate and dis-trust anyone who has a different opinion.
I suppose one of the big differences of opinions here is after reading asunder i dont think that the dispanding of the circle is the wrong thing to do, yes there were better options, but they began to dissapear more and more (and the fault for that was on both sides.)
So yeh i sorta see that both sides have there good and bad points, I cannot believe that anyone should be treadted like the mages have, simply because of how they are born and the actions of others. I dont see a fairness there.
Also the templars are dragging the world to war just as much as the mages, I'm not blaming them mutually! Its both sides faults.
But yeh i dont think that choosing to become someone who has the ablilty to kill hundred is worse then being born with it.