36 réponses à ce sujet

[Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna]

Polish game magazine, CD-Action, which is considered controversial by some back in PL, yet numerous people claim that it is 'prestigious' has reviewed Mass Effect 2 and gave it the highest mark of 10/10, what is very rare in CDA.

Also: reviewer says that he could not find and faults or flaws in game, that it is best RPG among shooters and best shooter among RPGs, he praised the characters and story... well, he praised every part of the game.

Also: there is Wrex screen shot, that's one thing.  There is note about 'only two characters from ME 1 are returning as squad members', and there is scrren shot with Garrus in the party for those who still doubted in him being a squad member.

Also (I like 'also!') : there is a note that you will have 'an assasin with problems with his son' in your party. Is it Thane?

That's all for now.

[DocLasty]

Also (I like 'also!') : there is a note that you will have 'an assasin with problems with his son' in your party. Is it Thane?



More than likely. That would explain the 'Cat's Cradle' achievement with him.

[Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna]

Yeah.But I still hope that this achievement means that you will have to give Thane some Ice-9

[Piccolotto649]

Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna wrote...
There is note about 'only two characters from ME 1 are returning as squad members'

Hold on! What now? That is huge. Let the speculation begin.
 oh wait. Tali damn. I am an idiot.

[izmirtheastarach]

Clearly this review is proof that the game is going to be very disappointing.

[Xeyska]

Fffffffff-

I don't Thane to have a son, I'm getting tired of family issue tropes.

[Br0th3rGr1mm]

As much as I think ME2 will be one of my all time favorite games, I think a 10/10 is suspcious and question the objectivity of any reviewer or site that bestows such a score.  Clearly, the game review industry now scores on a 6-10 scale (5 is an abomination and 10 is a very good game) rather than a 0-10 scale.  It's a pitty.

The "red veins when near death" is enough to lower the score by 0.5 points alone, IMO.

Modifié par Br0th3rGr1mm, 19 janvier 2010 - 04:49 .

[Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna]

Yeah, true dat!



Also: there is a screen form a some kind of souvenir shop, where you can buy fish, models (Normandy SR-1 and Destiny Ascension) and a Miniature Space Hamster. Sadly, no Minsc.



Also: concerning the models: there is a screen of model case, in which we can see models of turian cruiser and Alliance cruiser.

[Apollo Starflare]

izmirtheastarach wrote...

Clearly this review is proof that the game is going to be very disappointing.

Indeed, the end is nigh for this series I fear.


Great to see another 10/10. Don't have an opinion on CDA although I have heard good things about their reviews in the past. Also (heheh): Thane comes with baggage?

[DocLasty]

Br0th3rGr1mm wrote...

As much as I think ME2 will be on of my all time favorite games, I think a 10/10 is suspcious and question the objectivity of any reviewer or site that bestows such a score. The "red veins when near death" is enough to lower the score by 0.5 points alone.

Typically, I'd agree with you, but every review that's come out so far has been to the same tune. They can't all be in EA's pocket or whatever.

[Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna]

Br0th3rGr1mm wrote...

As much as I think ME2 will be on of my all time favorite games, I think a 10/10 is suspcious and question the objectivity of any reviewer or site that bestows such a score. The "red veins when near death" is enough to lower the score by 0.5 points alone.

To earn 10/10 in CD-Action, three revierwers need to agree that it is worth it. Those revierws said that the highst mark is gven due to ME2 being insanelt playable and addicting. This said.

Also: CDA gave DA:O only 8.5, so they are not in EA pocekt, for sure:P

Modifié par Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna, 19 janvier 2010 - 04:49 .

[Deinonychus]

Br0th3rGr1mm wrote...

As much as I think ME2 will be on of my all time favorite games, I think a 10/10 is suspcious and question the objectivity of any reviewer or site that bestows such a score. The "red veins when near death" is enough to lower the score by 0.5 points alone.

But that's your opinion. Some people don't care enough about the red veins to lower the score of the game by FIVE PERCENT.

I hate them too, though, but it's not going to affect how much I like the game.

Modifié par Deinonychus_Z, 19 janvier 2010 - 04:51 .

[iBadass]

10/10, how horrible. I knew that this game is going to turn into a generic shooter. All the characters must be one-dimensional killing machines. Cancelling my pre-order.

[Zoe Dedweth]

I lolled so hard at Thane's baggage - I wonder how many girls are going off him because of it.

[Fragglespank]

Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna wrote...

Also: there is a screen form a some kind of souvenir shop, where you can buy fish, models (Normandy SR-1 and Destiny Ascension) and a Miniature Space Hamster. Sadly, no Minsc.

GOTY!

[izmirtheastarach]

10/10 Clearly means the game is no longer an RPG.

[Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna]

Also: this is first 10/10 in CDA in over a year (last being GRID, AFAIR).



Also: it is 18th or so in 14 years of CDA existence.

[GmanFresh]

i have mass effect on my back

[Br0th3rGr1mm]

Deinonychus_Z wrote...
But that's your opinion. Some people don't care enough about the red veins to lower the score of the game.

I hate them too, though, but it's not going to affect how much I like the game.

10 == PERFECTION

Lower your standards if you like...I can't stop you.

[TheAnima]

iBadass wrote...

10/10, how horrible. I knew that this game is going to turn into a generic shooter. All the characters must be one-dimensional killing machines. Cancelling my pre-order.

The win of this post cannot be underestimated.

[Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna]

Br0th3rGr1mm wrote...

Deinonychus_Z wrote...
But that's your opinion. Some people don't care enough about the red veins to lower the score of the game.

I hate them too, though, but it's not going to affect how much I like the game.

10 == PERFECTION

Lower your standards if you like...I can't stop you.

Again, I  want to remind you that the reviewer actually liked the health regen system!

[izmirtheastarach]

And people, remember the Red Veins are for noobs, not for you.

[Cerberus Operative]

Excellent, sounds good

[SnowHeart1]

Cerbin aep Dol Blathanna wrote...

*snip* that it is best RPG among shooters and best shooter among RPGs *snip*

 Several ways to interpret that, but I'll take it in a positive light.  It is encouraging.  I wish there were English reviews available online, but until then... 

Can you explain why the magazine is considered controversial?