Aller au contenu

Photo

GI vs Geth Trooper which is better and why?


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
241 réponses à ce sujet

#76
RZIBARA

RZIBARA
  • Members
  • 4 066 messages
@Chromatix. You realize for one this a cooperative game right? It's not a competitive PvP game.

Also what you find fun and boring is the same for everyone. Stop forcing your preferences on people. It's a cooperative game let people play what the hell theyd like to play. Dont like it? Dont use, but stop your ****ing

#77
Heldarion

Heldarion
  • Members
  • 6 171 messages

IamZAE wrote...

David Diablo wrote...

I think Chromatix put it best. A well played GI will always be better than whatever a GT can do. But forgetting crutch or cheese arguments, It would be interesting to compare a GT flamer build using a reegar and a GI for pure DPS.
With incendiary ammo and the flamer, you can do insane amounts of damage. Add that to a team that can detonate FEs and the pure DPS could rival or possibly even surpass the GI in my opinion.


The platinum solos recorded by many players if u search google suggest the gt is the better kit. Flamer is more dps than tac cloak amped weapon


This is just flat out wrong. Because people prefer a certain class more, that doesn't mean it's better. And I'm not even going to start with the whole console-players-apparently-prefer-power-classes thing.

In fact, I crushed all the GT Plat times with the GI, with the console loading times being completely irrelevant.

#78
IamZAE

IamZAE
  • Members
  • 2 473 messages
@chromatix whoa woa let's get back on track. Let me ask you. Be honest. With all biased put aside. Wats the better kit... Flames based gt or the gi? I'm not talking about score I'm talking about purely destroying the enemy and extracting to victory

#79
IamZAE

IamZAE
  • Members
  • 2 473 messages

Heldarion wrote...

IamZAE wrote...

David Diablo wrote...

I think Chromatix put it best. A well played GI will always be better than whatever a GT can do. But forgetting crutch or cheese arguments, It would be interesting to compare a GT flamer build using a reegar and a GI for pure DPS.
With incendiary ammo and the flamer, you can do insane amounts of damage. Add that to a team that can detonate FEs and the pure DPS could rival or possibly even surpass the GI in my opinion.


The platinum solos recorded by many players if u search google suggest the gt is the better kit. Flamer is more dps than tac cloak amped weapon


This is just flat out wrong. Because people prefer a certain class more, that doesn't mean it's better. And I'm not even going to start with the whole console-players-apparently-prefer-power-classes thing.

In fact, I crushed all the GT Plat times with the GI, with the console loading times being completely irrelevant.


How many tries did it take you? 50? Would it take you 50 tries to break your own personal plat solo record with the gt? No sarcasm it's an honest question

#80
RZIBARA

RZIBARA
  • Members
  • 4 066 messages
@Yo Son, arent you the smart guy who didnt even know what Reaper forces belonged to which race?

Right, and you want me to take you seriously?

Btw, no such thing as flamer BS, dont like it? deal with it. Stop coming to the forums and complaining, it doesnt make you look cool, it makes you look like an ignorant douche

#81
Heldarion

Heldarion
  • Members
  • 6 171 messages

IamZAE wrote...

Heldarion wrote...

IamZAE wrote...

David Diablo wrote...

I think Chromatix put it best. A well played GI will always be better than whatever a GT can do. But forgetting crutch or cheese arguments, It would be interesting to compare a GT flamer build using a reegar and a GI for pure DPS.
With incendiary ammo and the flamer, you can do insane amounts of damage. Add that to a team that can detonate FEs and the pure DPS could rival or possibly even surpass the GI in my opinion.


The platinum solos recorded by many players if u search google suggest the gt is the better kit. Flamer is more dps than tac cloak amped weapon


This is just flat out wrong. Because people prefer a certain class more, that doesn't mean it's better. And I'm not even going to start with the whole console-players-apparently-prefer-power-classes thing.

In fact, I crushed all the GT Plat times with the GI, with the console loading times being completely irrelevant.


How many tries did it take you? 50? Would it take you 50 tries to break your own personal plat solo record with the gt? No sarcasm it's an honest question


Took me 20+ tries. It'd take me a lot more with GT, mainly because I don't play that class very often.  If there's anyone who would do it in no time, it would be Haxn14. GT is his specialty.

And don't even think others got those times in their first tries.

edit: misread at first

Modifié par Heldarion, 20 septembre 2013 - 01:32 .


#82
Chromatix

Chromatix
  • Members
  • 2 366 messages

RZIBARA wrote...

@Chromatix. You realize for one this a cooperative game right? It's not a competitive PvP game.

Also what you find fun and boring is the same for everyone. Stop forcing your preferences on people. It's a cooperative game let people play what the hell theyd like to play. Dont like it? Dont use, but stop your ****ing

Hey, i've stated my opinion and getting bullied for this. I have to answer.

Diablo is also a cooperative game.

@Zae, well it depends on a player. If i want to extract with pugs, i'd better have a GT in team (though personally i don't give a flying **** about pug teammates and their preformance, but that's a different story), the fact. But 1 vs. 1 GI will win GT.
Of course, on Glacier GT gets OP because of small environment.. Is there any kind of Riodome? There GI, with all his accuracy bonuses, free movement and tactical awareness, would make GT eat some dust.

Also, if you're so obssessed with solos, please, show me GT doing solos faster, than Alquinn with his GI?

Modifié par Chromatix, 20 septembre 2013 - 01:34 .


#83
RZIBARA

RZIBARA
  • Members
  • 4 066 messages
You can only extract with PUGs with a GT?

Wow....

#84
cato potato

cato potato
  • Members
  • 3 932 messages

RZIBARA wrote...

@Yo Son, arent you the smart guy who didnt even know what Reaper forces belonged to which race?

Right, and you want me to take you seriously?

Btw, no such thing as flamer BS, dont like it? deal with it. Stop coming to the forums and complaining, it doesnt make you look cool, it makes you look like an ignorant douche


But without douchebaggery and complaining this forum might wither and die  :crying:

#85
Chromatix

Chromatix
  • Members
  • 2 366 messages

RZIBARA wrote...

You can only extract with PUGs with a GT?

Wow....

I can only rush posts when i wasn't sleeping for 29 hours.

#86
ISHYGDDT

ISHYGDDT
  • Members
  • 6 930 messages

Chromatix wrote...

Also, if you're so obssessed with solos, please, show me GT doing solos faster, than Alquinn with his GI?

 I'm pretty sure you posted in the RedJohn thread last night. All teasing aside, I'm reasonably certain that is a legit solo, at least to the extent that exploiting the Incendiary Glitch is considered legit. 

EDIT:  Sorry 2 nights ago: http://social.biowar.../index/17342478

Modifié par ISHYGDDT, 20 septembre 2013 - 01:37 .


#87
RedJohn

RedJohn
  • Members
  • 7 164 messages
Both of them make the game really easy

#88
Chromatix

Chromatix
  • Members
  • 2 366 messages

ISHYGDDT wrote...

Chromatix wrote...

Also, if you're so obssessed with solos, please, show me GT doing solos faster, than Alquinn with his GI?

 I'm pretty sure you posted in the RedJohn thread last night. All teasing aside, I'm reasonably certain that is a legit solo, at least to the extent that exploiting the Incendiary Glitch is considered legit.

Well, we're talking about flamer only.

Of course incendiary glitch puts every other argument to the grave, but meh.

#89
Yo Son

Yo Son
  • Members
  • 707 messages

RZIBARA wrote...

@Chromatix. You realize for one this a cooperative game right? It's not a competitive PvP game.

Also what you find fun and boring is the same for everyone. Stop forcing your preferences on people. It's a cooperative game let people play what the hell theyd like to play. Dont like it? Dont use, but stop your ****ing


I find missle glitching boring; but is a perfectly fine way to grind credits; is the reason why playing an offensive volus is 10 folds more exciting than runing around shiled boosting people; is the same reason why using a weapon people put down as bad and doing well with it is better than using an OP weapon at lvl x, because thats the competitive edge of the game, doing something others wont try, doing something better than someone else, trying new kits and weapon loadouts; in this sense co op can be more competitive than Pvp.

Even female gamers have some degree of competition in them that drives them to game. Someone please explain to me how you can sunk in 1000+ hours into a game other wise.

#90
RedJohn

RedJohn
  • Members
  • 7 164 messages
Also, I would like to ask, in my opinion/experience Geth Flamer is better for plat than GI, because of lolflamer, you get a power that melts armor and everything has armor on plat.

Plus the fact that it can be stacked with Incendiary ammo and Reegar........... nuff said with that.

But better than GI?, well, i would say yes up to a point. GI is a better weapon plattform while GS is a power user.

#91
IamZAE

IamZAE
  • Members
  • 2 473 messages
@chromatix here ya go

http://m.youtube.com...h?v=r7w8zYJb0D0

http://m.youtube.com...a&v=9Sktdzb7WWQ

#92
Yo Son

Yo Son
  • Members
  • 707 messages
Like I mentioned before; GT wins because he is going to blind GI; even the GI cant escape the the blinding powers of lolflamer

#93
RZIBARA

RZIBARA
  • Members
  • 4 066 messages

Yo Son wrote...

RZIBARA wrote...

@Chromatix. You realize for one this a cooperative game right? It's not a competitive PvP game.

Also what you find fun and boring is the same for everyone. Stop forcing your preferences on people. It's a cooperative game let people play what the hell theyd like to play. Dont like it? Dont use, but stop your ****ing


I find missle glitching boring; but is a perfectly fine way to grind credits; is the reason why playing an offensive volus is 10 folds more exciting than runing around shiled boosting people; is the same reason why using a weapon people put down as bad and doing well with it is better than using an OP weapon at lvl x, because thats the competitive edge of the game, doing something others wont try, doing something better than someone else, trying new kits and weapon loadouts; in this sense co op can be more competitive than Pvp.

Even female gamers have some degree of competition in them that drives them to game. Someone please explain to me how you can sunk in 1000+ hours into a game other wise.


are you seriously comparing missile glitching (which is a form of glitching the game and cheating) to a power that is present for 3 different characters? 

I stopped reading there. You're arguments are terrible. stop posting althogether pls

#94
Guest_N7 Krisixus_*

Guest_N7 Krisixus_*
  • Guests
Neither I like both but I would give it to the GI just because of cloak IMO but its not an easy kit to handle because having to juggle with low shields from HM.

But at least geth trooper is a user friendly kit because of flamer so there's that to consider.

#95
Zyzimorph

Zyzimorph
  • Members
  • 1 564 messages

RZIBARA wrote...

lol @ all the butthurt over the flamer

I use flamer GT all the time. It's fun (yep deal with it). Stop insulting people for what they like to play.
It makes you look like a pathetic elitist douche


Lamer is a stupid annoying power, end of story.

#96
Chromatix

Chromatix
  • Members
  • 2 366 messages

IamZAE wrote...

@chromatix here ya go

http://m.youtube.com...h?v=r7w8zYJb0D0

http://m.youtube.com...a&v=9Sktdzb7WWQ

Okay, you win.

Well, is there any info about different maps? Like, who's faster on Hydra - GI or GT?

Glacier is a map different from any other, the fact.

#97
IamZAE

IamZAE
  • Members
  • 2 473 messages

RedJohn wrote...

Also, I would like to ask, in my opinion/experience Geth Flamer is better for plat than GI, because of lolflamer, you get a power that melts armor and everything has armor on plat.

Plus the fact that it can be stacked with Incendiary ammo and Reegar........... nuff said with that.

But better than GI?, well, i would say yes up to a point. GI is a better weapon plattform while GS is a power user.


agreed. But his flames potential overcomes any weapon combo the GI can wield... Assuming it's not being played by heldarion, hes a beast

#98
RZIBARA

RZIBARA
  • Members
  • 4 066 messages

Zyzimorph wrote...

RZIBARA wrote...

lol @ all the butthurt over the flamer

I use flamer GT all the time. It's fun (yep deal with it). Stop insulting people for what they like to play.
It makes you look like a pathetic elitist douche


Lamer is a stupid annoying power, end of story.


maybe you dont like it. Doesnt mean others dont like it. 

#99
Lady Abstract

Lady Abstract
  • Members
  • 1 574 messages

IamZAE wrote...

@prosthetic. You talk alot of crap for someone who can't back anything up. Gt: I am ZAE. Add me and we will thunderdome. And we will see who's dumb.


I believe she plays on peaesstree you can't tell? 

On topic the most optimal GI build is better than the most optimal GT build...why? because of how I play. It all comes down to personal preference and a persons play style really...what would you consider is the best build on both characters? 

#100
IamZAE

IamZAE
  • Members
  • 2 473 messages

Chromatix wrote...

IamZAE wrote...

@chromatix here ya go

http://m.youtube.com...h?v=r7w8zYJb0D0

http://m.youtube.com...a&v=9Sktdzb7WWQ

Okay, you win. 

Well, is there any info about different maps? Like, who's faster on Hydra - GI or GT?

Glacier is a map different from any other, the fact. 


Chromatic not my intention to be rude or pick a fight, I am merely bringing this debate for discussion with the hopes that EVERYONE reading will think about each kit with no biased and no coolness factor. And come to a logical debate about which of the two powerhouses reign supreme