34 réponses à ce sujet

[TwinWolf954]

In other words, are there any weapons or characters that you feel should be a higher/lower level card than what they are now?

In my opinion (mainly formed from experience... bear in mind that my manifest isn't maxed yet, however):


Blood Pack Punisher: Ultra-Rare → Rare

Collector Rifle: Rare → Uncommon

Disciple: Rare → Uncommon

Geth Pulse Rifle: Rare → Uncommon

Krysae Sniper Rifle: Rare → Uncommon

N7 Crusader: Ultra-Rare → Rare (mainly because of the weird shot delay it has)

N7 Valiant: Ultra-Rare → Rare

Reegar Carbine: Rare → Ultra-Rare

Venom Shotgun: Ultra-Rare → Rare


There are more, but I'll save some for everyone else.

Modifié par TwinWolf954, 25 septembre 2013 - 10:40 .

[Pearl (rip bioware)]

MasterReefa wrote...

GI, GT, GJ, AIU, TGI should be common.

Don't forget QMI

Modifié par FatherOfPearl, 25 septembre 2013 - 11:15 .

[Ledgend1221]

Crusader rare?
Make shotguns even more OP.

[hwd]

M-55 Argus - Uncommon

[I Am Robot]

TwinWolf954 wrote...

In other words, are there any weapons or characters that you feel should be a higher/lower level card than what they are now?

In my opinion (mainly formed from experience... bear in mind that my manifest isn't maxed yet, however):


Blood Pack Punisher: Ultra-Rare → Rare

Collector Rifle: Rare → Uncommon

Disciple: Rare → Uncommon

Geth Pulse Rifle: Rare → Uncommon

Krysae Sniper Rifle: Rare → Uncommon

N7 Crusader: Ultra-Rare → Rare (mainly because of the weird shot delay it has)

N7 Valiant: Ultra-Rare → Rare

Reegar Carbine: Rare → Ultra-Rare

Venom Shotgun: Ultra-Rare → Rare


There are more, but I'll save some for everyone else.

Gotta say I don't necessariy agree with a lot of your calls, I'll through them in the same order as you listed them: 
1. A reasonable argument, but I'm not sure. 
2.  it's not the best AR but it's certainly not with the like's of the Vindicator (not that the vindicator's bad or unplayable, just that the Collector Assualt rifles much better) 
3. No, it doesn't have the highest damage or the best rate of fire , sure, but it's still one of the best choices for power based classes. 
4.Yeeeeahh, maybe, but I've heard it can be very effective in certain combinations, need to do more research/experiments
5.  Definately agree, although it does work as a recharge-less primer, but still it's not good enough to be classified as rare. 
6. What? are you serious. Ok. sure it has a long wait between each shot but the damage of a shotgun at long ranges is certainly helpful. Also its more like a heavy pistol than a shotgun I think lol. In my opinion the only setback is that it can't get past shield gate. edit: I've been informed of the glitch associated with this weapon, I've actually never had it happen to me (or maybe I didn't notice it) Any way a glitches are not a factor when measuring the value of a weapon, only when deciding what to take onto the field.
7. You do realise its the highest DPS sniper rifle right? 
8. Agreed, even though I don't think it's that OP, it's still more than powerful enough to be an ultra-rare
9. It has a DPS higher than the wraith and works as a primer, that, I say, is the stuff of ultra-rare. 

Also the mattock should a be a rare. 

Modifié par Farid-Yoda-N7, 26 septembre 2013 - 11:00 .

[Pearl (rip bioware)]

^ When TW says "Crusader shot delay", it's in reference to a bug with the gun the shot actually hits where your crosshairs were 0.2 seconds before you pressed the fire button, not the refire time. In other words, the Crusader is a gun for people who enjoy time travel.

Modifié par FatherOfPearl, 25 septembre 2013 - 11:56 .

[I Am Robot]

FatherOfPearl wrote...

^ When TW says "Crusader shot delay", it's in reference to a bug with the gun the shot actually hits where your crosshairs were 0.2 seconds before you pressed the fire button, not the refire time. In other words, the Crusader is a gun for people who enjoy time travel.

Thanks for pointing it out, post edited. 

[I Am Robot]

hwd wrote...

M-55 Argus - Uncommon

You may have already seen this thread/ watched the video but in case you haven't: 
 social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/343/index/17367943/1

[LiL Reapur]

Harrier for common
Avenger for UR. It's deadly when fired on full auto.™

[Simba501]

Agree with everything in the OP. Made my own exhaustive list.

Mantis - uncommon
Eviscerator - rare
Argus - uncommon
Suppressor - ultra rare
Geth plasma shotgun - ultra rare
Claymore - ultra rare
Valkryie - rare

Geth scanner - ultra rare
Grenade capacity - ultra rare
Shield booster - rare
Hydraulic joints - rare

Vanilla adept/sentinel/infiltrator/vanguard - rare
Drell adept - rare
Turian soldier - rare
Asari vanguard - ultra rare
Salarian infiltrator - ultra rare
Drell vanguard - ultra rare
GI - ultra rare
Krogan vanguard - ultra rare
Fury/slayer/N7 paladin - ultra rare
Turian ghost - ultra rare
Asari valkryie - ultra rare
Krogan warlord - ultra rare
AIU - ultra rare

Volus adept should be buffed to fit ultra rare status.

[Maurader Sackboy]

Come on -- do we really need any more with UR status? Hundreds of hours to level up? I say make the URs drop at the same rate as the commons. Then, we'd have more PUGs with Harrier X's, etc., and more successes as a consequence (?)

[hwd]

Farid-Yoda-N7 wrote...

hwd wrote...

M-55 Argus - Uncommon

You may have already seen this thread/ watched the video but in case you haven't: 
 social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/343/index/17367943/1

I have seen that. Regardless it should still be Uncommon, although a lot of Rares shouldn't be Rare, I'll give you that.

[Red Panda]

hwd wrote...

Farid-Yoda-N7 wrote...

hwd wrote...

M-55 Argus - Uncommon

You may have already seen this thread/ watched the video but in case you haven't: 
 social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/343/index/17367943/1

I have seen that. Regardless it should still be Uncommon, although a lot of Rares shouldn't be Rare, I'll give you that.

Exactly. You try getting consistent headshots on console with it.

[TheShadyEngineer]

Pretty much all rare assault rifles should drop to uncommon status while bumping the mattock to rare.

[Miniditka77]

Maurader Sackboy wrote...

Come on -- do we really need any more with UR status? Hundreds of hours to level up? I say make the URs drop at the same rate as the commons. Then, we'd have more PUGs with Harrier X's, etc., and more successes as a consequence (?)

Excactly, we should be moving stuff DOWN in rarity, not up.  I don't know how many new players are picking up the game at this point, but the "curve" for new players has been ridiculous for a long time.  It will take new players a long time to unlock half the stuff in this game.

All the original Rare characters should be moved down to Uncommon (character rarity has nothing to do with their effectiveness), and a lot of the Rare weapons and Gear should be moved to Uncommon also.  Disciple, GPR, GPSMG, Adas, Carnifex, Argus, Krysae, Batarian Gauntlet, MediGel Transmitter, and all the ULM mods should all be moved to Uncommon status.  The Spitfire, Indra, BPP, and all UR characters should be moved to Rares.  

[capn233]

I would be more interested in making some of the common and uncommon weapons perform decently.

[Creator Limbs]

Scorpion -- Ultra Rare >> Rare
Geth Spitfire -- Ultra Rare >> Rare
M-99 Saber -- Ultra Rare >> Rare
Black Widow -- Ultra Rare >> Rare
Geth Plasma SMG -- Rare >> Uncommon
Krysae Sniper Rifle -- Rare >> Uncommon
Reegar Carbine -- Rare >> Ultra Rare (for less stupid cheese. ffs)
M-9 Ttempest -- Uncommon >> Rare
M-13 Raptor -- Uncommon >> Common
M-5 Phalanx -- Uncommon >> Rare

[d_nought]

capn233 wrote...

I would be more interested in making some of the common and uncommon weapons perform decently.

[holdenagincourt]

Since character rarity is essentially tethered to effectiveness not at all, I would say pretty much most of them if we're operating on the premise that it should be.

Even UR characters aren't UR anyway, though.

[Crimson Vanguard]

Claymore -> Ultra Rare
TGI -> Ultra Rare
AIU -> Ultra Rare
AV -> Ultra Rare

Modifié par Crimson Vanguard, 25 septembre 2013 - 05:15 .

[Creator Limbs]

GI should be Ultra Rare, btw.

[acicm2]

QFI- common
QFE- common

[Red Panda]

prostheticlimbs wrote...

GI should be Ultra Rare, btw.

Like the lancer?




You realize that would become frustrating, right?

Modifié par OperatingWookie, 25 septembre 2013 - 05:22 .

[Creator Limbs]

For who, exactly?