69 réponses à ce sujet

[KaiserShep]

That reminds me of the conversation Shepard has with the krogan shaman on Tuchanka when you're about to do Grunt's rite of passage. After putting Uvenk in his place by headbutting him, the shaman eventually comments on Shepard's inclination toward violence, at which point he/she makes a little smirk.

[KeraWildmane]

It's too hard to pick a serious one, so I'm just gonna go with telling that krogan in ME2 that there aren't any fish on the Presidium.

Modifié par Kerasth, 17 octobre 2013 - 04:28 .

[Sir DeLoria]

"I'm not sure wether to kill you with a bullet, or just take off your helmet and cough."

That was one of the funniest quotes of the Citadel dlc.

[General TSAR]

DuskWanderer wrote...


Personally, I think when the clone says "Like you, EDI. You're nothing more than electrons pretending to be alive." I thought that was brutal. 

The truth is often brutal. 

[teh DRUMPf!!]

gosimmons wrote...

"You're an Ardat-Yakshi Falere, I can't risk you leaving this planet."
Opting to shoot Samara's daughter after her mother decides to kill herself is about as unnecessarily dickish as it got.

I think the fact that she, as a AY, can be Banshee'd and has cravings to mate (thus, kill) makes it plenty necessary.

Samara not having the stomach to do it herself doesn't change that.

Modifié par HYR 2.0, 17 octobre 2013 - 12:33 .

[TheWerdna]

Honestly, Close Shepard's comments to every squadmate fits this category perfectly.

[perfectform]

That Shepard is such a jerk.

[conjmk]

When Shepard gets pissed at the Asari, it's pretty cruel.

[The Night Mammoth]

HYR 2.0 wrote...

gosimmons wrote...

"You're an Ardat-Yakshi Falere, I can't risk you leaving this planet."
Opting to shoot Samara's daughter after her mother decides to kill herself is about as unnecessarily dickish as it got.

I think the fact that she, as a AY, can be Banshee'd and has cravings to mate (thus, kill) makes it plenty necessary.

Samara not having the stomach to do it herself doesn't change that.

It's not necessary at all. The chances of her becoming a banshee are incredibly slim, she's clearly able to control whatever urges she might have if the past four hundred or so years of peaceful isolation are anything to go by, and she doesn't even have the capability of leaving the planet, or system, and doesn't have anywhere to go if she did.

Anyway, the harshest I've come across is during the Suicide Mission when you find the crew, and the renegade option is telling Chakwas that you didn't come for them and saving them doesn't matter.

Modifié par The Night Mammoth, 17 octobre 2013 - 03:37 .

[Sundance31us]

ME2 - Breaking up with Jack during the last meeting just before the Omega relay...renegade.

[AlexMBrennan]

It's not necessary at all. The chances of her becoming a banshee are incredibly slim

Based on what? The Reapers know about the AY monastery, so staying at the monastery will virtually guarantee that she'll get grabbed by the Reapers... unless you assume that the Reapers will suddenly stop trying to make banshees because Shepard shot a few disposable infantry units.

she's clearly able to control whatever urges she might have if the past four hundred or so years of peaceful isolation are anything to go by

At most you could conclude is that she's able to control her urges in isolation, but that's no longer the case since the Reapers destroyed the monastery; by your logic we should be fine releasing all prisoners because they didn't murder/steal/whatever whilst incarcerated.

and she doesn't even have the capability of leaving the planet, or system, and doesn't have anywhere to go if she did.

Source? Is there a magical repulsion field that stops shuttles from approaching the planet? Did Shepard check an entire planet to make sure there weren't any shuttles?

and doesn't have anywhere to go if she did.

What are you talking about? There is a war going on, so it would be easy to e.g. go to the Citadel and claim to be a refugee displaced by the war - and between overcrowding and the war I'd bet that it would take C-Sec a while to notice deaths piling up.

[teh DRUMPf!!]

Just about stole my thunder there, Alex.

[The Night Mammoth]

AlexMBrennan wrote...

It's not necessary at all. The chances of her becoming a banshee are incredibly slim

Based on what? The Reapers know about the AY monastery, so staying at the monastery will virtually guarantee that she'll get grabbed by the Reapers... unless you assume that the Reapers will suddenly stop trying to make banshees because Shepard shot a few disposable infantry units.

The Reapers would have to send forces to a Monastery they've already been to and know has been blown up, commit resources to capture one single asari, find Falere, who will likely hide, and then capture Falere, who swears to kill herself before she lets that happen. There are far more important things in the galaxy for the Reapers, she'll survive by being not worth the effort.

she's clearly able to control whatever urges she might have if the past four hundred or so years of peaceful isolation are anything to go by

At most you could conclude is that she's able to control her urges in isolation, but that's no longer the case since the Reapers destroyed the monastery; by your logic we should be fine releasing all prisoners because they didn't murder/steal/whatever whilst incarcerated.

She hasn't been behind bars like a criminal for four hundred years.

and she doesn't even have the capability of leaving the planet, or system, and doesn't have anywhere to go if she did.

Source? Is there a magical repulsion field that stops shuttles from approaching the planet? Did Shepard check an entire planet to make sure there weren't any shuttles?

A reasoned assumption. The only way she's leaving the system is in a ship. Where is she going to find one? If she finds one, how is she going to operate it? 

and doesn't have anywhere to go if she did.

What are you talking about? There is a war going on, so it would be easy to e.g. go to the Citadel and claim to be a refugee displaced by the war - and between overcrowding and the war I'd bet that it would take C-Sec a while to notice deaths piling up.

It's an age of DNA scanners and widespread electronic identification. The Reapers are all over the galaxy, the only place for her to go is the Citadel, and considering the only way she's going to get there is by somehow procuring another person's ship and she's more than likely known the asari government, I don't think she's going to succesfully find somwhere to lay low.

Modifié par The Night Mammoth, 17 octobre 2013 - 05:40 .

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

Sundance31us wrote...

ME2 - Breaking up with Jack during the last meeting just before the Omega relay...renegade.

That is cold. Shepard can be a dick for sake of being a dick. 

Does Shepard lose Jack's loyalty there? He should. Bioware should do a game where the squad or henchmen have certain things they won't put up with. For example, maybe if Shepard were to have crossed a character's moral line, they'd leave the crew on a hub world, and Shepard would have to recruit a replacement of a less desireable quality perhaps. Forcing role playing? perhaps but at least the crew behaves more realistically.

[SiniisteR]

Necanor wrote...

"I'm not sure wether to kill you with a bullet, or just take off your helmet and cough."

That was one of the funniest quotes of the Citadel dlc.

As funny as  it was, I still wished it had a renegade interrupt to punch the clone right in his face.

[Obadiah]

When Shep executes the Rachni Queen he says something unnecessarily harsh like, "This time stay dead!" This to a being that has basically been kept as a lab rat since its birth, and been mentally tortured by an Asari Matriarch.

Modifié par Obadiah, 18 octobre 2013 - 01:27 .

[Wynterdust]

Whenever you refuse to help a squadmate with their personal problems in ME2 that lead to their loyalty mission. It's not so much what Shepard says but the squadmates reaction to it that makes it feel harsh. Miranda's, Tali's and Samara's were particularly bad to me.

[teh DRUMPf!!]

The Night Mammoth wrote...

The Reapers would have to send forces to a Monastery they've already been to and know has been blown up, commit resources to capture one single asari,

Considering the value of just a single, solitary, Banshee... why not?

One Banshee can eat significantly into Shepard's war-assets when he comes back to Earth.

Call it an arms-race. It's not like Reapers don't have resources to spare. They'll likely face no resistance this time.

find Falere, who will likely hide, and then capture Falere, who swears to kill herself before she lets that happen.

Right, I wonder how many Reaper victims say that before they're taken.

I'm not even convinced you need to be alive for them to turn you into a husk. You see the victims impaled on Dragon's Teeth: they die, and then their bodies are recycled. You can't possibly live through that transformation anyway.

Only sure way would be to die something horrific, like throwing yourself into an incinerator, or vat of acid.

At most you could conclude is that she's able to control her urges in isolation, but that's no longer the case since the Reapers destroyed the monastery; by your logic we should be fine releasing all prisoners because they didn't murder/steal/whatever whilst incarcerated.

She hasn't been behind bars like a criminal for four hundred years.

Yeah, she pretty much has.

Only thing different between the monastery and a prison is the barred cells.

Otherwise, it's the same ish, different toilet.

A reasoned assumption. The only way she's leaving the system is in a ship. Where is she going to find one? If she finds one, how is she going to operate it?

... which is an even worse reality, if true. They're just about the perfect target for the Reapers.

Modifié par HYR 2.0, 18 octobre 2013 - 02:41 .

[Sir DeLoria]

SiniisteR wrote...

Necanor wrote...

"I'm not sure wether to kill you with a bullet, or just take off your helmet and cough."

That was one of the funniest quotes of the Citadel dlc.

As funny as  it was, I still wished it had a renegade interrupt to punch the clone right in his face.

Indeed<_<

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

Another mean line:

Tali: "Shepard you can't choose the Geth over my people."
Shepard: "Upload the code."

[Cainhurst Crow]

I still wish there were some way we could have selected what kind of mean response to give, as impossible as it may be.

Nothing really strikes me as being truly mean thanks to shock jock radio desensitizing me.

[Wulfram]

I don't know if "mean" is the right word, but the paragon response to Khalisah in ME2 if you let the Council die is incredibly callous. She asks you about the people who died and you respond with some screed about humanity being awesome? I really wanted to punch Shepard, though I settled for reloading.

The renegade response on the other hand is pretty OK.

[Baihu1983]

I am the catalyst.


Damn.