251 réponses à ce sujet

[Sasnak Kid]

Well, I was just broached with a dilemma that I had hope would not happen.  Miranda wants to know where she and I stand, relationally?

Truth is, I am digging Liara, though we haven't communicated that to each other.  And with Miranda being dedicated to Cerebus, quite frankly, I do not trust her.

Where is Dr. Phil, Dr. Ruth or Doctor Doctor when you need them?

[Steelcan]

Miranda > Liara

[Steelcan]

Miscellaneous Mind wrote...

Go with Miranda.

Yeah. I said it.

Welcome back

[Sir DeLoria]

Miri, no question.

[MassivelyEffective0730]

Miranda's not dedicated to Cerberus in ME3.

Go for who you want, but Miranda is who I'd always recommend. I personally believe she's the best romance - the only romance - in the series, for these reasons.

[Xilizhra]

Liara has an overall far better romance path, especially given many of the cuts that ME2 companions got in ME3.

[Hainkpe]

Neither. It'll just end in heartbreak man. Or Garrus. Choose Garrus!

[ClydeInTheShell]

Garrus.

[cap and gown]

I warned you not to cheat.

Look, I like Miri. A lot. But based on her reduced content in ME3 I would say Liara is the better choice. Even with the addition of the Citadel content Miri's content is disappointingly thin. In fact, I think Miri's Citadel interactions with Femshep are better than with a romanced mshep.

Also, I am surprised Liara hasn't already talked to you about continuing the relationship. I usually get that dialogue before I even have the chance to meet with Miri.

Anyway, nothing is settled until you get to the lock in point which is still a ways down the road. Just be aware that in ME3 you can only lock in with one partner. Bigamy (and serial monogamy) is off the table.

Modifié par cap and gown, 18 octobre 2013 - 06:51 .

[caradoc2000]

Sasnak Kid wrote...

Well, I was just broached with a dilemma that I had hope would not happen.

Hoped maybe, but did you seriously expect it wouldn't happen?

Where is Dr. Phil, Dr. Ruth or Doctor Doctor when you need them?

Doctor Who would let you time travel to ME2.

Modifié par caradoc2000, 18 octobre 2013 - 07:03 .

[Dextro Milk]

Miranda.

[rekn2]

miranda can take care of herself, she gets things done, she accomplishes goals etc etc.

i see the appeal of liara to some people. shes virginal, young and naive, book smart. but i dont like what they did with her character. imo, its way out of character to have her to be the SB and shes definitely NOT some one i want in a combat situation, they shouldve left her as a civilian

[MassivelyEffective0730]

rekn2 wrote...

miranda can take care of herself, she gets things done, she accomplishes goals etc etc.

i see the appeal of liara to some people. shes virginal, young and naive, book smart. but i dont like what they did with her character. imo, its way out of character to have her to be the SB and shes definitely NOT some one i want in a combat situation, they shouldve left her as a civilian

Look at what I wrote about Miranda in my links that I gave. Those pretty much define why Miranda is perfect in my opinion. 

[AlexMBrennan]

And with Miranda being dedicated to Cerebus, quite frankly, I do not trust her.

Given that you don't seem to like her, I'd suggest not picking Miranda.

I personally believe she's the best romance - the only romance - in the series, for these reasons.

You are either delusional, ignorant or deliberately lying because Miranda is not the only romance in the series; the other options exist whether you personally happen to like them or not.

Personally, I find it very difficult to imagine ever trusting a known terrorist under any circumstances, but that's probably just me being weird (respecting the law and such).

[Barquiel]

I thought Miranda's lock in romance is in the apartments, when she asks for alliance resources? As for the topic, I prefer Liara. She has more content and better scenes (imo).

Modifié par Barquiel, 18 octobre 2013 - 07:54 .

[MassivelyEffective0730]

AlexMBrennan wrote...

I personally believe she's the best romance - the only romance - in the series, for these reasons.

You are either delusional, ignorant or deliberately lying because Miranda is not the only romance in the series; the other options exist whether you personally happen to like them or not.

This isn't worth responding too due to its needlessly insulting and arrogant tone. 

That said, Miranda is the only romance for me, as I stipulated. There is no other romantic option. Even if Miranda was not in the game, I would not romance anyone else.

Seriously, get the hell off your high horse kid. You're just as confrontational as David.

Personally, I find it very difficult to imagine ever trusting a known terrorist under any circumstances, but that's probably just me being weird (respecting the law and such).

I'm going to jump straight for the jugular. Why do you think the law is worth obeying? Why do you constrain yourself to one organizations perspective on another's? Is there any kind of subjectivity to your views at all, or do you believe in objective right and wrong?

Modifié par MassivelyEffective0730, 18 octobre 2013 - 08:01 .

[eyezonlyii]

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...

rekn2 wrote...

miranda can take care of herself, she gets things done, she accomplishes goals etc etc.

i see the appeal of liara to some people. shes virginal, young and naive, book smart. but i dont like what they did with her character. imo, its way out of character to have her to be the SB and shes definitely NOT some one i want in a combat situation, they shouldve left her as a civilian

Look at what I wrote about Miranda in my links that I gave. Those pretty much define why Miranda is perfect in my opinion. 

If I remember correctly, it's M!shep that has to make the moves in the Miri romance, and I find that refreshing. That not only is this a strong capable, woman, (not unlike Jack in that regard), but she attempts to divorce her emotions from her goal. And M!shep is the one who falls for her, on her terms. Yes, he kinda has to lead her into the relationship, but to me it's well earned, not just a "WOW you're SHEPARD!!!!:wub::wub:"  Also the fact that she has seen him at his absolute worst (dead), brings you back and still makes Shepard work for it, is phenominal to me. 

[jtav]

Dumping Miranda in the docking bay has unpleasant consequences later.

As for the better of the two go with who you prefer. I find an imported Liaramance rather lackluster, but Cronos on is much better. Miranda's romance is more consistent, but I don't really like her in ME3.

[AlexMBrennan]

You're just as confrontational as David.

To terrorist apologists, maybe.

Why do you think the law is worth obeying? Why do you constrain yourself to one organizations perspective on another's? Is there any kind of subjectivity to your views at all, or do you believe in objective right and wrong?

Good question which I'm sure many wiser people have attempted to answer over the ages. Intuitively, I'd say that the law is worth obeying because otherwise there is no point in having a democracy at all if people will simply ignore laws they do not like.

Of course, all of that is completely academic because you, like any reasonable person, will call for the law to be enforced if anything ever happened to you; however, because this is a video game it's easy to rationalize (i.e. invent reasons for) why Miranda's obviously bad actions are actually alright because liking someone who does bad things creates conflicts.

[Sir DeLoria]

MassivelyEffective0730 wrote...
Seriously, get the hell off your high horse kid. 

Well now, that's ironic:whistle: