Aller au contenu

Photo

set me straight on mattock vs. pistols


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
44 réponses à ce sujet

#1
geezer117

geezer117
  • Members
  • 620 messages
I'mlooking for a light accurate weapon with range for my Huntress. Don't care for the CSR. The BSN loves the mattock, but I can't make the paper comparison agree vs. phalanx and eagle. 

First of all, I did a 10 second test how many mouse clicks I do as fast as I can:  52. That is 5+ mattock shots per second. I wonder if the mattockophiles are actually getting off the shots they think they are. The 4 phalanx shots deliver 4x144=576 damage in one second. 5.2 mattock shots deliver 5.2x130=676 damage. 

But, the mattock recoil is 3, while the phalanx is 0.13. Those phalanx shots are hitting where aimed; the mattock at max finger clicks and higher recoil are sure to have a bigger spread.  

Plus, phalanx at 0.25 weight beats mattock at 0.90. 

The eagle is equally lopsided. It gets an actual 6.7 shots per second at 6.7x108=724 damage, at a weight of 0.25. And recoil is 0.4, much less than mattock. Even my eagle II gets 6.7x89=596 damage for 0.43 weight, nearly as good as my indra VI at half the weight. 

the mattock has a slight accuracy advantage at 65% vs 50% for the pistols, but I think the high recoil works against accuracy. 

I know that in-game counts more than paper comparisons, but what am I missing here? Why choose mattock over a pistol?

#2
Simba501

Simba501
  • Members
  • 2 292 messages
Huntress? Use anything you want. Cloak cooldown takes priority; just cloak right before you do anything.

Modifié par Simba501, 18 octobre 2013 - 09:29 .


#3
HeroicMass

HeroicMass
  • Members
  • 3 579 messages
always use the Eagle

#4
ISHYGDDT

ISHYGDDT
  • Members
  • 6 930 messages
Use a better character.

#5
Sailears

Sailears
  • Members
  • 7 077 messages
Take pistol for the power amp - extra damage on DC is pretty nice for one.

Mattock is horrible - too much finger strain. If you can cope with a scope the valiant is more fun to use.

#6
Wizard of Ox

Wizard of Ox
  • Members
  • 2 658 messages

geezer117 wrote...
Why choose mattock over a pistol?


Because most of the pistols are way better than the Mattock? 

#7
EagleScoutDJB

EagleScoutDJB
  • Members
  • 740 messages
The Mattock is one of my favorite weapons in the game but for a power build I always take a pistol or SMG for the power amplifier.

#8
Moby

Moby
  • Members
  • 5 293 messages
Only 5 shots per second? Tsk tsk.

#9
MGW7

MGW7
  • Members
  • 1 086 messages

MofuggerX wrote...

Only 5 shots per second? Tsk tsk.


If you are on pc can't you set a macro to fire at insane speed without even needing to strain your fingers?

But yeah, five shots manually isn't the best, there are people who can make the mattock fire faster than most of the automatic weapons, and they can do some pretty great damage with it

#10
Moby

Moby
  • Members
  • 5 293 messages
Could use turbo controller on console too... but that's for lamers.

#11
Lucky

Lucky
  • Members
  • 2 677 messages
I'm not a big fan of the Mattock, not worth the effort IMHO.

Why do you want a light cooldown on the huntress? Tac cheat lets you have the same cooldown no mater how heavy of a weapon you use. I recommend the Crusader.

#12
LemurFromTheId

LemurFromTheId
  • Members
  • 3 356 messages
Claymore is sufficiently light and accurate for the Huntress.

#13
geezer117

geezer117
  • Members
  • 620 messages

rlucht wrote...

I'm not a big fan of the Mattock, not worth the effort IMHO.

Why do you want a light cooldown on the huntress? Tac cheat lets you have the same cooldown no mater how heavy of a weapon you use. I recommend the Crusader.


OK that's a new one on me. What is tac cheat, please?

#14
Lucky

Lucky
  • Members
  • 2 677 messages

geezer117 wrote...

rlucht wrote...

I'm not a big fan of the Mattock, not worth the effort IMHO.

Why do you want a light cooldown on the huntress? Tac cheat lets you have the same cooldown no mater how heavy of a weapon you use. I recommend the Crusader.


OK that's a new one on me. What is tac cheat, please?


A BSN hipsterism for tactical cloak.

#15
IllusiveManJr

IllusiveManJr
  • Members
  • 12 265 messages
Tac Cheat is a BSN term I came up with for Tactical Scan, not Tactical Cloak. Use it right.

#16
Lucky

Lucky
  • Members
  • 2 677 messages

IllusiveManJr wrote...

Tac Cheat is a BSN term I came up with for Tactical Scan, not Tactical Cloak. Use it right.


I haz been told Image IPB

#17
OniGanon

OniGanon
  • Members
  • 4 829 messages
People using the Mattock are probably clicking faster than 5/s. If that's your clicking speed, the mattock would be a waste of your time.

For light, accurate weapons I'd be thinking Valiant, Paladin, Executioner, Arc Pistol, Eagle, Indra, Suppressor, Carnifex...

#18
mybudgee

mybudgee
  • Members
  • 23 037 messages
Matlock in ME2 = <3

#19
Mask of Apathy

Mask of Apathy
  • Members
  • 440 messages
I use the Hurricane with Heat Sink and SMG Recoil System. GREAT DPS and very controllable recoil. Also, works well with Warp Ammo and DC. If you are tired of hearing people praise the Crutchcane, then use the Locust. I used to use that before i got the SMG Recoil System and i still scored top in gold when using decent equipment. (must use HVB with it though).

The Locust has supreme accuracy at range of all of the SMGs (and plenty of assault rifles). But if you are dead set on a pistol, I use the phalanx on most of my casters. Yes, the Carnifex or Paladin boast more DPS, same with the eagle. However, the phalanx shots always land where you aim them, has very little recoil (consistent headshot capable), and has a good capacity.

#20
Alien Number Six

Alien Number Six
  • Members
  • 1 900 messages
I use the Mattock on the huntress and do pretty well with it. It dosen't matter what weapon you use on this kit anyway. Her powers do the talking.

#21
Pearl (rip bioware)

Pearl (rip bioware)
  • Members
  • 7 294 messages
Gun doesn't really matter on Huntress, as others have said. Just cloak immediately before using a power and you're good to go.

Since you said you don't care for the CSR, give something like the Hurricane or CSMG a try. Both great caster weapons, just be careful to not overheat if you're using a low-level CSMG.

#22
LemurFromTheId

LemurFromTheId
  • Members
  • 3 356 messages

Alien Number Six wrote...

It dosen't matter what weapon you use on this kit anyway. Her powers do the talking.


FatherOfPearl wrote...

Gun doesn't really matter on Huntress, as others have said. Just cloak immediately before using a power and you're good to go.


Why do people keep saying this stuff? Of course your weapon matters.

Huntress is an infiltrator and cares very little about the weight of her loadout. Use that to your advantage and bring a good weapon: Claymore, Raider, Wraith, Graal, Kishock, Harrier, Saber, Hurricane, CSMG, Talon... You can never reach her full potential if you can't deal a lot of weapon damage along with all the power damage.

#23
Pearl (rip bioware)

Pearl (rip bioware)
  • Members
  • 7 294 messages

Aedolon wrote...

Alien Number Six wrote...

It dosen't matter what weapon you use on this kit anyway. Her powers do the talking.


FatherOfPearl wrote...

Gun doesn't really matter on Huntress, as others have said. Just cloak immediately before using a power and you're good to go.


Why do people keep saying this stuff? Of course your weapon matters.

Huntress is an infiltrator and cares very little about the weight of her loadout. Use that to your advantage and bring a good weapon: Claymore, Raider, Wraith, Graal, Kishock, Harrier, Saber, Hurricane, CSMG, Talon... You can never reach her full potential if you can't deal a lot of weapon damage along with all the power damage.

I mis-spoke. I meant that in the sense that weight doesn't matter, and incorrectly assumed that my meaning was clear.

#24
HusarX

HusarX
  • Members
  • 2 041 messages
U want an accurate pistol... hmmm Talon. Or if you wanna go hipster use the Paladin.

#25
squaredgonzo

squaredgonzo
  • Members
  • 764 messages
wraith or claymore,talon is nice too. but wraith or claymore, talon is nice too. but wraith or claymore. seriously, claymore