Lotion Soronnar wrote...
Why are people expecting everyone to act 100% rational and with full knowledge of everything (hindsight, player knowledge)?
Now THAT would make no sense. (excluding crazy mages everywhere, naturally)
Yes, there were people making stupid moves - but people do that in RL.
Some called Decimus stupid. Paranoid, maybe. But him attacking was not without reason.
Grace? There are poeple who will shift blame around or belive in crazy conspiracies. After all, how does Grace know that you are NOT an agent of the templars and have just been faking your support all the time?
Some people have trouble seeing things from any other perspective than the player characters.
This.
People aren't rational in the heat of the moment, nor when they've been through certain situations. They see it from their perspective which is naturally correct to them, I've had certain ideas that have been completely insane but I didn't see them as insane because they were private, they weren't questioned. But as soon as someone brought it up I realised it myself as well, so yes there should be moments where you can use reason do defuse a situation.
However, there should be moments where you can't no matter how insane their ideas are. Maybe because it's right before combat and they don't give you enough time to explain, and even if there was enough time, as said people aren't rational in the heat of the moment.
So I agree to a certain point but like with everything, it should be done with moderation.
Sorry for any grammatical errors.
Modifié par Huge_Beaver, 18 décembre 2013 - 05:29 .