Aller au contenu

Photo

Mage and Templar Support Thread


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
891 réponses à ce sujet

#301
XxPrincess(x)ThreatxX

XxPrincess(x)ThreatxX
  • Members
  • 2 518 messages

thetinyevil wrote...

Really? The same Cullen who wanted to used the Tranquil Solution. The same one who wanted the mages and templars who went against Meredith tortured and executed. He was as bad as Meredith. The majority of Clergy and Templars see mages as evil curesed creates that either need to be controlled or destroyed.


Mages are dangerous, they need watched & in some cases killed to protect normal people.

#302
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages
The Divine had no choice to let them walk out. Since Wynn pulled a fast one and it wasn't just the mages there that new about the tranquility cure. But of course she also sentenced Pharamond to the living hell that is Tranquility again. The poor man lived a month in hell, without turning into an abomination(shocking I know), before he was mercifully killed. She was weak and let her templars and seekers make all the decisions for her.

#303
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

Threat300 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...

Really? The same Cullen who wanted to used the Tranquil Solution. The same one who wanted the mages and templars who went against Meredith tortured and executed. He was as bad as Meredith. The majority of Clergy and Templars see mages as evil curesed creates that either need to be controlled or destroyed.


Mages are dangerous, they need watched & in some cases killed to protect normal people.

Then I guess they should also pick up people who have mentel illness and kill them to becuase they are dangerous and not normal. Or leaders who have become are unstable, they could send their armies to level village after village for whatever reason, they need to be killed becuase they are dangerous and normal people need to be protected.

Modifié par thetinyevil, 20 décembre 2013 - 12:29 .


#304
SgtSteel91

SgtSteel91
  • Members
  • 1 898 messages
So would that mean that Hawke may not be a wanted criminal if he sided with the Mages?

Cause it sounds like to me that Meredith may have been wrong to call the Annulment

Modifié par SgtSteel91, 20 décembre 2013 - 12:28 .


#305
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages

thetinyevil wrote...

The Divine had no choice to let them walk out. Since Wynn pulled a fast one and it wasn't just the mages there that new about the tranquility cure. But of course she also sentenced Pharamond to the living hell that is Tranquility again. The poor man lived a month in hell, without turning into an abomination(shocking I know), before he was mercifully killed. She was weak and let her templars and seekers make all the decisions for her.

Indeed, she was doing everything the templars and Seekers wanted. That's why Lambert decided to revoke the Nevarran Accord and leave the Chantry, I suppose. It wasn't because the divine aided the mages.

#306
XxPrincess(x)ThreatxX

XxPrincess(x)ThreatxX
  • Members
  • 2 518 messages

thetinyevil wrote...

Threat300 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...

Really? The same Cullen who wanted to used the Tranquil Solution. The same one who wanted the mages and templars who went against Meredith tortured and executed. He was as bad as Meredith. The majority of Clergy and Templars see mages as evil curesed creates that either need to be controlled or destroyed.


Mages are dangerous, they need watched & in some cases killed to protect normal people.

Then I guess they should also pick up people who have mentel illness and kill them to becuase they are dangerous and not normal. Or leaders who have become are unstable, they could send their armies to level village after village for whatever reason, they need to be killed becuase they are dangerous and normal people need to be protected.




People with mental illness don't attract demons & become abominations, they also don't raise the dead & control minds with blood magic

#307
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

hhh89 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...

The Divine had no choice to let them walk out. Since Wynn pulled a fast one and it wasn't just the mages there that new about the tranquility cure. But of course she also sentenced Pharamond to the living hell that is Tranquility again. The poor man lived a month in hell, without turning into an abomination(shocking I know), before he was mercifully killed. She was weak and let her templars and seekers make all the decisions for her.

Indeed, she was doing everything the templars and Seekers wanted. That's why Lambert decided to revoke the Nevarran Accord and leave the Chantry, I suppose. It wasn't because the divine aided the mages.

She went against the templars and seekers once. But that doesn't make up for the fact everything else she did.

You can build a thousand bridges but you kick one puppy you will be know as a puppy kicker for the rest of your life.(Not how the saying actually goes just decided to clean it up)

#308
EmperorSahlertz

EmperorSahlertz
  • Members
  • 8 809 messages

thetinyevil wrote...

Threat300 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...

Really? The same Cullen who wanted to used the Tranquil Solution. The same one who wanted the mages and templars who went against Meredith tortured and executed. He was as bad as Meredith. The majority of Clergy and Templars see mages as evil curesed creates that either need to be controlled or destroyed.


Mages are dangerous, they need watched & in some cases killed to protect normal people.

Then I guess they should also pick up people who have mentel illness and kill them to becuase they are dangerous and not normal. Or leaders who have become are unstable, they could send their armies to level village after village for whatever reason, they need to be killed becuase they are dangerous and normal people need to be protected.

Uhm... Are there a reason to NOT remove any of the ones you mention from public and/or remove them from power and keep an eye on them?
And your "kill them" argument is a non-sequitur, since mages are NOT just killed outright for being mages.

Modifié par EmperorSahlertz, 20 décembre 2013 - 12:41 .


#309
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages
@thetinyevil: Regardless of the fact that I disagree on your point, where I ever said that she's good? All I'm saying is that her opinion is different from Meredith. She helped the mages escape against the templars. If her opinion was the same as Meredith, she would've sided with Lambert.
The face that most pro-mages I saw (even some who are very anti-Chantry) have at least a decent opinion of her, should speak for her being different from Meredith. My point is the not everyone in the templar order and the Chantry are like Meredith. I have you two examples. Do you need others?

Modifié par hhh89, 20 décembre 2013 - 12:43 .


#310
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

EmperorSahlertz wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...

Threat300 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...

Really? The same Cullen who wanted to used the Tranquil Solution. The same one who wanted the mages and templars who went against Meredith tortured and executed. He was as bad as Meredith. The majority of Clergy and Templars see mages as evil curesed creates that either need to be controlled or destroyed.


Mages are dangerous, they need watched & in some cases killed to protect normal people.

Then I guess they should also pick up people who have mentel illness and kill them to becuase they are dangerous and not normal. Or leaders who have become are unstable, they could send their armies to level village after village for whatever reason, they need to be killed becuase they are dangerous and normal people need to be protected.

Uhm... Are there a reason to NOT remove any of the ones you mention from public and/or remove them from power and keep an eye on them?
And your "kill them" argument is a non-sequitur, since mages are NOT just killed outright for being mages.

Right. Sure. Yeah. 

Modifié par thetinyevil, 20 décembre 2013 - 12:52 .


#311
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

hhh89 wrote...

@thetinyevil: Regardless of the fact that I disagree on your point, where I ever said that she's good? All I'm saying is that her opinion is different from Meredith. She helped the mages escape against the templars. If her opinion was the same as Meredith, she would've sided with Lambert.
The face that most pro-mages I saw (even some who are very anti-Chantry) have at least a decent opinion of her, should speak for her being different from Meredith. My point is the not everyone in the templar order and the Chantry are like Meredith. I have you two examples. Do you need others?

Yeah. I do. 

#312
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages

thetinyevil wrote...
Yeah. I do. 


Thrask. Evangeline. Elthina. Gregoir. If you consider her part of the Chantry, Leliana. 

#313
EmperorSahlertz

EmperorSahlertz
  • Members
  • 8 809 messages

hhh89 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...
Yeah. I do. 


Thrask. Evangeline. Elthina. Gregoir. If you consider her part of the Chantry, Leliana. 

I don't think he is actually interested in understanding why he is wrong...

#314
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

hhh89 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...
Yeah. I do. 


Thrask. Evangeline. Elthina. Gregoir. If you consider her part of the Chantry, Leliana. 

Elthina made excuses for Meredith and let her run wild. Leliana is as anti-mage as you can get. Listen to what she has to say when you talk to her during Sebastian quest. She blames the mages completely for what going on in Kirkwall and wants the Exlated March as much as Meredith wants the R.O.A. Gregoir was a P.O.S who beats on pregnant women and hates mages as much as Meredith.

I will give you Thrask and Evangeline.

#315
EmperorSahlertz

EmperorSahlertz
  • Members
  • 8 809 messages
See what I said h to the double h? Can't really work with blind zealotry like that.

Modifié par EmperorSahlertz, 20 décembre 2013 - 01:00 .


#316
Senya

Senya
  • Members
  • 1 266 messages

thetinyevil wrote...

hhh89 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...
Yeah. I do. 


Thrask. Evangeline. Elthina. Gregoir. If you consider her part of the Chantry, Leliana. 

Elthina made excuses for Meredith and let her run wild. Leliana is as anti-mage as you can get. Listen to what she has to say when you talk to her during Sebastian quest. She blames the mages completely for what going on in Kirkwall and wants the Exlated March as much as Meredith wants the R.O.A.loans  Gregoir was a P.O.S who beats on pregnant women and hates mages as much as Meredith.

I will give you Thrask and Evangeline.




If Leliana was anti-mage, why did she help Mages escape the White Spire instead of helping Lambert?

#317
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

EmperorSahlertz wrote...

See what I said h to the double h? Can't really work with blind zealotry like that.

Same could be said for you. You just as blindly zealous.

#318
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages
@thetinyevil: I'm not going to debate again on characters. Even considering your two 'approved' characters, we have four (with Cullen, that disagreed with Meredith on the RoA and Justinia) characters that shown different opinions about Meredith's. So not every templars and priests would be okay with what Meredith did. Which means you were wrong (other than the face that Gaider stated that Meredith would've probably be punished for what she did).

Modifié par hhh89, 20 décembre 2013 - 01:07 .


#319
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

almostinsane99 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...

hhh89 wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...
Yeah. I do. 


Thrask. Evangeline. Elthina. Gregoir. If you consider her part of the Chantry, Leliana. 

Elthina made excuses for Meredith and let her run wild. Leliana is as anti-mage as you can get. Listen to what she has to say when you talk to her during Sebastian quest. She blames the mages completely for what going on in Kirkwall and wants the Exlated March as much as Meredith wants the R.O.A.loans  Gregoir was a P.O.S who beats on pregnant women and hates mages as much as Meredith.

I will give you Thrask and Evangeline.




If Leliana was anti-mage, why did she help Mages escape the White Spire instead of helping Lambert?

Got me there. I just really dislike Leliana. 

#320
Lord Raijin

Lord Raijin
  • Members
  • 2 777 messages

Lotion Soronnar wrote...

Lord Raijin wrote...
David Gaider indicated on another thread that after the Chantry was blown up Meredith invoking the R.o.A was perfectly legal.


Makes sense. Lacking any local higher authority, and with waiting for a reply (which could take weeks or months) being possibly disastrous and out of the question, it is not uncommon for the local commander to have full command.

Circumstances dictate different reponse and solutions.


I can't seem to find the thread, but he clearly said that she was legally bound to invoke the Right now that Elthina is dead.


You are not remembering correctly.
She has a legal right to invoke it, but she wasn't boud to do anything. In fact, DG said her annulment was borderline legal and if she survived, she would have been in a lot of trouble.



I found the thread and this is exactly what David said:

David Gaider wrote...

IanPolaris wrote...
Meridith
is not a member of the Chantry Clergy and certainly not the Grand
Cleric.  She had no more right to declare a Right of Annulment than
KCGregoire did (under far more dire conditions).  She was obligated to
seek permission from Divine Justina in absence of a local Grand Cleric,


And you decided this when, exactly?

A
Knight-Commander is second-in-command next to the Grand Cleric. With
Elthina's death, Meredith was legally in command of the Kirkwall
Chantry-- such as it was, and certainly in the absence of any ranking
Revered Mother or the Divine herself. Cullen's objection was not that
her invocation of the Rite was illegal, it was that it was unjustified.


URL: http://social.biowar...ex/6901812&lf=8 Scroll down until you see this post from him.

Modifié par Lord Raijin, 20 décembre 2013 - 01:08 .


#321
Veruin

Veruin
  • Members
  • 1 237 messages

thetinyevil wrote...

EmperorSahlertz wrote...

See what I said h to the double h? Can't really work with blind zealotry like that.

Same could be said for you. You just as blindly zealous.


I've yet to see Emperor slander people simply because he doesn't like them.

#322
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

hhh89 wrote...

@thetinyevil: I'm not going to debate again on characters. Even considering your two 'approved' characters, we have four (with Cullen, that disagreed with Meredith on the RoA and Justinia) characters that shown different opinions about Meredith's. So not every templars and priests would be okay with what Meredith did. Which means you were wrong (other than the face that Gaider stated that Meredith would've probably be punished for what she did).




A finger waging isn't much of punishment. Cullen disagreed with Meredith only after pretty much every mage was dead and probably only said no because he didn't want an actual challanage by fighting Hawke. He prefers fights against people he can reder helpless butcher to his hearts content. 

Modifié par thetinyevil, 20 décembre 2013 - 01:18 .


#323
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

Veruin wrote...

thetinyevil wrote...

EmperorSahlertz wrote...

See what I said h to the double h? Can't really work with blind zealotry like that.

Same could be said for you. You just as blindly zealous.


I've yet to see Emperor slander people simply because he doesn't like them.

Neither have I. But this has nothing to do with the the comment. Also unlike Emperor if I am wrong I will admit it and I will consider what other people say. 

Modifié par thetinyevil, 20 décembre 2013 - 01:16 .


#324
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages
@thetinyevil: Cullen stated this earlier than the final confrontation. There were mages who surrendered and Cullen goes against Meredith, that wants them killed. Meredith ask Cullened if he was willing to be responsible for what would've happened if those mages would turn our to be blood mages, and Cullen said yes, because he believes that this is what a templar duty is about. Or something similar. Plus, he disagreed that the Circle should be Annulled.

Modifié par hhh89, 20 décembre 2013 - 01:20 .


#325
Master Warder Z_

Master Warder Z_
  • Members
  • 19 819 messages

almostinsane99 wrote...

Would people on here kill each other if they were in Thedas?

Just wondering...


Yes :)