[quote]101ezylonhxeT wrote...
[quote]EmperorSahlertz wrote...
[quote]101ezylonhxeT wrote...
[quote]EmperorSahlertz wrote...
[quote]101ezylonhxeT wrote...
If bioware were to do this it would mean we can't play as mages anymore and not being able to play as a mage is a deal breaker for me because the other 2 classess are 100% boring.
[/quote]
A bit of a premature blanket statement since you havn't played any future DA games, no?
[/quote]
Any future DA game without mages or I am unable to play as a mage = boring game and not worth my time to play.
[/quote]
You just did it again..
[/quote]
Ok hypothetically if Bioware were to do this i wouldn't buy DA4.
[/quote]
LOLwut? It would be based on player choice and it wouldn't reach all mages. Even if it did then it would be limited to your world where you made that choice.
[quote]Nefla wrote...
It will be one of 3 choices:
-merge all life with demons and everyone becomes an abomination against their will ( inquisitor has to die)
-inquisitor's personality is used as a template for an ultra mega demon that controls all the others (inquisitor has to die)
-kill all demons but all mages randomly become tranquil (inquisitor lives for 1 second if you play multiplayer)[/quote]
Where did you get this information from? Damn! Now I have to think of new endings to send to Bioware!
[quote]TheKomandorShepard wrote...
[quote]Elton John is dead wrote...
I think most of us templar supporters are joking. At least I am when I say
"burn all mages!" and I actually want a circle system back but one that's fairer on mages.
And TheKomandorShepard, it's not sadism since it did serve a purpose. Maybe some of the templars in Kirkwall were sadists but then so were many of the free mages who were also blood mages.[/quote]
It is sadism because it doesn't serve a purpose killing mages is less di*** quicker and less expensive than that solution so only reason behind this is deliver individual fate worse than dead so person who want to do that have serious issues.
[/quote]
Think about it. Not all templars want to kill those who fail their test and the tranquil solution was invented so that they might still live even if devoid of emotion. Kurremurre also made some good points you ignored. But okay, you think it's rape. Whatever. It's an evil thing. We agree on that. This thread isn't about advocating it or even defending it, I'm simply proposing what the consequences could be and I think that's an interesting discussion.
[quote]Magdalena11 wrote...
[quote]TheKomandorShepard wrote...
[quote]Elton John is dead wrote...
Well it's not mind rape either
unless this is your definition of it.That's the first time I've ever heard someone liken tranquility to rape. It's an evil thing but it's neither sadism nor sexual.[/quote]
Well it is sadism that serves no other purpose than kick dogs something i will rape your wife and then burn her i could kill her immediately but nah im screwd up so i will choose option that gives more suffering with smiliar effect.
[/quote]
Imposing tranquility on an unwilling mage would be similar to rape because it is imposing your will to violate and inflict harm on another person. Rape is a crime of violence, not sex. Sadism is deriving satisfaction from inflicting harm on others. I think the analogy is valid.
@TheKomandorShepherd - Your posts have become much easier to read and you're making your points much more clearly. Well done!
[/quote]
But what templar derived pleasure from making a mage tranquil? Again I'm not arguing it's a good thing, your taking away personal will, reason and emotion but I don't see how it can be sadism when not many templars enjoy doing it if DA:O is anything to go by.
[quote]Emrys Ansgar wrote...
I think most people in this thread are forgetting just how large of a role mages played betting the Qunari and without mages how quickly Thedas would fall to the Qun.[/quote]
Not many are supporting it. Remember there are personal opinions and role-playing ones. Sending out this order as the Inquisitor would clearly make for some interesting consequences and ones I would like to see in a play-through as a ruthless character who absolutely hates all mages. No one said anything about it being the
"go to choice" because it's clearly the worst solution but also one of the few which would have a world-wide impact which could lead to interesting ramifications.
Of course I don't see Bioware putting in such a choice and even if they did it wouldn't reach every mage. But hypothetically it asks what would happen to the world.
But I think Thedas would survive without mages against the qunari especially if they united. In fact it was the alliance of the Andrastian Chantry with the Imperium Chantry that really turned the tables on the qunari. Mages helped but I reckon the war would have been won without them.
Modifié par Elton John is dead, 29 décembre 2013 - 11:42 .