256 réponses à ce sujet

[Sebby]

OMEGAlomaniac wrote...

Am I the only one that thinks it's odd sites put cross platform games on these lists? :/

Not necessarily, some cross platform games are simply flat out better on the 360 and are the "true" version(case and point Bayonetta).

Oh and LOL @this story.

[AresKeith]

Mesina2 wrote...
List is hugely unprofessionally made.

IGN

[Sebby]

AresKeith wrote...

Mesina2 wrote...
List is hugely unprofessionally made.

IGN

Can't spell "ignorant" without....

[CroGamer002]

AresKeith wrote...

Mesina2 wrote...
List is hugely unprofessionally made.

IGN

Even for IGN, this is very unprofessional.

[CroGamer002]

Cthulhu42 wrote...

spirosz wrote...

I should reword that, 25 good exclusive games.

I can't think of a single one except Gears of War.

Well Halo games since 3( 1, 2 are on PC too), Fable 2, Dead Rising 1 and... eh, that's all I can think off.

[Kingthlayer]

This list is honestly pretty horrible. Mass Effect should not be included in as a trilogy. The third game should not be in a top 25 list of any sorts, Mass Effect 1 is top 10, Mass Effect 2 might slip in somewhere.

Dragon Age: Origins, Grand Theft Auto 4, Oblivion, Witcher 2 not be included hurts the list.

But at the end of the day it's just IGN, their list is honestly no different than me and a few friends getting high and listing our own favourite games and posting it on YouTube. IGN staffers have no more expertise in the industry than anybody else, just some college kids writing horrible reviews and sucking up to EA.

[spirosz]

Big Mac Heart Attack wrote...

This list is honestly pretty horrible. Mass Effect should not be included in as a trilogy. The third game should not be in a top 25 list of any sorts, Mass Effect 1 is top 10, Mass Effect 2 might slip in somewhere.

Dragon Age: Origins, Grand Theft Auto 4, Oblivion, Witcher 2 not be included hurts the list.

But at the end of the day it's just IGN, their list is honestly no different than me and a few friends getting high and listing our own favourite games and posting it on YouTube. IGN staffers have no more expertise in the industry than anybody else, just some college kids writing horrible reviews and sucking up to EA.

Don't have a heart attack now.  

[AresKeith]

spirosz wrote...

Big Mac Heart Attack wrote...

This list is honestly pretty horrible. Mass Effect should not be included in as a trilogy. The third game should not be in a top 25 list of any sorts, Mass Effect 1 is top 10, Mass Effect 2 might slip in somewhere.

Dragon Age: Origins, Grand Theft Auto 4, Oblivion, Witcher 2 not be included hurts the list.

But at the end of the day it's just IGN, their list is honestly no different than me and a few friends getting high and listing our own favourite games and posting it on YouTube. IGN staffers have no more expertise in the industry than anybody else, just some college kids writing horrible reviews and sucking up to EA.

Don't have a heart attack now.  

He should lay off the Big Macs

[Funkcase]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

J. Reezy wrote...

Gears of War >>>>>>

Whatever though.

ME is a Gears clone, after all.

Gears of war isn't exactly original either..

Borrowing some mechanics doesn't make a game a clone;  in that case all survival horror games are clones of Alone in the dark (even if they're better) and all RPGs are clones of Fallout and Baldurs gate,  even though they weren't original (Wasteland), and The Witcher 2's combat reminds me of Batman Arkham asylum. 

Modifié par Funkcase, 05 janvier 2014 - 10:52 .

[The Night Mammoth]

That's the ****tiest Top 'X' games of 'X' list I've ever seen.

Mass Effect is a top ten series, personally, but when it's got competition like fething Rock Band 3, a bunch of forgettable indie games and random stuff like Mirror's Edge and Batman: Arkham City, no wonder it grabbed the top spot.

Modifié par The Night Mammoth, 05 janvier 2014 - 10:55 .

[Kingthlayer]

AresKeith wrote...

spirosz wrote...

Big Mac Heart Attack wrote...

This list is honestly pretty horrible. Mass Effect should not be included in as a trilogy. The third game should not be in a top 25 list of any sorts, Mass Effect 1 is top 10, Mass Effect 2 might slip in somewhere.

Dragon Age: Origins, Grand Theft Auto 4, Oblivion, Witcher 2 not be included hurts the list.

But at the end of the day it's just IGN, their list is honestly no different than me and a few friends getting high and listing our own favourite games and posting it on YouTube. IGN staffers have no more expertise in the industry than anybody else, just some college kids writing horrible reviews and sucking up to EA.

Don't have a heart attack now.  

He should lay off the Big Macs

Don't be hating.

[spirosz]

The Night Mammoth wrote...

That's the ****tiest Top 'X' games of 'X' list I've ever seen.

Mass Effect is a top ten series, personally, but when it's got competition like fething Rock Band 3, Halo 4, a bunch of forgettable indie games and random stuff like Mirror's Edge and Batman: Arkham City, no wonder it grabbed the top spot.

LIMBO is a forgettable indie game?  

[AresKeith]

The Night Mammoth wrote...

That's the ****tiest Top 'X' games of 'X' list I've ever seen.

Mass Effect is a top ten series, personally, but when it's got competition like fething Rock Band 3, Halo 4, a bunch of forgettable indie games and random stuff like Mirror's Edge and Batman: Arkham City, no wonder it grabbed the top spot.

IGN

[spirosz]

Big Mac Heart Attack wrote...

AresKeith wrote...

spirosz wrote...

Big Mac Heart Attack wrote...

This list is honestly pretty horrible. Mass Effect should not be included in as a trilogy. The third game should not be in a top 25 list of any sorts, Mass Effect 1 is top 10, Mass Effect 2 might slip in somewhere.

Dragon Age: Origins, Grand Theft Auto 4, Oblivion, Witcher 2 not be included hurts the list.

But at the end of the day it's just IGN, their list is honestly no different than me and a few friends getting high and listing our own favourite games and posting it on YouTube. IGN staffers have no more expertise in the industry than anybody else, just some college kids writing horrible reviews and sucking up to EA.

Don't have a heart attack now.  

He should lay off the Big Macs

Don't be hating.

Dont' be so stressed over something that has no concern to you, Mac Attack. 

Modifié par spirosz, 05 janvier 2014 - 10:54 .

[Nole]

This place disgusts me. Especially now with the increment of otakus.

[spirosz]

WittingEight65 wrote...

This place disgusts me. Especially now with the increment of otakus.

You seem to have a lot of obsessive interests in this digusting place, sis. 

[Nole]

spirosz wrote...

WittingEight65 wrote...

This place disgusts me. Especially now with the increment of otakus.

You seem to have a lot of obsessive interests in this digusting place, sis. 

It was a decent place...once.

[Sebby]

Funkcase wrote...

The Mad Hanar wrote...

J. Reezy wrote...

Gears of War >>>>>>

Whatever though.

ME is a Gears clone, after all.

Gears of war isn't exactly original either..

Borrowing some mechanics doesn't make a game a clone;  in that case all survival horror games are clones of Alone in the dark (even if they're better) and all RPGs are clones of Fallout and Baldurs gate,  even though they weren't original (Wasteland), and The Witcher 2's combat reminds me of Batman Arkham asylum. 

Given how ME2 and 3 removed a lot of ME1's RPG elements(stats, inventory,exploration,etc) and how their prime selling points like narrative/story and choices carring over(nevermind choices made in the game itself) turned out to be a dud, and how all that's left is the shooting mechanics, then yes it does.One has to be pretty willfully ignorant to ignore how ME2 is more of a TPS than 1 .Being in denial of that is akin to thinking that Witcher 2 isn't more of
a hack and slash game than the original, it simply isn't so.

Outside of the spellcasting/TPS hybrid mechanic, the games are sub-par Gears clones with dialogue options(3 manages to be the best at being one).

[spirosz]

WittingEight65 wrote...

spirosz wrote...

WittingEight65 wrote...

This place disgusts me. Especially now with the increment of otakus.

You seem to have a lot of obsessive interests in this digusting place, sis. 

It was a decent place...once.

 

It still very is one, you choose to open up threads like this or involve yourself in participating, no?  

[spirosz]

Seboist wrote...


Given how ME2 and 3 removed a lot of ME1's RPG elements(stats, inventory,exploration,etc) a

Going to copy and paste planets = a sense of exploration?  Interesting.  You call that inventory an RPG element, I call it a terrible execution of an RPG "element" and the stats were very well done in ME3 or do you choose to ignore that?