30 réponses à ce sujet

[Pateu]

 Assume the fights take place in the Denerim Market square.


1. The Warden vs Hawke

2. Alistair vs Aveline

3. Sten vs Fenris

4. Morrigan vs Merril

5. Wynne vs Anders

6. Leliana vs Varric

7. Zevran vs Isabela

8. Shale vs the Arishok

[naddaya]

1. Warden. My Warden was an Arcane Warrior, it's not even fair.

2. Tough one. I'd say Alistair, but not by much.

3. Sten

4. Morrigan

5. Wynne. She almost became First Enchanter.

6. Varric?

7. Another tough one. Zev.

8. The Arishok. That guy was a chore to kill.

I loved the companions in DA2, but the DAO party is more experienced.

[cJohnOne]

1. The Warden defeats Hawke because his story is more epic.

2. Aveline defeats Alistair 'cause she's mean.

3. Sten defeats  Fenris 'cause he's qunari.

4. Morrigan defeats Merril  'cause she's badass.

5.  Anders defeats wynne 'cause he's a guy.

6. Varric  defeats Leliana because Varric has a better skill tree.

7. Zevran defeats Isabela but it's close because Zevran is master assassin but Isabela is a duelist.

8. the Arishok pummels Shale.  Shouldn't be close.

[thats1evildude]

1. Depends on class and circumstance.

2. Alistair, if only because sword and shield warriors were tougher in DAO.

3. Fenris. Sten was a glass cannon in DAO and Fenris' lyrium markings give him more durability.

4. Merrill can soak up tremendous damage and blood magic easily trumps shape changing, assuming Morrigan hasn't figured out her mom's dragon trick.

5. Pretty close, but Anders is more geared for offence than Wynne.

6. At range, Varric has the edge. But Leliana is more deadly in close quarters, so it depends on when and how they fight.

7. Zevran, by a hair.

8. The Arishok was quite a bit tougher than Shale.

Modifié par thats1evildude, 23 février 2014 - 08:17 .

[ShadowLordXII]

1. Good one. Hawke's faster, but the Warden is tougher. The Warden has more varied skills and abilities across every class including having more specialities, but Hawke has enough to match it. Ultimately it comes down to experience and strategy which I'm giving to the Warden. The Warden's accomplishments encompass everything that Hawke has done and much more.

2. Seeing that Alistair was able to match and defeat Stenshok, I don't see any reason why he couldn't beat Aveline.

3. Sten's strong, but Fenris can use his lyrium tattoos to reach into people's hearts and crush them. Even then, Fenris is strong enough to match Sten blow for blow and considerable faster as well.

4. All Merrill has to do is Blood Wound Morrigan in place and it's pretty much over from there.

5. No contest, Wynne is more experienced, more skilled, more mature and much more level-headed. Anders wouldn't have a chance.

6. Tough...Leliana has the advantage up close, but Varric is good at long range. Ultimately, I'd say Varric as he would be quick and agile enough to utilize Bianca at close range and Leliana is a bit rusty from her bard days.

7. They'd end up in bed after a stalemate battle...fight again and then back to bed, rinse and lather until they depart after a "parting" dance. But in all seriousness, Zevran has been fooled by pretty face in the past and Isabella doesn't exactly play nice when all things come down to the wire.

8. The Arishok is strong, but Shale can pick up boulders and throw them with one hand. She can also punch the ground hard enough to emulate an earthquake. If Shale can pick up boulders as large as she is with one hand, think of what she'll do with the Arishok! Exactly what she does to birds.

Modifié par ShadowLordXII, 23 février 2014 - 10:09 .

[Lady Sif]

1. The Warden
2. Alistair
3. Fenris
4. Morrigan
5. Wynne
6. Leliana
7. Isabela
8. Shale

[Aurelet]

1. The Warden vs Hawke

Warden - My Hawke was a wimp who couldn't even keep his own companions in line.

2. Alistair vs Aveline

Close one but I think Alistair would pull it out.  He beat Loghain after all.

3. Sten vs Fenris

I think Fenris would take Sten. The Lyrium Ghost thing is pretty cool.

4. Morrigan vs Merril

Morrigan-She'd distract Merril with kittens then kill all of them while they weren't looking.

5. Wynne vs Anders

I think Anders could take Wynne

6. Leliana vs Varric

Varric  He has Bianca to back him up.

7. Zevran vs Isabela
Isabela would easily distract Zevran with cleavage and then stab him where it hurts.
8. Shale vs the Arishok

Shale - The Arishok couldn't get through the first layer of rock.

[KANDIRIT]

1. Depends

2. Aveline

3. Fenris

4. Morrigan

5. Anders

6. Leliana

7. Zevran

8. Shale

[Pateu]

imo it's

 

1. Warden by a landslide. Hawke fought the Arishok and a High Dragon, The Warden fought and killed the Archdemon, Branka/Cairdin, Flemeth, The Architect, The Mother.

 

He has leadership, experience and superior equipment. 

 

2. Alistair rather easily.

 

Aveline is a sturdy woman, sure, but she is nothing out of the ordinary.

 

Alistair is an ex-templar, a Grey Warden that fought through the Blight with The Warden and a king.

 

He wins in the training/equipment department by a landslide.

 

3. Sten.

 

Bigger, stronger, fought his whole life.

 

Fenris was a slave.

 

4. Morrigan.

 

I don't know how much Blood Magic Merril knows ( she seems completely oblivious to how powerful demons are ) but The Dark Ritual puts Morrigan way above her in my eyes, as far as Blood Magic knowledge goes.

 

That and when she runs out of mana she can just go spider form.

 

5. I'd say Wynne.

 

I do not know if her spirit is stronger than Justice, but she is surely more skilled and experienced than Anders is.

 

6. Leliana, due to being a top tier bard and having superior experience.

 

Varric was nothing extraordinary until he met Hawke, Leliana ran with the big guys back in Orlais.

 

7. Zevran, no question.

 

Isabella is good against sloppy brawlers, but Zevran is an assassin, not an amateur.

 

8. The Arishok.

[dragonflight288]

Hard to say.

 

My Warden would kick my Hawke's butt. 

 

Alistair and Aveline would give it a good go, but Alistair is a Grey Warden, with all the natural strength that comes from the taint, and he beat Loghain and Stenashok, so I'd give it to Alistair.

 

Based on how much damage they gave out and how much they could take in my party, I'd say Fenris is tougher than Sten.

 

I love Merrill, I really do, but Morrigan would kick her butt any day of the week. 

 

Hmm, Wynne vs Anders...doesn't matter. I executed Anders and Wynne died in Asunder. 

 

Leliana and Varric is also a tough one. Chances are they'd stop fighting, tell each other a few stories, Leliana would try to seduce him, he'd buy her a pint, and they would leave each other with a butt load of stories of varying truth. 

 

Zevran and Isabella would start out fighting and end up making love before agreeing to try again later. 

 

Arishok would beat Shale.. 

[Undead Han]

Any Warden would destroy any Hawke. Like not even close. Hawke might get one-shotted.

[VucraTheGreat]

Warden - A tainted grey warden, champion of the realm, who single handedly beat the Arch demon would destroy the sloppy Champion.

 

Alistair - ex templar, fought alongside the Hero of Fereldan, helped killing the Arch Demon , tainted, more experienced in warfare.

 

Fenris - has the lyrium tatoos that make him extremely strong, sten is not used fighting that type of foe.

 

Morrigan - Master survivalist, extremely knowledgeable, experienced, daughter of the Witch of the Wilds.

 

Wyne - More experienced, First Enchanter would -be . Not being an obnoxious brat helps alot too..

 

Leliana -Very tough.... , but she fought as well with the Hero of Ferelden, and is more experienced. She knows tricks from back when she was a bard.

 

Zevran - cold blooded killer, reckless and fearsome. A professional, all life trained assassin. It-s close but hes methodic execution would win him the match.

 

Arishok - dudes a goddamn beast

[queencousland]

1My Warden  would win because she's so badass and defeated a fraking archdemon while Hawke only watched Merideth destroy herself.

2Aveline ause she can run 5 miles while carrying a cow over her head

3Sten and Asala because he's a giant Qunari.

4Morrigan because Merril would get distracted by a rainbow or butterfly

5Wyne because she's older and wiser and has a spirit in her that hasn't turned crazy.

6Leliana cause once she gets close enough Bianca doesn't stand a chance.

7Isabela cause you know, cleavage

8I think that would be a really long fight that I would fall asleep watching before it ended.

[themikefest]

Warden

Aveline

Sten

Morrigan

Wynne

Leliana

Isabela

Arishok

[Icy Magebane]

Warden

Aveline

Fenris

Merrill

Anders

Varric

Zevran

Arishok

[WarriorOfLight999]

1) Warden. No matter the class/spec, Wardens gain advantages from the Joining. Not to mention the kill record....

2) Alistair. Also a Warden

3) Tough. Sten is better trained, but Fenris has the markings. Could go either way.

4) Morrigan, without question.

5) Wynne has more experience, and while an Abomination, she's much more level headed in battle.

6) Draw

7) Isabela

8) The Arishok is mighty, but Shale is made out of stone.

[JJ Likeaprayer]

1.My Warden and my Hawke could go at it for hours,because my Warden can summon 3 animals fight alongside him,but my Hawke can cast fire ball rain.

2.Aveline,no doubt,she's Lara Croft in DA!

3.Sten,once he gets crazy,he's really crazy!

4.Morrigan,I just don't see Merill has any chance against a dragon.

5.Wynne,the older mage with more experience of course.

6.Leliana,because she could use both arrows and daggers,Varric is so f*ing stubborn with Bianca.

7.Isabela,she stabs she disappears and she kicks in the crotch!

8.Shale,the Arishok is strong but no flesh is stronger than rock!

[Catilina]

Warden (higher level, than Hawke, and know much more useful magic schole: shapeshifter, spirit healer, keeper, and elemental + spirit. Hawke only know force and blood magic, and Hawke strongly aoe-specced, not single tartget, warden have better chance against one man. [The comparison is subjective: my main warden and my main Hawke.])

Aveline (Alistair are a king.Out of practice.)

Fenris (lirium ghost warrior seems strong)

Morrigan 

Wynne (more stable, than Anders... and still alive – it is not a handicap)

Leliana (professional)

Zevran (professional)

Shale (stone)

[GoldenGail3]

1. Warden. My Hawke is a wimpy Mage. All he'd be is a distraction to my Templar/Champion sword and shields Cousland

2. Aveline

3. Fenris

4. Morrigan, she'd beat Merril by her own merit

5. Varric, oh my gosh, if he lost I'd be sad.

6. Isabela. Beast power! Zev would get dristacted by her breasts and end up losing

7. Shale. She'd pummel the puny Arishock.

[MzChaos]

1. Hawke 

2. Aveline

3. Fenris

4. Morrigan

 

5. Wynne

 

6. Leliana

7. Isabela

8. Shale 

 

My Mage-Hawk could take out my Sword and Shield Warden with no problem.

Aveline seemed to me to be a lot more aggressive and better at fighting than Alistair.

Fenris has his lyrium tattoos and is smaller and faster.

Morrigan... she'd win just by giving Merril one of those looks.

Wynne would beat the snot out of Anders.

Bianca isn't as fast as Leliana at reloading and firing.

Isabela and Zevran would be close, after all he was with the Crows and was trained to kill from a very early age, but Isabela's been a captain of a ship... full of men... doing all types of piratey things.

Shale... huge rock creature who feels no pain.  Would love to hear them in a conversation though.

[Artona]

1. Well, I don't see any point in comparing Warden and Hawke since they both have unspecified class and Warden can be human, or elf, or dwarf. My Warden with two-handed Vigilance and in Sentinel's armour would probably beat sassy rogue Hawke, but why would they fight in the first place?
 

2. In depends. I think Aveline would start having a chance with Alistair around seventh year - assuming Alistair didn't became drunk and stayed with Grey Warden (as a king he wouldn't have had much time for practice).

 

3. I believe Sten's superior training would prevail.

 

4. That's interesting pairing. Merril has blood magic, and that gives her an edge, but on the other hand she is nice and innocent, while Morrigan is ruthless. I can imagine that Merril would be winning, then Morrigan would surender and of course Merril would stop attacking... just to die from unexpected treacherous spell. 

5. I would say Anders, because Justice seem to be much more powerful spirit - for me. 

 

6. Since Leliana is designers favourite pet, I think answer is obvious... But honestly, Varrik doesn't strike me like a fighting type, so he would probably lose, I think.

 

7. Zevran, no doubt. He is skilled assasin. 

 

8. Arishok. That bastard was tough and absolutely not squishy. 

[Midnight Bliss]

1. Warden
2. Aveline
3. Sten
4. Morrigan
5. Anders
6. Leliana
7. Zevran
8. Arishok

[AnimalBoy]

Hawke
Aveline
Fenris
Morrigan
Anders
Leliana 
Zevran 
Shale 

[sylvanaerie]

1. Good one. Hawke's faster, but the Warden is tougher. The Warden has more varied skills and abilities across every class including having more specialities, but Hawke has enough to match it. Ultimately it comes down to experience and strategy which I'm giving to the Warden. The Warden's accomplishments encompass everything that Hawke has done and much more.

2. Seeing that Alistair was able to match and defeat Stenshok, I don't see any reason why he couldn't beat Aveline.

3. Sten's strong, but Fenris can use his lyrium tattoos to reach into people's hearts and crush them. Even then, Fenris is strong enough to match Sten blow for blow and considerable faster as well.

4. All Merrill has to do is Blood Wound Morrigan in place and it's pretty much over from there.

5. No contest, Wynne is more experienced, more skilled, more mature and much more level-headed. Anders wouldn't have a chance.

6. Tough...Leliana has the advantage up close, but Varric is good at long range. Ultimately, I'd say Varric as he would be quick and agile enough to utilize Bianca at close range and Leliana is a bit rusty from her bard days.

7. They'd end up in bed after a stalemate battle...fight again and then back to bed, rinse and lather until they depart after a "parting" dance. But in all seriousness, Zevran has been fooled by pretty face in the past and Isabella doesn't exactly play nice when all things come down to the wire.

8. The Arishok is strong, but Shale can pick up boulders and throw them with one hand. She can also punch the ground hard enough to emulate an earthquake. If Shale can pick up boulders as large as she is with one hand, think of what she'll do with the Arishok! Exactly what she does to birds.

 

LOL this is SO Zevran (unromanced) and Isabela.  Not to mention, her bosom isn't magical but it is epic.  Serious distraction factor there.  

 

As for OP, Shadowlord answered what I think/feel quite nicely already, so...ditto, with one exception.  Both warden and Hawke are PC's.  How they do their different professions varies from warden to warden and Hawke to Hawke.  So, to be safe, I'd call that fight a stalemate.

 

And my Kit Hawke would offer my Neria Surana a drink at the Gnawed Noble after to relax and listen to Varric and Leliana spin some tales, because no hard feelings.

[Artona]

"Who would win in a fight - Andraste or Archdemon?" .