Aller au contenu

Photo

Suggestion- "Helpful Member" Tag


50 réponses à ce sujet

#1
LPPrince

LPPrince
  • Members
  • 54 738 messages

So, given we've just moved into a new stage of Bioware forum life, everyone's a bit clueless, running into things, and looking around for help. Help is being given by pretty much everyone, naturally.

 

But down the road, there's going to be people in need of help with various things, whether its game trivia, getting around the forum, needing a particular thing, etc etc.

 

On various other forums, those members with a good track record of helping others and being positive in the community are attributed a "Good Member" or "Helpful Member" tag(latter is preferable), so as to let people know that if they need assistance with something trivial, they can trust whomever has the tag to help them.

 

No extra privileges are awarded, no responsibilities or tasks are given, its just helpful for those in need of information or assistance to know that the tagged person is typically ready and willing to assist and if they can't, will help redirect to someone who can.

 

This is chosen by management, usually discussed between moderators and developers(depending on the forum and what its for), and given on a case by case basis.

 

I don't recall Bioware forums ever using a system like this, but I'm throwing it out there as an idea to be considered in the future. I remember seeing quite a few people come to certain posters for help with various things, whether it was uploading an avatar on the BSN to asking a question about a particular game, and a lot of times, these people who need help end up asking the wrong people for assistance and get trolled HARD.

 

That clearly sucks, and does nothing for forum positivity. So I wonder, if it was made evident to those in need of help that a particular user was the kind of person you could trust with a question about various subjects, or could direct to someone with the answer, would it be proactive to make that evident with a "Helpful Member" tag?

 

I can think of a few people who helped me dearly and repeatedly in the past, and not just me but others as well. I feel like down the line some may be lost about who to come to, but a tag such as this can help them get the help they need from posters as helpful as they were.

 

This is under the assumption that the Bioware forums are an optimistic enough place to not assume these helpful people are being put on a pedestal or being made to look like a special group. If the majority feels that way, then the tags would do nothing but hurt.

 

I'm curious if the Bioware team has considered this before? Shut the idea down for whatever reason? Held it in thought for later implementation? Its certainly not necessary, now or even later, but I think it has the potential to be a benefit.


  • CroGamer002 aime ceci

#2
Billy-the-Squid

Billy-the-Squid
  • Members
  • 393 messages

I propose a "wind up merchant" tag. Dibs by the way.



#3
Captain Crash

Captain Crash
  • Members
  • 6 933 messages

Personally I think a post should be treated on indivual merit, it shouldn't depend on who posted it (A developer or moderator being the exception here of course).  Frankly Im a little annoyed seeing a post count, treating everyone on an even footing was great idea.  I mention the post count because those who post a lot are more likely to get that title. Doesn't mean that their contribution is any more or less helpfull then someone who posts for the first time.

 

If you see a face and you already know they post good responces it's something you will consider as helpfull.  A badge or title shouldn't be needed.



#4
spirosz

spirosz
  • Members
  • 16 354 messages

If you see a face and you already know they post good responces it's something you will consider as helpfull.  A badge or title shouldn't be needed.



#5
LPPrince

LPPrince
  • Members
  • 54 738 messages

If you see a face and you already know they post good responses it's something you will consider as helpful.  A badge or title shouldn't be needed.

 

The whole point of this suggestion is to help those who don't know the helpful people around here.



#6
Captain Crash

Captain Crash
  • Members
  • 6 933 messages

The whole point of this suggestion is to help those who don't know the helpful people around here.

 

Thus the first part that a post should be treated on indivual merit, it shouldn't depend on who posted it.



#7
LPPrince

LPPrince
  • Members
  • 54 738 messages

Thus the first part that a post should be treated on indivual merit, it shouldn't depend on who posted it.

 

Then what would you suggest? Flagging individual posts as helpful? Threads?



#8
Animositisomina

Animositisomina
  • Members
  • 2 699 messages

Then what would you suggest? Flagging individual posts as helpful? Threads?

 

This made me realize something: we no longer have the ability to rate threads. That was (sometimes) a good way to spot a thread worth checking out on the old forum. Now they're all just one big mass of random threads with no indication of what the general public thinks of them.



#9
MegaIllusiveMan

MegaIllusiveMan
  • Members
  • 4 440 messages

Yah. I agree with this.

 

Specially when trolls atack :pinched:

 

@Animositisomina: Well, you can check if they are hot, which means that various people frequent it...



#10
Animositisomina

Animositisomina
  • Members
  • 2 699 messages

Yah. I agree with this.

 

Specially when trolls atack :pinched:

 

@Animositisomina: Well, you can check if they are hot, which means that various people frequent it...

 

True, I forgot about that.



#11
LPPrince

LPPrince
  • Members
  • 54 738 messages

A thread can be "hot" for any number of reasons. Thats definitely not a marker for anything besides, "there's a lot of activity here"



#12
Animositisomina

Animositisomina
  • Members
  • 2 699 messages

A thread can be "hot" for any number of reasons. Thats definitely not a marker for anything besides, "there's a lot of activity here"

 

Hmm... also true. There have been plenty of terrible threads that got a lot of traffic in the past.



#13
Ninja Stan

Ninja Stan
  • Members
  • 5 238 messages

A thread can be "hot" for any number of reasons. Thats definitely not a marker for anything besides, "there's a lot of activity here"

A user tagged as "Helpful" may also not be a marker for anything besides "posts a lot."



#14
LPPrince

LPPrince
  • Members
  • 54 738 messages

A user tagged as "Helpful" may also not be a marker for anything besides "posts a lot."

 

Wouldn't that be up to the mods and devs, though? I doubt they'd randomly decide, "This person has posted a million times, they're cool"

 

I'd think they'd do it on a case by case basis. I recall a few times when a dev thanked a user for being helpful and kind to another- thats what I'm referring to.



#15
metatheurgist

metatheurgist
  • Members
  • 2 429 messages

Some sites have a "Rep" meter. But I don't know how reliable those are, usually ends up being the same bunch of people patting themselves on the back. Maybe if rep was only awarded/removed by Mods?



#16
LPPrince

LPPrince
  • Members
  • 54 738 messages

Some sites have a "Rep" meter. But I don't know how reliable those are, usually ends up being the same bunch of people patting themselves on the back. Maybe if rep was only awarded/removed by Mods?

 

Don't look at it that way. This would have nothing to do with rep points or anything that can be affected by outside people. Its purely on a case by case reputation basis as decided by mods and devs.

 

For example, mods will give a break to a newbie who breaks a rule, but won't be so easy on someone who's been here a while since they should know what they're doing by this point.

 

Same thing here. A "Helpful Member" would be someone mods and devs have recognized as a helpful person around the boards who does good things for others, instead of someone who's notorious for distracting, trolling, spamming, etc etc

 

Numbers would have no effect on the distinction. It couldn't be boiled down to a value. Its all about how you're known across the forum. And how you're known around the forum is one of the many things taken into account already by mods and devs, in the case of making someone a moderator.

 

Except in this case, it wouldn't be for moderating. Just for helping new folk, the clueless, those in need of help, etc etc.

 

Might actually make the PM boxes of mods and devs a little lighter and easier to deal with, so they can just handle rule breaks instead of having a million backlogged questions.



#17
spirosz

spirosz
  • Members
  • 16 354 messages


 

 

Except in this case, it wouldn't be for moderating. Just for helping new folk, the clueless, those in need of help, etc etc.

 

Might actually make the PM boxes of mods and devs a little lighter and easier to deal with, so they can just handle rule breaks instead of having a million backlogged questions.

 

So now it would be their active duty to seek those out?  I've helped out plenty of folks on here, from varying issues, but I can still consider myself to "troll" once in a while, when the mood kicks in and I still wouldn't see the need to have the title.  

 

Most folks around here go around helping each other regardless of their past behaviour and not caring how they are viewed, past and present and the title would be irrelevant. 



#18
spirosz

spirosz
  • Members
  • 16 354 messages

A person is going to be helpful regardless, just saying.  


  • Mr.House, ruggly et The Don's Hound aiment ceci

#19
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

How is anyone new going to just seek you out? Should your name come up in flashing lights when they create an account? 


  • spirosz aime ceci

#20
ruggly

ruggly
  • Members
  • 7 540 messages

Is there really a need to have a tag to say you're a helpful person? If a new person is struggling, just help them.



#21
Guest_Catch This Fade_*

Guest_Catch This Fade_*
  • Guests

 

Might actually make the PM boxes of mods and devs a little lighter and easier to deal with, so they can just handle rule breaks instead of having a million backlogged questions.

I'm sure one of a mod's many tasks is to help forum members so what's the point of this?



#22
Mr.House

Mr.House
  • Members
  • 23 338 messages

How is anyone new going to just seek you out? Should your name come up in flashing lights when they create an account? 

When you log into the site his name should dance naked right in front of you.


  • Billy-the-Squid aime ceci

#23
Guest_JujuSamedi_*

Guest_JujuSamedi_*
  • Guests

I'm a helpful member.


  • The Don's Hound et Rusty Sandusky aiment ceci

#24
niniendowarrior

niniendowarrior
  • Members
  • 1 451 messages

I think marking posts as answers in a thread would be enough.  Promoting such posts would at least highlight actual helpful posts and content instead of promoting individual members into such positions.



#25
Guest_JujuSamedi_*

Guest_JujuSamedi_*
  • Guests
My two cents is that It's not needed in the system really. This would require developers to add another user profile module. The "Helpful member" profile filled with it's own data structures and what not. Also if a question is being asked it is up to the person asking the question to determine if that answer is sufficient enough for him. Another issue is that back in the day, someone would just post on the forums if they are having a problem. The current system still works and such a system would improve it but the cost of improvement is not worth the time they would actually put in for this.