Yes. All very fascinating. Almost none of it made it to the page in the first act of the game, or at least as much as I got through. I shouldn't have to read a bunch of books to get some empathy with a walking bunch of misogynist cliches. Yes, we all get it, he's James Bond, only, like, totally medieval. And the world is all GrimDark, in a kill-the-kitten-or-save-the-village way.
You are carted unconscious into a castle. You have amnesia. That was old in the days of text adventures, for Christ's sake. Some improbable jiggle physics happens. Then it's fetchquest after fetchquest and a bunch of simplistic binary choices with a combat system that may as well be random button mashing for all the difference it makes. Oh yay.
A matter of taste.
I liked TW1 - not too hard yet not too simple - with it's richness of detail. It made me feel like an outcast in a medieval society and really pulled me into the whole atmosphere. As for the amnesia, i guess the developers went for that solution because of the complex backgroundstory of the books. Like turning a lettered page into a blank one and filling it up slowly, so that even those who didn't read the books could follow the story. and after i played through ieven startedreading those and greatly enjoyed it.
And be fair: these fetch- and killquest are in every RPG. Here thye're bound into a storyand not like some MMOs where i go into a town, pick 30 and run of... and at some points in the middle of the game, those choices effect later quests.
Its not that its a male/female, I have the same issues for male or female. When its a full character fleshed out, I dont feel I can get into their shoes that much. I prefer them to be less fleshed out and allow me to fill it in myself. Which is why I prefer RPGs.
Hmm, ok... strange to me, but ok.
I'm more the opposite. These blank, less fleshed out charakters... well they often feel like a foreign object. It's hard to explain, why they don't fit in - in my regards.
i guess it's easier for my to empathise with the main-charakter, if he/she has a background and some personality.
TES like Skyrim... well... i like leveling up my charakter and go exploring but... in the end it feels cheap and stupid if i end up being head of the dark brotherhood, archmage, head of the fighter guild, chosen of this daedric and that and so on and so on.... and still most Npc act as if i wasn't there or just say some oneliner like "oh, arent you...", "did you hear about" or "isn't that the sword of incontinence". somehow the world starts feeling sterile and i start feeling misplaced.
Oh, and don't get me started on MMOs...This "you are the chosen saver of the world... well you and 4.000.000 other..." can't break immersion more.