That makes sense, though it's a pretty big coincidence.
Yeah, you'd be surprised at the coincidences that maybe involve him - lol. Right, I did mean to get around to typing that journal entry in again, so here it is:
Maliphant's Journals
Some Pages Later:
There is a new soldier in our battalion: Gordian. He's an odd fellow, with an accent I can't place. Like he'd spent time in the Marches. It doesn't matter, in the end. He's been a comfort, listening to me talk about those who died. He also lost friends in Celene's war. And he's tired, like we are. He said a very wise thing: "There is no war without soldiers." The empress can't wage her war if we refuse to fight.
Maybe it was Blackwall, maybe not. I found the specific mention of the guy's Free March accent and his description as being odd somewhat suspicious (along with the wise words of wisdom), myself - heh.
Oh, as for the bandit note - just redid that bit earlier while recruiting Blackwall (started a Nightmare playthrough recently), and this is what they were shouting during the actual fight:
Bandit: "You're dead, bastard! Dead!"
Blackwall: "I wasn't here to fight. Stop, and think!"
Bandit: "Too late for that! You know how this ends!"
Think Ceol posted that bit before too - anyway, it sounded strangely personal in retrospect.